Versi versus Keble College, Oxford & Roger Boden (Bursar) 2005

Evidence item D260
Communications between Diamond Versi and Roger Boden, 2001, concerning Warden Averil Cameron's 'under payment'

Cameron pic

Averil Cameron

Explanation (paragraph 16 of Versi's witness statement)

I refer the Tribunal to pages 260-260H of the bundle [reproduced below]. On 28 November 2001 Roger Boden sent me a note asking me to pay the Warden at a higher rate and compensate her for an alleged underpayment. All pay rises have to be authorised by the Governing Body and therefore this instruction was unauthorised. The Warden's pay was originally authorised as an additional Schedule III departmental allowance at a Finance Committee meeting of 4 October 1995 and approved by the Governing Body meeting of 11 October 1995. There was no need to visit this issue without getting the Finance Committee and Governing Body involved. I pointed out to Roger Boden in my email (at page 260) that the new schedule V was the old schedule III. There was no need to pay the Warden back pay with interest for the alleged underpayment as she was paid correctly. He ignored my objection and asked me to pay her a higher sum. The attached 'FC note' of 30 January 2002 shows that the Finance Committee authorised a rise to schedule II without knowing that Roger Boden had already given the Warden an unauthorised pay rise at an incorrect pay scale (schedule III when it should have been at schedule V). I brought this matter to the attention of the auditors at the audit for the period ended 31 July 2002. Roger Boden told the auditors that the pay was authorised at the finance Committee meeting of 30 January 2002. This is partly correct but the unauthorised pay increase took place in his instruction to me dated 28 November 2001. Soon after the Warden passed a minute at a Governing Body giving Roger Boden a pay rise of about £5000 on an open ended pay scale of academic related grade VI.


Note from Boden to Versi, 28th November 2001

Diamond

1. Please would you increase the Warden's salary to £53,487 p.a. with effect from 1st December 2001, this being the sum determined by Professorial basic salary plus Schedule III allowance (see FC 95.87)

2. Please would you also add a monthly uplift of £424.96 for the next 39 months (from 1st December 2001) to reimburse the Warden for past underpayment

R. Boden
28-11-01

Calculation of salary adjustment required to reimburse Warden for underpayment since 1/10/98
period underpayment Cumulative
inc interest
No. of
months
Months
in year
Interest
rate
Interest
1/10/98-1/4/99 2,112.00 2,112.00 6 125.00% 52.80
1/4/99-1/4/00 4,372.00 6,536.80 12 12 5.00%326.84
1/4/00-1/4/01 4,503.00 11,366.64 12 12 5.00%568.33
1/4/01-1/9/01 1,932.92 13,867.89 5 12 5.00%288.91
1/9/01-1/12/01 1,171.25 15,328.06 3 12 5.00%191.60

So £5,328.06 is the accumulated shortfall to be paid over next 39 months in equal monthly instalments

Assume interest at 5% to be calculated on half that sum for 39 months:

Additional interest amounts to: £1,245.40

So total to be amortised is £16,573.46

Monthly uplift 1/12/01-1/3/05 £424.96

Warden's Pay

Paid s/be Difference Under payment
01/04/95 40,038 40,038 0
01/04/96 41,199 41,199 0
01/04/97 42,394 42,394 0
01/04/98 43,242 43,242 0
01/10/98 44,005 48,229 4,224 2,112.00 6 months
01/04/99 45,545 49,917 4,372 4,372.00 12 months
01/04/00 46,912 51,415 4,503 4,503.00 12 months
01/04/01 48,319 52,958 4,639 1,932.92 5 months
01/09/01 48,802 53,487 4,685 1,171.25 3 months
14,091.17


Email from Versi to Boden, 29th November 2001

From: Diamond Versi
Organization: Keble College
To: Roger Boden
Date sent: Thu, 29 Nov 2001 12:25
Subject: Warden's Pay and Schedule III Allowances

Dear Roger

I am afraid the interpretation of Schedule III allowance is not correct. In October, 1998 there was a major review (U of 0) of schedules of allowances for the heads of department. The number of schedules was increased from 4 to 6. In doing so the values were also increased by 10%. Therefore an equivalent of old schedule III is schedule V. We therefore need to revise our figures to reflect the correct situation.

Diamond


Email from Boden to Versi, 29th November 2001

From: Roger Boden
Organization: Keble College
To: Diamond Versi
Date sent: Thu, 29 Nov 2001 12:59
Subject: Warden's Pay and Schedule III Allowances

Dear Diamond

Thanks for this - we have since spoken.

Just for the record, I have no doubt that the reason why the University revised its schedules in 1998 is that they realised Professors who were heads of department were falling behind compared with their equivalents in other institutions - hence the substantial increases in existing schedule allowances and the creation of two new schedules, 5 and 6. By the same token, the Warden's salary was falling behind, and in fact is still considerably below what, for example, St Peter's and Brasenose are advertising for new Heads of House (£60k plus housing). I shall be asking Finance Committee, next term, to review the Warden's stipend with a view to increasing it above the current formula of Professorial basic plus Schedule III allowance. But meanwhile please implement the adjustment that we have discussed - to restore the stipend what that formula provides and to reimburse the Warden for underpayment since 1998.

Many thanks

Roger


Oxford University Salary Scales, 2002 (extract)

ANNEXE A

NON-CLINICAL ACADEMIC AND ACADEMIC-RELATED STAFF
WITH EFFECT FROM 1 AUGUST 2002

Professors (A20)
Salary scale
effective from
1 March 2002
£
Salary scale
effective from
1 August 2002
£
Basic salary 45,338 46,789
Allowances:
Schedule I 12,793 13,202
Schedule II 10,874 11,222
Schedule III 8,684 8,962
Schedule IV 5,759 5,943
Schedule V 4,350 4,489
Schedule VI 2,208 2,279


Keble College Finance Committee note, 22nd March 1994

49. Warden-elect: terms of appointment

The Sub-Warden and Bursar reported that negotiations with the Warden-elect on the terms of her appointment were nearly completed. The main difference compared with the terms for the present Warden was that the College will have to make provision for the Warden-elect's pension. Fellows will have the opportunity of seeing the letter of appointment before it is sent. The cost of refurbishing the Warden's Lodgings is unlikely to exceed £10,000.


Keble College Finance Committee minute, 4th October 1995

FC 95.87 Remuneration of the Warden and Bursar

The Committee considered the report of it sub-committee on the remuneration of the Warden and Bursar. Following some detailed discussion the Committee decided to amend the recommendations of the sub-committee as follows:

Warden It is recommended that the Warden's stipend be increased by the addition of the Schedule III departmental allowance to give a total stipend of £40,038 with effect from 01.04.95. In addition the Committee recommends that the Warden should be entitled to a book allowance at the Tutorial Fellows' rate of £473 with effect from 01.08.95.

Bursar The Committee noted that Keble's single bursar establishment leads to a very heavy work-load and limited time during which the present Bursar was able to take leave. The Committee recommends that the College should look favourably on any request which the Bursar might make for extended leave of up to a term's duration, with the proviso that the College should appoint a Fellow as acting Bursar during this period.


Oxford University General Board papers, Trinity Term 1998 (extract)

GENERAL BOARD OF THE FACULTIES
HEBDOMADAL COUNCIL

Pay award for academic and academic-related staff: settlement for 1998

Vol nos. EMS/6; EMS/10; WP899.058
Prev. refs. Council Papers: Vol. 346, HT 1997, pp. 346, xiv(15)
General Board Papers: Vol. CCV, HT 1997, pp. 155, ccv(4)

1. The Universities and Colleges Employers Association has notified universities that a national agreement has been reached on the 1998 pay increase for non-clinical academic and academic-related staff. The agreement provides for an increase of 2 per cent to take effect from 1 April 1998 and a further increase of 1.8 per cent on the rates which applied before 1 April to take effect from 1 October 1998.

2. The effect on the rates payable to non-clinical academic and academic-related staff from 1 April and 1 October 1998 is annexed at B in the form in which the information would be made available to those members of Congregation who requested it.

3. The latest forecast considered by the Resources Committee on 5 and 19 May has assumed a 2 per cent salary increase in the budget for 1997-8 while for the budget for 1998-9 the committee has allowed for the award in exactly the form in which it has now been agreed.

4. Council and the General Board are asked to approve

(i) the increases to the rates of the salaries of academic and academic-related staff to take effect from 1 April 1998 and 1 October 1998;

(ii) increases to the joint maxima as follows

Rate from 1.4.97
£
1.4.98
£
1.10.98
£
Readers 36,623 37,355 38,015
University lecturers 35,754 36,469 37,113

ANNEXE B

ACADEMIC AND ACADEMIC-RELATED SALARIES AND SALARY SCALES: 1998 REVIEW

Ref. No. EMS/6

Salary rates for non-clinical academic and academic-related staff from 1 April 1998 and 1 October 1998

The new rates (Col. B) represent a 2 per cent increase on the rates paid from 1 April 1997 (Col. A) rounded to the nearest pound. The rates in Col. C represent a further increase of 1.8 per cent on the rates payable from 1 April 1997.
A
£
1 April
1997
B
£
1 April
1998
C
£
1 October
1998
1.1 Professors (A20)
Basic Salary
38,994 39,774 40,476
Allowances
Schedule I 6,788 6924 7,046
Schedule II 4,502 4,592 4,673
Schedule III 3,400 3,468 3,529
Schedule IV 1,726 1,761 1,792


Email from Boden to Versi, 3rd April 2002

From: Roger Boden
Organization: Keble College
To: Diamond Versi
Date sent: Wed, 3 Apr 2002 10:14
Subject: Revised stipends and allowances

Dear Diamond

Attached are the recommendations that were approved by Finance Committee (FC02.16) and GB (GB02.34), As the note recommends, all the revisions (including the Warden's salary) should take effect from 1-8-02, but at that time they should be adjusted in line with the annual rise in salaries.

Please would you let me have an amended stipends and allowances spreadsheet.

Many thanks

Roger


Stipends Survey: Summary, 30th January 2002

Stipends Survey: Summary of Recommendations

Note: The figures proposed below are at the level that would apply were they in force now: if they are not implemented until 1-8-01 they will at that point be uplifted in line with the general increases in academic stipends.

1. Academic allowances for Fellows should be increased from £573 p.a. to £750 p.a.

2. The stipend of the Sub-Warden should remain at £1,299 p.a. save that, if called upon to serve as Acting Warden for a period of more than a month the Sub-Warden's stipend should be quadrupled for the period of the Acting Wardenship.

3. The Senior Tutor's stipend should be increased to £6,000 p.a.

4. The teaching remission allowed to the Tutor for Admissions should be increased from 1.33/12ths to 3/12ths.

5. The stipend of the Dean of Degrees should be increased from £534 to £649.

6. The Warden's stipend be equivalent to that of a Professor receiving a Schedule II allowance (rather than, as currently, a Schedule III allowance). This represents an increase of some £2,200 p.a.

7. The above revisions should take effect from 1.8.02 and should be adjusted in line with the general uplift in academic salaries.

RJB (Roger Boden)
30-01-02


CLICK TO GO/RETURN TO:

THE NEXT ITEM in the VERSAGA or THE READING JUDGMENT or THE VERSINDEX

THE OXBRIDGE COLLEGE ACCOUNTS: INDEX AND EXPLANATION

THE SURPRISING TRUTH ABOUT OUP'S 'CHARITABLE STATUS'

THE HISTORY OF AKME AND OF THIS WEBSITE

THE OXFORD WAS NOT RACIST SUB-INDEX

THE AKME OXFORD CUTTINGS LIBRARY

THE AKME LITERARY LAW LIBRARY

ABOUT MAKING NAMES

ABOUT THE REMEDY

THE SITE INDEX

e-mail: akme@btinternet.com