Player

Season

Opposition

Comp./
Division

6

Douglas Hunt

1938/39

Norwich City

2nd

5

Derek Dooley

1951/52

Notts County

2nd

Jimmy Dailey

1947/48

Barnsley

2nd

Jimmy Trotter

1925/26

Stockport County

2nd

Jimmy Trotter

1924/25

Portsmouth

2nd

Toddles Woolhouse

1891

Halliwell

FA Cup

Bob Gregory

1883

Spilsby

FA Cup

4

David Hirst

1990/91

Hull City

2nd

Steve Whitton

1990

Aldershot

LC

Derek Dooley

1951/52

Hull City

2nd

Jackie Sewell

1951/52

Cardiff City

2nd

Derek Dooley

1951/52

Everton

2nd

Clarrie Jordan

1949/50

Hull City

2nd

Eddie Quigley

1949/50

Chesterfield

2nd

Eddie Quigley

1947/48

West Ham United

2nd

Jack Ball

1932/33

Wolves

1st

Walter Millership

1932

Bournemouth

FA Cup

George Stephenson

1931/32

Blackburn Rovers

1st

Jack Allen

1929/30

Manchester United

1st

Jack Allen

1928/29

Bury

1st

Jimmy Trotter

1925/26

Preston North End

2nd

Sid Binks

1923/24

Crystal Palace

2nd

David McLean

1913

Grimsby Town

FA Cup

David McLean

1911/12

Sunderland

1st

Jimmy Stewart

1905/06

Wolves

1st

Harry Millar

1899/00

Gainsborough Trinity

2nd

E Rhodes

1882

Staveley

FA Cup

3

Gerald Sibon

2000/01

QPR

D1

Andy Booth

1997/98

Bolton Wanderers

PL

Mark Bright

1996

Crewe Alexandra

LC

Chris Bart-Williams

1992/93

Southampton

PL

Carlton Palmer

1991/92

Queens Park Rangers

1st

Dalian Atkinson

1990

Aldershot

LC

Colin Walker

1987

Stockport County

LC

Carl Shutt

1985/86

Birmingham City

1st

Imre Varadi

1985

Oldham Athletic

FA Cup

Andy Blair

1985

Luton Town

LC

Imre Varadi

1984/85

Leicester City

1st

Andy McCulloch

1980/81

Cambridge United

2nd

Andy McCulloch

1979/80

Rotherham United

3rd

Rodger Wylde

1978

Doncaster Rovers

LC

Mick Prendergast

1973/74

Crystal Palace

2nd

Brian Joicey

1973

Crystal Palace

FA Cup

Brian Joicey

1971/72

Leyton Orient

2nd

John Sissons

1971/72

Burnley

2nd

Jack Whitham

1968/69

Manchester United

1st

David Ford

1966/67

Burnley

1st

John Fantham

1966/67

Southampton

1st

John Ritchie

1967

Queens Park Rangers

FA Cup

John Hickton

1965/66

Arsenal

1st

John Fantham

1964/65

Burnley

1st

David Layne

1963/64

Ipswich Town

1st

David Layne

1964

FC Utrecht

Fairs Cup

David Layne

1962/63

Manchester City

1st

Gerry Young

1962

Roma

Fairs Cup

John Fantham

1961/62

Birmingham City

1st

Gerry Young

1960/61

Manchester United

1st

Keith Ellis

1961

Manchester United

FA Cup

Roy Shiner

1958/59

Scunthorpe United

2nd

Redfern Froggatt

1958/59

Sunderland

2nd

Keith Ellis

1956/57

Birmingham City

1st

Alan Finney

1956/57

Tottenham Hotspur

1st

Roy Shiner

1955/56

Lincoln City

2nd

Jackie Sewell

1955/56

Plymouth Argyle

2nd

Jackie Sewell

1952/53

Sunderland

1st

Derek Dooley

1951/52

Brentford

2nd

Derek Dooley

1951/52

West Ham United

2nd

Redfern Froggatt

1950/51

Liverpool

1st

Walter Rickett

1949/50

Grimsby Town

2nd

Jimmy Dailey

1946/47

Tottenham Hotspur

2nd

Charlie Tomlinson

1946

York City

FA Cup

Walter Millership

1938/39

Blackburn Rovers

2nd

Douglas Hunt

1938/39

Luton Town

2nd

Charlie Napier

1938/39

Southampton

2nd

Neil Dewar

1936/37

Everton

1st

Ellis Rimmer

1935/36

Everton

1st

Jack Palethorpe

1934/35

Birmingham City

1st

Neil Dewar

1934

Oldham Athletic

FA Cup

Jack Ball

1932/33

Leicester City

1st

Harry Burgess

1932

Bournemouth

FA Cup

Walter Millership

1931/32

Blackburn Rovers

1st

Harry Burgess

1930/31

Blackpool

1st

Mark Hooper

1930/31

Birmingham City

1st

Mark Hooper

1930/31

Blackpool

1st

Jack Ball

1930/31

Leicester City

1st

Jack Ball

1930/31

Sunderland

1st

Mark Hooper

1929/30

Manchester City

1st

Jack Allen

1929/30

Derby County

1st

Mark Hooper

1929/30

Everton

1st

Jack Allen

1929/30

Leicester City

1st

Ellis Rimmer

1928/29

Leeds United

1st

Ted Harper

1928/29

Derby County

1st

Jack Allen

1928/29

Birmingham City

1st

Mark Hooper

1927/28

Tottenham Hotspur

1st

Ted Harper

1927/28

Derby County

1st

Jimmy Trotter

1926/27

Arsenal

1st

Jimmy Trotter

1926/27

Sunderland

1st

Jimmy Trotter

1926/27

Everton

1st

Harold Hill

1925/26

Chelsea

2nd

Jimmy Trotter

1925/26

Darlington

2nd

Sam Powell

1924/25

Fulham

2nd

George Ayres

1924/25

Stockport County

2nd

Sid Binks

1923/24

Bristol City

2nd

Sam Taylor

1923/24

Gateshead

2nd

Sid Binks

1922/23

Stockport County

2nd

Sam Taylor

1922/23

Leyton Orient

2nd

C Binney

1921/22

Coventry City

2nd

Johnny McIntyre

1920/21

Coventry City

2nd

David McLean

1914/15

Bradford Park Avenue

1st

David McLean

1914/15

Aston Villa

1st

David McLean

1913

Chelsea

FA Cup

David McLean

1911/12

West Bromwich Albion

1st

Frank Rollinson

1909/10

Newcastle United

1st

Andrew Wilson

1908/09

Arsenal

1st

Harry Chapman

1908/09

Manchester City

1st

Frank Bradshaw

1907/08

Arsenal

1st

Jimmy Stewart

1905/06

Nottingham Forest

1st

Jimmy Stewart

1905/06

Arsenal

1st

Jimmy Stewart

1904/05

Bury

1st

Vivien Simpson

1904

Manchester United

FA Cup

Harry Davis

1902/03

Bolton Wanderers

1st

Andrew Wilson

1902/03

Everton

1st

Fred Spiksley

1902/03

Notts County

1st

John Wright

1899/00

Port Vale

2nd

John Wright

1899/00

Barnsley

2nd

John Wright

1899/00

Loughborough

2nd

Fred Spiksley

1899/00

Luton Town

2nd

A Kaye

1898/99

Wolves

1st

Bob Ferrier

1896/97

Blackburn Rovers

1st

Harry Davis

1895

Middlesbrough

FA Cup

Alec Brady

1893/94

Derby County

1st

Billy Ingram

1888

Nottingham Forest

FA Cup

H Newbould

1883

Spilsby

FA Cup

Tom Cawley

1883

Spilsby

FA Cup

Tom Cawley

1882

Upton Park

FA Cup

Bob Gregory

1881

Blackburn Rovers

FA Cup

PL=Premier League

LC=League Cup

4

Glennon

1917/18

Sheffield United

MS S

Burgin

1942/43

Mansfield Town

FLN

Melling

1942/43

Nottingham Forest

LNC

3

Capper

1915/16

Derby County

MS P

Capper

1915/16

Sheffield United

MS P

Burkinshaw

1916/17

Lincoln City

MS S

Glennon

1917/18

Huddersfield Town

MS P

Glennon

1917/18

Barnsley

MS S

Glennon

1918/19

Lincoln City

MS P

Burkinshaw

1918/19

Lincoln City

MS P

Millership

1939/40

Notts County

EM

Napier

1939/40

Leeds United

LNC

Ward

1940/41

Rotherham United

NRL

Robinson

1941/42

Sheffield United

FLN

Melling

1942/43

Rotherham United

FLN

Robinson

1942/43

Mansfield Town

FLN

Robinson

1942/43

Mansfield Town

FLN

Burgin

1942/43

Mansfield Town

FLN

Melling

1942/43

Chesterfield

FLN

Robinson

1942/43

Lincoln City

LNCQ

Robinson

1942/43

Rotherham United

LNCQ

Wright

1943/44

Notts County

LNCQ

Robinson

1944/45

Lincoln City

FLN

Robinson

1945/46

Sunderland

FLN

Rogers

1945/46

Sunderland

FLN

EM

5

Gregory

1880/81

Providence

SCC

Gregory

1880/81

Ecclesfield

SCC

4

Bingley

1880/81

Lockwood Brothers

SCC

Sugg

1883/84

Heeley

F

Davy

1885/86

Holmes

SCC

Cawley

1887/88

Mexborough

F

Waller

1887/88

Welsh Amateurs

F

Ingram

1888/89

Doncaster Rovers

GNCC

Ingram

1888/89

Notts Rangers

F

Cawley

1888/89

Sheffield

F

Bennett

1889/90

Small Heath Alliance

All

Ingram

1889/90

Clifton

F

Spikesley

1891/92

Partick Thistle

F

3

Reaney

1871/72

Derby St Andrews

F

Hatherley

1873/74

Exchange Brewery

F

Woodcock

1878/79

Heeley

WCC

Cawley

1881/82

Heeley

WCC

Bentley

1883/84

Derby Midland

F

Hiller

1884/85

Mexborough

F

Waller

1887/88

Holmes

SCC

Cawley

1887/88

Eckington Works

SCC

Ingram

1887/88

Derby County

F

Cawley

1887/88

Derby County

F

Waller

1887/88

Collegiate

F

Ingram

1888/89

Ecclesfield

F

Woolhouse

1888/89

Ecclesfield

F

Mumford

1888/89

Sheffield

F

Woolhouse

1888/89

Birmingham St George's

F

Winterbottom

1889/90

Clifton

F

Woolhouse

1890/91

Darwin

All

Gibson

1890/91

Birmingham St George's

All

Gibson

1890/91

Derby County

F

Brown

1891/92

Small Heath Alliance

All

Woolhouse

1891/92

Canadians

F

McConachie

1891/92

Accrington

F