Home               

LC

Brent

Other Areas

About LCW 

Contact LCW

Quest Scores

Complaint Tips

LC Dossier

LC Cutbacks

Other Sources 

Links

Vale Farm April / May 2004

From: Paul Burns To: Christine  Coppack  Cc: Rez Cameron
Sent: Friday, May 21, 2004 8:42 AM
Subject: Vale Farm

Dear Christine, Thank you for your email of 18 May, in response to my email of  the 17th. I am delighted to hear that staff are now instructed to vacuum the pool every night but regret to inform you that this morning I presented three sticking plasters from the pool to the life guard. I saw a fourth one but it was not within reach of my swimming lane. Does your pool vacuum cleaner have some difficulty picking up these items?

Also this morning Vale Farm opened two minutes late, without a Duty Manager on site and short of other staff. It appears that there was still no duty manager till after 7 am. Are your centres allowed to open without a Duty Manager? I would also like to know if this is acceptable to Brent Council.

There also appears to be a new arrangement whereby people can use the gym without a member of staff being present. If in the past it was a safety requirement for the gym to be staffed, what has changed that now makes Leisure Connection feel this is no longer needed? Is this new arrangement just at Vale Farm or does it apply to other gyms / Harpers Fitness managed by your company?

Again, I want to know whether the reduced gym staffing at Vale Farm, and any other Brent centre, is acceptable to Brent Council. I would also like to know if Brent was given prior notice of the intention to vary the staffing for Harpers Fitness.

I note that the Vale Farm website page about Harpers this morning still claims:
"Full supervision from fully trained, friendly and helpful staff" 
http://valefarm.leisureconnection.co.uk/activity5.html  

LC reply of May 25 and my response to it.

From: Paul Burns   Sent: Monday, May 17, 2004 8:58 AM
To: Rez Cameron   Cc: Christine Coppack
Subject: Vale Farm Complaint - Pool Floor 17.5.04 

Dear Rez, I was at Vale Farm at 6.30 this morning. In the pool were pieces of rubbish. I showed the Duty Manager, Rohan, a tissue, matted hair and a sticking plaster that I found in the pool. Rohan was unable to say when the pool was last vacuumed. 

I understand that you have asked for the pool to be vacuumed four times a week. I would like to know on what evenings the vacuuming is scheduled to take place.

From: Paul Burns    Sent: Saturday, May 15, 2004 8:29 PM
To: Sue Harper     Cc: Christine Coppack
Subject: Vale Farm Stage 2 Complaints - Your Ref. SH/RC
 

Dear Sue, Thank your letters of  4.5.04 and 6.5.04 in reply to my third and fourth stage two complaint about the standards at Vale Farm. My primary complaint was about the council’s failure to manage the contract and ensure that Leisure Connection does what it should. Among the matters complained of were dirty conditions in changing rooms, litter in the pool and around it, failure to open due to lack of staff, failure to notice trip hazards or to deal with them, and uncomfortable temperatures in showers, pool and changing rooms.   

You promise better monitoring and regular meetings with Leisure Connection but these have been promised before without any overall improvement that I am aware of. In your reply to my first Stage two complaint in May 2003 you said that you would ask the Contract Management Officer “to closely monitor cleaning at Vale Farm to ensure it is of an acceptable standard.” That letter also speaks of regular meetings with the contractor to review performance. 

You now mention that the Council has a new monitoring officer. In addition, several times in the last month I have noticed Rez at Vale Farm at opening time. His presence seems to have led to some improvements. The pool and the lockers are cleaner of late but this morning the men’s wetside changing room floor was very littered at 8.20 am and not improved when I left the pool at 8.55. I reported the litter to Jackie, the Duty Manager as I left. I also told her that one of the swimming lane ropes was so slack it had an S-bend in it at times. At other times it was so bowed in the middle as to reduce significantly the width of a swimming lane.  

Given your new member of staff I will wait a month before deciding whether to escalate the two complaints to Stage 3. 

Other Recent Items

April 2004 saw another round of price increases at Vale Farm. Charges used to go up in May but  now start in April. For example, between 2000 and 2004 the Brent Leisure Card zoomed from £17 to £27.50 ( 61%) and an Off Peak swim for card holders went from £1.00 to £1.40 (40%). Inflation over the same period has averaged 2.3% a year. Many users would object less to the increases if they had experienced a decent standard of service.

26.4.04  The last week has seen daily, early morning inspection visits by a Brent

As of 4.5.04 I am still waiting for a reply from Brent's Chief Executive. I wrote to him on 8 March asking for a more complete reply to my second Stage 3 complaint. The complaint was sent on 30.11.03 and the CE's reply posted on 1.3.04. Brent claims that "The Chief Executive will normally send you a full written reply within 30 working days". After asking on 20.4.04 when I would get the fuller reply, I was told by one of the CE's complaints staff that "We will reply just as soon as possible".  Reply received 5.5.04. See my letter in response Escalated Complaints

8.5.04  Vale Farm opens late. No one would have minded the three minute delay if it was a rare occurrence and if we were allowed to queue inside the lobby rather than out in the wind and rain.  The men's wetside changing room floor had much rubbish on it as did the foyer leading to it. This was all seen by Rez, inspecting on behalf of Brent Council so I won't bother to email him. I find a clump of hair in the pool and present it to Rez as further evidence about the quality of pool cleaning. 

When I get home from swimming there is a reply from Sue Harper, Assistant Director Sports & Leisure to my third, stage two complaint, lodged on 17.3.04. The letter speaks of a new monitoring officer (unnamed) and regular meetings with LC and concludes, " We believe the way forward is to work in partnership with Leisure Connection to improve our services through them." 

Faith is a great thing but it should be tempered by reality once in a while. How can the council have faith in LC after four years of failings?

Other Complaints about Vale Farm Since 15.04.04

-----Original Message-----
From: Paul Burns  Sent: Tuesday, May 04, 2004 8:53 AM
To: Rez Cameron   Cc: christine.coppack@leisureconnection.co.uk
Subject: Vale Farm Complaint and Queries

Dear Rez, My complaint is about the continuing problem of rubbish in the pool. I am still waiting to hear how often the pool floor should be vacuumed (20.4.04).  

Both on Sunday 2rd and today, Tuesday 4th May, there was debris in the pool, both on the floor and a lump of hair floating around the half way up the water. I mentioned this to the Duty Manager this morning. 

I register the items below as queries.

I mentioned to the Duty Manager on leaving today that I had noticed on my last three visits that the sole Lifeguard in the pool hall was often looking down into a red ring binder or, today, an exercise book. I told Rohan that I  wondered if they were studying for an exam. Rohan said the thought they were involved in a pool headcount.  If it is a headcount I am still concerned. My understanding is that Life Guards are meant to maintain consistent and concentrated monitoring of the environment.

The Men's wetside showers are very warm and clearly one child on Sunday was uncomfortable with them. They have been like this since at least last Wednesday morning. On Sunday a woman swimmer told me that the women's showers were cold on both Saturday and Sunday. There was a sign to warn women about this.  I don’t know if the women’s showers were fixed by this morning.   

I was at Vale Farm at opening time this morning and was struck by how few of the men’s wetside lockers have keys. And even some of those with keys do not work. I assume Leisure Connection collects the £1 deposits for non-returned keys. If this is so, should this not cover the cost of replacing at least the key if not numbers, wristbands other attachment devices. How much money is in the kitty from deposit coins? 

The cleaning of the floor of the men’s changing room and lockers has improved in the last two weeks. Given the previous, frequent relapses in cleaning standards, it will take some time for me to be convinced the changes will last. 

Paul Burns

From: Paul Burns  Sent: Tuesday, April 20, 2004 10:41 AM
To: Rez Cameron   Cc: christine.coppack@leisureconnection.co.uk
Subject: Add to Stage 1 Complaint Re Vale Farm

 Dear Rez, Thank you for your reply of 19.4.04. I wish to add the following to my Stage 1 complaint of April 15th.

On Sunday 18th I was at the pool. There was debris in the water - a clump of matted hair and tissue. The showers in the Men's wetside changing rooms were cold. The Duty Manager, Tina, said this was due to a power cut during the night. This morning other swimmers told me that the showers were still cold on Monday morning and the same excuse was being given.

This morning at 6.30 I showed the Duty Manager, Darren, two lockers that had not been cleaned. One was particularly dirty. The floors had already been "cleaned", that is they were wet. By 7pm the lockers had been cleaned.

The pool appears not to have been vacuumed since at least Sunday. There was much debris. Could you confirm that the Centre now has a reliable pool vacuum? If so, how often is it meant to be used on the pool? When was it last used? Does a "robot" do the vacuuming or does someone actually guide the cleaning head?

As I entered the pool today the lifeguard was walking around the edge ladling water out to wash down the perimeter. I noticed less than two metres from the lifeguard's chair bits of tissue paper, a sticking plaster and a piece of gold foil. This does not suggest that staff are picking up rubbish when they see it, which Leisure Connection indicated some months ago that they would be doing.

The walls of the showers and changing cubicles appear not to have been cleaned for some time. Can you advise me when these were last done and how often they should be wiped down?

From: Paul Burns     Sent: Thursday, April 15, 2004 9:14 AM
To: Rez Cameron (Brent Leisure Services)   Cc: christine.coppack@leisureconnection.co.uk
Subject: New Stage 1 Complaint Re Vale Farm

 Dear Rez, I was at Vale Farm this morning for the first time in four weeks. Again I feel the need to complain about the Council's failure to ensure that the Centre is properly managed. While the matters listed below deserve replies from Leisure Connections my primary complaint is about the failure of the Council over a prolonged period to manage properly its contact with Leisure Connection.

I arrived at Vale farm at 6.45. The floor of the men's wetside changing room was wet but not clean. There was puddle by the entrance that was still there when I left at 7.25. Several lockers had dirt in them. I asked the Duty Manager, Darren, to inspect with me. I showed him that a piece of clean tissue wiped on the floor over a small area was stained. There were several small bits of rubbish on the floor, especially alongside walls.

Darren said that the cleaners were still in the building but was unclear what work they had carried out in the changing rooms. He agreed that it would make sense for the cleaners to start in the wetside changing rooms. As no swimmers had returned from the pool at this time it appears that the cleaners wet the floor before they had cleaned out the lockers (if indeed they intended to do this). I have commented before that a superficially hosing the floor is not cleaning. Adding moisture to dirt simply assists the reproduction of microorganisms.

I also pointed out to Darren that the fire stop door leading the entrance to the wetside changing rooms is still not closing properly.

The pool was excessively warm and certainly not the 28 degrees displayed at reception. Other swimmers told me that on Monday the main pool was so cold that many of them swam in the learners' pool. I understand from one of the other swimmers that new equipment to regulate temperature has arrived but as yet there have been no instructions as to how to use this.

The floor of the pool was free of sticking plasters and generally looked much better. However, there were two clumps of hair and tissue floating about a foot from the floor. I removed one of these from the pool and showed it to the lifeguard along with a sticking plaster I found at the side of the pool. The clump lost much of its tissue as I removed it and when not floating is about a tenth of the size it appears in the water. I have complained about these clumps for over two years and still have no explanation as to how they appear in the pool so often.

Paul Burns