Malcolm vs. Oxford University, 1986 Chancery Division Ch M. 7710

xB005.gif scan

Evidence (Red) File pages 9 - 14, Making Names Page-by-Page Guide, Suggested cover/dust-jacket design, Index, Author background, December 1983

Making Names Page-by-Page Guide with suggested running headlines (to be italicised).

In the eventual published version of Making Names, most of these running headlines were rephrased, but the principle and their style were retained. - A. M.

CHAPTER ONE: MINDS AND BODIES

(in the contracted rewrite for OUP, this first chapter was split into two, MINDS AND BODIES and PERSONS AND THINGS.)

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 The Landscape
2 The University Town
3 The Near-accident
4 Coffee in the Market Square The Rarity of Accidents
5 Effect Introduces Himself Science Missing Something?
6 The Traffic Lights
7 People Have Minds
8 How Do You Know That?
9 Cause Introduces Himself What is Philosophy?
10 Why a Problem?
11 Other Minds Exist
12 Extrapolating Myself
13 'Deductive' and 'Inductive'
14 Questioning the Premises
15 This Argument Fits Neither Paradigm
16 Yet One Is Certain
17 Why Human Beings?
18 The Bookshop Incident A Philosophical Record Player
19 The Italian Café J. S. Mill's Argument
20 Questioning Mill's Premises
21 The Human Form
22 A Constant and Regular Sequence?
23 Missing Links
24 Questioning Mill's Inference
25 Skulls Contain Brains
26 Brain Events and Mental Events
27 Brain Events Cause Mental Events?
28 The Adrenaline Example
29 Brain Events Are Mental Events?
30 Brain Events Themselves Problematic
31 Doubts
32 And Doubts
33 Inordinate Certainty
34 Understanding People
35 Trusting People
36 Mental Illness
37 Philosophy and Madness
38 Descartes
39 A Racist Assumption
40 Everyday Trickeries
41 Philosophical Racism
42 "Let's Go" The Stone is Angry
43 The Parking Ticket Cause is Angry
44 The Drive to the San. 'Empiricism', 'Rationalism'
45 'Logical Positivism'
46 The Verification Principle
47 The Tea-Room at the San. The Babies and the Bathwater
48 Ryle's 'Concept of Mind'
49 Knowing Things
50 Being Angry
51 I Had a Dream
52 Epistemology and Ontology
53 A 'Category-Mistake'
54 The Ghost-in-the-Machine
55 The Double-Life
56 A Linguistic Problem?
57 A Little Algebra
58 M-Language and b-language
59 Ways of Feeling
60 The Emotional Litmus-Paper
61 Imagining the Sea
62 Racism Again
63 Four Statements
64 Four More Statements
65 Linguistic Madness
66 Berkeley, not Descartes
67 Vested Interests
68 A Necessary Partnership
69 Danger: the b-Language is Here
70 The Drive to Hartlands Mind and Body
71 Hartlands Zoo Park Effect's First Story: Darwinian Evolution
72 The Soup
73 From Molecules to Protists
74 DNA
75 Genetic Information
76 Adaptation
77 The Tree of Life
78 The Chimpanzees
79 Us and Our Effects
80 Objections: the Scale-Feather
81 Purpose in Evolution
82 Beauty Exists
83 Everything Comes Through the Genes
84 The 'Problem' of Altruism
85 Misleading Tendencies
86 The Language of Evolution
87 What is a Man?
88 Where Does He Come From?
89 How Does He Work?
90 Squeamish or Prudish?
91 What is Consciousness?
92 Where Do We Draw the Line?
93 Organic' and 'Inorganic'
94 'Animate' and 'Living'
95 Eyewash in Arts Block
96 What is a Nerve?
97 What is a Brain?
98 Machines
99 Why so Begrudging?
100 The Ability to Philosophise
101 Philosophy and Survival
102 Other Intelligent Life
103 Anthropocentricity
104 Other Evolutionary Histories
105 Language: Wittgenstein and I
106 The Landscape 'Mined' by Language
107 Back to the Physics Labs. A Mind-Less World
108 Driving Through the Countryside The Future
109 Repairs in a Lay-by A Science Fiction

CHAPTER TWO: CAUSES AND EFFECTS

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 The Physics Labs. Effect's Research: Hydrogen Fusion
2 Effect's Room A Glass Billiard-Table
3 The First Collision, the Phone Did You Spot the Causing?
4 Hume Notebook: What is a Causal Relationship?
5 Four Statements
6 Necessary Connexions
7 Causal Connections Objective?
8 Hume's Blind Alley
9 'The Same Thing'
10 Inductive Evidence
11 Cause Takes a Nap A Freak Collision
12 What Caused That?
13 The Physics Common Room Beneath the Surface: Glass is a Liquid
14 Imagining Experimental Possibilities
15 The Causes of Variations
16 A Third Possibility
17 Randomness
18 Explanations and Descriptions
19 "Why?" Questions
20 Necessary Connexions Do Not Exist
21 Causality Adds Nothing
22 "Every Event Has a Cause"
23 Coincidences
24 The Number on the Door
25 Effect's Alarm Clock
26 Networks of Connections
27 The Fluorescent Tubes
28 The Car Accident
29 Different Answers to "Why?" Questions
30 Framework or Strait-Jacket?
31 The Atomic Quicksand
32 'Fitting Things In': A Fourth Possibility
33 Inadmissable Hypotheses
34 Uncheckability-Land
35 Causality a Stumbling-Block?
36 The Coffee Machine Incident A Change in Usage?
37 Conjunctions and Connections
38 A Law-Governed World
39 Law-Breaking
40 Customs Can Change
41 A Logical World?
42 Christian Names at Last Or a Free One?

CHAPTER THREE FREEDOMS AND LAWS

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 The English Library Canteen Freedom in a Caused World
2 Determinisms
3 "As long as I Don't Know..."
4 Predetermination and Predictability
5 Psychology, Neurophysics
6 Proving One is Free
7 Genuine Answers to "Why?" Questions
8 Reasons for Acting
9 No Escape
10 Things We Can Do
11 Teleological Processes
12 Digestion
13 Evolution and Teleology: I am the Purpose
14 A Causal Web Round the World
15 Freedoms in Physics
16 "Let's Go to the Pub." Some Unlikely Stories
17 Traffic Lights Again
18 Cars and Billiard-Balls
19 Back to the Car Men and Machines
20 The Car Won't Start Putting it Right
21 Driving to the 'Volunteer' A One-Way System
22 The Policeman, the Institute Evasive Action
23 The Walk by the River Scientific Laws and Legal Laws
24 Causes of Criminality
25 Treatment or Punishment?
26 An Anarchist's Fantasy
27 Providing Excuses
28 Aristotle: Compulsory Reading
29 'Personality': a Category-Mistake
30 Revenge, Reform, Deterrence
31 The Joys of Motoring
32 Freedoms Bring Responsibilities
33 The Role of the Police
34 Saving Life
35 The Health Service
36 Social Phenomenon or Social Problem?
37 Real Dangers
38 Determinism Self-Verifying
39 The Pub's Still Open!

CHAPTER FOUR: UNIVERSALS AND FAMILIES

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 At the 'Volunteer' Word-Games
2 The Demand for Definitions
3 What is a Table?
4 Don't Think, Look!
5 Universals
6 Realism, Plato
7 Nominalism
8 Effect's College Rooms Wittgenstein
9 What is a Game?
10 Family Resemblances
11 Forms and Patterns
12 Philosophers
13 New Resemblances
14 A Family Photo
15 The Analogy Fails
16 Recognising Things
17 Spot-the-Family
18 Family Resemblances In the Mind?
19 Genes
20 Inherited Characteristics
21 Beneath the Surface Again
22 Living Together
23 More Racist Assumptions
24 A Wide-Angle Lens
25 A Choice of Patterns
26 Only a Photograph
27 Being Born
28 Cutting Cords
29 Tea-Break Parents' Rights
30 Child-Bearing a Moral Act
31 We Have the Technology
32 "I Can Help It"
33 Totalitarianism?
34 Child-Bearing and Child-Rearing
35 A Case for Law?
36 I Know my Rights!
37 The Wrong Reasons
38 Suitable Parents
39 Family Life
40 Despite the System
41 Alternatives
42 'Natural' Bonds
43 Inheriting Names
44 It Won't Wash
45 Motherhood, Fatherhood
46 Effect's Photo The Ideal Family
47 Up For Grabs
48 Back Into the Melting-Pot

CHAPTER FIVE: GOODS AND MORALS

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 At the Cricket Match Every Game Evolves
2 We Have To Start Somewhere
3 Recommendation the Name of the Game
4 The Nom-de-Plume
5 Effect's Moral Sense: the Positivists' Problem
6 What is a Good Car?
7 Subjective or Objective?
8 Goods Form a Hierarchy
9 Goods and Functions
10 A Choice of Pyramids
11 Goods and Uses
12 Meanings and Uses
13 Uses of Language
14 What are Morals?
15 Good Bombs
16 People Have Morals
17 Ways of Behaving
18 Doing One's Job
19 Moral Equality
20 Moral Goodness Elusive
21 Public Morals
22 Utilitarianism
23 'Natural' Morality
24 Subjective or Objective?
25 Effect's Dilemma: The Function of a Man
26 What is a Good Man?
27 Moral Ideals
28 Greek and Christian
29 Selflessness
30 In the Genes?
31 Hume on Sympathy
32 Sympathy a Mechanism
33 Benevolence a Virtue
34 Trying to Bridge the Gap
35 Hume's Humanity: the Perfect Ambiguity
36 Wherever one Pitches Camp
37 The 'Is/Ought' Passage
38 Hume's Recommendation
39 Dimensions of Mentality
40 Moral Truths
41 Recognising People
42 Immorality and Racism
43 Moral Goodness Objective?
44 'Absolute' Morality

CHAPTER SIX: GODS AND MODELS

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 Walking Back to College Effect is a Christian
2 Christian Scientists
3 What is a God?
4 Existing as
5 The Greek Gods
6 History and Myth
7 Gods Form a Family
8 Supper in Hall The Pre-Socratics
9 To Arche (Greek) of the World
10 Effect's a Vegetarian
11 The Whole Gamut
12 The Senior-Common-Room-to-be What are Atoms?
13 Effect's Second Story: the Nature of Matter
14 The Idea of Elements
15 The Periodic Table
16 The Fudging Starts
17 More New Words
18 Into the Nucleus
19 Isotopes
20 The Pattern Lost
21 A Very Strange Chemistry
22 Out of Our Depth
23 Quarks
24 Gobbledegooks
25 Cause's Theory
26 Tracing Resemblances
27 Physical Objects and Mathematical Objects
28 Some Unusual Language-Games
29 Naming Atoms
30 Objects of Perception?
31 Aids to Seeing
32 Microscopes, Animals
33 Non-Visible Light
34 Images
35 'Obtaining Results'
36 What Do We See?
37 What is a Photograph?
38 Being Visible
39 Seeing Things
40 Interpretations
41 Whose Duck-Rabbit?
42 Bewitched by Philosophy of Language
43 Picasso's Guernica
44 Perception and Intelligence
45 Seeing Atoms, Seeing God
46 Taking Things Literally
47 What is a Model?
48 What is the Model?
49 Algebraic Functions with Names
50 'Meta' Family Resemblances
51 From Logic to Physics
52 Beyond Verifiability
53 Priests and Scientists
54 A Political Juggernaut
55 Indoctrination
56 A Little Psycho-Analysis
57 Memories of School
58 Recommended for the Priesthood
59 Too Late to Recant
60 Only Small Boats
61 The Philosophy Option
62 Lip-Service

CHAPTER SEVEN: PHYSICS AND METAPHYSICS

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 The Walk back to the Car Personal Motives
2 What is Metaphysics?
3 The Positivist Attack: a New Definition
4 A Necessary Partnership
5 What is Gravity?
6 A Working Compromise
7 Staking out the Territories
8 The Criminology Car-Park The Concept of a Wall
9 The Walk to Cause's Flat Get it Right!
10 Discovering Things
11 Hypothetical Histories
12 Alternative Models
13 Technology and Metaphysics
14 The Technique Top Ten
15 Knowing About Things
16 Indirect Links
17 Number Ten
18 The Well Now Dry
19 Technology Irrelevant: Back to Behaviourism
20 Changing the World
21 Down the Wrong Road
22 What was Einstein?
23 Rationalism and Empiricism
24 Plato and Particle Physics
25 A Sexist Theory of Knowledge
26 State Changes and Atomicity
27 The Notion of an Object
28 What is a Gas?
29 Imagination Running Away
30 Scrap the Lot!
31 Mountainside Madness
32 Effect's Third Story: Modern Cosmology
33 What is a Star?
34 Mapping the Sky
35 Star Evolution
36 How Do We Know?
37 What is a Galaxy?
38 How Do We Know?
39 What Are We looking At?
40 The Redshift
41 Cosmological Facts
42 Relativity
43 Whom is Scientific Explanation For?
44 Bending Out of Sight
45 Lapsing Into Meaninglessness
46 The Big Bang
47 Receding Credibility
48 Quasars
49 Gravitational Collapse
50 Black Holes
51 The Last Horizon
52 No More Light
53 A World of Words

CHAPTER EIGHT: ABOVE OLYMPUS

Page Setting Topic of conversation
1 Cause's Flat Coming Clean
2 Practical Realities
3 Our Gods Have Failed Us
4 The Functions of Myths
5 Cause's Model
6 A Light Show
7 The Scientist and the Philosopher
8 Naming Forces
9 Cause's Drama
10 The Prologue
11-19 ACT I
20-21 Interval
22-26 ACT II
27-30 Interval
31-35 ACT III
36 Gut and Glass and Glue
37 A Fading Shot The Cold Light of Day


Suggested cover/dust-jacket design

Throughout the book, a number of key objects and images recur. I suggest that these be used to make an ordered design (say in rows of 3 across and 5 down) on the book's cover, and include:
  1. A Photograph of a battered MGA Sports-car in an urban street
  2. An artist's impression of a Carbon Atom (electrons green, protons red, neutrons white)
  3. A Photograph of a red and a white billiard-ball, just touching
  4. A Photograph of a young woman's face; sternly beautiful, with cropped hair
  5. A Photograph of a village green cricket match
  6. An artist's impression of the Planet Earth in space
  7. A Photograph of the Spiral Galaxy M31 in Andromeda
  8. A Drawing of a set of traffic-lights
  9. An old (black & white) Photograph of a family group (2 adults, 3 children)
  10. A Photograph of a Chimpanzee
  11. A Photograph of a Bomb
  12. A Photograph of a Greek Statue
  13. A Photograph of Ants swarming
  14. A Photograph of the Sea and
  15. at the centre of the design, a drawing of a book, on the cover of which a hand-held fountain pen is writing the words: "MAKING NAMES by Andrew Malcolm"


INDEX of philosophers referred to in the text (chapter.page). Also, certain scientists and other writers and some key scientific or philosophical terms. Underlining indicates quotation.

Aeschylus 8.4
Anaximander 6.9
Anaximenes 6.9
Aristotle: on voluntary action 3.28, 4.12; on goods 5.9ff; on moral ideals 5.25ff; 'elements' 6.14; 'metaphysics' 7.2
Atoms, atomic numbers 1.49; neon 2.29; atomic weight 2.31; atomic theory 6.13ff, 7.13, 7.25ff
Ayer, A. J. 1.46, 1.55, 4.12, 6.45
Behaviourism 1.44ff, 1.93, 5.14 , 7.19
Berkeley, Bishop George 1.66ff, 1.107, 4.12, 6.42
'Big Bang' theory 3.16, 7.46ff
'Category Mistake' 1.52, 3.29
Carbon 1.49, 1.72; carbon-compounded 1.94, 6.15ff
DNA molecule 1.74ff
Dalton 6.13ff, 6.25
Darwin 1.71ff
Deduction 1.13ff
Democritus 6.11, 6.25
Descartes 1.38, 1.54, 1.63, 4.12, 6.51
Determinism 3.2ff
Einstein 7.18, 7.21, 7.22, 7.42ff
Electra 4.39, 8.4ff
Electrons 2.29, 6.17ff, 6.27ff, 7.14ff, 8.6ff; e. microscope 4.18, 6.34ff
Empedocles 6.11, 6.14
Empiricism 1.44, 2.11, 7.23
Epistemology 1.52
Euripedes 8.4
Existentialism 3.29
Genes 1.74ff, 4.18ff
Gravity 5.22, 6.56, 7.4, 7.49
Heraclitus 6.9, 7.14
Heisenberg 3.15, 6.61
Hume, David: on causation 2.4-8, 2.20, 2.7, 2,37, 2.39, 4.12; on sympathy 5.31-35; 'is/ought' 5.37ff
Induction 1.13ff, 2.5
Isotopes 6.6ff
Joyce, James 6.23
Leucippus 6.11
Logical Positivism 1.44ff, 5.1, 5.12ff, 6.47, 7.19
Mill, J. S. 1.19ff, 4.12, 5.22
Newton 1.45, 1.104, 7.4ff, 7.42ff
Nominalism 4.7
Oedipus 4.39, 8.4ff
Ontology 1.52
Organic chemistry 1.72, 1.94
Parmenides 6.10
Picasso's Guernica, 6.43
Plato 4.6ff, 4.10ff, 4.12ff, 5.25, 7.24
Periodic Table, the 6.15, 7.11
'Polar concepts' 1.36
Protons 2.2, 6.17ff, 6.27, 8.7
Pythagoras 6.10
Quarks 6.23ff, 6.27, 7.16
Rationalism 1.44, 7.22ff
Realism 4.7
Ryle, Gilbert 1.44ff; Concept of Mind 1.48 ff, 4.12
Socrates 4.11, 4.12, 5.25
Sophocles 8.4
Teleology 3.11ff
Thales 6.8
Utilitarianism 5.22
Verification Principle 1.46ff, 1.55, 6.45, 7.3
Wittgenstein: 'I' 1.105; family resemblances 4.8, 4.9ff, 4.12ff; meaning & use 5.11ff; the duck-rabbit 6.40ff


Author background

I: was born in England in 1948 into the hert of the green-belted middle-class; was educated at Tonbridge School, gaining a scholarship in Natural Sciences to Queens' College, Cambridge, where I took a three-year course in Philosophy ('Moral Sciences' as was), receiving by B.A. (M.A.) in 1971; travelled extensively in Europe (East and West), India, the Far East and Russia; settled in Brighton and for four years held a number of adult education lecture courses in Brighton, Haywards Heath and the surrounding areas. It was as a result of this lecturing that the ideas and arguments involved in Making Names began to take shape.


Go to the next item, or the previous item in the Evidence (red) file.

Go to Malcolm's Statement of Claim, to the Case History, to the Affidavits: Ivon Asquith (1), Asquith (2), Henry Hardy, William Shaw (solicitor) (1), Sir Roger Elliott (1), Margaret Goodall, to the Witness Statements: Elliott, Hardy, Richard Charkin, Nicola Bion, Goodall, to the courtroom testimony of the Oxford Six, 14/3/1990: Elliott, Goodall, Bion, Asquith, Charkin, Hardy, to the testimony of Andrew Malcolm 13/3/1990, to the Chancery Court Judgment, to the Appeal Court Judgment, to the Damages assessment, to the Settlement agreement.

Return to the Malcolm vs. Oxford I (1984-92) Index, to the Malcolm vs. Oxford II (2001-02) Index, to the blurb for Making Names, to its reviews, to The Remedy, or to the SITE INDEX.