| No. | Day | Date | Home | Score | Away | Competition | Attendance | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sat | 12/7/08 | King's Lynn | 3-2 | Cambridge Utd | Friendly | ??? | |
| 2 | Wed | 23/7/08 | Soham Town Rangers | 2-4 | Cambridge Utd | Friendly | ??? | |
| 3 | Sat | 26/7/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-3 | Coventry City | Friendly | ??? | |
| 4 | Tue | 12/8/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-3 | Kidderminster | Conference | 3008 | |
| 5 | Sat | 16/8/08 | Cambridge Utd | 2-1 | Barrow | Conference | 2663 | |
| 6 | Sat | 23/8/08 | Eastbourne B | 0-3 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 2105 | |
| 7 | Mon | 25/8/08 | Cambridge Utd | 0-2 | Kettering Town | Conference | 3489 | |
| 8 | Sat | 2/9/08 | Ebbsfleet | 1-1 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 1832 | |
| 9 | Sat | 6/9/08 | Cambridge Utd | 2-0 | Wrexham | Conference | 3076 | |
| 10 | Sat | 13/9/08 | Cambridge Utd | 2-1 | Torquay Utd | Conference | 4041 | |
| 11 | Sat | 20/9/08 | Mansfield Town | 1-1 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 3171 | |
| 12 | Sun | 28/9/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-0 | Grays Athletic | Conference | 2971 | |
| 13 | Tue | 30/9/08 | Spalding Utd | 3-0 | Grantham Town | Unibond League President's Cup | ??? | |
| 14 | Tue | 7/10/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-0 | Lewes | Conference | 3194 | |
| 15 | Sat | 11/10/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-0 | Weymouth | Conference | 3981 | |
| 16 | Thu | 16/10/08 | Forest Green R. | 2-2 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 789 | |
| 17 | Sat | 18/10/08 | Mildenhall Town | 3-2 | King's Lynn Res. | Ridgeons Premier | 129 | |
| 18 | Sat | 1/11/08 | Cambridge Utd | 0-0 | Rushden & Diamonds | Conference | 3547 | |
| 19 | Sat | 8/11/08 | Kidderminster | 1-0 | Cambridge Utd | FA Cup 1 | 1717 | |
| 20 | Sat | 15/11/08 | Crawley Town | 2-2 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 1570 | |
| 21 | Tue | 18/11/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-0 | York City | Conference | 2914 | |
| 22 | Sat | 29/11/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-0 | Ebbsfleet | Conference | 2807 | |
| 23 | Sat | 13/12/08 | Histon | 2-3 | Cambridge Utd | F.A. Trophy | 1146 | |
| 24 | Sat | 20/12/08 | Cambridge Utd | 4-0 | Salisbury City | Conference | 3340 | |
| 25 | Fri | 26/12/08 | Cambridge Utd | 2-2 | Histon | Conference | 6488 | |
| 26 | Sun | 28/12/08 | Cambridge Utd | 1-1 | Stevenage | Conference | 3351 | |
| 27 | Wed | 14/1/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-5 | Crawley Town | F.A. Trophy | 1233 | |
| 28 | Sat | 17/1/09 | Cambridge Utd | 4-1 | Woking | Conference | 2696 | |
| 29 | Sun | 1/2/09 | Rushden & Diamonds | 1-2 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 2058 | |
| 30 | Sat | 21/2/09 | Lewes | 0-2 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 962 | |
| 31 | Tue | 24/2/09 | Grays Athletic | 0-1 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 754 | |
| 32 | Sat | 28/2/09 | Cambridge Utd | 1-1 | Crawley | Conference | 3231 | |
| 33 | Mon | 2/3/09 | Histon | 1-1 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 2579 | |
| 34 | Sat | 7/3/09 | Cambridge Utd | 2-0 | Burton Albion | Conference | 4377 | |
| 35 | Tue | 10/3/09 | Cambridge Utd | 2-1 | Mansfield Town | Conference | 2781 | |
| 36 | Sat | 14/3/09 | Cambridge Utd | 4-1 | Northwich Vic | Conference | 2662 | |
| 37 | Sat | 21/3/09 | Downham Town | 2-1 | Cornard Utd | Ridgeons League 1 | 46 | |
| 38 | Tue | 24/3/09 | Mildenhall Town | 1-2 | Cambridge Regional College | Ridgeons Premier | ??? | |
| 39 | Sat | 4/4/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-1 | Forest Green | Conference | 3245 | |
| 40 | Tue | 7/4/09 | Stevenage | 2-1 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 3408 | |
| 41 | Sat | 11/4/09 | Cambridge Utd | 2-1 | Eastbourne | Conference | 3391 | |
| 42 | Mon | 13/4/09 | Kettering Town | 1-2 | Cambridge Utd | Conference | 2340 | |
| 43 | Sun | 26/4/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-0 | Altrincham | Conference | 7090 | |
| 44 | Mon | 27/4/09 | CUFC Legends | 4-3 | Cambridge Utd Youth | Friendly | 1703 | |
| 45 | Thu | 30/4/09 | Stevenage | 3-1 | Cambridge Utd | Conference Play Off Semi Final Leg 1 | 4446 | |
| 46 | Thu | 4/5/09 | Cambridge Utd | 3-0 | Cambridge Utd | Conference Play Off Semi Final Leg 2 | 6507 | After extra time |
| 47 | Sun | 17/5/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-2 | Torquay Utd | Conference Play Off Final | 35089 | @ Wembley |