| No. | Day | Date | Home | Score | Away | Competition | Attendance | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tue | 7/7/09 | Ely City | 0-3 | Cambridge Utd | Friendly | ??? | |
| 2 | Wed | 8/7/09 | Cherry Hinton | 0-9 | Cambridge Utd | Friendly | ??? | |
| 3 | Sat | 11/7/09 | Cambridge City | 2-2 | Cambridge Utd | Friendly | 605 | |
| 4 | Tue | 14/7/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-4 | Blackburn Rovers | Friendly | 1813 | |
| 5 | Sat | 18/7/09 | AFC Sudbury | 0-0 | Cambridge Utd XI | Friendly | 180 | |
| 6 | Wed | 22/7/09 | Cambridge Utd | 1-1 | Barnet | Friendly | 823 | |
| ? | Sat | 25/7/09 | Stamford AFC | 0-4 | Gainsborough Trinity | Lincolnshire Senior Shield QF | ??? | |
| ? | Sat | 1/8/09 | St Ives Town | 0-5 | Cambridge Utd | Friendly | ??? | |
| ? | Mon | 3/8/09 | Cambridge Utd | 1-2 | Histon | Cambs Prof Cup | 886 | |
| ? | Sat | 8/8/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-2 | Barrow | Blue Square Premier | 2990 | |
| ? | Tue | 11/8/09 | Ebbsfleet | 1-3 | Cambridge Utd | Blue Square Premier | 1523 | |
| ? | Tue | 18/8/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-1 | Crawley Town | Blue Square Premier | 2733 | |
| ? | Sat | 29/8/09 | Cambridge Utd | 3-0 | Gateshead | Blue Square Premier | 2417 | |
| ? | Mon | 31/8/09 | Rushden & Diamonds | 1-1 | Cambridge Utd | Blue Square Premier | 2344 | |
| ? | Sat | 5/9/09 | Cambridge Utd | 7-0 | Forest Green | Blue Square Premier | 2646 | |
| ? | Tue | 8/9/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-0 | Altrincham | Blue Square Premier | 2749 | |
| ? | Sat | 12/9/09 | AFC Wimbledon | 0-0 | Cambridge Utd | Blue Square Premier | 4128 | |
| ? | Thu | 17/9/09 | Newmarket Town | 1-3 | CRC | Ridgeons Premier | ??? | |
| ? | Sat | 19/9/09 | Cambridge Utd | 2-0 | Wrexham | Blue Square Premier | 2823 | |
| ? | Sat | 26/9/09 | Cambridge Utd | 3-4 | Luton Town | Blue Square Premier | 4870 | |
| ? | Sun | 4/10/09 | Histon | 1-1 | Cambridge Utd | Blue Square Premier | 2371 | |
| ? | Sat | 10/10/09 | Cambridge Utd | 4-0 | Ebbsfleet | Blue Square Premier | 3668 | |
| ? | Sat | 17/10/09 | Hayes & Yeading | 3-0 | Cambridge Utd | Blue Square Premier | 744 | |
| ? | Sun | 25/10/09 | Lincoln United | 1-3 | Cambridge Utd | FA Cup 4Q | 837 | |
| ? | Sat | 31/10/09 | Cambridge Utd | 2-0 | Kidderminster | Blue Square Premier | 3508 | |
| ? | Sat | 7/11/09 | Cambridge Utd | 4-0 | Ilkeston Town | FA Cup 1 | 2395 | |
| ? | Sat | 14/11/09 | Cambridge Utd | 0-2 | Kettering Town | Blue Square Premier | 3088 | |
| ? | Tue | 24/11/09 | Cambridge Utd | 2-2 | Rushden & Diamonds | Blue Square Premier | 2612 | |
| ? | Sat | 28/11/09 | Cambridge Utd | 1-2 | York City | Blue Square Premier | 3505 | |
| ? | Sat | 12/12/09 | Cambridge Utd | 3-1 | Luton Town | FA Trophy 1 | 1665 | |
| ? | Sat | 16/1/10 | Cambridge Utd | 0-1 | Eastbourne Borough | Blue Square Premier | 2969 | |
| ? | Tue | 19/1/10 | Cambridge Utd | 2-2 | Eastbourne Borough | FA Trophy 2 | 913 | |
| ? | Sat | 23/1/10 | Cambridge Utd | 0-1 | York City | Blue Square Premier | 2646 | |
| ? | Tue | 2/2/10 | Cambridge Utd | 0-0 | Salisbury City | FA Trophy 3 | 1237 | |
| ? | Sat | 6/2/10 | Eynesbury Rovers | ?-? | Peterborough North Star | United Counties Div 1 | ??? | |
| ? | Sat | 13/2/10 | Cambridge Utd | 2-2 | AFC Wimbledon | Blue Square Premier | 3087 | |
| ? | Sat | 6/3/10 | Norwich Utd | 1-3 | CRC | Ridgeons Premier | ??? | |
| ? | Sat | 3/4/10 | Gateshead | 2-0 | Cambridge Utd | Blue Square Premier | 841 | |
| ? | Sat | 1/5/10 | Ipswich Wanderers | ?-? | Saffron Walden Town | Ridgeons Div 1 | ??? | |
| ? | Sat | 8/5/10 | Steve Fallon's Legends | ?-? | Cambridge Utd XI | Steve Fallon Testimonial | ??? | @ Abbey Stadium |
| Due to my poor record keeping during the 2009/2010 season there could be some matches missing from this list. |