An invitational competition for the Sheffield F.A.'s top teams in its earliest days. Like the Senior Cup, Wednesday began entering their reserve team after they entered the Alliance League, and eventually ignored it completely.
The competition was last played in 1984, when Kiveton Park won.

Wednesday Wins
1879
1882
1883
1886
1888
1893(shared with United)

Wednesday Reserve Wins
1900
1903
1905
1906
1908
1909
1911
1915
1922
1925
1931
1933

Wednesday 'A' Wins
1938
1939
1957
1958
1959