|
On Our Attitude to
the Poor
From a speech
by Aldous Huxley, 1934
There was a time, not so long ago,
when it was universally taken for granted that the poor belonged
to a different and inferior species. In nineteenth-century novels,
for example, the Poor are spoken of as though they were a curious
race of African savages - odd creatures with customs that at
the best were laughable or quaintly touching, and at the worst
were downright repulsive. Some of the Poor, it is true, came
rather nearer to being fully human. These were the beings beautifully
described as `the Deserving Poor'. But, alas, the Deserving Poor
were few and far between. Most of the Poor were definitely undeserving,
and good care was taken by those in authority to see that they
got no more than they deserved.
Things are certainly better than
they were. But traces of the old mentality still persist. People
in official positions, people in any sort of authority, even,
in too many instances, the givers of charity feel themselves
justified in assuming towards men and women with small incomes
an attitude which they would never dream of assuming towards
men and women with large incomes. Who ever heard, for example,
of the Deserving Rich? And who ever heard of a rich person going
round interrogating other rich persons, to find out whether they
really were deserving? The thing would be regarded - and rightly
regarded - as the grossest impertinence, an infringement of the
most elementary rights of spiritual privacy. And yet this sort
of infringement is constantly being made upon the rights of people
with small incomes. There is a whole class of well-meaning people
who still seem to believe that impertinence towards the very
poor is not only justifiable, but actually virtuous. How passionately
these same people complain whenever, for any reason, they are
momentarily treated as though they themselves were poor! Passport
formalities, for example, arouse in them a fury which can only
find vent in letters to The Times and unprintable conversation.
These outraged travellers may thank their stars that they are
not regularly treated like the very poor and destitute. For the
life of the destitute, even on their native soil, is one long
succession of pass-port formalities and interfering impertinences.
And, unlike the rich, they have no Times to write to.
|