Notes on the Second Meeting on the "Future for Allotments Report" hosted by the Local Government Association, 23 October 1998

Introduction ...

These notes have been placed in the QED Virtual Potting Shed as a service to allotment and community gardeners who wish to make a contribution to the debates which follow on from the publication of "The Future for Allotments" Report. The Local Government Association has asked for any comments from allotment associations and allotment holders to be channeled through the NSALG and NFCF rather than being sent directly to the LGA. The postal addresses of both organisations are appended. Alternatively, you may send a response by e-mail to the QED Website: all e-mails will be passed on to NSALG, NFCF, relevant members of the LGA group and (unless an instruction is given to the contrary) to the kitchen.gardens e-mail group.

The Notes ...

Present:

Lee Searles

Local Government Association

Cllr Keith Whitmore

Manchester City Council and LGA

Mike Branaghan

Bristol City Council

Martin Stott

Oxfordshire County Council

Melvin Jagger

Bradford City Council

Alun Rees

Chairman of NSALG

Eric Louder

Welsh Region of NSALG

Ron Niblett

South East Region of NSALG

Mario Rozanski

West Midlands Region of NSALG

John Smyth

South East Regional Allotments Committee

Clare Mason

DETR

James Emmett

ILAM

Darren Fizackerley

Harlow District Council

Patrick Phillips

Bromley Borough Council

Graham Clarke

Amateur Gardening

Richard Wiltshire

QED Allotments Group, Dartford

Apologies:

Cllr Nicky Gavron

London Borough of Haringey

Steve Place

National Federation of City Farms

1. Two options for progressing work on allotments best practice were discussed. The first was to do the work through the working group and the second to prepare a brief for consultants to do the work provided appropriate funding partners can be found.

2. It was felt that the second option would be preferable. However, any brief would have to be sufficiently detailed to ensure that consultants, who may not be conversant with allotment issues, can get underway quickly and require minimal supervision.

3. The LGA proposed to develop its paper further for the next meeting in order that progress can be examined to make a more informed decision on which areas of work need to be progressed through a research project (funds permitting) and which can be done in-house. The paper would also serve as a draft interim strategic statement on the recommended approach to allotments. This would fit in with any timetable for gaining LGMB funding in any case. this was agreed.

4. One of the important aspects of the work will be to establish how the process of improving allotments' place in local governance begins and works, and on what factors it depends.

5. A series of regional consultative meetings was suggested to gain a better understanding of the issues and initiatives in different areas. The LGA will investigate this further.

6. The group discussed the draft LGA paper and highlighted organisations to be contacted and sources of information to be followed-up with regard to the different roles of allotments in local communities.

7. There is a general need which will be reflected in the next draft of the paper prepared by the LGA to refer to Best Value and the New Duty to meet the Social, Economic and Environmental well-being of local communities.

8. The LGA agreed to inform the NSALG when consultation draft Planning Policy Guidance Note 3 is made available.

9. The LGA agreed to supply a list of relevant journals and contacts which could be approached for the placement of articles on successful initiatives on the different roles of allotments.

10. The LGA will check what has been done on allotments with regard to Best Value service pilots.

11. On consolidating legislation, it was agreed that it would probably be a very time-consuming and confusing process to undertake, and might divert from the more important task of improving best practice. Also the current work may reveal further changes needed to legislation which should be promoted together with the need for consolidation. Two separate legislative exercises would probably not be supported by Government. It was agreed to talk to the Statute Law Revision Society to see what they are offering but to await the outcome of work on allotments best practice before examining options for legislative change.

12. Members of the working group agreed to contribute papers and information by 15 December 1998, on the following topics:

James Emmett

Information on GP referral to the LGA. Also training needs.

John Smyth

Tenancies and relationships.

Pat Phillips

Promotion, awareness, and involving private sector.

Mick Branaghan

Local authority management models, processes, mechanisms.

Richard Wiltshire

Devolved management models and processes. Also Local Agenda 21.

Darren Fizackerly

Devolved models - local authority issues.

Mario Rozanski

The wider role of the allotment society in the community.

Martin Stott

General thoughts on community role, education etc.

The remaining members of the group would contribute papers as appropriate.

Date of next meeting

It was agreed that following receipt of papers, the LGA would distribute them to the group before the next meeting. This will be held on 12 February 1999 at 10.30am.

UPDATE (12/1/99): The next meeting has been postponed until 3 March 1999.

Please send your responses to the issues raised in this meeting to:

  • NSALG, O'Dell House, Hunters Road, Corby, Northants NN17 5JE
  • NFCF, The GreenHouse, Hereford Street, Bedminster, Bristol BS3 4NA
  • or by e-mail to QED for onward transmission

Please do not send responses directly to the Local Government Association

Return to the QED Virtual Potting Shed

Return to the QED Allotments Group Home Page