Under New Labour, everyone should just pay taxes and do nothing politically incorrect, so do not act upon this information. I have no wish to be closed down like other useful websites from threats by parasitic lawyers. The dogs of law lie around every corner. As lawyers get richer, society gets poorer.
This text is available to view as there are not enough high
quality trikes out there. If you like the text, please offer
feedback as this helps me to refine the contents. I'm here to
help.
Lots of other stuff via the website at
www.btinternet.com/~jhpart./index.htm.
Being long term unemployed motorcycle mechanic, technology and
science teacher, marine and nuclear engineer, B.Sc, B.Ed. and
draughtsman, I'd like a job. Please consider this monograph a
bit of a C.V.
Feel free to email me at jhpart@btinternet.com
Because of a plague of litigious lawyers infesting the planet,
nobody should read this, nor ever attempt
to act upon
the following information.
Frame design I.
Engines II.
Transverse engines.
Differentials.
Frame design II.
Bike frames.
Front ends.
Steering head.
Forks.
Building the frame.
A build sequence.
Main components.
Seats.
Gearchange.
Steering.
Controls.
Brakes.
Parking brake.
Clutch.
Fuel system.
Carbs.
Cables.
Fuel injection.
Cooling.
Radiators and aerodynamics.
Wheels.
Exhaust.
Engine adaptations.
Other bits.
Wiring.
Load carrying.
Keeping it tidy.
Testing.
Non destructive testing.
Destructive testing.
Final Testing.
Extras.
Shells.
Aerodynamics.
Welding.
Basic tool kit.
Basic materials check list.
Redesign.
Invalid bikers.
Finally.
Begging.
Useful info sources.
This monograph is a bit long. Don't try reading it all in one
go, (I wouldn't.)
I'd recommend a skim through, then properly read each section
when you need it.
I've kept it down to just the basic stuff, plus some of the more
interesting bits and bobs. There is almost no arithmetic and
certainly no maths, leaving you to gauge trike structural and
handling requirements by using common sense and non arithmetic
geometry assessments and other ways to make your trike handle
better from the design stage onwards and also make it safer.
If anyone wants the maths, physics and geometry stuff to be
added, I'm a licensed engineer and have a science degree, just
ask !
This monograph does not get to building a trike until about half way through, which is far different to the design processes of most trikes I have seen, and it shows.
For the wiring, well that's another (42,000 word) story, also freely available on my website.
I help design and build trikes, from mini's to V12 fuel injected
trikes. These trikes can out-handle rally cars on corners, and
Jags on the straight. I build custom trikes and trike
modification kits to order, if local, see appendix. If you want
to build the worlds ultimate trike and do it on a sensible
budget, just ask.
I'm unemployed, so feel free to ask for free advice.
NOTE: The following is based upon personal experience and is for guidance only. No-one should try building such machines without reasonable abilities and know that injuries can ensue from the materials, tools and from riding of machines. Those using this information do so entirely at their own risk. Fully understand the implications and dangers before building, testing and riding.
This monograph is aimed at those who wish to learn from a
hands-on approach using commonly available technology. The
intention is to make trike design and manufacture available for
all.
This is not a 'stick part A to part B' type of guide, neither is
it a 'how I built a trike' guide.
It is exactly what it's called. - A Builders Guide To Trike
Design.
Attention is drawn to the fact that there are few other
reference works explaining the technical and theoretical
application of similar machines, mainly regarding on single
front wheel - dual rear wheel stability.
This monograph is how to design and build a trike is a full
process, from initial idea to final testing and beyond. You will
be expected to use YOUR brains to design and build and test YOUR
dream trike. This monograph should hopefully keep you on the
right path, and hopefully help you build a much better trike. If
you are prepared to learn, and want a better trike, welcome.
I have many emails from those who have built trikes and can't get them to handle, often from simple failures of design. Not everyone gets to find this website before venturing into trike building, and although I commend their wish to trike, the pitfalls are still there. Therefore there is an appendix called Redesign, so for those who suffer this part of trike building. One poor chap spent eight thousand pounds on his trike and could not get it to handle, and is now doing a compete rebuild. This is mainly for those like him, I hope it may help many others too.
Getting it right is not simple, but neither is it unduly
difficult, as many home builders can manage excellent machines
without expense. Yet far too many trikes start off as a good
idea, but often suffer with poor design if any, with bits bodged
on as and when needed. Some trikes that are road legal simply
frighten most people; we all know what we are talking about.
I often get people emailing me asking for advice after an expert
has built them a trike and it handles appallingly because it is
of such bad designs.
In some of these photos I see excellent welding, new tubing and
a big workshop, but although the mechanic is working to their
best, it simply is not enough. A good mechanic is all to often
not a chassis designer, the ability to design a trike is
desperately in need of more than just simple mechanic work. I
hope this helps make a mechanic into an engineer, and then a
designer.
A mechanic is a person who repairs by replacement. but never
bothers to find out why it fails. (Usually a GNVQ monkey).
A fitter is a skilled mechanic who can repair by repairing the
worn or damaged items, and thus find out why it fails and if
possible, eliminate the original fault. (Usually a time served
apprentice under the tutelage of a skilled old bloke who has
seen it all before.)
An engineer knows the underlying design of a piece of
engineering, and the theory behind it, but may not have the
skills to make or repair the item, so has to get a skilled
person to do the job. (Often a college trained manager or
freemason.)
A designer not only understands the underlying theory, but has
the skill to design structures and machines from scratch, then
understand why they fail and redesign further. A bad designer
will need a PR manager or MP to cover up the crap. A good
designer will be venerated - Brunel, Mitchell, Issigonis, Dyson.
(Ships and rail, Spitfire, Mini, Dyson.)
I realise that most who build trikes are not engineers nor
perfectionists, but usually know that a better trike is
possible, hence this monograph. So I've written the following to
help them look a little further - towards a better trike.
It is the common failure to develop the fundamental machine in
the initial stages that is usually the main reason why so many
potentially good trike concepts remain less than perfect.
Designing a trike is not just a case of building the nearest
idea that will work. Anyone can design a simple machine, and
many trikes look like they are thrown together rather then
designed. Take your time to think first, only then can you build
the best.
This monograph does not want the reader to follow like a sheep,
as this simply limits the readers boundaries. This monograph is
a means to help develop the initial idea for a dream machine.
It is possible to make a simple trike such as welding a Austin Metro subframe to a bike frame or a couple of scaffold poles, or fixing forks on the front of a VW with a bit of box-section, but a triker's life could, and should be far more exciting.
To make life more interesting and highlight what this can
involve, the following is based on a a good 'ole car engined
trike approach with the whole frame designed from scratch, with
bike framed trikes also considered where appropriate.
The following describes a path through the design stage, the
building jungle and traps, to properly testing and fettling a
working machine.
From this, the sculpting and other options are then discussed.
This monograph is aimed mainly at designing the larger, car-engined trike and is based on first hand experience building trikes which out-handle sports cars in the bendy bits of the road. The processes are not expensive. Many excellent machines are built on a small budget and good wits.
Each trike will be different to what is described herein, but the guides and suggestions will be applicable to all. It's assumed that the reader is able to rebuild an engine and know the basics of transmission and suspensions. If not, the workshop manual of the donor machine will help.
For first timers, it's best to build to a budget at first, then to decide if to modify, elaborate or simply try again.
I hate spending money because I don't have any. Only the foolish
or rich can waste money. Great art is not expensive to create.
A budget trike can also be a work of art without compromise. It
can be easily based on a fairly sensible (and surprisingly cheap
or free) car engine. The cost of creating a well-built trike
need not be expensive, thereby allowing for a few tries or major
modifications before the final form is acceptable. The processes
described herein are all fairly cheap and can enable a good
working trike to a sensible budget.
Even if the first attempt does not work well, rebuilding a frame
is not as bad as it may seem, as a total rebuild does not
require making new steering head, gearchange nor a host of other
re-usable components, leaving just the frame tubes to be
re-designed.
Flourishes can be added later, such as a full engine rebuild,
better wheels, seats and paint. This should be done preferably
once the basics are refined to a level where it stonks around
corners, stops on a sixpence and performs reliably.
The basic costs are a decent welder or paying for the services
of a professional welder, the cost of an almost complete donor
vehicle, usually a car and also the steel tubing. See check list
at end.
Tools are minimal, but an angle grinder (20 quid) and a good
second hand engineers vice (40 quid) mounted on a strong
workbench make for a much easier life and are always worth the
cost. (Some concrete blocks and two halves of a scaffold pank
make a perfect workbench.)
The only real costs are having the steering head, spindle and
slab yokes made professionally, although even these can be
circumvented as described later.
Both the donor vehicle and stock metal tubing are surprisingly
cheap.
I can build almost ANY trike for about three hundred quid using
a scrapped donor car. So can you.
The biggest cost is time and effort. Time and effort lead to
good design, accuracy and good handling.
This monograph is long and I doubt if anyone will follow all the possibilities, but even if just a few aspects mentioned herein are of use, then I hope it can lead to a better trike.
Your ideas will change, perhaps as your wife and kids hassle you
for better seating, while you prefer sleeker styling, meaner
look. There are a thousand and one other needs, such as where to
put the shopping. Yes, trikes are often used as day to day
transport for shopping and to take the kids to school.
When the rough outline gets close, follow up with simple plan
and side sketches to decide how the engine, kids, shopping and
macho image will eventually fit into your design. This takes
time and many a good cuppa or beer, usually over many weeks or
months.
A trike by it's very nature is a lifestyle statement, but this alone should not be seen as justification for a second rate machine. If making a lifestyle statement, be it high tech, post-apocalyptic in style, or a sculptured art form on wheels in the Italian style, then make it a superb example. Do not accept second rate.
All good trikes start with a clean sheet of A4 paper and a pencil. After dozens of sheets, the design will flourish and evolve far beyond the original concept.
For those with garage or other floor space and enthusiasm, buy a
roll of pain wall paper, often known as lining paper. Join two
ten foot lengths together with a little glue to give a large
sheet to draw the machine full size in side view, which can be
rolled up when not in use or pinned to a dry garage wall. A
full-size side view is important. This will greatly help getting
much of the design right, including the weight balance, centre
of gravity, rider seating, deciding the vertical forces and the
frame design. A full-size side drawing is also very important to
ensure the side view styling will be as good as possible.
The other side of the paper can contain most of half a plan
view. As lining paper is cheap, simply use more paper for the
plan. For those with dedicated garage space, then the basic
machine can be drawn roughly full size in chalk upon the floor,
modified with a damp cloth as the design progresses.
Drawing full size gives the best chance for the fundamental
design and overall styling to be refined. This saves time and
money, by allowing the engine layout and seating to be thought
through and refined before purchasing anything. Always note that
full size drawing do not always look the same as what you
imagine. Stand next to an ordinary car and imagine that if you
drew this on the wall, it would look to small to get into. For
this reason you will also be drawing full size shapes of the
rider and passengers. If drawing on the lining paper or on
floor, then time to sit down and draw some outlines. Welcome to
ergonomics.
Decent centre lines can be painted on the most level part of the
garage floor, allowing the chalk ideas to be regularly
re-developed. A taught string accompanied by two strips of
masking tape each side followed by a narrow line of paint. For
those who seek total accuracy in poorly painted lines, accurate
scribe lines can be made in the paint with a knife blade.
Eventually an idealised layout must be decided. If deciding to build around a specific engine, then that is OK. Trikes can be built engine first, or style first. But there is no need to decide on a specific engine before designing the trike, as there is a vast choice of engine layouts available for fitting into almost any trike design.
The next step is to draw a trike and a stick man on your sketch
pad.
It does not have to be accurate, simply measure the probable
wheel diameters, relative to the stick man, e.g, wheels up to
the knee. Check by standing next to the potential choices of
donor car, to find how far up the leg the wheel is, then place
the feet toe to heel across the front or back to get the overall
width across the wheels. Welcome to research.
To make a scale drawing, measure your height, divide by four or
whatever is usable to get a scale drawing of the wheel
arrangement and a man which roughly fits the page. Make a note
of the scale on the page.
Then measure the outside width of the driven wheels of the
potential donor vehicle and make a basic plan view using this
wheel width and centre line. (Plan view is looking down from
above.)
If a scale drawing is too much hassle, simply use approximate
drawings.
Before buying a donor vehicle, buy the workshop manual and
sketch or trace the engine and wheels onto the pad first. Do
this in side and plan views. The intention is to get a general
shape of the engine to see where any awkward problems may arise.
Once these drawings are reasonable, draw the lines much bolder.
Now use this general arrangement of engine and wheels to slide
under the pages to help make many more drawings. With side and
plan views of the engine and wheels, then this easy drawing
system will allow a large number of designs to be easily
created. It is not unknown for two or three different engines to
be drawn allowing a better range of options for the final
design.
It is now much easier to make many drawings of the machine in
various forms, styles and passenger layouts. Usually done at
work or while watching TV, and may probably become more
interesting for all the family. If the kiddies want a parasol
top or twin rocket launchers, then at least they are becoming
part of the design process and may soon grow up to learn a lot
faster about design, technology and style than other kids.
The design associate involved with taking the kids to school and
the shopping will be much more dedicated in certain concerns,
such as a cool luggage compartment so the ice cream does not
melt above the exhaust on the way home from shopping.
Even a family friendly trike can still be an intimidating
machine to other road users, or an art form, often both.
Design many times, to build the best once.
Study the workshop manuals or actual machines.
Many engines in the front of cars can be moved rearwards in a
trike. This applies to both in line and transverse engines.
Decide how much further to the rear the engine can be moved to
give better overall trike balance. The typical front wheel drive
transverse engine, wheels and transmission can be positioned to
the rear as one lump. A traditional in-line car engine can
shorten the prop shaft.
Draw the various options to slide under the sheet until the
engine can be repositioned until ideal, or to see where it can
and cannot go. The stick man rider and passengers will compete
with the engine for room, but a good accommodation of all should
ensue.
As time progresses, there will gradually develop a need to have
an engine with perhaps a specific shape, layout, mounting,
gearchange or braking system. The range of possible proportions
and layout is priceless knowledge.
As the ideas gradually fall into place like a jigsaw puzzle, the choice of engine will become more defined. This is where paper simply saves so much hassle later - the process of creating a better design from the start. There are many trikes which suffer from the outset from using less than ideal layouts. Only the reader will know whether the choices will work well and also look good later.
By having a basic drawing of the engine and rear wheel layouts over which to trace, it is possible to draw up many different chassis designs. The front wheel can now be positioned wherever it will give good style and balance with a decent turning circle. The stick man will give overall scale, which is very important to get the ergonomics and all-round proportions and the styling close to the real thing.
When building any trike, get the basics right and many of the details well-sorted before the hard work starts, so there will be fewer hassles, possibly none. Make sure it's fun, a trike made with loads of hassles from the outset will always be second best. The best way to eliminate most hassles is to get it right before starting the hard work or spending money. The reader may not know the problems, so drawing will help highlight the many ways a dream trike can become a nightmare, and so prevent problems later. Brain work done in the first few months will save more than three times the effort later - guaranteed.
By taking time in the early stages and constantly refining the design, the builder will enjoy watching the original ideas grow and flourish on the paper. By gradually working though the design, finding better or easier alternatives or work-arounds for major problems, the processes will develop fewer hassles, and finally design an effective machine, perhaps the trike to beat all other trikes. Engine choices may change and refine, seating will get better, and overall profile will gradually evolve towards the perfect shape and form.
Should your kids one day point at an Italian sports car and decide the cut lines are 'totally incongruous', then smirk quietly and consider becoming a design and technology teacher.
I receive many requests from emaily interwebby-land. Here is a typical example.
A Yamaha 1100 V twin modified into a trike and a perfectly
acceptable choice. The owner had many problems with it and
emailed me as the mechanic he hired seemed less than happy to
solve them. I suspect this builder had no pipe bender, and
although not vital, it does help produce a nicer machine.
There are superb welds, but also some classic trike design
problems.
The arrow points towards the white mark on the rear wheel
showing that accuracy is probably good and that the basics are
understood, needing just a little initial thought prior to
making a much better design. The mechanic knows the need for
accuracy, but has not taken time to design the trike on paper,
and thence refine the design for greater strength, less weight
and less hassle.
The Yamaha 1100 front end was standard right back to the swing
arm. This shows a lack of courage to modify parts, especially
the prop shaft and the wheel drive shafts.
Because it was a shaft drive, a ford rear end was used and there
is nothing wrong with this, although I'd use something a little
less heavy. Both engine and trans are very reasonable starting
choices. What was wrong was the serious lack of forethought. So
please, please, please use the paper and pencil before anything
else, as it solves so many problems and always makes for a
happier trike and a happier mechanic.
The propeller shaft from the engine to the diff was left at its
original length, and therefore the rear end was too far to the
rear that it put nearly the weight over the front wheel and it
became atrociously heavy and possibly dangerous.
A possible solution:
As this is a fixed rear differential, then there is no need
whatsoever for a long propeller shaft. Even a sliding spline
link need only slide a millimetre or so, to allow for chassis
flexing and engine fitting play. Therefore cutting down a prop
shaft needs only the grinding of the weld and sawing the tube
much shorter, then welding the end accurately with a set square
and file. Then spin and balance between a couple of spikes, or
with the wheels off. Prop shaft end pieces are usually made with
a stepped machined face, so are fairly easy to fit. Because the
modified prop shaft is much shorter, balancing it is also
easier.
The angle of the prop shaft to the differential will need it to
be offset, and this not a problem, as the motorcycle pros shaft
is designed to work at angles causes by a moving swing arm.
Like many, the rear end is far too wide and so shortening the
left drive shaft will have two advantages: It allow a less wide
trike, and also allow the differential to line up with the bike
shaft would be much neater, and the overall width would be
decided by the right hand drive shaft length, the other being
shortened, Both left and right side wish bones wold be matched
to the shortened left hand side.
I believe the prop shaft length and inability to solve it from
the outset, has led to most of the heavy front end problems.
This in turn causes poor handling.
(Perhaps the mechanic was not a designer or fitter. A
designer would see the need for a shorter prop shaft. A fitter
can cut and shorten the prop shaft, then balance and thereby
redesign a better trike. Anyone can see that the engine on the
far front would need a short rear end to improve overall
balance. Anyone can learn to use a hacksaw, file, set square and
welder to shorten the prop shaft.)
With a short prop shaft between engine and differential, (and
another shortened prop shaft on the left drive side,) the
overall balance of the machine is far better, much less weight
is placed over the front wheel, preferably a similar load to
that of the original machine and would be far closer to a good
trike.
But there is much more to be done before I could live with this trike chassis. The radius arms are appalling, the shock mounts are poor, it's far too heavy and has no style or shape. None of this costs money to resolve.
Secondary solutions.
Staying with this example, the width at the rear was atrocious.
I believe that lithe trikes are better.
Therefore I would also shorten the LEFT shaft from the diff to
the wheel axles, buy cutting, shortening then sleeveing and
balancing, to bring the rear wheels in about 20 percent closer.
This would also align the diff to line up with the bike shaft
output. I would also check if there were any mass dampers on the
original wheel drive shafts. Then make sure both wishbones are
identical, but the diff offset to one side in the frame a little
to optimise the diff alignment, and reduce overall width of the
machine.
The wishbones could be triangular, . more akin to Formula One,
etc, a little narrower and designed to match the left side, and
would allow a stronger central frame.
The minor offset of this fixed mass could be offset by placing
the battery appropriately so the axle loadings are impeccably
balanced.
The wishbones could be a lot sexier, and they also looked
identical in length for upper and lower, units, which is another
wasted opportunity. The wishbones have no triangulation, so
under power, they will want to bend forward along the horizontal
plane as an unstable four bar linkage. For this reason,
wishbones are usually triangular as shown in my sketch.
The trike example will need to change them from a rectangle in
top view, to an upper and lower pair of triangles. I would have
made the lower triangular wishbone extended forward, with the
extended front tube pivoted in simple rubber block to take the
acceleration and braking loads, thus making the upper wishbone
lighter and leaner for easier passenger room. The bottom
wishbone does most of the work as it has the suspension unit
mounted on it, so it takes most of the load. Therefore the upper
wishbone can be smaller and used mainly to maintain geometric
accuracy when the wheel moves up and down.
In the example, there is also no cross piece between the lower
rear wishbone mounts, so this part of the frame is prone to
spread dangerously under load and will cause steering problems
but welding one would permanently prevent the diff being
removed, while a bolted version would place undue stress on
bolts unless well designed. I would weld the lower tubes and
employ an upper, bolted tube in compression for easier removal
of the differential. The shocks in this example are poorly
placed and offset. The vertical shocks, just under the arrow are
not the happiest of items.
As an extra to the design, and to reduce unsprung mass and
improve style, the ford diff has fine set of six bolts on the
output of the diff, and to this I would contemplate fitting
motorcycle discs outboard of the diff, so that I could use wire
spoke or three spoke alloy wheels with a very light, clean and
open look.
My sketch is for a car engine, whereas the trike example with the Yam 1100 bike engine will need a shorter rear sub frame, unless the forks are greatly extended to ensure the front wheel does not take too much of the load. Never put more then half the trike load on the front wheel, preferably less.
If needing a low profile for perhaps a top rack or seats, then
two lighter shocks on each side (4 in total if carrying many
burly bikers) is preferable to maintain balance, although it
would look much nicer to take the opportunity to use Formula
one technology and fit compression struts from the bottom
wishbones to shocks mounted horizontally above the differential.
This would also allow the shocks to be adjusted in leverage to
match the final rear axle loadings and also allow the horrible
upper structure to be removed to leave clean lines.
The superstructure is also most likely to push up and bend if
not supported with a stay tube from the present upper shock
mount to a point on the lower tubes, preferably near the diff to
prevent bending. The best solution is to mount two small
motorcycle shocks either side of the lower wishbone outer pivot
and have these shocks either side of the prop shaft to a low
upper mounting. Such shocks are often available from 125 and
250cc bikes, - so choose a commonly scrapped bike for donor
parts. A simple rear end would be to place the shocks on the
upper of the axle housings and fit a small triangular
arrangement to the frame over the differential should it be
needed.
(I have shown this picture a second time, to save the reader
from having to scroll up and down, and takes no extra room on my
website.)
Simple rebuild option:
First, shorten the left drive prop shaft to bring the
differential more in line with the bike shaft, then move the
differential forwards to take the load off the front wheel. Then
cut the frame tubes beside adjacent the bike frame and move the
whole forward to an optimum front prop shaft length and
alignment. The width of the bike frame will allow a slightly
offset differential.
Mount the differential offset as needed, then build the long
side wishbone first, then make a symmetrical copy for the other
side using a cut down drive shaft for a narrower trike. The
shaft is cut shorter near the inside splines, then welded,
sleeved and welded futhur.
Then position the bottom of the shocks close to the prop shafts
to minimise distortion, then decide the shock loading, and mount
the tops of the shocks accordingly, while allowing reasonably
supple suspension.
Because the new frame tubes do not reach up far onto the frame, then there is a natural tendency for the upper rear tubes to bend the frame tubes inwards, This bending force would be reduced with a shorter frame, but must be checked nevertheless. This should be checked under a load of sandbags or a bathtub of water, and see if the rear engine bolts are too tight to remove, indicating a distorted frame which could crack the engine casings. If so, then I'd recommend that the upper tubes are welded higher, by making a bend in them - and then at the bends, adding a triangulating tube down to the bottom tubes where they meet the lower bike frame.
Although this trike is not finished, there is no lateral triangulation in this frame. As a trike does not lean, there is a far higher lateral, (sideways) loading on the frame and this frame most definitely needs a triangulation in the horizontal plane. Therefore a tube on both the upper and lower sections between bike and diff will be needed. By making them the same looking downwards, the side loads will be even, but if placing one as a X cross to the other, then there is a chance for a torsion twisting if the vertical load is too large. So keep it simple and symmetrical for best handling.
Nice ankles:
Here is a nice example of a trike rear end I just happened to
find parked at my local shop.
The axles originally had MacPherson struts, but have been
beautifully crafted to take adjustable upper wishbones.
This is a nicely done rear end, although a little heavily built because it's a chain drive GSX. It also has nice adjustable inner links to adjust the camber and resolve the acceleration and braking forces well. The shocks just miss the prop shaft for a neat arrangement with an almost central shock force resolution under compression, thus improving handling when cornering.
Apart from the whole assembly being closer to the engine as
mentioned, the bottom wishbones could be better if pivoted from
more forwards of the frame to assist acceleration and braking
forces more safely into the frame, with rubber ftont wishbone
bushes from a small car or from a 250cc bike swing arm.
The rear shocks are very neat, strongly supported and may be
close to the original Yamaha shock angles. Frame triangulation
could enable the differential to be removed, probably by using a
few spacers on the through bolts holding it in place, so the
rear end is well triangulated for resistance to flexing. Adding
an anti roll bar would be simple, with just a couple of U
brackets under the frame and rubber sleeves to take a standard
car anti roll bar, and bolt the ends in rubber, in U clamps near
the base of the axles, near the shocks.
The other photos shows how the lower car shock mount has been
neatly employed for the wishbone pivot mount.
I would implore all trike builders to contemplate a few
similarly neat arrangements.
Consider the simple 3D graphic, which shows what is possible
with sketching before turning to metal.
This is not complex and is just plain old standard arrangement
found in many trikes and kit cars. - Just look and learn.
The bits are out there for pennies, beautifully made - so use
them.
Other notes.
Like all trikes, the example 1100 Yam car rear end uses discs,
so parking brake may also be a pain.
I'd consider adding a parking brake by fitting a small
motorcycle disc on the propshaft flange where it enters the ford
diff, then mounting a simple mechanical or hydraulic brake
calliper onto this, restrained by a bracket on the frame such
that any excessive braking forces are resolved parallel to the
disc to prevent distortion. A drum brake is also possible for an
easier life, - but make sure it is a bike rear brake, as this
allows the brake to be applied forward and in reverse, whereas
some drum brakes have twin leading shoes and only work well in
one direction.
In such cases, the owner often say the trike handles very poorly
and pulled to one side. After emails, it transpired the forks
were out of alignment, and presumably need straightening or the
front end was not aligned accurately in the vertical plane. Many
people use a tape measure between the centres of the wheels and
the steering head, but fail to check the steering head is
vertical relative to the rear wheels. This is why I leave the
front end until last on complete frame builds, so my machines
are supremely accurate.
Other potential problems could have been sticking rear brakes or
uneven wishbones, or incorrectly aligned rear wheels with
perhaps toe out or non symmetrical alignment.
The owner also said the trike was hard to steer, a classic complaint. I recommended shortening the prop shaft and rear frame first, to take some of the load off the front wheel. Then if this was not enough, trying a little toe-in to see how it feels, (rear wheels pointing just slightly inwards at the front, so the outside wheel takes most of the load and helps turn the machine in the desired direction). If this was not enough, then slotting the upper yoke central hole slightly then shimming it forwards slightly to reduce the amount of trail, which should make the handling more skittery, but as it was too heavy, then this should eventually reach a happy medium,- but ONLY after careful high speed tests and possible use of a steering damper if any signs of potential problems occur.
This trike rear end could be totally rebuilt over a weekend
using the same items, plus a hacksaw, welder, tape measure and
some thought, to make it as good as any trike.
If the mechanic is reading this, please do not be offended, as I
have seen much worse. - You will find that shortening prop
shafts is quite straightforward, and then much of the rest
should fall into place. I would also consider using the donor
Ford rear suspension wishbones and also the ford handbrake and
hydraulic linkages for an easier life.
Some trikers minds are seriously warped - trust me on this. But luckily, most trikers minds are about right, close to, but not too far from the real world. This is the best place to be.
From the outset it is necessary to get the handling right.
Handling is theoretically imperfect for a single front wheel.
But all the theory and science to the contrary has not managed
to make itself apparent on many a good handling trike - so it
can be done. The theory and trike riders who like power drifts
do not always agree.
The main problems are weight balance, decent rake and trail,
good wheel alignment and of course, the overall set-up.
Basic chassis design will always be dependant upon the engine, causing the design to require certain engine mounts and the way the transmission and wheels are manufactured relative to the engine.
Weight balance is a moot point on trikes, but for general awareness, the following can be considered:
With equal weight on each of the three identical wheels,
basically, neither wheel will want to break away first, for
ideal grip.
Unfortunately most trikes have wider rear tyres and a narrower
tyre at the front.
Worse still, when cornering, the outside wheel will become
loaded, while the inner gets light.
Worse still, such rear tyres have a flat profile, while the
front is probably a partially rounded section because of action
of forks, with their large rake angle compared to cars.
On a heavy loaded front wheel, the traditional motorcycle fork
leg suspension may often be close to its limits (unless
specially designed).
When cornering, the inside rear wheel unweights dependant upon
cornering forces, and will allow the inside wheel to break away
first, causing slippage in the differential. Never rely on any
wheel break-away as a good idea. It is not.
From this you will realise that too many trike tyre choices have more to do with style than engineering.
But good style can still include responsible or even superb
engineering choices.
The engineering choices of balance and traction while cornering
or braking are notorious on trikes, so always do yourself a
favour; consider the better choices from the outset.
If worried about imbalanced wheel sizes and loads and
footprints, then just consider how much weight is on each wheel
while stationary, then decide if it is ridiculous or adequate or
good.
While cornering, consider the wheel loads and how they will or
will not help the tyres in doing their job.
Also while braking, the loads on the tyres will need some
reasonable balance or brakes modified to ensure the braking is
done sensibly and safely.
If is for such reasons that some car engines cab benefit trikes,
so they can give more optimised weight balance over the rear
wheels.
(Car engines are also free and very cheap to maintain. the cost
saved on a bike engine can pay for the whole build of a decent
trike. Yes, I highly recommend you build your perfect trike for
mere pennies - I do.)
As the fundemantal part of the design process is likely to cause
worry, the process is described in more detail later, but please
do not worry too much at this stage: Just make sure your overall
design looks reasonable and not too stupid, unless a purely show
trike.
For road use then simple common sense is usually acceptable.
Ride as many trikes as possible.
If not, ask all owners how they handle, especially around
corners. Always take the opportunity to study the way the
various trikes handle to check what is happening at the
boundaries of the ride envelope, then ride within a safety
margin.
You do NOT have to thrash someone else's trike to discover how
well it handles.
I simply park up and have a few minutes looking at the trike
firstand guess where any faults may lie. The ride and build up
the braking speeds and cornering to discover where any faults
are, then again decide where the problems(s) lie, and re-test
using body lean to see if this improves feedback. Gradually
build up the speeds around your favourite twisty roads. I then
park up and have a few minutes looking at the trike again.
Get to know the break away signs and refine the riding reactions
necessary to control them. See testing later. Unless the trike
balance is good, then take care and consider the weight
distribution carefully.
I have yet to ride a truly decent trike, or at least one that comes up to my standards of handling, although I have ridden a few that are very close and can ride the pants off sports cars. (Thanks Spike !)
Do not get overly worried, as many trikes have terrible weight balance yet are quite adequate for most purposes of daily transport. If building a better machine, consider that, although most cars, including factory rally cars, they often have the engine in the front and the driver too, with a lightly loaded rear, yet they still handle fairly well. For a much better approach, formula one cars usually prefer a mid engined design, with weight distribution between 45/55 to 40/60 percent front/rear. This is not always possible on some trikes, but a mid mounted engine greatly helps.
So : For a single front tyre, aim for around equal load on each
wheel, giving about a third of the weight on each wheel. Then
adjust to match the front wheel size. If it's a light, custom
front wheel, then reduce the weight on the wheel more than if
the front wheel is a car wheel.
In the worst case such as a VW trike, with the engine hanging
out the rear, this may even require front weights. At the other
extreme, this may not be possible with a Jag V12 trike without
serious modifications and a strong front end.
Sensible engine choice and overall layout of engine, wheels and
riders is going to pay dividends later. Aiming close to a
sensible weight balance is unlikely to do any harm.
Making trikes with bike engines and frames is a doddle.
If you want to use a bike engine but make a new frame, then the
following chassis design also applies.
The bottom line is that using car engines is the best way for
maximum stonk for minimum pennies.
Car engines are the main way described in this monograph, as
there are many more variations with car engines than with
motorcycle engines. The only hassle with motorcycle engines and
frames is fitting a differential and rear axle(s), as described
in detail later.
Note: Do not use a car engine with a narrow power band, as
changing gear on a trike is not so well controlled as in a car.
Choose an engine with a wide power band, so you don't have to
change gear while diving in to a fast corner, where removing
your hand from the handlebars can lead to poor control.
Modern electronically controlled metal tapered belt auto
transmissions are excellent ways of beating most vehicles off
the starting grid.
Only use fiery engines if they have an automatic transmission or
have electronic 'paddle' gear changes. (Yes, you can fit paddles
to handlebars.)
When it comes to car engines, most trike builders begin knowing little about car engines. This is not surprising, as nearly all trikers are bikers and most car engines are boring.
Welcome to the wide and wonderful world of the infernal combustion engine.
Car engines are a wide world of inline fours and sixes (mainly
boring cars, with a few exceptions), transverse fours and fives,
yes, fives!, V6 and V12's. (Transverse Lambo V12s are rare.)
Flat fours and sixes (VW's Porches, Subaru, Alfa Romeo), Vee and
flat twelves, inline V6, V8's, V12's and a whole lot more.
If it's not there, then bikes can furnish V twins, fours,
transverse, 2,3,4's and sixes. If looking long enough, the
builder will be spoilt for choice.
Or perhaps one or two bike engines.
Perhaps a snowmobile or small aircraft engine.
Jets are mentioned later.
The local newspaper adverts and scrapyards are ready to offer some serious metal. Start by looking at the cheap cars section in papers, as many excellent donor vehicles, usually with rusted chassis, are available for spares or for next to nothing.
When starting your hunt for the engine, go for the whole
package, in both design and in building.
The prime concern for a trike is overall layout of engine and
transmission relative to the wheels and overall weight balance.
We now live in the age of political correctness gone mad. But I
highly recommend you hunt out a few scrap yards.
Scrapyardin' used to be a traditional British hunting sport and
I have the old oily, scarred dockers leather boots to prove it.
I was taught by an expert: Thanks Andy.
The only thing missing from scrapyarding as a British working
man's sport was copper top boots, hunting pink jacket and a
horn.
The usual rig was an old pair of boots, big pockets a pair of
pliers, 'Stilsons' and a multi point screwdriver.
Oh - such happy days.
(Stilsons shown bottom in the 'how to fix a tap web page').
Today, due to the assholes of the burEUocracy, there are very few old-style scrap yards which will allow builders to scramble over their stock. This is a great shame, for inspiration always comes from looking. When up to the ears in rusty, bent and twisted metal, one always spots a new idea, a little jem, a new concept or design possibility. Occasionally one will spot a truly worthy machine, from which inspiration can flow in torrents.
Before going to the local scrapyards, stroll off to your local
library, if there is still one. Sit close to the workshop
manuals and similar vehicle publications. Work through them,
study the layouts, their possible options etc. Always take the
sketch pad for notes, tracing paper or some cash for the
photocopier. If you have a digital camera, then use it to good
effect. I'm occasionally found in various sections of libraries
reading and often clicking away. Even if the ideal engine is not
found, at least what to avoid will be learnt the easier way.
Most trikes can be built on a tight budget, so knowing the
basics with simple research is a good way to save money, time
and effort: It works every time.
If you find a suitable engine, then you will be either buying
the manual, or taking lots of photos. As digital photography is
pennies, then snap away. Don't forget the specs page and fitting
sizes, and ignition diagrams. If you can take the book out for a
week, then do so and photo or scan every page, so it does NOT
get dirty when returned. If the pages are dirty in some places,
then always take note of this and additionally scrutinise the
donor vehicles in this specific area.
I don't dislike dirty or badly thumbed books, as they can tell
much more than any pristine tome.
(Tip for college students. - Always go to the library as soon as possible before anyone else. Then check the racks for your subject. Then look for the most popular book, usually many copies, and check all of them. Hopefully one or more will be annotated in pencil in the margins and this is the area which you need to study well. Such an annotated book saves a lot of time and helps get higher marks. Always annotate books with light pencil marks in the margins. Never use highlighter pens. Learning from boringly written computer screens certainly makes the process sterile. )
There are two main forms of car engines as used in trikes, either with the engine between the riders legs at the front, or hidden at the rear, between the rear wheels.
Free monkey.
Once a general idea is created using your preferred form and
layout of engine and transmission, check out and find the local
friendly scrap yards. If scrap yards are not local, or are less
than their normal friendly type, then get to know engines by
simply looking under as many bonnets (hoods) as possible, as
there is no substitute for seeing the real thing first. This
will lead to a working knowledge of what engines are good, bad
or indifferent.
The best alternative is to help out in a garage, or preferably a
large scrapyard for a few days, especially if unemployed,
ideally in exchange for a donor machine. Just ask, you may be
pleasantly surprised.
"Hi mate, need any help? - I can sort out that pile of plastic
and alloy or whatever needs doing, in exchange for a half decent
ending engine for a project I'm doing. No cash, just mutual
benefit."
They may ask you to do a small test sort or clean, and then, if
you are not completely incompetent, may ask you back in the
morning for a couple of days work.
Make sure you turn up in tough clothes and boots, be honest with
them. If no immediate work, leave your phone number and mark it
'free monkey in exchange for car engine', they may get a rush of
vehicles and need some help soon, possibly during the new car
registration season.
Not only will you get a cheap motor, you will also know how
machines are actually held together and work. If you get this
lucky, take notes and always stroll around during your lunch
break.
In whatever way is available, helping out ALWAYS helps to understand the underlying engineering and makes for a good, short and very effective apprenticeship.
Car engines offer a wide expanse of options.
Although weight balance is poor, engines like old VW's are easy
for trikes, as the engine, gears, final drive and suspension are
all in one lump and set up ready for use. Even the gearchange is
a doddle.
Never take the easy option - you will have to ride it.
Some engines can be very difficult. What looks simple may have major design flaws. Look, think, then buy. Be prepared to scrap the engine if a better design is found, as there will be a lot of time and effort put into building a good trike. When done properly, the trike may be kept for decades, so if a better design of engine turns up, be prepared to go for gold. The best is to spend time getting the ideal 'generic' engine and transmission from the outset, so time and effort spent choosing the best donor vehicle is never wasted. It need not be an expensive version donor vehicle at this stage, as the better engine can be fitted later, possibly the later turbocharged version if the trike handles well enough.
If buying a V8 off a friend because it's going cheap, you may be going about this the wrong way.
Heavy engines at the front tend to understeer.
Engines at the rear tend to oversteer.
Engines with too much weight behind the rear wheels such as VW's
can have you pulling wheelies in second gear every time you pull
away. Great fun the first few times, but when you get annoyed
doing it every day, you may think differently.
Engines with iron cylinder blocks are heavy.
Engines with dubious reliability or poor spares backup should
always be steered clear of.
Engines: An example.
Here is the crankcase of a Porsche V8 engine, from the front
engined versions which have a terrible reputation for
reliability, (Because the yuppies drive them in to the ground
without bothering with servicing). These often get sold for
pennies. A car for spares for 500 quid and a runner for 1,000 to
1,500 quid. This includes matched transmission, serious brakes
and all the other bits, including the badge and key fob - and
probably the T shirt if you suffer from excess of vanity or are
a poser.
Such machines give the trike builder many excellent starting
points, not only in engine, but transmission and most important
of all, a low slung engine and plenty of serious stonk.
Note the engine is unlike some V8's; It is perfectly balanced,
eight cylinders in 90 degree format, just like having 4
Ducatisthat'll do nicely !
For this engine, a low, all alloy and more racing character
would be inherent in the design, more than any aftermarket
custom catalogue could ever hope to achieve. Built properly, it
can also be very reliable.
See also sketch of Porsche V8 transmission for a complete, well
balanced, yet nicely overpowered trike design.
I am not advocating the fancy German crap as the only choice,
far from it. But with car engines, for bang per buck, you can
not only get excellent power, handling, but also get that
feature missing all too often - charisma.
It all boils down to choosing the best donor car or bike for
you.
You simply cannot buy the fundamentals of a real custom machine
from catalogues, no matter how much you spend.
You may prefer to start with a bike engine and end up with an
overpriced Harley motor and cute frame, but they all look the
same from a distance. I now tend to yawn at (yet another) Harley
custom.
So please think about going for gold, not spending cash like a drug dealer looking for another 'Hardly Maybesome'.
Another good choice is the Citroen 2CV, 600 twin engine. Yes,
you read correctly.
This is at the economy end of the engine world, but is a superb
example of having an almost ideal trike engine if you don't have
an overdeveloped ego or a fat belly.
The weight is forward of the rear axle and very low, with
inboard brakes and the gear linkage on the top.
Such an ideal layout can be built with a rear suspension design
similar to formula one. Only the upwards exhausts are a minor
problem. This makes a superb two or three seat trike for general
use at normal speeds.
I see these motors being relentlessly thrashed across France.
They are simply indestructible and I consider them far more
reliable than Porshes or Harleys.
For a large capacity compact and low engine, with fuel injection
or carbs, then this is a water-cooled VW motor I recently played
with and makes a very low profile option to most standard car
engines.
For most of us, the classic choice is the bog-standard transverse front wheel drive, four cylinder water-cooled car engine and transmission. These are often available for free.
Whatever you choose, the whole engine and transmission and wheels can be moved to the rear of a trike design for minimal hassle. Only the gearchange and rear passenger seating may be problematic, so check first for the best design choices. See later.
These are just three of many very different yet good possibilities.
To repeat; Do lots of homework, then enjoy the pleasure of knowing you have the best design route towards your version of perfection. Take your time and use some imagination to get the engine, transmission and wheels with the perfect shape and layout. Searching library, scrapyards, garages and workshops is the best way to see how engines, transmissions and suspensions are arranged. Take your time - as the more you know, the more you will understand how to build your ideal machine, and the fewer the hassles.
When a good choice is made, search the local ads for a suitable
and cheap test failure, and always get a receipt and the
documentation. Don't get fobbed off with excuses.
No documentation - no purchase.
It may be necessary to place an advert for an unusual machine.
If all else fails, then it's the scrapyard again. With a little
common sense, you may wish to search for a specific machine in a
special way, such as old four wheel drive Subarus which are
often left neglected by farmers, so go a huntin' and ask around.
I know of two rather excellent if rather rusty Subarus in
farms that I have lined up for future customs. - They just need
me and a customer needing a trike, to make them very happy
again.
Wherever possible, ensure the engine, suspension and ancillaries
are all from a single donor machine so it all fits together and
works properly. Ideally the donor machine should have failed for
something which is not needed on a trike, such as rusty
bodywork.
Ideally the engine should run and the whole machine may often be
driven back, complete with receipt and paperwork.
An ideal trike would have the engine, transmission and final drive in one unit to minimise alignment problems and with the weight forward of the rear wheels. There are quite a few almost perfect engines out there, but in the real world, no engine will be perfect for every aspect of every trike design.
In an ideal world, a donor vehicle will be a serious crunch job,
(preferably with no blood or body parts in the driver area),
with only 10 miles on the clock and no real damage to the parts
required. As these types of machines are soon stripped for
spares, keep your wits about you and carry cash when hunting.
For beginners, it is far better to build with an older version
at first, then keep an eye out for a pristine engine later.
Decide how these strange engine and transmission shapes will fit
into your design.
Have a good long look at anything promising, then chat to the
guys in the garage trade and scrapyards. Tell them what you want
and they will tell you if it's a dog or a doozie. If you don't
see your dream machine, they can often tell you where to start
looking, and what at engines are going to be close to what you
need.
For example, if intending to use an Alfa, ask the Alfa garage
what problems are common. Don't ask the salesman. If you want
the truth, go around the back and ask the mechanic. Wait and ask
the mechanics at lunch time, when they are not busy and never
annoy. A good scrap yard should be able to advise you if you
know what to ask. Do your homework first, and think up just
three best questions to ask them. Any more then three and like
most mechanics, they will want to get back to work, unless it's
a ciggie break.
You may not be buying the donor machine from the scrap yard, but
you will probably find them very useful later on, for larger
wheels, exhaust bits, special tail lights, and a host of other
componentry. Scrap yards are often required to write off
vehicles, you may not be able to get the paperwork from them,
requiring the builder to get a new identity for the machine, so
receipts are a must.
So preferably privately buy a rough but legal donor vehicle for
its identity.
Your ideal engine and suspension layout is out there somewhere,
you just have to hunt it down.
For example. An Alfa Romeo engine unit lay in a corner of a
local scrapyard. I had never noticed these engines before, but
it had promise, the 1500 OHC flat four engine lay forward of the
rear wheels, with the engine, gearbox and final drive in one
unit. It even had the luxury of inboard ventilated discs on the
gearbox output shafts, to allow wire wheels for a very clean
look. A few faults would need working around including the total
lack of carbs, gear linkage and engine mountings. As the bulk of
the problems will be in design and preparation, this is a good
example for designing and making a trike.
As the machine did not have a body shell around it, a search for
a second donor machine was immediately begun. This was
eventually found, so that by the time the chassis was built
around the first engine, a second, running engine was ready for
transplant, complete with all the ancillaries - no need for an
engine rebuild, or excessive new wiring etc. As the Alfa is
popular with junkyard racing, a totalled, barely running but
'complete' machine was almost free, but needed a few spares to
look nice, and a very serious service.
The Alfa unit is in many ways similar to a VW, except it points
the right way, forward, with the engine weight forward of the
rear axles. In style, the Alfa is a poor man's Ferrari, as the
rocker covers will polish up nicely and sit either side of the
rider, with the Alfa Romeo logo in resplendent polished alloy.
In ease of build, it is similar to a VW, because the engine,
gearbox and differential are one piece, even better as the
brakes are inboard ventilated discs. Being water cooled it was
quieter and would allow a lower body shell and allow alternative
radiator layouts.
To make life easy, make sure you get any subframes, suspension,
gear linkages, clutch and brake cylinders, wheels, propshafts,
carbs, water gauge, electric ignition, and everything else you
need. Buy it all the same time as one car, so they work
properly, it's also much cheaper than buying separately.
Where possible, fire up the engine and check for a good motor. A
crash damaged or badly rusted vehicle is the best bet for a good
engine, as its unlikely that the engine has caused the machine
to be scrapped. For rust, Italian cars are excellent, as they
have alloy, fiery, twin cam engines, but may be atrocious for
spares - so check.
Don't choose an engine you cannot get or afford parts for.
Before paying out a large amount of money for a donor vehicle, first try buying a cheap, but unusual new spare part for the engine. If you can't get or afford it, think again !
If it's your dream engine, be prepared to build up your own
spares supply from scrap donor vehicles.
A friend has a Citroen SM car, with its Maserati V6 engine with
everything polished, even the con rods, a superb and truly
wonderful classic car, but a totally irresponsible choice for
any trike.
If, like most sensible builders, you choose a common donor car, you will enjoy buying a new set of brake discs and pads for less than the cost of a set of motorcycle brake pads. Even a new set of four alloy wheels with new tyres can cost less than a big bike tyre, and the scrap yards are full of excellent items at exceptionally happy prices. It can truly be surprisingly cheap to build a very good trike to a high specification when based on a typical donor car.
In these days of political correctness and recycling, many car dealers will buy an older make so as to sell a new car to the same owner. The y may well have old Volvo (other makes available), siting in the back of a dealership which were bought to sell the new car. They may even sell it to you for one pound ! It may even be road legal and you may even be able to drive it home. Try - they can only say no if you ask politely.
I've got my dream engine!
Clean, check and run the engine, if you find any serious damage
or noises, forget it.
For a front wheel drive, where possible, get the scrap dealer to
grind out the engine complete with engine mounting brackets and
such like. Preferably get the whole engine bay, right back to
include the dashboard and steering, you will then have all the
necessary wiring and mountings.
If rear wheel drive, get the whole machine.
The better choice is to buy the whole machine, run the engine
and fettle it, then preserve it carefully. Most scrap yards will
deliver a wreck to your door. (An unusual experience, it's
usually the other way around.) Such machines can be found
locally for pennies, usually MOT failures with mostly rust
problems.
The best way is to search the papers for a cheap car and drive
it home. If there is no paperwork, or you cannot drive it, don't
buy it.
Once you have got it all back home, there is often only room in a garage or garden for either the donor vehicle or the trike. Do not worry. In such cases, metamorphosis gradually removes the unnecessary parts until the core remains still intact - engine, transmission and suspension. Then the trike begins to grows in it's place.
First of all, give the whole donor vehicle a good clean, scrub
the engine and hose off the crud. Check the engine and
transmission works again and to dry it out thoroughly.
The machine will gradually transform until the engine and
transmission sits precariously on the core donor chassis,
supported on wood blocks and wedges.
The wiring loom ends up hanging up in the roof space held
loosely in place wrapped around the attached dashboard like a
demented python. Likewise brake plumbing and other bits.
Do not throw anything remotely relevant away.
If in doubt, keep it in poly bags in the garden (NOT next to the
trash) or tucked away in the garage roof space.
At all stages, you will be prone to loosing an important lug,
bracket, clip or other component. It always happens and will
always happen, so protect yourself from such annoying hassles
from the outset. Refit all nuts, bolts and brackets back where
they came immediately after disassembly and carefully bag all
the rest.
Before touching a spanner, (wrench), make a permanent note of
the outside width of the driven wheels of a transverse engine.
This allows the transmission shafts to be properly aligned
later. It is also important to measure the distance of the
engine / clutch housing face to the nearest wheel. To prevent
later drive shaft and suspension inaccuracies, do not replace
these wheels until the chassis is built. Also measure the ground
clearance of the sump, so the engine will be blocked and
positioned correctly for standard suspension set-ups.
Keep the original car speedo that probably works off the gearbox
to calibrate any new speedo. Same goes for the tacho. Keep the
seats for foam and complete seats for total passenger retainment
systems. Seat belts too. Consider flowery pattern seat coverings
as patterns for remaking any passenger seats in vinyl or
leather. Tail lights, side lights, boot (trunk) lid and its
lock, ignition switch, steering linkage, handbrake lever and all
the brake bits, both front and rear, all into polythene bags and
free from dust, rain or from getting lost.
If you use an automatic transmission, check if setting up the
system will need special access to certain parts of the
transmission housing. If in doubt, keep it intact as much as
possible.
Never use an angle grinder until having removed all the wiring
and hydraulics, as it is possible to cut through something
useful such as a brake pipe or tail light wiring.
Tip from an old scrapyarder: The traditional way to compact a
car shell is to remove the roof, and use it to stow all the
parts as the shell is gradually cut into chunks. Either by use
of a traditional two handed battle axe and heavy boots, (he
Viking heritage of real bikers) or the newer method of angle
grinder and saw.
The petrol 8 inch angle grinder is now affordable for those who
are not afraid to loose their arms and legs. I hate the things.
If on a very serious budget, or suffering wallet attack, then
buy a cheap 4.5 inch angle grinder and a few cutting discs.
ALWAYS buy goggles and gloves at the same time. - Then use them
!
I hang my safety equipment on the grinder, so I have to
remove them before use, - it works for me - it can work for
you.
Continue until just the floor pan is left, into which all else
can be dumped and tied down for transport by trailer to the
local recycling centre.
It is extremely common to have to change a few bits as the design is refined. So keep friendly with the scrap dealers, they will probably have a later model, possibly with turbocharger, as these are harder to find in local adverts, - often having been wrapped around a lamp post.
Car electrics are simple, as the modern alternator is self contained, with a regulated DC 13.8 volt output to charge the 12 volt battery and even a warning light connection which can be ignored if you feel lucky. The rest can be just as simple as you wish.
If you don't like electronic ignition, or if it fails, you can
often replace it with the older contact breaker system of
earlier models if you know their history. Choose your engine
carefully, as many car engines have surprisingly long pedigrees.
Again, talk to the trade to make life easier. Always buy the
workshop manual before buying a donor vehicle, as money spent on
this may save you much money later. Read fully and if all is OK,
you have the manual. If not what you want, you have only lost
the cost of a manual.
If the engine does not have electronic ignition, then you can
make your own, using old bike pulsers and CDI units with
integral electronic advance curves, which use the standard
motorcycle dual HT lead coils, which work just as well with 4
cylinder car engines. Alternatively you can use parts from other
car engines with a similar basic layout, as they are nearly all
the same in their basic formats. See making your own CDI systems
on my website.
The final engine choice will be narrowed down to an ideal, specific engine during the design process.
Often, part way into a project, a completely different engine may be chosen which may improve the design by leaps and bounds. So start with open eyes.
The transverse engine is often a good, well balanced, honest set-up, such as exemplified by the European classic later Ford Escorts. Some engines have the transmission exiting to the rear if the engine unit, while a few others have the engine behind the transmission output. The latter is better for trikes if carrying passengers very low.
Most of these usually employ McPherson struts which may need
widely placed tubing over the top of the engine. Therefore it
may be preferable to design for the engine to be removed from
the rear.
The top of the suspension struts can be resolved without
upsetting passenger room, as most of the braking and
accelerating forces are taken by the bottom radius arm / anti
roll bar, which should be kept 'as is'. This set-up applies to
most common machines.
The McPherson strut can be cut down into a more traditional
suspension setting, made using the bottom parts of the McPherson
strut, to allow a much neater and lower design, more in common
with formula one.
Like the mini, the gearchange and parking brake will be the
biggest hassles, so do your homework. (See gearchange and brakes
later.)
The transverse engine is good for weight balance, allowing the
trike to have most of the weight just forward or to the rear of
the rear wheels, and an open book for the front end. If choosing
a transverse engine layout as used on most front wheel drive
cars, then for ease of adaptation, always choose a design with
the gear linkage on the top of the gearbox. Unlike the real
mini, the engine and transmission is not usually on a sub frame,
so it may be preferable to keep some relevant parts of the
chassis interface to weld to the trike frame tubes.
The front engine in-line. From Moggie Thou (A series) to
Jag V12.
There are always problems with heavy front ends, so always
expect to design with a shortened prop shaft to move the engine
to the rear to improve axle loadings. Always keep the prop shaft
sliding spline. Do not allow dangerous angles on the universal
joints at each end of the prop shaft. Check the differential
movement of a solid rear axle and use a Panhard rod where
needed. Radius arms will usually be needed and are part of the
donor machine.
Independent rear suspensions are usually far better.
The larger engines will cause a heavy front end, and may demand
a car front wheel, so expect to build a heavyweight front end.
The frame will need to support the engine and will probably need
to be a variation of four heavy tubes. Two over the top of the
engine to the steering head, the other from the steering head,
around or below the engine to take the engine mountings. A
massive version of the Norton Featherbed works well if a tube
bender is hired. Box section tubing makes an alternative and is
very strong per unit weight but square section tubing is rarely
stylish unless it's done well. If suitable rectangular section
tubing is available, a wrap around design is possible using
single box beams, or variations on multiple tubing.
The rear axle from a donor van may use leaf springs, so the
trike will require longer lower main frame tubes, but simply
replace with alternatives from the saloon variant. If the prop
shaft is very short, it is better to discard leaf spring set-up
and use radius arms to maintain good angles on the prop shaft as
the rear axle moves up and down, and to reduce excessive frame
overhang at the rear.
There are a few decent rear ends, with notable mention in
dispatches for Jaguar's definitive limited slip differential /
independent drive shaft set-up.
Where rear ends are rarely seen, standard components usually
suffice.
Solid rear axles are not as good as independent rear
suspensions, so choose carefully and be prepared to mix engine
and transmission.
Check the gearing. As most cars use very similar diameter wheels
and fourth gear is usually direct drive and if engine revs are
similar, then gearing hassles will often be minimal. Adjust
gearing with van, saloon, or other gearbox and differential
ratios, or other rear axle units, or more simply with smaller or
larger diameter wheels and tyres. Always check first gear is
sensible and will not cause clutch slip. As most cars are
similar, gearing may not be much of a problem, but always check
first.
Jet engines. If using a jet engine, (extreme show
customs only), ensure the exhaust is deflected for zero back
pressure and with even, positive down forces. (Vent exhaust to
the sky.) Do not allow the exhaust to be deflected such that
wheelies are produced, (unless for show) so keep the rear wheels
just behind any acting point of exhaust pressure.
For 'general' use or close to crowds, do not expect pure thrust
for power, as other road users do not like scorched front
grilles. In such cases, use helicopter transmission set-ups, to
use the power take off turbine and gearing to drive a modified
car transmission. Gears may not be needed, but a clutch is
important. You may need an intermediate gearbox with oil cooler.
You will most definitely need large fuel tanks and also damn
good brakes, as reverse thrust is not acceptable nor practical.
The exhaust may need decent heat and sound shielding.
The intake will need a large screen air filter for road use,
which is impractical, so the intake area may need to be enclosed
in a large box, covered with coarse cloth as a basic filter.
This will help prevent large particle debris from entering,
which is much more common on surface machines. (Most jet engines
work in clean air away from the ground, and can handle a bird
strike or two.) Alternatively, the intakes could be designed to
take 'clean' air from ahead of any wheel turbulence. A large
concertina stack of many car air filters may help, but is
normally unnecessary except in sandy or gritty countries.
Gas turbines are very light and powerful, so don't go stupid and
get something totally unmanageable. Gas turbines are designed to
burn fuel like paraffin, so don't expect to fill up at petrol
stations on the way to the shows. Do not choose turbines which
need excessive start up procedures or equipment. Get all
ancillary equipment including any necessary ground crew support
kit and installation and service manuals. Choose an engine with
a low number of hours since its last rebuild or expect to have
expensive services by officially approved turbine engineers.
Turbines like to work for hours when up to working temperature,
so any stop-start use is likely to reduce the hours between
services. Ensure access is good enough for regular visual checks
of blades. Always retain and use the number of hours run counter
and keep all documentation, especially the maintenance log.
Spares will need to be via specialist dealers. Be prepared to
use 24 volt and exotic electric starting systems.
When a car engine goes bang, usually just the con rod appears
out of the sump. When a jet engine goes bang, there can be a
massive amount of turbine flying in all directions, so inspect
and maintain regularly, and build a serious steel or aramid
guard around the areas of the most vulnerable blade paths,
especially where the exhaust turbine and power take off turbine
are near passengers. These are not toys.
Rotaries. A sensible alternative to a jet engine is a
multiple rotor wankel. (Mazda)
They are small, powerful, light, uncomplex and very smooth. Do
not expect to tune or modify the engine. Exhausts will get very
hot. They drink fuel and will need larger fuel tanks, an oil
tank and need better brakes, but well worth the effort for an
extremely low, extremely serious trike. The RX8 offers 200+HP
from a very small, if somewhat overly complex package.
Whatever the donor vehicle choice, always keep the receipts for the parts and get all documentation. This will show the official inspector that it's not stolen. It may even still have a 'valid' road legal status.
Sound. (Noise).
Anyone who has heard a large Detroit lump fire up, will never
forget the sheer thrill of burbling excess of cubic inches. A
V12 on song is sheer poetry of engineering, while a wankel
rotary makes its own strange music. Playing with noises requires
getting the exhaust correct and tuned in and may not always be
legal, so always make sure there is also room for a legal
exhaust system or a butterfly valve in the pipe.
Looks. (Style.)
Style of engine is very dependant upon two main facts. Status
and aesthetics. For some, it may be possible to get away with an
amorphous blob or ugly engine if it has the right badge. Many
high status engines are ugly, but to be truly perfect, an engine
must look good.
Looking good for a front engined trike, the engine must be
alloy, at least a V six, so the pipes look good, and with decent
rocker covers. This must then be backed up with crankcases and
heads which will also look the part. An iron block with oil and
fuel pumps sticking out is not perfect. A sleek alloy lump,
clean, neat and devoid of plumbing and wires will always polish
up and look the part - light and powerful.
There is a Rolls Royce Merlin engine in the Imperial War museum in London in a glass case. It has style, clean looks, perfectly detailed and finished components, a magnificent number of oval exhausts and a superb name resplendent on the rocker covers. It is also nice to know that these engines are still thrashed regularly in air days and spare parts are still easy to get. (I recently asked a Supermarine Spitfire owner if engine parts were hard to get - he said 'about 24 hours'.) If you ever get the chance to look inside one of these engines, the highly polished camshafts and other components will leave a lasting memory.
Trikes too, can choose from a similar array of much more available and appropriate, yet equally resplendent engines. In the real world, there is still an excellent range of engines for day to day triking.
Unfortunately, engines also require air filters and other items, if only to reduce the intake roar and prevent excess wear. Therefore make ancillary items either hidden as much as possible by mounting the air filter under the seat and using subtle ducting, or a rethink to make them part of the overall style.
Here's a few pointers to engines of note.
Please note that the engine descriptions in this monograph are
as used in a trike, not as used in the donor vehicle.
No apologies for aiming high.
No apologies for leaving out many also-rans.
No apologies for comments.
When choosing an engine, only the builder can call the shots.
Rear engine in line. (Engine behind the wheels.)
Older VW's and 'real' Porsches - don't bother unless you like
wheelies.
Mid engine inline. (Engine just in front of rear wheels.)
Subaru flat fours, good trike material and ideal for powered
trailers.
Some Alfas.
Citroen SM with dated V6 Maserati engine, be prepared to get
lost in the plumbing. If you chose this, I will happily attend
your meeting with Madame Guillotine.
Ferrari flat twelve's, - mmmm, nice, but perhaps just a little
too pretentious?
For low budgets Citroen 2CV and '4CV'. If disabled, get the
version with the optional automatic clutch. 2CV's are thrashed
mercilessly across France on a daily basis and seem to last
forever.
Front engine in line. (All must have a suitable prop shaft to
shorten.)
Model T Ford - don't even think it, or I will personally perform
your lobotomy.
Porsche water cooled V8. A fine piece of metal, low and light
for the power. Well worth a look, but don't expect to get a
genuine workshop manual. A surprising number of automatics
available, and very cheap too.
Jaguar V12's. Sheer music, but how far will a tankful get you?
(It still works for me.)
Rover and American V8's - join the clan.
Mazda wankels. Surprise yourself - get really low for stonkin'
around corners. For high power, compact engines, the latest RX8
Wankel (1300cc) offers 200+HP.
Gas turbine jets. (Usually from helicopters. You will have
serious hassles becoming road legal, but Frank Bell and Spen
King at Rover Cars managed it - see UK registration number JET1!
and others too, including G.M.) Best kept for show use only.
Mid engine transverse.
Honda and other micro vans and cars, 550cc, 'er, well guv, it's
a trainer trike for the kiddies'.
Ferrari transverse V sixes - its just gotta be done. Rich
punters please call the author.
Lamborghini Miura V12 - prepare to be lynched by owners club.
Front engine transverse.
The ubiquitous and all round favourite - Alex Issigoniss's most
excellent Mini. (Not the lardy Brazilian BMW motor.)
Ford Escorts and almost every common car - It will get you to
work every day.
V sixes from various manufacturers now available and coming to a
scrap yard near you soon.
Front engine transverse. - Bikes.
Bike based trikes: Mopeds to Harleys to 'busas upwards.
Engines and frames usually as supplied.
Mopeds only suitable for kiddies trikes.
Other engines.
Honda Gold wings and modern Rocket Three's seem a waste of time
when equally large car engines are available for much less cash
and already have the dual rear wheel drive totally sorted. Cars
also offer turbo options, tuning mods and such like for much
more affordable pennies.
Although mainly for show use, there is no reason not to use a
dual engined machine. This will require an extra wide double
differential set-up, but quite feasible and usable with limited
slip differentials. Consider differential mods or differential
locks should one engine fail.
Other set-ups also possible.
For reliability and ease of build, keep the engine and transmission as standard as possible.
It is assumed that if wishing to build a particular type of machine, the reader will have hopefully ridden a number of similar trikes and also thought seriously about the engine.
The first thing that may come to mind when riding the average trike is - the awful control, - especially the clutch and gearchange. For some, the experience may end abruptly as reverse is found to be hiding yet again. This is often soon followed by the awful wallowing around corners as passengers and luggage struggle to remain with the machine.
When designing trikes, especially those requiring the subjective needs of usability and good handling, then the designer should begin with a fierce approach to the prime purpose, only ameliorating the form to fit the real world.
Sukoi's Fulcrum, possibly the worlds finest air superiority
aircraft, began with the Russian designers just creating the
most perfect wing. Only then were added engines, nose and
controls to see how much the ideal wing was compromised. The
Americans still cannot do a 360 loop while travelling forwards
like the Sukoi's.
Perfection does not, nor will ever equate to dollars, - it
depends upon skill.
This is an excellent way to build a trike, beginning with
perfect weight distribution and a low centre of gravity.
Then compromise the design with the best engine layout to fit,
plus rider and secondary components which will minimise any
compromise of the potential ride envelope.
Finally, the testing and refining the fundamental structure will
help ensure the best overall design is possible.
Know and understand exactly what is wanted: Good handling, good control, safe and comfortable passengers, reliability. A trike that truly can be enjoyed every day.
The first step is to know the dimensions with which to work.
Dimensions are in three forms, the fixed, the dependant and the
free. Knowing the difference enables the process to develop in a
fairly logical manner.
Fixed. The fixed dimensions are those which due to their nature
cannot be changed: The sizes, shapes and weights of the rider
and standard components such as engine, wheels and transmission.
Even these may need modification before a final design is made.
(I often modify engines - not for power, but just to be better).
Decide if the machine is for various rider sizes and which size
of wheels etc.
It is the fixed dimensions which give us generic forms.
Once these 'unchangeable' dimensions are decided, they become
the starting point of the design process.
Dependant. These semi-variables are decided by the design as it forms, rather than by a totally free path. This includes the wheelbase and ground clearance which can change within specific limits set by engineering constraints. Spend much time thinking about the variables, as this is where the underlying parameters of a good design are created. For trikes, such as the possible propshaft shortening for adjusting overall weight balance, and how and where you are going to sit.
Free. The free variables which must be created in the mind are the overall shape, colour, seat style and form and the many small styling options which make a machine a whole and competent device, a complete mess, or a work of art.
The best way to design a machine is to tie down all possible fixed dimensions and optimise their arrangement to create the best basic form. - It's often referred to as 'juggling the bits'.
Initially rough sketches on paper at first to assess the overall
style before buying anything, then subsequently more accurately
to scale or full size on paper once the main contenders are
chosen, then finally in full size in chalk on the garage floor.
Once the fixed dimensions are sorted, (usually engine
transmission and rear wheels) the dependant variables will often
fall naturally into place. Finally the builder can begin to
mould them together to create the best possible design, as seen
in the eyes of the designer.
Use that chalk: The reader may not consider themself a designer,
but this is a genuine hands on design process.
Computers. (It had to happen. If galled or vexed, then skip
to 'The most important design skill is being able to use paper
and pencil.')
If preferring to use a drawing package on computer, then
simulate the paper process. Although computers are superb for
refinement, they cannot replace the paper and pencil stage.
Neither is there a substitute to handling full size components
and the true feedback they always give.
Computers have the advantage of allowing the designer to model
the design and view it from all angles, to see faults and places
of refinement. Both paper and computers have their uses, and
both should be used where appropriate.
A note before buying expensive CAD packages.
Although dimensionally based drafting packages are the seemingly
natural choice for designers of engineering projects, they do
not have the flexibility of 3D packages such as Newtek's superb
Lightwave, which has enabled many fine machines to be developed
and refined. Two industry standard CAD drafting packages with
university training were rarely used by my preference to
Lightwave. As the trike is basic engineering, the design can be
seen primarily as an art form.
I always run a trike design though Lightwave before building, to
see where further refinements can be made. An example is shown
here, when asked about access for a disabled triker from
wheelchair to riders seat.
Fundamental engineering is easily accomplished with or without a
computer, but the overall final form, shape, style, colours and
final detailing of the trike are usually more important, and
more easily accomplished is it can be studied on a 3D software,
or on a clay model which can be viewed from all angles.
The last paragraph may be controversial, as many designers will
offer the standard reply that building a mechanical design
requires mechanical drawing software. This is often a trap, as
the actual design is never done on the computer, but with common
sense.
Computers do not design trikes, - people do.
Sketching a frame tube on a full size or scale drawing on paper
or screen is quite good enough for most purposes.
A trike is not an oil rig or aircraft and therefore does not
need a set of working drawings. Even if a design is to be mass
produced, a simple jig from the original machine often suffices
at this level of engineering. Therefore do not get sidetracked
by having to spend many hours making technical drawings. As a
draughtsman from the marine, military, nuclear and electrical
industry, the author does not see any need to waste time where
true design should be done more productively elsewhere in the
design process. Trikes are a fairly basic engineering structure,
aiming, in most cases, to be an art form. Treat them as such.
Art forms develop nicely with 3D visualisations from all aspects
and Lightwave does this extremely well. Understand what is being
created and use the tools available in an appropriate and useful
manner. Do not waste time on computing if it's not needed.
3D modelling (computer or clay) can greatly help refine an idea,
especially overall styling or where components may come into
conflict, such as exhaust runs through frame tubing, steering
linkages or items which move relative to each other. Inverse
kinematics is useful for refining complex steering and
suspension systems or particularly evil gearchange routings.
If very keen, exporting work between various packages such as
drafting and finite element analysis should also be checked
prior to purchase. Data transfer is particularly important due
to the steep learning curves of some packages, should the reader
wish to become deeply involved in the design process. Therefore
always carry floppy with a test piece, to see if it transfers
easily and correctly. The test piece can be generated on the
first item to be tested.
The most important skill is being able to use paper and pencil.
This works perfectly well for most people and it still remains
the definitive design process for innovation.
If using a computer or on a good 'ole paper sketch pad, begin by roughly modelling the three best choices of engines, transmission, wheels, front end plus riders. The engine, wheels and rider can then be positioned relative to each other, until a refined layout is accomplished. This is the same as laying parts out in the garage with chalk, or sketching on paper. The advantage of using a 3D package is that the various virtual engines can be easily tested and adjusted for looks and fitment, then seen from all angles for the best possible layout. For basic assessment, the virtual 3D components need not be much more than a dimensionally accurate box for the engine, and simple extruded cylinders for clutch and gearbox, wheels and such like. Then the overall weight distribution can be calculated on paper once the basic design is optimised.
The requirements are many, from the fixed dimensions of engine
mounts and suspension set-ups, to the overall structural shape
and its styling requirements. This means understanding the way
the frame must work, and the many parts it has to contain and
control.
A good frame is not designed overnight. If you take this
seriously you will (must) be constantly changing the design and
refining it.
Every second spent refining the design will reduce the amount of
grief when building.
This will also save you from having to ride a less than perfect
trike in the years to come.
At this stage, you will have begun drawing sketches to get your
head tuned in to what you want, and have a good idea of where
you are going.
Even if you failed hand painting in kindergarten, you can still
use a pencil and paper: Do it.
If you get stuck, feel free to email your ideas to me - but no
more than two small, compressed jpeg sketches - for a
free assessment and a few hints. emails no bigger than 15kb.
I do not expect works of art, just a chance to see where the
problems may be.
First get the engine and rear wheels suitably positioned, then position the forks or steering to get a sensible amount of weight over the front wheel.
The structural part of the frame is the most important and is
designed first. This will decide how you will mount the engine,
suspension, wheels and steering. The engine mounting will also
demand certain requirements of the chassis.
The non-stuctural parts will be added later, such as the seats
and radiator mountings etc.
The following is what you need to understand your design more closely.
It is assumed the scrapyarding and early drawing stage will have helped decide the best engine and the other main components such as rear axle. It does not give hands on feeling for the overall effect, as paper and pencil is only a part of the game.
Start off with a rough assembling of the engine, wheels etc. on
the garage floor or perhaps on a garden patio, or simply on
three levelled concrete slabs in the garden. This will highlight
any possible problems and to help get your ideas growing.
Clear the scene and block the basic engine, transmission and
rear wheels in a working position using wooden blocks etc. If
other bits are still hanging off then tidy them so you can see
the main parts. Use original dimensions, so the assembly is as
it was for the original donor machine, to ensure maximum
accuracy and reliability.
Then juggle the bits around to find the best layout.
Measure the static ride height of the engine (ground to sump)
before removing the car bits or wheels. Wherever possible, keep
all the transmission and other heavy stuff intact as one.
If you have forks, prop them on a chair or hung from the roof to
be in the approximate position for good overall balance.
For front engined trikes, do not modify the prop shaft to the rear differential until after deciding the final positions of the components. The prop-shaft need not be positioned in place at this stage, just leave sufficient room for a shortened prop shaft. Strip, inspect and decide just how short it can be. Most other parts should be arranged as the manufacturer intended and has been tested for many years. Use of standard parts and dimensions are central to long term reliability. Get plenty of scrap wood or other packing and use simple wooden wedges where necessary for perfect positioning. Likewise wheel blocks. Do not unnecessarily compromise the ideal positions of the items. Position the front wheel if possible, resting the forks against an old chair or strung from the roof.
On transverse car engines, there is often little to do. On trikes using front engined cars, the engine should be moved backwards enough to give good weight balance and ensure a shortened propshaft works well, yet still allow room for the riders. It may take days or weeks to decide the best weight distribution.
Take your time laying out the bits.
Adjust, look, contemplate.
Then adjust, look, contemplate.
Then repeat many times.
Now cover with a cloth and walk away for a week while you do
some styling and detail design.
When you look at your last layout after a week, you may get a
better feel for its overall layout and balance with fresh eyes.
Check what can be rearranged to improve your options, both for
aesthetics and for engineering purposes.
Engine parts which stick out or look ugly should come under
closer scrutiny. An alternator can be repositioned using longer
or shorter V belts, or an awkwardly positioned mechanical fuel
pump which could be replaced with an electric fuel pump
somewhere else. See fuel later. On front engined machines, the
radiator can be removed from the front of the engine to clean up
this area and make the machine look leaner. See Cooling later.
Carbs can be shuffled around, perhaps by simply cutting and
re-positioning their inlet tract. If very lucky, simply bolting
back to front or from side to side on flat fours may suffice,
perhaps with just a little re-porting of the inlet tract to
ensure a smooth flow. Keep the carbs level as intended and
ensure all linkages are retained.
Some engines use an iron exhaust header. This can often be
replaced for cosmetic purposes by the four into two into one
from the sports version. Leave the rear half of the exhaust
system for later.
If the shocks are not mounted on a sub frame or similar, allow for ground clearance by measuring the movement of the suspension. Do not trust the amount of dirt wiped off the suspension chromed central shaft. The trike should have reasonable ground clearance on full compression. A basic comparison with the shock movement and the ground clearance will often suffice. For simplicity and reliability, or if in doubt, use the same ground clearance as the donor machine.
For a low, better handling machine, you may wish to go for
stiffer suspension, lower the ground clearance a little and add
a little more rubber to the bump stops, but first check the
local roads for speed bumps.
For very low trikes, consider a sump guard with a firm rubber
block interface between guard and sump. The sump guard should be
both curved up and strongly supported at the front. This should
allow a little high speed skiing with bottomed suspension on
less than perfect roads and hump back bridges, (the ones with
sump marks on the road either side of the brow) such as
Postbridge, Devon.
For a nice, low, forward mounted engined trike, consider the 2CV
for a well balanced design with excellent economy. Or perhaps a
V8 water cooled Porche or similar designs which have a nice low
engine, with a 90 degree vee bank for perfect engine balance and
many being available in automatic versions. The five litres of
stonk should do quite nicely for show trikes. The Porsche engine
can be repositioned nicely much closer to the rear by minimising
the high speed prop shaft between clutch and excellent design of
rear mounted gearbox. Seating may be problematic and require a
little juggling.
In some cases where the gearbox is on the differential, a high
speed prop shaft similar to a water cooled Porsche is used. The
drawing shows that the distance between engine and transmission
is up to the builder and a little imagination. From a couple of
feet to a couple of inches or as one lump. Likewise the
gearchange is an open book.
If you can match the shaft gearbox splines in a safe manner to a suitable clutch plate and match the flywheel starter ring to the starter motor, Then use an intermediate mounting plate between the back of the engine and the transmission bell housing. In some cases it may be necessary to machine the flywheel to take the correct starter ring or more easily by simple modifying of the starter motor mounting to fit the standard starter ring. The clutch plate for the transmission will sit happily between the engine clutch clamp plates. Some fore to aft alignment may be needed, but not very often, as the splines can take up much of this minor misalignment.
A classic example is fitting a Ford Pinto engine to a VW
transmission unit.
This is a Ford Pinto motor using a large sheet of steel to mount
the VW transmission, a very popular arrangement for dune
buggies. The ford splined clutch plate sits happily in the VW
clutch housing.
If you want such an engine extremely close to the rear diff of a design with independent rear suspension, then you can mount the diff on the back of the engine, using intermediate struts or brackets. But make sure the engine and diff are rubber mounted. The engine mounted to allow torsional rotation and any vertical and sideways vibration, and also allow the diff to take and resolve the torsion from driving the wheels.
Another problem when looking at the bits laid out neatly in the
garden, is the rear suspension, especially McPherson struts.
Double check the prop shaft splines are in the correct position
relative to the engine and wheels with the machine at rest. Then
temporarily brace the tops of McPherson struts using a plank and
blocks of wood across the engine etc. The McPherson strut spring
rates are normally set to take the weight of the engine plus
half the weight of two car occupants, so the spring rates are
fairly close to ideal for a two or three seat trike.
For those who want to get rid of the seating problems associated
with upright shock units, consider the suspension of some
smaller, older Renaults which use suspension arms in conjunction
with torsion bars to give a very low mounted suspension set-up.
The torsion bar mountings can be tweaked to get adjustable
spring forces with minimal hassle. Alternative top ends to the
tall McPherson struts are mentioned later for very nice chassis
and as shown in the piccie. Today, the extremely common
suspension mounting on front wheel drive transverse engines is
the McPherson strut, often mount directly into the cars body
shell, so upper mountings will have to be built into the trike
frame. An alternative is to chop off the top of the strut and
use the mounting hole in the axle to mount an upper wishbone.
Note that in the picture, the upper suspension pivot bush joint
is threaded into the upper wishbone, allowing the vertical
alignment of the wheel to be adjusted for optimum handling
during testing.
5,000cc Porsche engines are not compatible with small car suspension components. Never apply the power of large engines through ordinary components. Always use parts that are appropriate for the purpose.
If making an 'open' design of trike without a covering or shell, then try not to use large sections of the cars chassis, such as the areas around the shock supports or around the engine mounts which will usually look ugly. These areas may be kept until the frame is aligned, and then removed, possibly keeping just a small part of the old mountings and brackets for ease of manufacture of some important fittings. Many car suspension parts are made from stamped steel and look awful, so cosmetic rebuilding is often important after final testing.
This is an interesting example of a VW trike.
I dislike the VW engine because it hangs out the back and causes
poor handling, but the rest of this otherwise fine example is
worth a look. The frame is minimalist and phenomenally sleek,
possibly just two scaffold tubes used with excellent artistic
flair. - It stands out from the crowd.
The front suspension is also a work of art, being one piece fork
legs pivoting on parallel linkages with adjustable shock
absorbers. Although the front end unsprung mass is fairly high,
it is far better than most trike front ends. (I have not ridden
this machine, but looking at the massive amount of trail, looks
to be a tad heavy to steer at speed through twisty lanes and may
well be designed thus to compensate for the VW rear end.)
Of a lesser note is the motorcycle riding position, which is rare on trikes, as it looses the opportunity to restrain the sideways body forces with a car seat.
Finally, the gear change is the standard VW unit, and it looks
as if the designer had problems integrating the standard gear
change into the design. Never allow any mechanical item to
dictate the trike design, as nearly all items can be redesigned
and modified to make a better machine. But with a little work,
could have been extended forward a little to be closer to the
handlebars for faster gearchanges. If the clutch is on the left
handlebar, then the gearchange could extend slightly to the
right for ergonomic convenience rather than sitting under the
riders belly.
If the seat was lowered and forward footrests added, then the
gearchange could be rotated to extend out to the side, or simply
extended forward to be nearer the handlebars.
I would have had the gearlever to the left and added a secondary
hand operated clutch lever on the gearchange for one handed,
slicker movement. And if the clutch was not modified and rather
heavy, I would include a small vacuum or solenoid servo unit.
Common car chassis components.
As found siting carefully on the garage floor.
If wanting to have a more commonly available engine, then the
front transverse engine is a world wide design started in modern
mass produced cars by Alec Issigonis at Austin Motors.
Most modern cars have the same layout as the Real Mini which started it all back in 1959. On the mini, the whole engine, drive and wheels can be assembled as one system as found on the original vehicle, using Alex Issigonis's most excellent sub frame.
Either side of the transverse engine's differential exit the propshafts, with their appropriate spline positions. Some splines are part of the wheel axle unit. Splines are the way the shafts allow for the changing distance between the differential housing and the wheel axle. At rest, splines should be positioned so they can be slid in, to shorten the shaft as the wheel goes over a bump. They are usually hidden under a rubber concertina boot and must be correctly positioned. If an anti-roll bar is used, then this often statically aligns the width of the items correctly, but make sure the centre line of the engine and the roll bar are marked prior to removal, so all will align correctly. Again, use original dimensions if in doubt. If a crunchy donor car, then be careful. This is best done by measuring the gap between the inside of each wheel to a datum point on the engine, such as the clutch housing to engine face. If the wheels are to be changed, then align with standard wheels first, or else measure to a retained component such as the hub carrier bottom pivot. Then remove the shocks and physically move the wheels up and down to check the prop shaft splines work as intended and do not suffer from tight spots.
The radius arms will need to mount to strong parts of the frame,
forward from the hubs to a point on the intended chassis and in
a manner that allows them to control the rear suspension. In
many cases, radius arms are often the same item as the anti roll
bar.
The wheels will also be positioned either side of the vehicle by
a bottom wishbone or arm, which is there to take the sideways
loads from the wheel into the frame. Again the position will be
dependant upon the correct position of the prop shaft splines.
Where these bottom support arms will eventually mount on the
trike, the frame will want to flex out, so cross support will be
required between the trikes lower frame rails to prevent
spreading.
The wheels are positioned to lie vertically. Allow the position of the upper cross member to support the tops of the two suspension units. The whole weight of the rear of the trike will be supported on the tops of the spring units, so distortion of the shock unit springs depends upon the weight placed upon them at this major structural part of the chassis. If used, the top of McPherson struts must also be constrained from slight fore and aft movement. Triangulation is a nice word.
Where torsion bar suspension springs are used, (Renault 4, WW2 Tiger Tanks etc) the fixed ends must be clamped securely, as the whole weight of the rear of the trike is acting at these very highly stressed points. Make these mountings strong, as a lot of torque is developed at the ends. The trike frame torque arm mountings can be adjustable to allow for slight adjustment in the amount of torsion used, to give slightly heavier or softer suspension spring rate. Although torsion bars don't look like springs, they are indeed springs, they just happen to look like bars. They support the whole load of the machine. Read the manual to check the amount of preload required. See also primary testing, later. Tosrion bar suspension can make an incredibly lean suspension setup, but end stops and movement dampers must also be employed, such as remote dampers acting through tension/compression struts as per F1 cars. If using remote compression struts, then it is still better and neater to use concentric coil springs to support the mass of the trike.
The differential takes the power from the prop shaft or rear
sprocket, and turns it through a right angle to drive the wheels
on each side. It also modifies the gearing by about 3:1.
(Luckily, for engineering reasons, this gearing is similar to
motorcycle chain drive and shaft drive gearing.)
Differentials also allow both wheels to rotate at different speeds when cornering, hence their name.
For trikes with bike engines at the front which have to adapt
differentials, then there are usually two types of rear axles
available: The basic, old style is a one piece differential /
axle unit. The other uses independent rear suspension with a
differential fixed on the chassis and separate drive shafts to
the wheels.
The solid rear axle is not a superb solution, as it is heavy and
offers poor suspension movement. But it is much easier to fit,
often needing just radius arms, spring mountings and a Panhard
rod.
The Panhard rod on the top of the solid axle prevents it from
moving left or right, while still being able to move vertically.
The independent form of rear drive from the differential is far superior, but more complex. The radius arms in the picture keeps the fore and aft position correct, especially under acceleration and braking.
With a front car - engined trike, the propshaft between the gearbox and differential must first be laid out and the engine then adjusted for best position allowing for prop shaft mods. For solid rear diff / axle units, the propshaft gearbox output should be level with mid point of the rear axle up and down movement, to ensure the prop shaft splines will suffer minimal sliding. This is controlled by the radius arms.
Once piece rear axles.
If the one piece axle unit with the differential, it may use
leaf springs as standard and these are usually replaced with
radius arms for styling purposes. Leaf springs require longer
and lower main frame tubes. If the prop shaft is very short, it
is better to discard leaf spring set-up and use radius arms and
coil springs to maintain good angles on the prop shaft as the
rear axle moves up and down. The leaf springs act as radius
arms, so build or use radius arms which are similar to this
movement and which pivot at the front either side of the front
of the central prop shaft. This will require minor modifications
of the mounting brackets on the axle, although the shock units
can remain essentially as fitted. Leaf springs are not a good
idea for trikes, and is often easily replaced by using the
saloon version of the donor vehicle which often uses radius
arms.
For many modern basic trike designs, there is not always a need
to change anything unless necessary, as most suspension designs
are specific to the donor machine and are often used as the
manufacturer intended.
When using front mounted engines it is common to cut down the prop shaft to get the engine weight more to the rear. With once piece diff / axle units, this will require positioning or modifying the radius arms to closely follow the arc of the prop shaft. Ideally, the front of the radius arms will be pivot approximately either side of the gearbox output universal joint. The prop shaft spline will allow the radius arm pivots to be positioned aft of the universal joint, so overall accuracy can be reasonable rather than perfect.
Independent rear suspension.
Independent suspension offers better handling, better control
over some adjustments during building but is more complex to
fit. Because the central diff housing is on the frame, the frame
also requires suspension arm pivots and spring mountings to be
positioned relative to the differential housing and it's drive
shafts.
For independent rear suspension, the differential housing is
fixed on the frame, so the prop shaft only needs a little
flexibility in alignment and length for the movement in the
engine mountings, and thus can be a lot shorter if required.
Chain drive and differentials.
If the engine has a chain drive, such as for many motorcycle
engines, then fitting a rear sprocket to the differential will
be the biggest problem.
Sprocket ratios must be adjusted to match the diameter of the
new rear wheels. If the new wheels are the same outside diameter
as the original bike tyre, then the standard sprockets will
often suffice.
The rear sprocket should be mounted onto the differential
crownwheel, in place of the original gear ring. This usually
requires a sprocket with a fairly large hole in the centre,
which can be machined or ground away by powered hand tools. It
is always better to choose the sprocket nearest to the proposed
requirements; Some aftermartket suppliers have excellent
sprocket guides in their catalogues, complete with dimensions.
If a standard sprocket is close, then preferably machine the
crown wheel mounting to match the sprocket for easy replacement
of this high-wear component. Always get a few spare sprockets.
(If heavily modifying sprockets to fit differentials, then drill the mounting holes as needed, then grind away most of the inner sprocket as needed, with just the areas near the mounting holes used for alignment. Use a vernier caliper between the base of the teeth and the mounting face on the alignment point to make life easier. By having to only file the sprocket alignment at four or six places, they are much easier to make and fit by hand. )
If there is not enough room in the housing of a solid rear axle
unit to clear the chain and sprocket, simply build up a set of
at least four wraparound cross braces to support the outside of
the differential housing, which will then allow the differential
housing to be gently trimmed back to clear the chain and
sprocket without loosing shaft alignment. These could be strong,
long, curved tubes to support both sides of the differential
unit. Alternatively build a suitably large box structure to
support the differential bearings, and clear the sprocket, which
would also integrate into or be a removable part of the trike's
rear chassis.
Before cutting the diff housing, fit and weld up the external
support brackets and when cross braced, remove just enough to
clear the chain and sprocket. This can become ugly, but must be
strong. The ideal would be a strong, bent steel tube along the
horizontal plane, but as the diff is normally removed from a
large plate in the rear, then the rear supports should be above
and below this removal zone. The cross bracing tubes can be
flattened along the ends to weld directly to the axle tubes.
Secondary tubing will be needed above and below and another
running in the front, between the upper and lower chain runs.
The open area where the rear sprocket runs, can now be built up with a light sheet metal or fibreglass GRP shell to help protect the differential bearings and the chain entry and exit points.
Because a trike differential and sprocket are often removed from the rear, then the front section where the chain runs, can be moulded into tunnels to give the chain weather protection and keep the oil in the differential.
Make sure the chain and sprocket can be easily replaced.
If replacing the sprocket is particularly difficult, and if it
is not transmitting too much power, and if it is mounted on at
least six bolts, then the sprocket can be bisected with a
hacksaw and mounted as two halves to fit into the standard axle
housing.
If you think that running a rear differential without its hypoid gear oil is likely to lead to extreme wear, fear not. The gear oil is to overcome the high shear force between the prop shaft pinion gear and the crownwheel. The rest of the differential does not need this and the main axle bearings holding the core of the diff does less work than the wheel axles which run in grease, so greasing the main brarings is plenty enough in most cases. The central star gears do very little work and then only in corners and at relatively low revs, so can be regularly lubricated by graphite motorcycle chain lube or drip feed with a thick oil.
If using a one-piece, solid rear axle, then the sprocket alignment will be badly offset from the centreline: One side of the rear axle may need to be cut and shortened using high class engineering techniques. Alternatively the bike engine can be moved slightly to one side, or the sprocket on the diff can be spaced out by half an inch and also one of the road wheels spaced out to give a reasonably even rear wheel spacing or usually a mixture of all three to get the wheels evenly spaced. It is for this reason that it is recommend to use independent rear suspension for chain driven bike engines.
With independent rear suspension, the differential is mounted as part of the frame, with the independent drive shafts exiting to left and right. Because the differential is mounted to the frame, then much of the unit can be rebuilt for trike use and can be brought very close to the engine for better overall balance.
A design example.
If new to this game you may well be confused by the conflicting
needs of fitting a differential to a trike. You are not the
first, nor last to face trike rear ends.
This is just one example of making your own engineering
solutions, to show how you may wish to approach the engineering
problems. for classic reasons, the example has a car
differential with independent suspension and a chain drive, just
to make the example as difficult as possible.
It is not simple DIY, but needs a reasonable degree of good
engineering skill, rather than any expensive engineering machine
shop solutions.
Done badly, it can be very dangerous, so take your time and
don't skimp the problems.
First of all, the differential can be removed from a modern car
such as an Escort Mk 3 or 4 fiesta or Vauxhall, they are al the
same under the skin. Then mounted into its own metal cradle
subframe supported from the bike swing arm pivots and shock
mounts.
The Escort diff is mounted on taper rollers which are preloaded
axially by large belville washers, so a simplified housing is
possible, without any need for shimming the bearings.
Start by taking the Escort gearbox and diff unit from the
scrapyard and strip.
Remove the original large diameter crown gear which leaves a
nice mounting face for a sprocket.
Machine the diff ring gear area to take a standard bike sprocket
of the same size as the original bike or relative in diameter to
match the new rear wheel relative to the original bike tyre
outside diameter. The bike rear wheel and the trike rear wheels
are often of a very similar outside diameter.
Later, you may need to slightly adjust the sprocket ratios if
the rear wheel diameters are different.
To mount the bare differential assembly in the fixed sub frame,
make shouldered steel rings or cups to take the diff bearings.
These can be mounted on the left and right sub frames, such that
the halves can be bolted together to make a well mounted
differential unit on the bike frame. Such bearing cups can be
made by steel tube, split to fit and welded to be a snug fit
over the bearings. Then an end plate added which has a hole
just big enough for the prop shaft to fit through. The cups are
tack welded, removed and fully welded, then take a hand grinder
to ensure the bearings will fit in them snugly.
Measure the width of the assembled diff and bearings, then add
two thirds of the width of the belville washers, so that some
compression is available when the left and right sub frames are
bolted together to hold the diff in position. The belville
washer will be partiality compressed when the assembly is built
in the trike, so the taper roller bearings will be securely
preloaded.
Check the chain alignment and adjust as needed.
Place the rear wheels where desired relative to the rest of the
trike, - be it just an assembly of parts on blocks or a
partially finished trike.
Lay the differential and sprocket on the garage floor and draw
the chain rub, then measure the offset of the differential from
the trike centreline. The rear frame and sub frame will be
deigned to align the differential to this overall arrangement.
The differential will also be mounted on blocks further above
the wheel centreline, by half the distance of the suspension
movement.
This will give the final width of the differential housing in
the sub frame. As such a sub frame is usually a symmetrical pair
of left and right hand brackets, then the differential can be
positioned between them and these are easily bolted together
with spacers to ensure the correct width for the differential to
about 1 mm tolerance in width. This will compress the belville
washers enough to hold the main bearings in place. This makes
for a very simple and easy design, with few engineering skills.
To ensure the differential can be removed, one of the bearing
cups can be fixed into the trike frame, with the other securely
and very accurately mounted in a strong removable sub frame. As
the differential will line up with the chain and sprocket, then
this can also be the removable side, so that sprocket
replacement is much easier.
Chain adjustment is a minor problem, solved by mounting both
cups in plates with slotted bolt holes.
To ensure better accuracy, the bottom bolt holes which support
the bearing cups cold be fixed, with just the top bolt holes
slotted, and when aligned, they are then marked with alignment
marks using a cold chisel, plus other graduations to ensure the
differential remains accurately aligned at al times.
The frame is gradually built up to hold the differential in
position - the cups are welded to a thick steel adjustment
plates. Then the rear frame tubes are extended back to mount the
differential bearing cup holder plates. The sprocket side of the
frame is built up first, then the differential fitted and the
other side built up to accurately hold the differential and its
sprocket perfectly in line.
The other side must be able to tighten into place to ensure the
belville washers apply their pressure to the main taper roller
bearings. This will include strong cross tubes between the left
and right hand sides of the rear frame, so the differential is
securely mounted.
When welded in place, the differential is checked for alignment
and chain adjustment, then the rest of the rear end can begin.
Check it can be removed for maintenance or replacement.
Where possible, add extra support for rubber seals on the
outsides of the taper rollers to prevent oil loss. To protect
the spinning differential body which holds the sun gears, it
should be covered partially with steel plate and in fibreglass
to ensure it is regularly greased with aerosol chain lube.
Build up a snug, small steel or fibreglass surround or cover to
ensure that the spray from the chain and differential
lubricating grease does not spoil the rest of the trike. If the
diff is open to the rain, snug fitting plastic bearing covers,
possibly with felt seals will allow grease nipples to be used to
maintain reliable bearings.
The sub frame is then adjusted for prefect chain alignment and
cross braces used for final alignment and furthur strength.
Now the rear suspension and drive shafts can be made.
The donor car drive shafts are not the same length, so one will
have to be modified to ensure an even rear end. The designer can
decide which to use, perhaps choosing the shorter drive shafts
if living in a congested city, and cutting the other to fit, or
the longer one if living in the wide open plains and of the
scrap yard for another longer one to fit to size. If the diff is
heavily offset, then use the shaft lengths to advantage.
Remember that the diff is also offset in the car, so perhaps
very little modification may be needed.
for a narrow trike, perhaps for inner city use, then use the
short shaft on the longest side to the wheel hub, and
drastically shorten the longer shaft to give a narrow trike.
for a wide trike, the problems are difficult, as lengthening a
prop shaft is never recommended, as the torsion loading and
vibration problems are legion. Just stick with standard, or
shorting the pros shafts to the wheels.
The wheels are now mounted on the ends of the drive shafts and
the wheels blocked in place relative to the differential and the
prop shafts.
It is vitally important to ensure the splines which allow
the prop shafts to change their length under suspension movement
are set at ALMOST full extension so they will be able to slide
inwards as the suspension is compressed. MAKE SURE the wheels
are therefore correctly positioned and blocked in place for the
props shafts to work properly.
Some offset of wheel alignment is possible as an inch or so should not unduly affect handling or braking. If the wheel alignment either side of the centreline is beyond an inch or so, then adjust the props shaft length until perfect.
The wishbones are now designed to be pivoted close to be similar
length and angle to the prop shaft. Or if needing even wishbones
then some compromise in length can be fitted.
The wheel axle units will often use the standard car bottom
wishbone mountings, and the upper shock mount modified as this
photo for an upper wishbone.
As per Formula One, using a longer front part of the bottom
wishbone will help resolve heavy braking forces into the trike
frame for slightly better handling and less rear end distortion.
As mentioned earlier, the bottom wish bone may use the donor car
assembly for simplicity of manufacture and assembly.
If you wish to retain the car front suspension completely, then
the upper McPherson suspension strut will compromise the rear
seating possibilities.
The shocks are now mounted close to the wheels and adjusted to get the best suspension rate. See later. Bump stops are now fitted to limit the maximum movement.
If you are completely happy with this arrangement, then start looking for similar sprockets for spare, and another differential for spares, as the differential is designed to run in heavy oil, so may eventuality fail earlier than the car design.
Fully enclosed chains are possible.
A few larger machines use rubber tubes for the purpose which can
be modified to fit. By using a fully enclosed chain, the
differential oil will reduce chain wear, although it may be
messy at the front sprocket area. If too messy, simply allow
room to regularly use spray-on chain lube on the differential
and chain, possibly with aftermarket automatic motorcycle chain
oilers to lubricate the differential bearings and another
automatic oiler for the chain.
Alternatively fit a pan to catch the oil as it flings off the
front sprocket and include a small return pipe back to the diff
housing.
Differentials are not pressurised, so a simple fibreglass
covering is that's needed to retain most of the oil. Where the
sprocket reaches the lowest part of the differential, splashing
is guaranteed and the oil level will not last very long unless
well sealed. Scrapers and splash deflectors will help retain
oil. The best compromise is to enclose as much as possible and
use dual motorcycle automatic oilers: one for the chain and one
for the differential.
For long term reliability of solid full width rear axle units,
the outer wheel bearings should be given a metal shield and well
greased via a grease nipple.
The chain can run easily in rubber tubes or nylon lined alloy or
steel tubes bolted to the differential. This will keep much of
the lubrication in place. If a lot of oil is carried along the
upper run, then an oil drain cup arrangement can be incorporated
into the lower front of the lower chain tube around the sprocket
to drain excess back to the differential via lower run. This is
not perfect, but every little bit helps. For those who cover
many miles but don't want to keep toping up the differential,
the ideal is to fully seal the whole, including the front
sprocket. The heavy oil used in differentials is there for the
hypoid gears, which are replaced by chain and sprocket, so a
lighter oil is possible for splash lubrication. The inner sun
gears of the differential unit may wear a little more, so always
ensure any oil drip feed is to these as well, should oil loss be
a problem. Always add graphite additive to the oil to reduce the
sun gear wear.
To make an enclosed chain run for a differential set up, then because the chain is well adjusted, and does not flex like a bike with rear suspension, then the chain is always at constant tension,. Therefore the chain can be run in steel tubes or strong plastic tubes. To prevent rattling, then inner faces of thin wall steel tubes are covered with hard rubber. A hard rubber tube slid inside will gradually wear to the point where the chain will happily rub with minimal noise. Ideally the hard rubber would be on just the upper and lower faces, but a snug fitting four sided hard rubber inside , epoxied in place will give a good, oil tight and safe chain run. Where the tubes enter the differential casing, then need only fit into a hard rubber bush, plus a welded flange to stop them being dragged out of position by the chain drag. The front sprocket cover is harder to make, and usually involves a fibreglass cover integrated into the standard bike engine sprocket cover.
To stop the more prinitive, one piece differential / axle unit
from moving left or right, a Panhard rod is used which is about
two thirds the length of the axle - or preferably longer. The
rod is positioned on one end of the differential unit, the other
end mounted on the frame and kept as horizontal as possible at
mid point of movement. The Panhard rod is usually on rubber
bushes to allow the axle to move up and down without leaving the
centre line of the trike. The Panhard rod should be taken from a
similar car, as it must not buckle under severe cornering
forces. The fixed pivot on the frame should be positioned at mid
point of the suspension movement, so it will keep the rear axle
centrally positioned across its whole movement.
Leaf springs and other types of suspension have been used in the
past, but the standard concentric damper/spring unit seems here
to stay. They can be separated for ease of development, but are
not usually worth the extra effort. Leaf springs can keep spring
height really low, eliminate panhard rods and also prevent one
piece rear axle/differential units from rotating, but will need
a wide, lower frame with more rear extension which can
compromise a clean design.
When used merely as a spring, leaf springs need not be
positioned fore and aft, but a single, evenly balanced leaf
spring mounted across the frame can spread the load to both rear
wheels. It can be further refined if an adaptable mounting is
used.
There are many types of rear drives and axles which are
indirectly joined to the frame using a variety of methods, so
check you know how your choice of axle works and whether it will
fit and integrate well in the design of trike.
A rigid rear end is not worth considering.
Independent rear suspension is the better design for trikes, as the system has lighter unsprung mass, should handle much better, allows constant chain tension with easier full enclosure. The wheel bearings of independent suspension are sealed and the differential unit can be modified to fit within the removed swing arm area for standard bike frames. It must still be capable of adjusting the distance between the sprockets for chain wear, but suspension movement need not be considered between the sprockets, so perfect chain tension is possible.
Shortening propeller shafts.
With many front mounted car engines, the drive is usually a prop
shaft. When shortening propshafts, always mark the alignment of
the ends first and only modify just one end, preferably where
there are most balance weights. Please note that the positions
of the universal coupling pivots are symmetrically aligned, so
note and check it is replaced in the same alignment. Then cut
and check the end of the shortened tube is accurate by a set
square so the end piece fits accurately. Reassemble using the
marks and tack weld, then make sure the shaft runs true
initially, by rotating them between centres. Nothing fancy is
needed to make a basic check, just two thin spikes to fit into
the central centring pilot drill holes usually machined in the
ends of each unit.
Adjust for minimum friction, then spin and adjust the bare shaft
until it balances. To spin fast, place a spike in an electric
drill and use a rubber flange on the spike to turn the shaft. If
the shaft is not balanced, vibration may trash the couplings.
For the final test, block the axles, remove the wheels and run
the engine in top gear to check the propshaft in situ. Very
gently applying a marker pen to a clean, rotating shaft may show
up the high spots requiring modification. Weld on sheet steel
weights opposite, then grind down the weights until vibration is
eliminated. When true, fully weld the weights in position and
check again.
You usually need to dismantle the couplings to get the bare shaft for balancing. If you don't want to do this, place the modified shaft in the trike and run it freely in place while checking for any problems at high speeds. Do this with the wheels off, and the whole trike on strong blocks so the props shafts can rotate to their maximum revs.
Careful consideration of the intended design will reduce the
frame tube count.
A common example is a cross-tube doubling as the seat backrest.
For example, if a McPherson strut cross-tube is positioned just
a little behind and below the strut mounting plates, then this
will allow the passengers to recline more comfortably. Not all
suspensions will allow this, whereas a few unusual suspensions
will allow almost anything, and triangulation can overcome most
problems.
If something gets in the way, consider redesigning or using a
different component, so the trike will be as uncompromised as is
sensibly suitable.
The classic Jaguar differential and suspension rear end is a
classic example which allows almost total design freedom.
Once the general structure for the frame is decided, start designing how the parts will fit in, on and around the frame. The suspension, engine and transmission mountings are often fixed, so how the frame must fit to these is a first priority. Having the donor components in place will always help, especially with the old engine and suspension lugs, brackets etc.
Carefully sit between the bits to finalise where the rider and passengers can sit, and where the frame can and cannot go. This in turn will decide the position of the gearchange, footrests etc. Adding riders will increase the load on each wheel, so make sure the axle loadings will be sensible and fairly even when the trike is eventually ready to roll. Begin to get a feel of where is the best place for the front wheel. - Just because you have placed a concrete paving slab in the front of the assembly for the front wheel, does not mean this is where the wheel will eventually go, so place two or three pacing slabs to allow you to vary the front wheel position as you refine the overall balance of the machine.
The frame itself will be most important, but must also take into
account the purpose of the machine when building a trike for
people. Far too many trike passenger seats are 'sit up and beg'
designs.
Do not accept a second rate design. Trikes should be fun for
all. A frail 85 yr old lady found some trikes to be extremely
comfortable; easy to get in and out, and very comfy too.
Always take the occasional ten minutes to think of the weight on
the whole machine. Stand back and simply look, then contemplate
the weights and loads. Just stand and look, with a cuppa or a
real beer, not just for a few seconds, but as long as it takes
to grasp the overall feel of the machine as it develops in the
early stages.
Ensure approximately a quarter to a third of the weight is on
the front wheel, with one rider. Preferably the same with
passengers, which requires they should sit over the centre of
gravity of the machine. If you have the car seats, simply sit,
relax, look at the bits laid out. Allow the mind to do what
great artists have been enjoying for hundreds of years - free
thought - nothing forced, nothing directed.
This should take at least three days, each time with a hot cup
of tea to contemplate, or a beer etc.
Keep the notepad handy and make notes before the best thoughts
are forgotten.
When loaded with passengers, try not to have too much extra load
on the front wheel, as the rear end is invariably the main load
carrying area. On heavy front ends, keeping the extra loads to
the rear will help with the steering and manoeuvring in car
parks etc.
By mounting the passengers just in front of the rear wheels, the overall load on the three wheels will remain optimised for better handling with and without passengers. This also allows the passengers to sit low and more comfortably, nestled between suspension and frame. Being lower, the centre of gravity will be less prone to roll the trike, so the machine will handle much better, improving handling and comfort, especially around corners. Another major advantage with low riders, is that aerodynamic drag can be reduced, allowing a higher top speed and the passengers will get less wind and rain buffeting, - very important on long journeys.
For those with many kids, consider the old USA design, where the boot (trunk) would open to become an extra pair of seats, with the boot lid folding backwards to become the backrest. Occasionally referred to as a 'rumble seat'. Many modern versions of this are possible. A couple of recessed foot steps, aircraft style, will assist their entry and add a little extra style.
It may be necessary to take the design process a stage further. It all depends upon what you want.
Although most trikes will be quite good using standard components as intended by the manufacturer, and some atrocious machines still get used daily, it is nice to be able to see the underlying design when looking at the machine laid out before ones eyes.
Therefore, while standing with a cuppa and perusing the parts
laid out on the garage floor, a little theory will help develop
the plot and improve the possibilities.
As a general rule, it is often advised that the centre of
gravity of a three wheeler should not exceed thirty five prevent
of the distance from the two rear wheels towards the front
wheel. (That is to say, the central overall weight of trike and
rider(s) should be closer to the two rear wheels.)
If making or modifying engine layout or suspension, as most trikes demand, then consider the following.
Trikes can turn as good as some cars - if well designed. This is
for many reasons, mainly lower mass and how this mass is
positioned relative to the wheels.
With good balance, a traditional single front wheeled vehicle
will tend to oversteer; that is to say, it tends to turn further
into the corner than required. If the single wheel was at the
rear, it would tend to understeer, which is usually considered
safer for ordinary drivers and for example, usually the safe
set-up when handed LeMans car to try, if new to the racing game.
When cornering with a single front wheel, where oversteer is a
problem, because the front wheel has little grip, then
accelerating out of a corner tends to work better, but braking
into a corner tends to de-stabalise a trike. This is reversed
for a rear single wheel.
This is not a perfect description, as it also depends upon
whether the weight of the engine is at the front or at the rear
of the trike.
Unfortunately for a single front wheel, the forces involved in braking are higher than accelerating, so making sure the ability for a trike to brake when in a corner must also be very carefully considered. When further compromised with a narrow front tyre, with a round profile which tends to limit braking ability, then problems can accrue. Hence, like a bike, brake in a straight line before the bend and accelerate out, unless it is poorly balanced and you need to compensate for poor handling.
When cornering, the designer must realise that if sufficient
traction that the wheels will not slide, then the weight
distribution of the trike will determine how it handles. When
turning a corner, you are moving heavy loads such as the engine
and riders around a corner. The heavy bits will either tend
towards the rear or front of the trike.
Making them go around corners happily will depend how the loads
relate to the wheel positions.
The more the centre of gravity is towards the front of the
machine, the greater the tendency to understeer; it will tend to
move towards the outside kerb.
The greater the centre of gravity is to the rear, the greater
the tendency to overtseer; it will want to tuck into the turn
and is usually the more dangerous option. (If you are ever
offered a test ride of a very high performance machine such as a
race Ferrari, then the mechanics will usually set up the
steering to understeer, so you don't get into too many problems
on the test track.)
When considering the overall way your machine will behave, it is
not the way the steering works, but the way the masses act in
relation to the wheels. Getting the mass central to the wheels
will help the trike handle well in corners, even when
accelerating and braking heavily.
If making a stonking brute for serious thrashing, then it will
be difficult to minimise understeer if using a V12 at the front,
unless a long wheelbase can keep the engine unbelievably close
to the rear.
With a poorly handling trike, perhaps for show use, then there are suspension and geometry tricks to ameliorate the suspension and steering to reduce the effects of imperfect weight distribution.
Now a short guide to what you should be looking at when considering the overall layout of your trike.
Heave up and down.
Stiffer suspension makes handling better, but gives a harsher
ride. Therefore trike comfort is dependant upon many factors. If
standard components are retained and are in good condition, most
problems from suspension bounce and rebound etc will be fairly
acceptable. When changing to different wheels or suspension arms
and links, the dynamics may alter, but the natural frequencies
of most standard and slightly modified suspension systems are
usually within acceptable limits.
Most acceptable systems allow the springs to compress about ten
to fifteen percent in normal riding conditions. If the springs
do not, then choose lighter springs, or re-position these items
until they act more softly. This slight initial compression is
to allow the suspension to already be in an active state,
allowing both up and down movement so the wheels can comply with
all normal road irregularities. If the springs did not compress
slightly under normal conditions, they may act as a stiff block
until a large bump is encountered, and this means a very harsh
ride and inferior handling.
For a lightly loaded rear end of a front engined trike, the
weight of a couple of passengers will compress the suspension
further, which may cause problems of a light rear end, such as a
trike with the engine at the front. For this problem, use
springs and dampers from a similar situation, such as from the
rear a light family car which also has a front engine.
When using a front engined car engine and suspension, placed to
the rear of a trike, the load is fairly close to standard. In
practice, this rarely needs much, if any adjustment.
Next time you are beside a car, push down on a front wing, and also on a rear wing, to see how it reacts and behaves and try to get your trike to be in the same ball park. Get a feel for what is happening. Decide if the engine mass affects the movement appreciably. Get to know what is happening, so you can also check this against your trike as it's being built. If possible, do the same on a proper sports car such as a Lotus Super Seven.
The amount of sprung to unsprung mass is more important on a
lightweight trike. On a heavy machine, the greater mass usually
absorbs the forces of maintaining the wheels in contact with the
road. Trikes are usually much lighter. The unsprung mass of the
wheel, tyre and half the suspension is going to have a larger,
negative effect on a lighter chassis. It is best to keep such
weight low, such as inboard discs, alloy wheels and such like
wherever possible. This is especially important if aiming for a
good handling, comfortable, lightweight machine. This is further
refined by adjusting the damping rates to suit. Where the shock
unit is rebuildable, this may require changing the damper fluid
to get better results.
Do not get overly cautious as the spring rates often do not need
to be changed if they compress a little at normal static road
loadings.
Pitch fore and aft.
Fore and aft pitching is a problem for many trikes, especially
those with tall, front engines while braking, where the nose of
the trike dips down. This causes minor problems with geometry
and suspension. Antidive is a secondary solution, but it is
better not to have the problem, or at least to ameliorate it
from the outset.
Therefore it is important to keep the centre of gravity low and
nicely positioned between the front and rear wheels to reduce
most pitching problems. Poorly designed trikes with this problem
can be greatly improved with leading link suspension systems or
hub centre steering.
It is not just the suspension which causes comfort problems. The
classic VW engine hanging out the rear will give rise to
wheeling tendencies, especially if a fierce clutch linkage is
used.
Roll.
When cornering, there will be a rolling action towards the
outside of the turn. The mass of the trike further above the
ground will cause greater roll. Roll works in harmony with the
suspension set-up, but the lower the mass is to the ground, (low
centre of gravity) the less the roll and the more effective and
subtle the suspension can be.
From a safety aspect, there is less chance to roll-over if the
centre of gravity is low. In plan view (looking down from
above), draw a triangle between front and rear wheels. The
closer the centre of gravity is to the centre of this triangle
when seen in plan view, the less the roll effect. Unfortunately
this can be improved by moving the centre of centre of gravity
rearwards, by positioning the heavy bits to the rear, but not
always at the expense of poor weight balance required of a small
front tyre. Therefore in some cases, it is better to get the
best polar moment of inertia and accept a little more roll. To
do this, get the centre of gravity proportionally between front
and rear axles in such a position that the heavy bits are acting
fairly evenly on all wheels, then adjust for the choice of front
tyre.
The use of an anti roll bar is designed such that some of the
forces involved when cornering are transferred from the inside
suspension to the outside suspension, to limit the amount of
roll. Roll bars are common on most modern vehicles and should be
employed on trikes and always on taller trikes using motorcycle
frames.
Yaw side to side.
The ability to quickly set a trike up into a turn from a
straight line is much faster than most cars. The ability for the
heading to change, - that is to point to left or right faster,
is called the yaw response time. With lower mass and reasonable
road holding, the trike can have a great advantage. As steering
involves the front wheel, a single front wheel trike is not as
good as the two wheels front, one wheel back version, but the
conventional trike still remains a good contender in the
cornering game.
The trikes lower mass enables the forces available to redirect a
trike to be more responsive. The polar moment of inertia (force
to move a mass through an arc) can be lower on a trike than a
car, hence cornering is greater fun. Polar moment of inertia can
be considered as a 'dumb bell', as used in weight lifting. If
the weights (mass) are at the ends, turning it is difficult. If
the mass was in the middle, if would be easier to turn.
The best polar moment of inertia is if the centre of gravity of
the whole mass is positioned fairly central with the wheels
relative to a sensible wheelbase. A front engined trike such as
a V12, will have more of a dumb bell action: Whereas a mid
engined trike with the engine and passengers just forward of the
rear wheels will be very nicely balanced and allow the steering
forces to turn the machine much easier and will be a lot more
fun on twisty Dartmoor roads.
Camber angle.
When seen from the front, if a rear wheel leans outwards at the
top, it has a positive camber angle. Leaning in at the top is
negative camber.
One piece rear axles cannot be modified.
Independent rear suspension can be adjusted for camber, and
usually have a longer lower wishbone than the top wishbone to
enable the camber to change as the suspension compresses, or use
McPherson struts or similar.
In normal use, the wheel should be vertical or have a slightly
positive camber, sitting square in the ground and ideally
positioned for straight driving. When cornering and the
suspension compresses, then the outside wheel should ideally
become slightly negative in camber, to keep the outside of the
tyre fairly normal with the road and to help reduce tyre wear
and maximise grip.
Centre of gravity.
A lot of the above has mentioned the centre of gravity. To find
the centre of gravity of an item, simply hang it from a point
and draw a line vertically down from pivot. Then do so from
another point. Where they meet is the centre of gravity. For a
piece of unusually shaped card, use a pin through the item, and
draw a vertical line down from the pin, then a different point
on the card, hang and draw another line. Where they cross is the
centre of gravity, where it should balance perfectly well.
Unfortunately for a trike, this is not so easy.
As the trike has not been built yet, is impossible at this
stage, only an approximation can be done. The further the engine
and riders are to the rear, the further the centre of gravity is
to the rear. Likewise for the height of the components off the
road surface. This is then modified during test riding.
For the initial stages, finding the centre of gravity will have
to be done either with arithmetic or a little common sense.
Will it want to Roll or Skid ?
As a general rule, it is possible to find out approximately if a
machine is going to roll or skid first. This is important to
those who are going to thrash their machines along British
country roads and Alpine passes.
As this is an early stage of the design, then general
approximations to overall weight balance of the trike can be
made.
With all the parts arranged on the garage floor, weigh them and
work out the amount of each load on each axle. If the engine is
half way between front and rear wheels, then half will be on the
front wheel and half the weight split between the rear wheels.
Do likewise for all the other bits including riders. Then work
out roughly where all this mass will be along the centreline of
the trike. Mark this guess of the centre of gravity on the floor
as 'X'.
Next draw a line between front and on eof the rear wheels, to
go through the middle of the tyre contact patch where they touch
the ground.
Now make a reasonable guess of the height of the centre
of gravity above the ground. This can be guessed by averaging
the centre of gravity of the engine, riders etc, to get a rough
idea of the whole machine with riders etc. It may be a few feet
above the ground for an average machine, perhaps more, hopefully
less.
The final step is to draw a circle on the floor, using point X
as the centre. Draw a circle with a radius the same as the
height of the centre of gravity.
If the circle goes outside a line drawn between the wheels, it
will tend to roll, but if inside, it is more likely to skid. The
further the circle is inside the line between the wheels, the
safer the machine will be, tending to skid rather than roll
over.
(Now you know why many good builders like to keep their
centre of gravity of thier trikes central and slightly to the
rear to the trike, and to have a low centre of gravity.)
See also how to check the centre of gravity of the basic rolling
chassis, later.
Tyre adhesion will also effect the roll / slide situation.
Modern tyres often have the ability to retain friction with the
road up to eighty percent of their load. This will vary with
roll, etc. and if problems occur, then simply use less efficient
tyres to allow the tyres to slide before rolling the trike over.
Tyre pressures will also affect this situation slightly.
In some conditions, the inner wheel may tend to loose adhesion
before the outer, due to the lighter load causing it to lift off
the road, and the diff will then transfer little or no power,
causing the trike to slow. Loosing power in this manner is
dangerous. This usually causes a line change, and can be
considered a desperate warning just before things get seriously
out of control. If considering such problems because you are a
serious thrasher, then seriously consider limited slip
differentials as used in some Jag and Porsche rear systems and
ideal for over powered trikes.
The tyres are the main point of control with the road. The way
tyres are controlled is by the suspension. This means the load
is carried by the springs, the damping control by the dampers,
and the way it moves (the geometry) by the suspension arms and
rods etc. The way the suspension moves can be designed or
modified such that the wheel moves in a positive manner, to
control and augment the natural steering of the trike.
When cornering, the outside wheel takes most of the weight and
the spring compresses, lowering part the trike. The design
should be such that the suspension can keep the wheel level when
cornering. This is usually done by using uneven suspension arms
to control the wheel alignment as the suspension moves. An anti
roll bar can be used to reduce the roll of the chassis.
When cornering, the suspension moves as the trike rolls, and
when seen from the front, the position from which the wheel
seems to arc is called the reaction point. If a line is drawn
between the reaction point and the road contact point on the
tyre, then the place it crosses the centreline of the machine is
called the roll centre. The roll centre should be as low as
possible for trikes.
McPherson struts (special car shocks) usually work in a similar
manner, but as they are from the front of the donor machine and
therefore used for steering, the centre line of the strut is
also designed as the steering axis. This axis may not be
directly in line with the centre of the tyre contact point,
causing the steering under the strut to want to pull the wheel
off line. As this is normally on a two wheel set-up on both
donor and on a trike, the effect of both sides is evened out.
When the machine corners, the more heavily weighted side has
greater effect, which should be designed to act in a positive
way. Placing the engine and suspension systems of a front wheel
drive car to the rear, as in a trike, these actions will remain
in play. But what is good for the front of a car is not always
the best for the rear of a trike. Normally this is not of much
importance, but on powerful machines such minor imperfections
should be recognised, if handling becomes problematic.
In general, a lot of theory can be applied, but not always
necessary, but a basic understanding helps.
The standard components of most cars are usually quite
acceptable for most trikes, but can always be improved. The tyre
sizes, aspect ratios and pressures will also affect the
steering. Within sensible limits, many items can be adjusted to
refine a machine.
Getting the balance right is not easy, and often best assessed
by riding as many trikes as possible.
Test ride while understanding what exactly what a test session
is looking for. Write the parameters on a piece of paper and
choose road conditions to test each one. In an ideal world it is
preferable to have a few different types of trikes available for
back to back testing. With a single test machine, simply set
standards high and expect the best, whereupon the problems will
often be seen more easily.
Bear in mind the understeer or oversteer, suspension, roll,
dive, braking around corners, pulling away uphill, steering
stability or twitchiness and the general ability to be thrashed
through twisty roads. If the test session is short, it is best
done in an unused, large carpark, so the limits of roll or slide
may also be assessed, with plenty of room for a safety run off.
Take time to assess the various requirements, noting each in
turn, then understanding how they will all work in best possible
harmony.
Have a general look at the machine before riding it. Start by pressing down on the rear suspension to see how stiff or soft it is. Guess the centre of gravity. Then make a guess as to how you think it will handle. Then ride it. Afterwards, decide if your guess was correct and modify your thinking to suit. You will probably want to look again at the machine to see why it handles thus. Is your machine going to be like this, or better ?
No machine will be perfect, but another refining stage is to get the many conflicting aspects of the design sorted into the best compromise as possible from the outset, then by gradual steps, improve the design by various means.
Having the facilities to make complex engineering parts from scratch is great, but few have such luxuries.
Searching out parts and ideas from other vehicles, already
built, or closely manufactured to the intended purpose will save
a lot of work. This will also give greater reliability and make
parts replacement so much easier.
There are perfectly good solutions to most problems somewhere in
other vehicles, or perhaps in divers other machines, so keep
eyes open and use imagination. It should all fall in place with
a little time and effort.
When starting to use parts from many machines, use a permanent
paint marker pen to ensure the make, model and year of the donor
vehicle is permanently on the item. This way it is possible to
replace or repair with minimal hassle. It is easy to forget much
about the components, so make life easier from the start with a
simple parts list.
Never modify a standard component such as engine mount or prop
shaft until the last moment, as the design will change many,
many times.
I know many people who need to replace a axle, clutch or
whatever, but when asked -' what's it off'? , they have
forgotten or have no clue. A scrapyarder may know. So keep most
of the main parts to one donor car wherever possible.
Car engines can, and do leap about in their mountings, so keep
the original rubber mounts for the engine as these will reduce
the chances of frame fracturing.
If making very special engine mounts, they should be 'tuned' to
the engine vibrations, to minimise the worse effects and be able
to resolve the torque reaction from the engine into the frame.
Always use any original engine steady bars in the same way as
used in the car, as they are not always obvious in the way they
should be mounted.
This Jag efi V12 engine in a trike is mounted on just two main
rubber blocks the size of a fist, with a simple spring at the
rear of the gearbox. Very simple and very effective, but then,
V12's are delightfully smooooooth.
This may sound obvious, but make sure that parts can be reached
easily and that it is easy to remove the engine. Some poorly
designed trikes are atrocious to work on. If it is necessary to
remove the engine to set the valve clearances, try again.
ALL maintenance should be simple.
In an ideal world, it should be possible to lift the standard
engine, complete with mountings and all ancillaries, out of a
standard car, straight into the trike with just a couple of
friends, a plank and some ropes.
It is not unusual for car based trikes to get through many
engines a year, being thrashed regularly as their owners demand
the same acceleration as their motorcycle.
Wherever possible, make the engine easy to replace. For those
who wish, the frame can be designed to have removable sections
for extremely easy engine replacement. Far too many trikes
either need the engine to be stripped for removal, or to be
hoisted out from above, or fitted from underneath. Make life
easy for yourself. If design problems get bad, at least make it
easy to drop the engine and simply lift or roll the trike off.
An adequate compromise is to be able to block the rear wheels
and lift the front wheel very high, to extract the engine from
underneath.
Even a five litre V12 can be designed for easy engine removal
and yet such engines are easily designed to flex safely upon
their standard engine mounts, albeit with attitude to enhance
the experience.
Ordinary engines should be an absolute doddle to maintain and replace. If the popular transverse engine is mounted normally on its rubber blocks, then most engines can be removed easily. The rear of trikes can be simply removed or unbolted for total and easy access and removal. This is particularly useful for changing the clutches of some transversely mounted engines.
If the engine has a turbo, complex fuel injection system and loads of computers and electrical junk to make it work, then consider mounting some complex assemblies in modular form so they are both waterproof and easily removed as discrete units to allow a complex engine to be more easily repaired or replaced.
Frames. See below. Once the rear is reasonably well defined, the
general layout of the frame must know just where the tubes are
to end at the front. The front end tubing is important for
trikes, as not only is structural integrity important, but the
style is also a critical component of the design.
Some of my road-legal hubcentre steering motorcycles have been
ridden quite happily with almost vertical steering angles, while
some of my friends severe customs seem to get away with
extremely long forks.
If in doubt, don't go stupid, stick to what looks right. That
is, the same as bikes, especially if using standard bike forks.
Steering head angles are often chosen to reduce stiction in
telescopic forks.
Extended forks are weak on bikes and even more so on trikes,
especially when braking.
A rake bigger than normal as on extended forks may occasionally
lead to an enormous turning circle, so at least make sure
reverse gear is easy to find to get out of tight situations. As
trikes do not lean, they can get away with less radical front
tyre profiles, allowing a greater foot print to take a larger
load while maintaining sensible tyre pressures.
Good design will allow even a long raked set of forks to have a
sensible amount of trail. Alternative front ends are mentioned
later.
Take at least a week to design a couple of frames, preferably a
month or more with a difficult design.
The average is about a couple of weeks to a month, but for some,
it takes so long that rust gets there first.
Do not give up easily, but definitely do not rush the
design.
As the design develops, you may soon fall into the trap of
following a single, obvious frame design. Use your sketches or
drawings and trace out at least three different frames. At least
one frame design should be radical, - really off the wall, blue
sky thinking.
The final frame will probably be a mix of the better aspects of
each.
Always work in all three views, side, plan and front views, as
what seems good in side view can be awkward or dangerous in
front view. It is a process of continual refinement.
When satisfied, you will surely want to make it better a couple
of days later, in the light of inspiration when daydreaming at
work. Talk it through with friends when they call, make a cuppa
and stand around in the garage discussing, with all the bits
arranged as intended. It happens all around the world.
Always start frame design with imagination, with a feeling of the weight and position of the components. Then imagine just what is happening to the main components. Get a feel of the whole machine. Write down good ideas immediately so they won't be forgotten later. (All too easily done.) Even experts forget superb insights and possibilities for want of a piece of paper. Backs of cigarette packets and napkins attest to the ambiguous nature of the design process.
From the start, mark in the steering head, engine mounts and
suspension positions which are often demanded by the chosen
engine and suspension.
Carefully rearrange or compromise anything which gets in the way
of a strong frame with good weight distribution.
Play around with the components until they look about right. To
get the forks positioned (if used), simply rest them against a
chair, or strung from the roof by the handlebars. Use modelling
clay or tape to keep the front wheel in position on the floor.
Tubes that are spread wide and well supported to make various
triangles will give some of the strongest frames.
Design
the main tubing to connect the steering head, engine and
suspension first. Then subtlety add any secondary tubes to
improve triangulation to prevent these main tubes from flexing
or buckling. For simplicity and strength, main frame tubes
should be one length from front to rear.
Wherever possible, make the frame design a mirror image each
side, as this makes for easier manufacture and alignment. More
importantly, this also keeps any frame flexing even, creating
less distortion and better handling under heavy loads. Try not
to have all welds grouped close together unless well gusseted.
The style of the frame is an open book, there are no
all-encompassing constraints other than common sense and safety.
Only 'mass produced' trikes have any similarity in design. The
standard trike is often far less than the art form it could be.
The exceptional trikes, - and there are quite a few select
machines out there, - have an overriding theme to their form,
with form being drawn into the function in a positive way.
An exceptional trike will naturally draw people to it.
Occasionally a trike does it so well while making a bold
statement.
This is art, possibly even aggressive art.
A trike should be a statement, be it parked outside a pub or
cafe, conveying bridesmaids to the church, on show in an
exhibition, or being thrashed around a corner in a power drift
past open jawed pedestrians.
Trikes need not be simple front ends with tubing to hold bits together. They can be gracefully swan necked in the Swedish style, perhaps styled as an alien artefact, or a techno or engineering tour de force. As car based trikes are not afraid of a few extra pounds of weight, consider using stronger tubing if a 'swan neck' design is preferred.
Trikes should always be art forms and a little extra strength in the right place will keep them looking great.
A few more weeks drawing radical designs can often change the whole path of the project.
Then sweat blood to keep and enhance this style so it will also stand out from the crowd when built.
Whatever is designed, do not be happy until your sketches stand out from the page.
Occasionally, the concept shouts at you from the page that it must be built. You will know when this happens.
Everyone has at least one exceptional idea hidden inside them.
This will surely need to be built for the real world, so
engineering is the fundamental stage.
With the sketch pad in one hand and a tape measure in the other,
study the components laid out in the garage and consider the
following.
Looking down from top.
How much weight is on the front wheel with rider(s). Too much,
too little?
Sketch in the radius arms and where they will mount to the
frame. (to prevent the rear wheels jumping ahead of the machine
when opening the throttle, or flying off behind when you apply
the rear brakes.)
What part of the frame actually supports the weight of the trike
at the top of the shock springs.
What will keep the top of any McPherson struts from flexing fore
or aft when accelerating or braking, it may be a light force,
but it exists. Will the bracket support or foul the rear of the
passenger seats, or can it be angled back and down slightly with
extension brackets.
Where will the gearchange linkage fit relative to the riders
seat.
Will the rider be able to reach the handlebars or is a linkage
needed.
Will there be enough room for passengers and a trunk. (boot).
Are the riders and passengers feet going to be in the right
places.
Exhaust routing.
Radiators.
Fuel storage.
Looking from the side.
How much weight is on the front wheel.
Will the rider be comfortable, and how low can the seats be
positioned without compromising strength, or will the rider be
hanging onto the handlebars like a flag in the wind when
thrashing corners.
Will the steering head bend upon landing after the first wheelie
or over a hump back bridge. Steering head extra support tubing
and fillets: size and shape.
Are the tubes from the steering head to bottom of the frame
securely positioned at their low points and what type of fillets
or gussets are needed to maximise strength.
Is the ground clearance adequate.
Are wheelie bars needed because you decide to use an air-cooled
Porsche engine hanging out the rear.
Will emergency stops become dangerous.
Are the riders and passengers feet going to be in the right
places.
Gearchange routing.
How can an exposed engine be made to look better.
Exhaust routing.
Radiators.
Fuel storage.
Looking from the rear.
What exactly is holding up all the weight. Decide what is
actually holding up the top of the rear shock absorbers and the
springs. Also decide what is preventing the shock mounts from
being pushed up and inwards when landing off a hump back bridge
at fifty miles an hour.
What is keeping the bottom tubes from spreading apart.
Is the ground clearance adequate.
Is the engine easily accessible for replacement.
Where will the gearchange linkage fit. - Is there a suitable gap
between gearbox and sump on a transverse engine. Can it run
safely under or over the engine in a straight line towards the
rider, or need to be routed over the motor or gearbox.
How can an exposed rear engine be made to look better.
Exhaust routing.
Looking from the front.
Can you see the side lights.
Will the passengers be safe when cornering.
How will cooling air flow be captured and directed to the
radiators.
How can an exposed front engine be made to look better.
Exhaust routing.
Also consider the general style from all angles.
Will the passengers look good for the camera, or are they stuck
like flags in the wind. Will the radiator ducts blend in and
around the frame tubes.
When not using safety belts, the passengers should be considered
as dumb, unsecured loads, especially when braking or powering
around corners. Also give them decent foot rails to take the
braking forces. Seat side support or hand rails also offer a
chance of survival.
With the above in mind, the main structural areas are now marked
on the drawings. These are then gradually refined, especially
the steering head, engine mounts, rider load points. This is the
important part of frame design, but the engine and frame
component mountings will decide and constrain much of this work.
Also mark in the forces of both the static loads and the full
acceleration and braking forces, and when landing off a jump.
Mark them on the paper as arrows if necessary, to maintain the
most effective use of such drawings.
Marking the arrows on the sketch pad proportionally large to the
forces involved, helps direct the subjective design of the
frames form and structure. A yellow felt tip pen will allow the
drawing to be modified over these underlying guides to highlight
what will be happening to the overall structure.
Always try to break the design in your mind.
Where are the weakest places, where are the places of greatest
load. What happens to the frame when the bike is cornering hard
with a full load? What will break first?, What happens if.....?
Get to fully understand the designs and ask everyone what they
think and how they would design the frame. This gives more
options and time to spot any hidden problems in the design at an
early stage.
Overall design and bracing will require careful design of the chassis. Computer aided finite element analysis can help. Those without access to such assistance can model the structure and test load until inappropriate distortion occurs.
The main tubes are often four long tubes with engine and
suspension fittings often mounted directly.
On a recent V12 the front frame was essentially a massive Norton
Featherbed frame. On another, the frame was four almost parallel
tubes with the flat four engine slid in between them.
Modelling.
If you can make a real frame, you can make a wire model. It
doesn't have to be accurate, just use solder and straightened
paperclips or similar materials. With a soldering iron and some
wire, build an approximate model of your frame, then load it to
see where it breaks. If you have a small soldering iron, then
straighten some paperclips. If you have a big soldering iron,
then scrape the flux off a few arc welding rods.
Don't just see which wires bend, but also the direction that
they bend. Model the engine and suspension at their mounting
points to apply the loads at as required. See what the engine
and suspension mounts are going to do. Modify and try various
designs until feeling confident. Do not confuse poor soldering
with poor design. If you make three different wire frames,
comparative tests can be used using standard weights such as
bags of sugar balancing precariously on the structure for spot
loadings. Load and twist it in many ways so it distorts or
breaks. An evening spent like this tells you loads (pun
intended) about your design.
Consider the frame as a means of holding all together and the
forces under acceleration, braking and cornering. The rider and
passengers are just loads, whereas the engine and brakes are
much more interactive parts of the structure and apply the
larger loads and forces.
If you don't like soldering, then get some drinking straws and
blue tacky office putty and make a lightweight test rig.
If you want to know what type of loads are acting on each weld,
then make a model from straws and blue tack, then load gently to
see how the structure pulls apart.
If a trike is to take a few months or more to build, just one
evening studying and testing the structure is always time well
spent. The final frame design will probably be a mixture of the
initial frames envisioned. More importantly, you will have much
greater understanding as to what is happening to each part of
the frame. Design it many times, so you need build it only once.
Which would you prefer - build a model and find out problems on
the kitchen table, or after you have welded up the real frame ?
Reading the way the designs finally fail will highlight the
probable way the forces are acting and where. Scale models do
not always model truthfully at full size, but anything which
gives insight will always help understand the forces and their
problems. Final testing will be at full size, although the loads
are much higher, which can get awkward. See testing later.
Passengers deserve consideration, so always make your machine
comfortable and safe.
The best trikes are very comfortable for many hours, often
employing modified car seat components. The best trikes should
have the passengers luxuriating in comfort comparable with the
best cars, with plush armrests and well angled foot rests. Your
grandmother is usually the best tester for comfort.
Trikes do not lean, so thrashing around corners will have the
rider hanging off the handlebars like a flag in a tornado. This
is acceptable in cars with side supports on their seats and
doors. But trikes with unsupported riders can cause steering
problems of rider leaning inwards against the centripetal forces
while trying to steer. Therefore ensure the riders legs and butt
are positioned to handle excessive twisty lane thrashing. For
the rider, the handlebars can be hung on to if the pivot is
fairly central between the grips, but if the handlebars are long
pull-backs, things can get annoying, so consider the design
well.
Monster amplifiers and cup holders although not compulsory, may also be considered, as some superb trikes are sometimes naturally used merely for posing on boulevards. Not everyone has serious thrashing as the main goal, for others a trike is used for daily transport. If polished walnut trim, connoly hide and champagne is the style required, then go for it. Trikes are designed and built to be enjoyed. See sculpting later.
All frames will differ.
The problems with an Alfa 1500 flat four engine meant the
lower frame rails will have to run partially under the front of
the engine, but with the main support tubes over the engine to
allow engine removal. The frame had four main tubes from the
steering head, triangulated with smaller tubes in between, like
a space frame. A Ducati trellis is similar. Two tubes ran above
and two tubes spreading wider and lower to hold the engine
mounts. The upper tubes let the rider sit astride them and have
hidden box section support tubing widening out and up to the
upper suspension points at the rear. The suspension is mounted
to the frame at the top. As the suspension was pushed upwards, a
cross member prevented them folding. The radius arms were
mounted on the lower tubes near the engine in a rubber bush at
the front, near the clutch housing via welded brackets. This was
later changed to a combined radius arm and anti roll bar to
improve strength and reduce complexity. The rear swing arms
pivoted near the gearbox in the original bushes. The upper arm
was also the suspension unit, fitted to the frame using the
original rubber block. The biggest problem with the Alfa was
that the engine tended to push out of its rubber mountings when
braking or accelerating hard. A rubber mounted rod was chosen to
transmit the braking and accelerating forces between the engine
and frame. This was later replaced with a small suspension
A-frame as it also prevented sideways motion. Engine vibration
was not transmitted as the gearchange rod is placed neutral to
the way the engine vibrates. If needed, a triangular engine
brace will allow an engine to move without misalignment.
All the parts you need are available, they just have to be discovered and decided how to be used to advantage in differing ways.
For all designs, there are many problems, but their solutions are not always obvious. Spend time to check the various possibilities.
On most trikes, the front end is usually the steering head,
although hub centre steering and other options are also
available. The distance from the steering head to the nearest
upper and lower engine or suspension mounting points will
usually decide the general shape of the front of the frame. In
plan view, the width should be reasonable, allowing the rider to
straddle the frame comfortably. In side view the front may not
look quite right with straight tubes, so tubing may need to be
bent for giving a better shape to the tubing. Trikes with rear
engines often look good with a gently reducing frame taper or
swan neck, but this must be strong. If the steering head support
tubing makes a triangle when seen from the side and from above,
then this is unlikely to flex, with only a few fillets or
gussets needed to keep the head stock from distorting under
load.
Extreme swan necks may need extra support near the headstock to
prevent distortion. For those who want to keep the clean lines
on their front tubing, the usual side fillet plates can be
replaced with a much stronger central fillet plate between the
frame tubes. This may need to be fully welded to the steering
head before fitting to the tubing, so that it is welded securely
in an area otherwise impossible to reach.
Trikes with engines at the front will often naturally have a
well supported head stock as they often employ tubes over and
under the engine, which naturally curve up to form a well
supported head stock.
Hydraulic pipe benders can be hired.
When bending main tubes which are also cosmetic, make sure the
hydraulic benders formers do not make scratches or other
imperfections. A light polishing of the formers with emery cloth
or wet and dry paper or a flap wheel does no harm, and if
pampering the tubes, consider a nylon cloth lining. I use sheets
of plastic cut from old plastic oil containers, as the HDPE
(high density polyethylene) is a superb material, as used on
replacement hip joints and takes high loads with minimal
abrasion.
It is not necessary to make just one bend in the frame tube. A
series of gentle bends can enhance both the styling lines and
riding position. As the rear of the frame widens past the front
rider, the tubes can sweep up towards the top of any shock
absorber mountings, but these may often compromise passenger
seating. Secondary or alternative upper frame tubes, running
each side of the engine can usually support separate
triangulated suspension tubing which clears the ideal passenger
seating areas.
In both plan view and from the side, the main tubes must not be
able to spread apart under load, so upper and lower central
cross tubes are often used. When designed badly, cross tubes can
prevent engine removal and cause other annoying problems. It is
better to position two well spaced tubes for an easier life than
a single tube to save a little weight. Alternatively one very
large frame tube may make servicing easier.
The lower frame tubes will usually support the radius arm loads
and must not spread apart under load.
The Rob North Trident frames show what can be done with a tube
bender.
Assuming a four tube frame with motorcycle forks : Take careful note how the main tubes from the steering head will flow backwards and downwards to the obvious engine mounting points. There may be a problem with decent seating and so the upper tubes may need to curve low to allow the rider to straddle them comfortably, and then up to the upper engine mounts or rear upper suspension points. If the upper tubes are low, then the lower tubes must be even lower to allow a decent distance between them for structural strength. If the tubes were too close together, as seen from the side, then the front end would want to bend upwards and collapse the frame. If the tubes are close together, then consider a trellis design of intermediate strengthening as seen on mass produced roof frames in sports halls and cheap conference centres. This is a pair of tubes with an intermediate zig zag to give intermediate triangulation to prevent bending and collapse. This applies to both side and plan views.
Like many trike engines, the Alfa engine was front wheel drive,
so the original steering linkage is stripped to use just the
inner cross shaft which holds the inner steering ball joints.
This shaft is welded to a frame bracket to prevent moving left
and right, and positioned in the same way as the original, so
that up and down suspension movement will not affect wheel
alignment.
It is often seen that the cars' steering rack outer retained for
easier mounting, with the steering shaft stub welded to prevent
movement. The best method is to retain just the inner rack shaft
and weld mounting brackets directly onto it near the ends for
greater security and lightness.
Retaining and fixing the steering linkage is very common on
trikes and if done properly will allow adjustment toe-in of the
rear wheels. This is important during testing so always build it
so it can be adjusted, usually at the outer ball ends. The angle
of the steering link arm should parallel the drive shaft or
lower wishbone link, as seen from the rear.
If a very long or awkward trike, then it is possible on some designs to include three wheel steering for parking purposes, where the normally fixed steering rack can be activated to enhance slow speed manoeuvrability.
Toe in, is when the wheels point inwards slightly, usually measured in degrees, or in differences in millimetres between front and rear of the rear wheel rims. Toe out is simply the same, but the wheels point out towards the front of the vehicle. Camber is the amount of lean from the vertical on the wheel, as seen from the front. This is often easily noticed on some formula one front ends. A simple ball park position is to set the wheels straight ahead and straight up when normally loaded. From this the toe in can be adjusted during testing to get the best handling. The camber is best left as vertical for best tyre wear in a straight line. The upper mounting of the suspension could be given adjustable positions to allow the camber to be adjusted, but is rarely applicable for most machines unless building your own suspension.
There are many variables which decide the optimum toe in or out
and the camber, such as when cornering, where the outside wheel
is the most heavily loaded and can take advantage of a little
toe in or toe out to help steer the machine should it exhibit
oversteer or understeer. Under power, the driving wheel will
want to gain traction in such as way as to cause problems in
poor suspension, where toe in or out can counteract problems.
Camber could be set-up so the outside wheel in a turn, when it's
suspension is more heavily loaded than the inside wheel
suspension, then the outside wheel will lie flat on the road for
maximum grip. There are many variables which are mentioned
earlier and can be studied in many standard books on the
subject. If in doubt, set at the standard for the original
machine. If it's a front wheel drive donor car components used
in a trike, some tyre wear may occur, requiring gradual
adjustment for a few weeks until the optimum is attained. Use
the worst two wheels of the four until the steering is optimised.
Suspension must be stopped just before maximum travel by a
strongly mounted rubber block. These are usually stuck to a
plate on the frame and can be carved to size, using any of the
many blocks available.
The McPherson strut design uses a rubber block in the upper
damper and spring unit to absorb the road shocks. This shock
unit also maintains the camber and supports the weight of the
vehicle at maximum load. On McPherson struts, alignment can be
done by simple positioning of the upper mounting point, which
also supports the weight of the machine. A little rearward
movement is possible, allowing the top of the rear shocks to be
further back by an inch or so, especially if the passengers can
sit lower, but may require similar angluation of the lower
wishbone or arm and anti roll bar or radius arm, only possible
with rubber bushes or spherical pivots.
When accelerating, the power to the wheels will make the wheel hubs want to move forward. For wheel hubs to push the weight of the trike forward, this is done by using the radius arms or wishbones connected from the wheel hubs to the frame or engine. Braking forces are the same, but simply working in the opposite direction. Brake drums or callipers must not turn and the radius arms or wishbones usually handle this problem.
When the suspension is at mid point, the suspension arms and
propshafts should be about horizontal. If you use a double
wishbone design, keep them the original length, unless you know
your geometry. Always make sure the drive shaft splines are
correctly positioned.
If making your own double wishbone design, then design the upper
and lower wishbones so that the wheel will remain as close to
vertical throughout the suspension movement. (In a roll
situation) This is usually done by having the upper wishbone
about 10 to 20 percent shorter than the lower wishbone,
depending upon the position of the pivots from the chassis
centreline.
Always build as matched left and right hand side symmetrical
pairs wherever possible, using a jig. A simple welding jig will
greatly assist the alignment of such suspension components. The
distance between the inner and outer axes should normally be the
same length as the distance between the centres of the universal
joints in the propshaft.
If you have a subframe such as used by mini's, then simply keep
the original set-up intact.
Although not recommended, there is nothing from an engineering point that prevents three wheel steering, taking advantage of this ability to steer the rear wheels. Not recommended for road use, but may make very long show trikes easier to manoeuvre and more fun to ride and easier to park. Some 1990's cars offered all wheel steering, but it seemed merely a fad.
Once the basic frame has been decided, refining the frame will
make life simpler as you work around, or even remove problems
that are discovered while looking at the assembled parts.
Sketch out ideas on paper. With a little extra time, parts can
be made simpler while adding reliability, by simply keeping your
eyes open and pinching ideas from other designs.
The more you look and think, the better your ideas will be, so
take time at this stage to make for an easier life later on.
Make loads of drawings no matter how bad they are, they are
worth more than gold at this stage. It must be right and if you
don't know why, then give up now or decide that you want to
learn more, and keep trying before building. The more thought
applied, the more possible it is to get the centre of gravity
lower, make the frame stronger, lighter and also easier to build.
Whatever the frame design, the steel tubes used will be either
tubular, square or rectangular, or a selection of all three.
Where parts are hidden, use square tubing, as its easier to fit,
stronger and easily shaped. Square section tubes which are open
to public view are usually considered a styling failure unless
styled really well.
Composites are still difficult for cars and bikes, so don't
bother. Likewise for monocoque, as the panel work will give a
little more rigidity and lightness at the expense of far too
many hours work and inability to repair easily.
If you want to go the composite route, start with studying
formula one design and modify from there, choose your engine
very carefully and consider at least six cylinders to reduce
vibration. Best of luck and feel free to email the author.
There is nothing wrong with tubes, they have a long history of
both success and failure.
Always mount engines as the manufacturer intended. Building an engine into a frame so it is part of a rigid structure is OK for bikes with their high revs and low reciprocating masses, but a car engine is often more agricultural. Only six cylinders and over should be contemplated for rigid fixing, as their vibrations are less. If rigid mounting is used, be very wary of fractures in the frame over long periods of time and spread the load into the frame with smooth and well spaced engine mounts. Rubber mounting helps resolve torsional effects around the flywheel axis and for this reason, most engines are rubber mounted and also have an engine head steady.
If you have an engine with dry sump, you may want to use the
frame for the oil tank. Use a good MIGor TIG welder which causes
far less slag in the tubing. Do not position any connecting
pipes where they can encourage fractures to occur. Drill
adjoining holes for both oil drain and air venting between the
connecting tubes before welding and always have an oil filter
after the frame outlet and definitely before the engine. Oil
holes in the frame tubes must be large enough for maximum oil
flow at top revs, otherwise oil starvation will occur. An
average engine will pump well over a litre every ten seconds at
LOW speeds, so always ensure the holes in the frame can handle a
lot more than this, and never rely upon pump suction to prevent
oil pressure loss.
A simple vented cap from a moped two stroke oil tank will
suffice for filling and venting, if hidden from sticky fingers.
Never take the oil feed from the bottom of the tank / frame,
always allow an area for unwanted sediment to settle, with the
oil pipe a little higher, preferably with a wire mesh screen.
Make sure most of the oil will drain out.
The simplest oil level assessment is via a dip stick. This can
be a flexible piece of thin wire strip to access the curved
frame tubes, possibly even an old speedo cable. Make sure the
oil level area of the dipstick is protected by dimples or bumps,
so the position of the oil level is not wiped off when removing
the dip stick.
Where oil level cannot be assessed by a dip stick, then the oil
level can be seen via small tubes above and below the level,
connected by a clear plastic tube. If welding small pipes is
difficult, simply push the pipe in a small hole in a safe part
of the frame, below the intended oil level. To save bends in the
small pipe, place a steel rod in the hole and lever the hole so
the pipe is fairly vertical and weld from the inside if
possible. Then run a drill though the tube to allow oil access.
Then solder around the outside of the tube to seal it. For
safety reasons, the oil must not be allowed to drain from a
broken pipe, so this should not be too far below the oil level,
but low enough to see when filling up. To protect the pipe, the
clear plastic tube can be protected along its whole length with
strong sleeving, and just the oil level area exposed for
inspection. Alternatively a second, larger bore clear pipe can
also be employed to protect the smaller oil level pipe. This can
then be run along the frame tube to be vented into the oil cap.
Oil in the frame can show up any fractures at an early stage and
should be considered a safety feature rather than a problem.
There are various techniques for welding frames.
Arc welding is the most common form of welding and when done
properly, can accomplish all needs of construction. Thin sheet
is the usually the most difficult, so fuel tanks can be flanged
to make welding easier, or tack welded then handed over to a
professional mig or bronze welder.
Bronze welding is better for strength and ideal for reducing
fracture points of small tubes and fittings.
Very lightly loaded fittings such as oil level pipe can be
heavily soldered.
Mig or Tig welding will leave the frame with minimal internal
slag which could flake off and clog the oil lines. Always clean
the insides of the tubes before final assembly and welding.
Where welds are to occur in the frame tubes, clean back to bare
metal prior to tig or mig welding to minimise internal slag.
Follow up with regular inspection of the outlet pipe to check
for any clogging.
The Lamborghini Countach has a tubular chassis which is made up
of a large number of small round tubes arranged to make many
triangles, called a 'space frame'. The triangle is the most
rigid shape around. If you don't want to bend tubes, then try
designing a frame from many big and small triangles. The later
Lamborghini Diablo used square tubing for it's space frame, was
easier to build than the Countach, and was stiffer and lighter.
Do not have long unsupported tubes. Always employ smaller tubes
to stop the long main tubes from flexing or bending. The whole
frame can be made from large and smaller triangles. A rectangle
can distort, so guess what you should do. Some motorcycle
trellis frames use an appropriate method.
With all your ideas down on paper you will soon see where you
can improve the frame.
Creating a merely adequate design is a weak excuse, while common
sense and inspiration are infinitely more applicable for trikes.
Bikes and their engines will need accurate chain-drive alignment
and a sprocket on the differential.
A modified swing arm is not adequate for the solid type of rear
axle unless for slow riding.
Radius arms are needed for decent independent rear suspension.
The rest is widely open to interpretation. Whatever you do, keep
it light, or at least keep weight down, unless you are using a
'busa or dual engined nitrous big bore Harleys.
Some quad bikes now use independent rear suspension with a
differential of a size and weight commensurate with a lighter
bike-based trike. Such items can be lighter and more appropriate
than heavier car items for a more balanced lightweight machine
which does not handle too much power.
It is very important to match the gearing of the shaft drive
systems. Work out the revs of the shaft at top speed and
calculate if this will match the revs required for the proposed
differential unit and wheel size. Most shaft drive bikes use a
similar arrangement and the differences may not be far from what
is needed.
If you don't like arithmetic, then wheel size can adjust the
final overall gearing to allow a decent top speed plus
reasonable hill climbing ability without trashing the clutch.
Gearing can be raised by fitting larger wheels, which may or may
not increase top speed and vice versa. Gearing can reduce any
bad design tendencies to wheelie, usually at the expense of the
clutch.
If the radius arms of a solid rear axle are positioned so they pivot concentric with the front sprocket, then chain play will be minimal and your chain will have a happy and long life. A motorcycle chain can handle a little amount of sideways play as the axle lifts on one side, but the panhard rod will ensure it keeps in line and does not wear badly.
There must always be allowance for chain adjustment, so the differential must be able to be adjusted on its mountings, or the radius arms lengthened to accommodate for chain wear. If this is not possible, then you may wish to use a roller on the lower chain run and a strongly sprung loaded jockey pulley, or preferably an adjustable pulley wheel which can be secured so that there is minimal slack on the overrun for a well behaved power train.
One-piece rear axle units, consisting of the differential,
brakes and wheels will need to be kept central while allowing
for suspension movement. Front to rear movement is prevented by
a radius arm on each side, as shown in the little animation
shown earlier, pivoting at the front in rubber bushes and
usually fixed to the axle unit to prevent its rotation. On some
designs, the radius arms do not prevent rotation, so the design
must prevent the whole lot turning when accelerating and
braking, requiring either an upper brace, or other method to
prevent the axle from turning.
Component choices: Swing arm and radius arm bearings are either
rubber bushes, metal bushes or needle rollers. Balls are not
recommended, nor are large rollers, because swing arms only
pivot over a few degrees, so the point loading of the bearing is
far too localised to ensure long life. Although taper rollers
are used on the swing arms of shaft drive machines, it may be
easier to use needle rollers, which spread the load wide and
roll over larger displacements for even wear. Needle rollers
cannot take end loads, so either bushes or some other form of
end load resolution should be accommodated as trikes suffer
vastly worse from this than standard motorcycles. If the swing
arm bearings are well spaced and the swing arm a rigid one piece
design, then rubber bushes are acceptable for many reasons
including simplicity and reliability.
There is no need to use metal suspension bearings to mount
shock absorbers, as the shock absorber is a flexible medium. The
use of rubber simply refines the set-up and reduces shocks into
the frame.
Forks are always the weak point of trikes from an engineering
point of view.
Forks are often the strong point of trikes from a styling point
of view.
The forks must have twin discs to stop a trike which is probably
twice the weight such forks and brakes were designed for.
Standard motorcycle front ends are not up to the job of a big
trike.
From a safety aspect, the forces applied by twin brakes will at
least be matched to the forks and allow the braking forces to be
applied evenly and fairly safely. The forces on standard brakes
will be similar to that which the forks can take, ensuring a
fair degree of safety. In many cases, standard brakes may not be
able to offer the braking forces required of a larger, heavier
machine.
Never accept the fact that because someone has already built a
two litre trike with 125cc trail bike front end, that it is a
good idea. Yes, they do exist, but probably not for very long.
I know of a car engined trike with 1980's 125 trail bike front
end. The owner says he 'only gets the front brake working once a
year for the MOT'. It oozes rust from the brake drum plate and
patently only there for legal rather than safety reasons. Such
machines are a statement of design failure far beyond mere
ignorance, and are most assuredly an engineering death wish.
Everyone has the right to be stupid, but never abuse the
privilege.
Standard forks should be used as intended, with their rake angles designed to take the shock loads as sliding tubes. The amount of trail will depend upon how they are mounted, but keep it close to original as this is how they are designed to work.
Long telescopic forks for styling purposes will often act as
simple beam springs, absorbing the shock by bending rather than
telescoping. This makes it a spring, not a damper, so will
resolve the force by flexing back in an uncontrolled manner. Go
carefully and make sure your forks act as shock absorbers, not
as undamped springs.
Girder forks at least offer the chance for their small bottom
swing arms to flex through an arc as intended and thus take some
shock out of the legs. Do not expect such designs to handle too
well or give any subtle feedback as to what the road is doing
with the steering, but properly designed, they can act
effectively as steering and suspension devices, and with an
easily adjusted amount of trail to refine the steering.
Long forked, custom front ends with a large amount of rake, will
allow a motorcycle tyre to be used in preference to other
options. This is because the amount of lean of the wheel in the
forks when cornering, (not to be confused with roll) will allow
the side of the tyre to be applied to the road surface. This
also reduces the amount of side force on the tyre, trying to
push it off the rim as found on heavier trike front ends.
Manoeuvring around tight car parks will demand a reverse
gearchange or friends to help push the machine backwards.
Standard telescopic forks may not be up to the heavy side loading as found with trikes, so the front tyre may want to roll off the rim. Therefore any design where this can be limited or designed around should be used. Tyres are more prone to bad effects such as wear on larger machines and will tend to distort when given the unusual side loads of a trike, which does not lean in the same manner as motorcycles. (An engineering advantage of long forks is that the front wheel lean relative to the road is improved, reducing the tendency of the tyre to roll off the rim, but as such forks usually cannot apply any reasonable force, this aspect of trike design is purely academic.)
Use of inner tubes should be considered where extreme side loads are applied to motorcycle tyres. Where inner tubes and tyres are used heavily with side loads, they may distort or lift off the rims and may on rare occasions get hotter, so check during early tests on twisty roads. The tyres should cool down to more sensible levels during straight line running and is rarely a problem, but inner tubes are well worth the safety factor.
Strength is a main area of concern. It must be kept in mind at
all times when choosing front end components. Therefore, where
style comes before practicality or suitability for the purpose,
make sure you do not put yourself in a position of danger.
With large engined machines, the builder must look for
alternatives to motorcycle fork legs unless the machine is
primarily for posing.
For fast road work in country roads, where braking into fast
corners and subsequent powered fast exit cornering, then
motorcycle forks and wheel design will compromise the limits to
which the design can push. Weight balance and centre of gravity
will also be major deciding factors as mentioned earlier. A very
low trike with strong, balanced front end working in concert
with the rear will handle almost any situation.
The car wheel is designed for, and less prone to the side load problems of trikes. Unfortunately car tyres and wheels are not designed for fork legs, where the steeper rake angle of fork design prefers a more rounded tyre profile. There is also the problem of the car wheel not being compatible with forks, or style.
Car rims usually have an inner lip to reduce the chance of the tyre from peeling off under extreme side loads. Using car rims with this attribute will assist with some extreme problems of thrashing a trike in twisty roads and fast corners. If the wheel size does not have inner lips on both sides, then either build up a similar profile inside the rim by careful welding, or mix split rims or lathe the rim on the trike and weld two halves together. This also allows for custom wheel rim widths, as found useful on some of the authors machines. See also wheels later.
A few pointers.
Most heavyweight trikes use serious front alloy wheels on
special axles, but the tyre is the main component, choose it
well. The basic car tyre can often be found in almost, or
partially round profile, usually on cheaper tyres with narrower
cross sections. For ordinary wheels such as the standard car 13"
wheel with narrower section, the cheaper tyres are often of a
partially rounded profile. So off to the local tyre dealer and
look at the tyres, then choose the one with the most rounded
profile. It is also usually the cheapest tyre.
If worried about fitting bike tyres on car rims, then check the
rim dimensions and profiles with the SAE standard dimensions.
SAE= Society of Automotive Engineers. I've been doing this for
years.
Look at the options available in tyre dealers, and choose your tyre profile first.
The tyre is the main component, choose it well. Then mount it on a decent front end.
If making new front ends, then making the wheel rim and hub is the best place to start. See making wheels later.
If not using a bike front end, get the steering head made
professionally. Invest in a decent item using larger taper
roller bearings available from any bearing shop.
As a good alternative, choose the often cheaper yet equally
suitable bearings as used in car wheel hubs. These often use
excellent large taper bearings at sensible prices and offer
excellent spares availability. Where wheel bearing kits are
supplied with two sizes, usually a larger outer taper roller and
a smaller inner, then buy two sets, as the price is still often
much cheaper. Alternatively, use the smaller bearing at the top,
where the forces are much lighter and the larger one to take the
main load.
Whether with identical top and bottom bearings, or a more
suitable, cheaper and lighter form, - always ask around first,
before building, as many people will machine a steering head for
a small fee during the night shift.
Keeping to standard components from other sources, means keeping it cheap and keeping it reliable.
If making a steering head, get tubing much stronger than the original and take time to get everything perfect. Where possible, reassemble accurately using old bearings, so you can weld to it without damage. Then be prepared to replace with new bearings after welding if they become damaged through excess heat.
The simplest steering head is a large tube with a close fit for taper roller bearing outer race which can be carefully ground or machined away inside to accept the bearings firmly. Alternatively use a split tube slightly smaller and clamp firmly over the bearings with Jubilee clips or exhaust clamps, then weld the gap. Alternatively use a larger tube and grind down the slot, and again clamp tightly then weld the tube to fit the bearings. Tack weld the tube, then remove the bearings and weld fully. Make sure the bearings are a firm fit, if they are not, saw a slot and tighten the gap slightly before re-welding.
The final tube must fully support the taper roller at each end and must be perfectly parallel, and axially concentric. If the bearings are a slightly loose fit, simply hammer the outside of the tube to reduce the diameter by a few thousandths of an inch. Do this evenly while rotating the tube, to ensure the tube remains circular. Gently fitting the bearing in position for checking during the process then removing before further hammering will allow the swaging to be applied with some engineering finesse.
Then make an inner spacer tube to fit snugly inside the main
tube to keep the taper roller outer races apart. Carefully lathe
the ends of this spacer tube so they are perfectly set at right
angle to the tube. Alternatively use a set square, file and a
practised eye. This is the work of a genuinely qualified engine
fitter. (No GNVQ's here!) The final head stock tube should fully
shoulder and support a taper rollers at each end, and they must
be perfectly parallel and axially concentric. A variety of large
holes and slots are then made in this inner tube so that it can
be securely welded inside the main tube. The welding of the
inner tube must be strong, as the bottom bearing presses against
this to take the whole weight of the front of the trike.
If the bottom fork yokes are close to the steering head, then
weld failure will not be catastrophic, as the bottom yoke should
be designed to collapse only a few millimetres until resting on
the steering head. A very small gap reduces the need for a dust
seal, requiring just a lightly fitted O ring or a foam washer to
protect the lower bearing from corrosion.
Careful design of all main components should be fail-safe
wherever possible.
The central spindle is usually a solid bar or large wall
thickness tube, machined to fit firmly into the bearing inner
races. As the spindle need only snugly fit the bearings where
they are positioned on the spindle, the rest of the spindle can
be slightly reduced in diameter, to allow the bearings to slide
easily into position. Only where the bearings will fit, will the
spindle need to be a snug interference fit, needing the bearings
to be lightly pressed into position. If the machining is a
little too keen, simply build up with weld and file or machine
until perfect.
Securing it all together will need a threaded adjuster to apply
just enough pressure to the taper rollers so they will turn
freely, yet have no play. This can be done by simply welding a
strong, fine threaded bolt, with spacers and lock nuts on the
upper part of the inner spindle or to weld a large barrel nut
inside the spindle.
Many firms can build steering heads, as it is basic engineering.
Take the chosen bearings along, plus details of the length
needed between them. Get the spindle made at the same time.
Likewise, many engineering firms will make slab yokes. Always
ask around first, as someone often knows of someone else who can
make a set at work during the night shift.
Always make a strong shoulder on the bottom of the spindle. It
is preferable to make the bottom yoke a very firm fit on the
spindle, preferably with a small taper section to ensure the
spindle fits securely and aligns perfectly in the yoke.
If alloy slab yokes are not suitable, too expensive, or just wanting something for testing purposes, the yokes can be built up from round and rectangular tubing and steel plate. It is possible to build steel yokes, then smoothed and alloy sprayed for styling purposes. (Alloy spraying is also useful for improving the external longevity of one-off steel exhaust systems, when used in conjunction with petrol additive to give a light oily internal film to the otherwise easily corroded exhaust steel.)
The usual set-up for heavy front ends, such as where a V8 is
used, is leading link and is often the first attempt, as it is
reasonably fail safe, adaptable, strong and comparatively easy
to build and can be set up to greatly reduce dive under braking.
It also has the advantage that it is much easier to play around
with the amount of trail to refine the handling prior to more
advanced designs. The down side is lack of style, so careful
effort must be made to glean every ounce of style from such
designs.
The two main fork tubes should curve down and backwards from the
yokes and end in pivots. These pivots are usually either side of
the rear of the front tyre and a couple of inches above the
front axle height. This is best done once the steering head is
on the trike chassis. Use the yokes and a long bar as a guide
for the position of the front wheel axle.
Once the front wheel is positioned, a pair of arms will pivot
forwards from brackets mounted on the bottoms of the curved fork
legs. Standard motorcycle style shock absorbers will maintain
the swing arms and axle in position. When testing, the steering
may be heavy or light, so be prepared to shorten or lengthen the
arms as required to adjust the amount of trail. If in doubt,
start with a couple of inches of trail, but prepare to modify as
all machines will require their own geometry. The easiest way is
to adjust trail is to remove the legs and slightly bend them to
suit until perfect. When in the hydraulic bender, pump up until
just the slightest movement is noticed, then count the number of
pumps. If in doubt, one pump, relax and check against the other
leg until the required difference is attained. Then use the
first leg as the gauge for the second. Always replace the fork
stanchions in the yokes with the spindle to ensure the pivot is
perfectly aligned.
Use plastic sleeving in the U groove of hydraulic benders to
prevent scratching of the tubing. HDPE high density polyethylene
from old plastic oil containers is ideal.
Trail is the distance between the ground position directly under
the wheel axle and the position on the ground, as projected
through the steering head axis. The normal amount of trail for
standard rake angles is the same as that for most motorcycles
It can be difficult to measure the amount of trail, as getting
an accurate line through the steering head is difficult. A piece
of extruded angle metal bar can lie alongside a steering head if
the head stock has parallel sides. This will help project the
steering head centre line to the floor, from which the wheel
axle can be positioned slightly behind, depending upon the
design. Although this way is good for checking, unfortunately,
this is not the best way steering heads are fitted to the frame.
See later. The rake and trail are best decided on the drawing
first, and built into the steering head, forks and yokes
accurately prior to fitting. It is common to temporarily weld
the steering head in position to check prior to final welding.
If trail needs adjusting, the fork tubes can be bent or
straightened slightly or the swing arms shortened or extended.
They can also be slid up and down the yokes to level the rear of
the machine, so always make the fork stanchions longer than
needed, to allow for later adjustments.
The front swing arm pivot bearings on the bottom of leading link fork legs must be strong and the whole arm assembly must be able to take the high side loads. (Trikes don't lean). For good results, machine the pivot tubes with internal shoulders to mount two deep groove ball races or taper rollers each side. Internal spacers are often needed. Needle rollers are even better, but side thrust washers are also needed. For the strongest pivots, use small motorcycle steering head ball races, or taper roller head races and use a very accurately fitting spindle. The spindle must be able to lightly adjust the pressure on the taper rollers and will therefore employ a lock nut or similar adjustment. Bronze or brass metal bushes are possible, tend to last only a year or so and will require regular greasing.
Rubber bush pivots are only acceptable if the whole swing arm
assembly is a single, well cross-braced item with the
left and right rubber pivots spaced well apart and this is
usually a large bore U bend tube.
No matter what bearings are used, the two swing arms should
ideally be joined as one piece, similar to a conventional
motorcycle swing arm. This is to prevent twisting under side
loads, especially when cornering. This usually means bending a
single tube to make wrap-around design.
The front wheel and brakes should be able to fit easily into the
assembly.
When the fork legs, swing arm links and front wheel are assembled and you are ready to mount the shock absorbers, lift the front end of the machine so the swing arm is at the middle point of travel. Then raise the front of the trike by a further half the vertical shock movement. This is normal rest position of the shocks. The front wheel and it's swing arm are then positioned for the shock absorber units to be in their fully extended, 'at rest' position. Knowing this before building the frame helps to create a little leeway in the frame manufacturing process.
If the engine is at the front and you want a little anti-dive to counteract the heaviness under breaking, then lock the front wheel to the swing arm prevent rolling, lift the rear of the front suspension swing arm on a freely rolling trolley jack, to adjust the height until the front end lifts a little when the trike is pushed forward to simulate braking forces on the front wheel. Do not exaggerate the movement, just have the slightest lift possible to counteract the braking forces. This may need a few friends and a long bar to lever the trike against the wall. This will get you into the ball park but real testing will be needed. When braking for real, this will tend to lift the front end, thus compensating for the dive effect, which causes forward pitching of the trike. In an ideal world, a little dive is recommended, to enable feedback from the braking to enable the rider to get a feel of what the front is doing while braking hard, so back off a little from the ideal position.
Once on the completed frame, the temporary front shock positions
can then be further refined so they are compressed slightly
under the static load. The shock positions should also be
adjusted so their movement is tangential to the arc from the
pivot, so they will compress in an even manner. Only use tack
welds at first and test lightly. This will give a rough starting
point for the suspension.
Do not confuse the difference between the position of the swing
arm angle to give anti dive, with the position of the shocks for
supple suspension. The swing arm angle is decided first, then
the shocks are mounted to allow a slight compression on standard
load. So first get the anti dive angle about right on the
trolley jack, then make a guess for the shocks, tack weld in
position, remove the trolley jack, and test. Then change the
shock positions relative to the amount of sack or stiffness in
the initial test. do many times until its about right and you
should be in the ball park for your first road test.
It will be noticed in the yellow and orange sketch of a front end, above, that the upper and lower shock mounts are plates either side of the main tubes. This will allow for almost any sort of positioning, not only for choosing the ride height of the swing arm, but also for the angle of the shock units to give a suitable spring and damping rate.
Correctly set up, the shocks should compress about five to ten
percent when at rest under the load of the complete trike. On a
trike with a heavy front end, the suspension should also want to
rise slightly when forced against a wall.
When about correct, weld a little more fully and try loading by
jumping up and down on the font end. Be prepared to readjust if
the full movement is too soft or too hard. If the action is too
soft, moving them further from the pivot increases the spring
rate at the expense of movement. If the action is too hard,
moving the shock units closer to the pivot makes the suspension
softer with more wheel movement.
On a recent V12 trike project, the single front shock compressed just a little while at rest, but it took a person jumping on the 2 inch thick, CNC machined alloy front end slab yokes to get a decent amount of compression movement. In this case, the shock was ready to compress further under the weight of the machine and respond well to the road surface in bumps as well as hollows. The main trick is choosing a suitable shock unit and optimising its position. Carefully considered rough guesses are fairly reliable for initial testing. During testing, the machine will show up if the springs and damping are not in the ball park. Most shocks are easily adjustable or replaceable. (For the V12, the front end used a monoshock with adjustable spring rate and damping from the rear of a 1200 cc motorcycle.)
Always ensure that the main fork components, especially the main
tubes are not compromised by badly positioned welds which will
weaken them.
Always make the welds up and down the length of the forks tubes
and most definitely never fully around the tubes. Warning: Fully
welding around the tubes can cause a potential weak area.
The swing arms should be linked for strongest alignment under
all suspension settings. A single large bore tube which wraps
around the back of the wheel is ideal, but not too bulky. Also
consider a strong wrap-over support to add further strength
which can be disguised as part of the mudguard support.
Where a car hub is used, the leading link 'fork' could be single sided, but must be very strong. An upright support tube from the axle, over the top of the wheel, curving back down to the rear pivot will help reduce distortion of a single sided axle mounting. This support tube can be disguised by a mudguard. Ensure the wheel can be easily removed, by using the standard car hub items as a starting point. For single sided axles, always make them stronger.
Other forms of front end should be done in the light of experience. The ultimate for some machines is hub centre steering, such as the variants used on the ELF 24hr racers. Also consider three wheeled cars as starting points for alternate front ends of heavier trikes, then gradually replacing parts to keep strength while enhancing style.
Design Summary.
You have chosen the best engine and transmission.
You have checked the engine runs, then carefully deconstructed
the donor vehicle.
The basic components of forks, engine, wheels and suspension are
laid out on blocks in their approximate intended position.
You have spent at least a week just looking at the layout and
considering how it will handle.
Some modifications and final juggling have led to the best
possible layout.
The frame has now been designed to fit the layout and three
designs developed and the final frame is probably a mixture of
the best aspects of these.
You have checked the ergonomics and seating are as you desire.
You have checked the gearchange will be reasonable and reliable.
You have checked all components are accurately aligned and
blocked it all to prevent any inaccuracies.
New stock steel tubing is surprisingly cheap. So are simple
hand-held angle-grinders, so make life easy for yourself.
Goggles, a dust filter mask and ear protectors are even cheaper
and will pay the highest dividends in the long run, while also
reducing hospital visits now and in later life.
There is no point building a trike if you cannot ride it.
Get safety equipment the same time as the tubing and welding
rods, plus the grinding and cutting discs for the angle grinder.
Make sure the discs are for metal.
When problems raise their ugly heads, use your head, not a hammer. There are many subtle ways to ensure good alignment.
Important notice: Never be afraid to discard a poor first try of building a frame, as the cost of tubing is minimal compared to the time and effort involved. Getting it right from the start ensures a much better machine. The first tubes to be built are the most important, so go for gold from the outset. If the first attempt at a main frame tube is less than perfect, then remove and refine, or simply make another, then use the remains of the first try for smaller cross tubes and other secondary items.
Decide how the frame will handle the loads and forces, then choose your tubing accordingly. Look at tubing used on bikes, trikes and cars to get a feel of the sizes needed. Find out the wall thickness of the tubing used, for this is just as important as the outside dimensions. If in doubt, always use stronger tubing. You may be able to afford a lighter seat lug to break, but not a structural part of the frame. A few extra pounds or kilos on the main frame tubes are always good insurance.
If in doubt about tube diameter and style, always make a cardboard tube to see what diameter tubing will look best when set beside the parts laid out on the garage floor. - Use those old kitchen towel roll centres as a starting point and reduce or enlarge as needed for good looks with strength.
If you dislike metal work, use square tubing, it's easier to fit. Round tubing needs a lot of profiling work to join properly.
Make sure you use ordinary steel and use seamless tubing if you
can. Iron is never used and stay clear of fancy steels unless
fully competent. Don't try saving money by buying cheap tubing
for the main structural parts of the fame, and stay clear of
wrought iron.
An cheap 4.5 inch angle grinder with cutting and grinding discs
is a must.
_________________________________________
Types of steel. -
For most frame purposes, just use mild steel.
TYPES OF STEELS.
DEAD MILD or low Carbon. 0.07 to 0.15 percent carbon.
Available as Black and bright bars. tubes, wire.
Pipes, chains, rivets, screws, nails, wire. boiler plates.
Easily worked when hot, but difficult to machine owing to
tendency to tear.
MILD. 0.15 to 0.25 percent carbon.
Available as Black bar sections and sheet Bright bar strip and
tubing Forgings.
Ship plates and forgings, gears, shafts, nuts, bolts, washers,
rivets, chains.
Easily machined and welded, and is cheapest steel.
Ideal for bike frames. Welds easily. Available in many sizes
shapes and wall thicknesses. Preferably non seam welded tubing,
but seam welded tubing is perfectly good too.
MEDIUM CARBON. 0.25 to 0.5percent carbon.
Available as Black bar, sheet, sections and plate Bright bar.
rods, flats and strip Forgings.
Machine parts and forgings. castings. springs, drop hammer dies.
Responds to heat treatment and can be machined satisfactorily.
HIGH CARBON. 0.5 to 0.7 percent carbon.
Available as Black bar and stripSilver steel rod.
Hammers, sledges. stamping and pressing dies. drop-forging dies,
screwdrivers hammers, set-screws
HIGH CARBON. 0.7 to 0.8 percent carbon.
Punches, cold chisels, hammers, shear blades, drop-forging dies,
lathe centres. spanners, band saws, rivet sets (not rivets).
vice jaws.
HIGH CARBON. 0.8 to 1.0 percent carbon.
Punches, rivets, sets, screwing dies, screwing laps, shear
blades. drop-forging dies, saws, hammers, cold chisels, springs,
axes, rock drills, milling cutlers, lathe centres, reamers. See
also my knife monograph.
HIGH CARBON. 1 to 1.5 percent carbon.
Drills, milling cutters, lathe tools, files, wire drawing dies,
hacksaw blades, ball bearings, screwing dies and taps.
ALLOYING ELEMENTS.
CHROMIUM Up to 1.5 percent. Used with nickel and / or molybdenum increases hardness and allows high UTS with considerable ductility
COBALT. 5 to 10 percent. Retention of hardness at
elevated temperatures.
COBALT. 12 to 18 percent. Increased corrosion resistance
in stainless steel.
COBALT. up to 40 percent. Improves coercive force in
magnet steels.
NICKEL. 1.5 to percent. Increases tensile strength and
toughness.
NICKEL. Over 20 percent. Used in corrosion- and
heat-resisting steels.
TUNGSTEN varies. Strengthens steels at normal and high temperatures.
MOLYBDENUM varies. Used in stainless steels to provide resistance to sulphuric and other acids.
VANADIUM varies. Increases hardensbility.
NIOMUM. TANTALUM. TITANIUM. All three prevent weld decay in chromium steels and in nickel stainless steels.
BORON 0.003 percent. Great increase in hardenability.
COPPER 0.2 to 1.0 percent. Increases corrosion resistance.
__________________
A shopping list.
You may already have spent as much as thirty quid buying a donor car, plus a few hundred for a front end. Hopefully less. Now is the time to buy some new stuff called metal tubing.
If you have read the above, you will see that the cheapest steel, called mild steel is also the best. This is why it is so cheap, as thousands of tons are used daily and thus is not only the best, but also the cheapest, and also in many sizes and shapes.
When I build a trike, I usually start with three lengths of main
frame tubing, plus two smaller square section tubes for
secondary supports, and a length of strip for brackets. To this
is added a box of 3.2dia welding rods for mild steel, a face
mask, six grinding discs, and a dozen decent hacksaw blades.
A small trike uses smaller main tubing, while a V12 uses monster
main tubing.
Make a rough guess of the sizes of tubing you will need, but prepare to change them slightly when confronted with the metal stockist's options.
When built, you will be loading the frame to see where it
flexes, so expect to add some more tubing, fillet plates and/or
gussets as required later.
A good looking trike is a subjective analysis of a machine which
needs not only strength, but also style and proportion of the
frame tubes in relation to the other components. To get a good
idea of what looks good next to the engine and wheels, make that
cardboard tube as long as possible, so it can lie along the
arranged components to help gauge the general look of the frame
tubes. Then find the nearest match in the steel tube available.
TIP: When choosing the diameter of the frame tubing, use the
cardboard centre of a kitchen roll or toilet roll as a general
guide. then slit and tape up the cardboard tube to the ideal
size. It is quite easy to get completely wrong sizes by using
just a ruler. You MUST use some tubing of the required size to
be able to properly to gauge the sizes of tubing which will fit
perfectly with the overall scale of the trike.
Note: Tubing often comes in three or more thicknesses, so a
medium wall thickness should be used for the main structural
frame tubes. Lighter tubing used where it is less important,
such as secondary seating, and battery supports etc. The
heaviest wall tubing is not needed unless you have a very flimsy
frame style, perhaps with a swan neck, where maximum strength is
needed.
Always measure the length of the main tubes, so they can be cut
a little overlength as a single length for strength and
reliability.
If you are building a long trike and only have a small car to
carry the tubing, then measure carefully so it can be carried,
otherwise, budget to have the tubing delivered.
Grab your drawings, metal tape measure, a pencil, then find the
local metal merchant and see what they have to offer, and ask
their advice.
There are many metal stockists around the world, and you can buy
anything, from single tube and a pack of welding rods, to enough
to build a battleship.
An acceptable way of deciding is often simply looking and
deciding what seems best. - 'I'll have two lengths of that heavy
tubing, four of that smaller square tubing and a sheet of that'.
But MAKE SURE you have the correct scale as it is all too easy
to choose the next larger tubing and have a bloater of a trike
frame.
This is not at all scientific, there are no calculations and no
structural analysis. If in doubt, use the scaffold tube as a
reference point. Do not put yourself down, even a poor mechanic
has a working knowledge of what has been used in similar
circumstances. Your main assessments are comparative to similar
structures plus a safety margin. The ability to use the eyes in
conjunction with common sense is a very powerful tool.
The good engineer and designer would consult engineers tubing
data, to check the actual working loads, then choose from
suitable tubing and give a safety margin. Later versions of the
design would then be refined according to bending tests and real
world loading feedback data, as mentioned later.
As trike builders do not like arithmetic, then use common sense
and a sense of proportion and comparison with other machines. I
have seen lightweight trikes built safely using three scaffold
tubes, and car engined trikes with four scaffold tubes.
If in doubt, look for similar successful engineering
equivalents. If in doubt, ask friends. If in doubt, build
stronger than expected. If in doubt, be cautious and try it
anyway, you will often be pleasantly surprised during early
testing. Doubt is a positive attribute, it can also be a safe
one.
If in the worst case, the frame fails during initial testing,
then you will need to strengthen, or even rebuild parts with
stronger tubing, simply returning to the start in the light of
experience before too much expensive work is done. Initial
testing is always done on the basic rolling chassis, so that in
the worst case, the whole basic frame can be affordably
discarded and a better frame made, before all the fiddly, time
consuming work is done to turn it into a work of art.
You may be surprised by the vast selection of tubing available
and it is always in a variety of wall thicknesses. Always
measure the tubing on equivalent machines for comparison.
Circular, square and rectangular tubing, strip and rod. Make
yourself a shopping list and be prepared to have it cut for a
small fee, as it usually comes in twenty foot lengths which the
supplier can cut to what ever length you need. Measure three
times, cut once, or do they deliver? I take along a hacksaw and
a few spare blades in a friends van, to keep costs down.
There will also be alloy sheet, wire mesh and a host of other
stuff. Don't forget to buy the welding rods and grinding and
cutting discs at the same time.
And to repeat; goggles, ear defenders and breathing mask
too.
A decent set of leather welding gloves is useful when handling
hot metal.
If in doubt, ask for a photocopy of their materials list, and
retire to a local cafe to think, or return next week.
When carrying long tubes in a car, always take newspaper or rags to cover the seats as the tubes are covered in preserving oil which stains easily. Take plenty of cloth to wipe off excess preservative. Most trike frame tubes can be cut overlength and still fit in a car if stuck into the passenger foot well, and the tail gate open with a warning red flag attached. The passenger seat may need to be removed, so take a few spanners. Take bungees to keep the tail gate from bouncing around.
When the tubing meets the trike bits, it may be decided that it
is not the right size. At this stage, a rethink will be a lot
better and the original tubing will become stock for other work,
such as to align the wheels to the floor lines, or gateposts and
drains, or perhaps an engine hoist.
Therefore just get the main tubing first, and if in doubt or on
a tight budget, simply get one length, then return for more as
needed. Practice bending and welding on the first choice of
tubes, and when competent, get the perfect tubing later.
To repeat, if worried about wall thickness, go safe. A few extra pounds in the main frame is weight well spent. You can be less cautious for non structural parts such as seat bases, battery box mounting brackets etc.
Check out the local hire firm for tube benders if needed. Get the hydraulic type and check the tubing diameters that the bender can handle the tubing you have chosen.
Before making the main frame tubes, it is better to make the suspension and engine mounting items first and position them correctly. Then the frame can then be made to fit the set of perfectly aligned suspension components.
Understand the hierarchy of the structure you are building.
The engine powers the tyres. The tyres transfer forces to the
machine and the steering controls the direction. Therefore the
wheels are the prime concern, with the suspension used to keep
them in an ideal state under all conditions. The frame is there
to keep the suspension in the right place, so it can do it's
work properly. The engine and riders, although not structurally
important, also sit on the frame, as this is a very convenient
way to accommodate them. Therefore if suspension is to be custom
made, it should be made first, to fit the perfectly aligned
wheels, but with the frame mounts left until later. The frame
then made to fit the perfectly aligned suspension. In reality,
the chassis is always made first, so the engine is well
supported, and then the suspension is built and probably lightly
adapted to ensure good wheel alignment to a possibly
unsymetrical chassis. The mounting of the steering head is left
for much later.
If you have to modify or make new suspension components, always
build them as mirror pairs before making the frame. A simple
wooden dimensional welding jig will help enormously. This
applies not only to front fork parts, but to all symmetrical
pairs of components, right through to the symmetrical rear
radius arms. Fit them to the components such as hubs etc and
ensure they work as required.
When making the suspension arms, fit the spindles and bearings
in their housings, supported level and straight on Vee blocks,
then carefully make the A frames or whatever to fit. Then tack
weld in position, with three tacks per join, remove bearings and
fully weld. When cooled in air, return to the jig and tweak if
distortion has occurred during welding. Where shock units are to
be mounted, leave these only tack welded, as they may need to be
repositioned once the rolling chassis is refined for overall
balance and suspension rates.
Never cool metal components by plunging in water, as it can
cause uneven hardening and fractures. Allowing the metal to cool
in air is much safer.
Unless you have a differential built into the rear of the frame, then it is best to build the suspension, then make the chassis fit the perfectly aligned and mirrored suspension systems.
Tweak, adjust and modify the frame tubes before assembling to
fit these pre- aligned components. If the suspension units are
symmetrical and built in a simple jig, the frame mounting lugs
are fitted easy to be tack welded to the frame, and the wheels
lined up accurately, then the frame will naturally be positioned
accurately.
Working from accurately positioned wheels to the frame will
allow the whole machine to be accurate and handle well.
The frame can now be built.
Building the frame should be surprisingly straightforward as by
now you will know what it is that you are intending to create,
and should have thought it though many times. The main clues to
the overall frame design are the components which have been
sitting in place ready to be joined with a competent structure
to take the forces which have to be resolved.
Clean all parts and tubing, then practice with, and set up the welder. Have safety equipment at hand and ensure plenty of room. Check the fire extinguisher, preferably carbon dioxide, or at least a bucket of water.
Always make welding a positive experience.
When everything is prepared, frame building can, and should be
fun - serious, but enjoyable. Very creative.
Warning: If you have never welded before, expect to spend a
month of an hour a day or more getting to learn to weld to an
acceptably high standard. Some people are born welders, but most
people are not. It takes skill and it takes time to make a neat,
fully penetrated, and clean weld with no distortion. So if you
have never welded before, get the welder six months before you
intend to start building the frame and practice, practice,
practice. If you are really bad at welding, go to a night school
on the subject, or learn to tack weld and hand over the
assembled frame to a professional welder.
A section on welding is in the appendix to this monograph.
Clean a flat and level floor.
If you don't have a level floor, then three concrete paving
slabs in the garden will suffice, but they must be level.
You may be able to get away with building on a less than perfect
floor, but it is imperative to keep the spirit level correctly
aligned. Therefore mark one end of the spirit level so it will
always be aligned pointing to the right and the front of the
machine. If this is not done, a less than accurate bubble will
soon be followed by a less than accurate machine.
If you have not done so yet, mark a thin and perfectly straight
centreline on the most even part of the floor, and another
centre line at ninety degrees to it for the alignment of the
rear wheels.
Straight lines can be made using a chalk string, pulled tight
and flicked vertically to leave a straight chalk line. Standard
building site practice. Then use tape either side to allow a
painted line to be made. This line is a guide, the final
accuracy will be done with a metal rule directly on the machine.
To get the perfect line at ninety degrees for the rear axle,
divide the main line in half, draw an arc from each end, and
where these intersect at each side, can be joined to give a line
at exactly ninety degrees to the centre line. Alternatively use
the sides of a good, big square machine-made cardboard box, or
fridge door or similar as a large set square. Double check this
alignment.
The original engine mounts should be ground out of the donor
machine if required, reprofiled to fit the new frame tubes and
lightly bolted on the engine to hold them in place. The
transmission is double checked, aligned and centred. All the
suspension will be blocked in place and accurately aligned, with
frame mounting lugs in position ready to accept the frame tubes.
Double check that all mounting bushes, brackets, spindles and
relevant components are in place.
Where the engine mount and suspension cannot both easy fit onto
the line of a frame tube, the suspension takes priority if they
cannot be easily modified or shifted slightly to clear the
engine mounts. The engine mounts can be extended or modified
later to fit the frame in a slightly better way. This may also
be a good opportunity to tease the centre of gravity a little
lower without upsetting the layout.
The gearchange should by now be well considered for future
reference, and decide where it can and more importantly, cannot
fit. If in doubt about the gearchange path, use temporary dummy
set-up using broom handles or whatever is suitable so it is not
obstructed by frame tubes. See Gearchange later.
Use blocks to accurately position the engine, transmission and
rear wheels in position above the centreline with the right
ground clearance. Use a spirit level, straight edge, plumbline
and your eyes to make sure everything is aligned and level. If
there is a propshaft between engine and differential, do not cut
it yet, but make sure there is adequate room so the splines will
be positioned to take all movements into account.
On independent suspension rear ends, it is important to have all
drive splines from the differential to the rear wheels in the
correct position for the movement they permit.
It is assumed the tyres are pumped up and the rear tyres are of
identical size and type. If you have four wheels to choose from,
always use identical wheels and tyres, with similar amounts of
wear, pumped to the same pressure.
Set up and check the rear wheel camber and toe in, ground
clearance and any other aspects of the design. If the steering
rack is retained, make sure it is set in it's mid position and
prevented from moving. Leave the toe-in as per original machine
until after the first few test rides. Refer to car manual.
Make sure any drum brakes are on the correct sides of the
machine.
Block securely and mark it all so you know when it's disturbed; do not line up perfectly to wrong positions.
Measure diagonally from points on the wheel mountings to front
and rear of the centreline using a metal tape measure. Do not
use string or a cloth tape measure which can stretch too much.
Accuracy should be less than 5mm across the widest parts,
preferably zero and don't take just one measurement, double
check, and triple check for all the main parts.
Position the front end with steering head just ahead of its
intended position, to allow a little room for excess front frame
tubing. Align with spirit level and plumbline, then block in
position. If this is difficult, fit the handlebars upside down
then rest them between two chairs. It's not ideal, but as long
as it's approximately in the right place when you start welding
the main tubes in position, this will do for now. Front end will
be accurately aligned later. Block or tape the front wheel on
the centreline.
The trike has the advantage of being a triangle in plan view, so
overall accuracy is easier than most other vehicles.
If simply building a trike rear end to fit a bike frame, then it is often easier to build the rear frame to align the differential to the chain run, then build the suspension afterwards.
There are two ways to build a frame from scratch for a car engine design: Front to back, or back to front.
Front to back means building the front end complete with steering head and mounting it to the engine mounts first, then aligning and then building the rest. This can lead to gradual misalignment. Used only for bike based trikes, which use a ready built standard bike frame.
Back to front is safer, because all the heavy work of
building the engine and suspension is done first. This then
allows a solid assembly for mounting the steering head and front
end. This allows the builder to tweak the bare front tubing
after the major rear alignment and welding are done.
When mounting the main tubes to fit the temporarily positioned
steering head, leave a little excess length at the front which
can be finally aligned and trimmed to size.
With the rear assembly tack welded in position, the front tubes
can then be teased and coerced into line for a perfectly
accurate steering head relative to the rear wheels. When
perfectly aligned, the steering head mounting tubes can be
ground back and fitted until a perfect rake angle is achieved,
then aligned and tack welded.
Test pieces:
Preparation is the key to good welding. Clean the tubing first
and also weld some test pieces and break them until you get it
absolutely right. For deep welds, cut through the welds to see
that the penetration is of good quality, with minimal slag
inclusion or holes. Unfortunately the first few welds are the
main frame welds. If in doubt, tack weld and hand over to an
expert.
If you know of a professional welder, then they will often do
extra work in their spare time and may come to the trike, so all
remains accurate. They can also offer advice prior to final
welding. Do not be surprised if the welder asks for many areas
to be dressed or chamfered and other requirements, as they know
their job, and are always worth the cost of a second visit. See
also welding later.
Always try to employ full length tubes from the rear suspension mountings through to the steering head for the strongest frames.
The bottom frame tubes should be able to have the radius arm
mountings or pivots welded to them. Likewise the bottom
wishbones and similar items. Where structural components are
welded, try to position the fittings to be fail safe. Check the
direction of the forces and position appropriately, so that if a
weld or tube fails, it will fail as safely as possible. Remember
the wire and solder model frame.
A strong frame will hold everything together.
A rigid frame will ensure the bits hold together without
flexing.
For best results, go for both.
Start making the frame by aligning one main tube, bending if and
where needed. Never exert any force while offering it up to the
machine for checking the fit. Always remove the tube and modify
until perfect. Then gently mount in position and check, or
remove and tweak further if needed. This reduces chance of
upsetting the alignment of the whole machine. It is much quicker
in the long run than causing unseen distortion in the aligned
components.
The more common designs use dual upper and lower main tubes.
Such a main frame tube will be running from the rear suspension,
past the engine and curve up to the steering head.
Where possible, always try to make frame tube as mirror images. When the first tube is made, it is easier to make a mirror of it when it's off the machine, allowing ease of comparison. (It also helps the frame to flex evenly under extreme handling conditions :)
Chalk or a felt tip permanent marker pen is also priceless at
this stage. It allows accurate marking of the centres of the
curves for the bender, where to clean the metal for fitting the
brackets and where to modify the engine mounts etc. A felt tip
pen can also stir the tea, as this is a slow, steady process
with plenty of looking and refining as the main components
gradually take shape. It is not a rush.
Align the main tubing on the engine and suspension mounts with
excess metal sticking forward for the steering head. Then mark
their position on the tube and carefully remove the original
engine mounts to allow final trimming to fit the frame tubes.
Replace and tack weld the tubes just enough to hold in position.
See welding appendix.
You may be very keen to get the main tubes in place and fitted,
but this is the time when a very slow approach is needed. You
can afford to rush the seats and battery box, but not the main
frame tubes.
Take your time and always take some time out to just sit and
look at the main frame tubes which are lightly tack welded in
position. your initial sketches will surely be modified at this
stage as you work through in 3D reality and this is what makes a
much better machine.
Now recheck the alignment of the wheels, engine, forks and
adjust as needed.
By making the tubes as mirror pairs, inaccuracies in alignment
will show up more easily, such as misalignments of suspension or
tubing etc.
Tweak and adjust as needed. When accurately aligned, add some
more evenly spaced tack welds on each join to prevent it all
moving about.
Then the other main frame tubes can also be added, again as
mirror pairs wherever possible.
Build the whole structure to make the smooth, clean lines so exemplified of better trikes. Making the tubes to fit the assembled components helps the builder refine the whole machine as it grows. There will be unseen problems, so take time to work out at least two different ways to solve any problems, as this is a crucial time in the machines creation and extra time spent now is well repaid.
Now check that the engine can be removed and replaced fairly easily.
There may be other main tubes, which may suspend the top of
McPherson struts or similar items and these secondary frame
tubes can now be positioned to support the main tubes.
To keep the main tubes aligned during side loads of cornering
and jumping hump back bridges, secondary tubes are required.
Unlike main tubes which should maximise the most natural and
strongest forces, secondary tubes can be fitted in a variety of
positions to help minimise distortion in the main frame tubes.
Triangulation between the tubes is will always make for stronger
and more rigid frame.
Once the basic frame is built without the steering head, the tack welds can be built up to be structurally competent enough to allow removal of the blocks. Some of my machines are road tested with fifty percent welds, but at this stage, just enough weld to hold all together will suffice.
First test: Part 1.
Testing for initial flexing.
At this stage the basic frame tubes are in position, with the
suspension and engine lightly tacked in place.
Tack weld a piece of tubing to roughly replace the forks for
basic testing purposes. This should keep the front of the trike
in the correct position off the floor as the frame is allowed to
relax when you remove all the blocks.
If you have tightened any mountings, then lightly loosen all
engine and suspension mountings, as this will allow the whole
structure to relax naturally.
Lift one rear wheel and slide a piece of plywood underneath and
a few ball bearings or marbles under the plywood.
Now you can gently load the structure, to see how the suspension
units behave and the rest of the structure distorts when gently
loaded with a rider.
Make another check of the alignment and look for any signs of
untoward distortion in the frame structure. If a rider can sit
gently on the structure, the differences when being on and off
can be viewed from various angles to see how the structure
behaves, especially the suspension units and also general frame
flexing.
Gently push on the upper suspension mounts to check the
suspension settings are reasonable and to see how the frame
flexes. If you have a digital camera or cam corder, you can make
a little animation of the frame flexing from front and side and
the rear, then run the animation sequence to check where the
main frame tubes flex.
Check if anything has bowed badly, curved inwards or other
unexpected problems. Likely areas are between the lower
suspension wishbones, where the frame wants to pull apart and
the upper shock mountings, which may not yet be finished, so use
this opportunity to assess the best possible way to keep these
highly loaded structural areas well designed and built. - Well
deigned and built does not mean lots of heavy metal.
Where the upper suspension mounting points can be adjusted to fit the frame tubing, it can be advantageous to lightly test the rear suspension mountings, adjusting them so the frame sinks just perceptibly on the springs indicating a reasonable amount of suspension in the rest state for a finally loaded frame. If a light machine is intended, then the springs should compress about ten percent with a single rider. If a heavy shell or three or more riders, then just a slight amount of spring compression with one rider may suffice at this stage. Reposition the suspension units until a balanced rear end is attained. This does not apply to McPherson struts, which may need the strut to be modified.
NOTE: It is very important to test the frame with one rear wheel
which can be allowed to slide sideways. This will show up any
sideways spreading of the frame. Place one rear wheel on a piece
of plywood so that it can slide on small balls or marbles and
then watch the way the rear of the chassis spreads apart under
careful loading. This will show if the rear frame is spreading.
This cannot be tested with both wheels on the ground, as they
prevent such spreading. They must be able to spread. Where any
spreading occurs, cure at this stage with suitably strong
tubing, as this is the main structure of the machine. Do not
fully compress the suspension, but a moderate load will show if
any unwanted distortion is happening at an early stage and that
the shocks are reasonably well positioned for their purpose.
Also carefully check the top shock mountings, the bottom frame
cross pieces and radius arms or wishbone suspension components.
First test: Part 2.
Two check to test the suspension movement.
Block the trike off the ground at its normal ride height.
Remove the shocks to allow the suspension to move fully, check
the wheel alignment as it compresses and that the wheels do not
change inappropriately from their vertical alignment. The rear
wheels should lean in slightly at full compression, so they will
stay fairly flat on the road, with just the outside of the tyre
being slightly more compressed.
NOTE: It is also important to ensure the prop shafts from
a central differential will slide correctly and that at both
ends of the suspension travel, there is no fouling of the prop
shafts. If there is friction or clanking, check the drive train
carefully and revolve the problems immediately before continuing
with the frame build.
If a solid rear axle, then check the Panhard rod works as intended, and any other design needs to ensure the rear suspension movement is safe and free to move - but only within set limits.
If all is well, add a few more tack welds to strengthen the
frame and test further.
If all is not well, it is easy to replace the blocks and wedges,
grind out the tack welds and replace or modify any components as
needed and this may even include the main frame tubes.
Perhaps you may wish to shorten the upper wishbones and make new
mounting points on the frame.
Perhaps you may wish to make a deep sump brace, so the engine
can be removed, but still have a strong lower frame.
Perhaps the upper shock mountings need a re-think.
This first test is a good time for reflection on the overall design, so use it to good advantage. It's called sitting in the garage with a cuppa tea or a can of beer.
If all tack welds are fairly equal, and wishing to know what part of the frame will break first, then this is an unique opportunity to do so in the simplest way possible. Loosely replace the blocks so that any component drop is less than an inch.
Once satisfied, a few welds to strengthen the frame are added,
you may now tweak, kick and/or adjust the whole assembly as
needed. This is a good time to begin to understand the way the
frame performs / distorts. Remember the wire frame model. If a
weld breaks, then little is lost at this stage and knowledge is
improved. Then re weld and try again until the frame is behaving
well.
If necessary, the whole chassis can be disassembled and
re-shaped by grinding off the tack welds with only a loss of
time and effort.
If all holds together well with minimal distortion, then
confidence is improved.
Re-tighten components and check for distortion when tightening
them to resolve such problems early. It is often possible for a
'relaxed' frame to distort slightly, causing engine or
suspension bolts to become misaligned. Check for this by
partially removing each bolt to check they slide easily in a
well aligned frame and it's mountings.
Further distortion will occur with full welding, so getting it
close beforehand will minimise any further misalignment and make
heavy maintenance much easier.
For mid or rear engined trikes, the non structural, minor seat
tubing at the rear of the frame can be removable, leaving just
the basic frame, engine and suspension in position. It can be a
good alternative for particularly awkward engine removal or for
maintenance on a fuel injected transverse Vee six with turbo
etc. This is similar to some motorcycles, where the rear is
bolted in place. It also allows for a rear shell to be fully
opened for showing the engine at custom shows.
Do not mount passengers on removable sub frames unless the
design is fail safe.
Fitting the steering head last will allow all the main parts of the frame to be sorted first. The wheels accurately aligned, the engine correctly aligned to the differential, and engine mountings correctly positioned and tested under load.
Once the rear end is sorted, the main part, the steering head can now be done at leisure.
Double check the rear end and add more tack welds to keep it all in position. If deciding to fully weld the rear at this stage, it should only be done after the gearchange linkage is made and fitted and any prop shaft modified, as many problems may yet be unseen, especially on transverse engines. See gearchange later. There is no need to fully weld at this stage, but all frame joins must have at least four evenly spaced, strong welds (three plus a safety) to prevent any movement or breakage of the temporary joins.
Check list for the engine:
Ability to flex on the original rubber mountings.
Alignment of the differential to the rear wheels.
Restraining of engineering using original engine struts.
Ability to remove engine easily and to change the clutch plate.
Clearance for the carbs and exhausts.
Gearchange routing clearance.
Check list for solid axles:
Radius arms which pivot at the front either side of the engine
output shaft or sprocket.
Upper suspension mounts.
Panhard rod.
Check list for independent rear suspension:
Shorter upper and longer lower wishbone sets, the lower ones
including radius arms, or have other support for fore and aft
force resolution into the frame under acceleration and braking.
The prop shafts are free to move across the full range of
suspension movement.
Shock mounts.
Differential mounting and any chain adjustment.
Take your time, get the front end perfect before reaching for the grinder and welder.
Fitting the front end demands good accuracy.
The two rear wheels do not worry if the engine is slightly off
centre, or a host of other minor inaccuracies. It is the
position of the two rear wheels relative to the front wheel
alignment that requires total accuracy.
Assemble the steering head, forks and yokes and front wheel.
Pump all three tyres to correct pressure, ensuring all is secure
and perfectly aligned on the floor once again. Use a plumb line
to get the wheels centres aligned on the floor.
Measure the position of the steering head from the two main
alignment points, these are usually the centres of the rear
wheels or their bearing housings. With the wheels perfectly
aligned and set, (double check) tyres pumped up, and blocked
underneath to prevent any movement, mark in the centre line of
the wheels.
Check the rear wheels are horizontal with a plank on them and a
spirit level.
Assuming the wheels and tyres are identical, then the most
accurate point is the outside edge, directly above the axle
centre line. Each rear wheel should be on the accurately
positioned floor line, securely blocked and identically aligned
with the other rear wheel and their axles at ninety degrees to
the centre line. Mark the top of the tyre above the central
spindle, using a plumb line to check. Block securely and do not
disturb anything. Marking a tyre is difficult, so use masking
tape on the rubber and the alignment mark should be easily made
to within a millimetre.
It is not possible to make a mark exactly at the edge of the
tyre, so an accurate point must be made on the masking tape,
close to the outside of the tyre, which is evenly positioned
from the centreline of the machine.
For real accuracy, usually the wheel mounting flange faces are
used for this purpose, by measuring in the distance from the
outer rim to the flange face and marking this on the masking
tape. Formula one rigs have dummy solid wheels for alignment
checks.
NOTE: It is imperative not to disturb these points, so block the
wheels securely by making four wooden wedges. If in doubt, then
use the upper pivot points of the outer rear suspension, which
cannot be disturbed. If in doubt, such as the kids playing
around without you knowing, always use a symmetrical part of the
wheel bearing housings.
To position the steering head central with the whole machine,
measure the identical distances from the alignment points on
each wheel.
If the front wheel is perfectly on the centreline, the rear
wheels are perfectly spaced on the cross line, and all else is
well, then the front end tubes can be tweaked into position to
match the steering head. Use a plumb line (string and weight) to
get these tubes accurately over the centreline while the rear
wheels are at perfect right angles to the centreline on the
floor.
The front tubes may need a little persuasion, by hammering with a length of similar tubing, (most hammers are too feeble) with a block of wood to protect the tubes. If larger adjustments are needed, then bracing a length of tubing through the frame using blocks of wood and ropes, such that the tubes can be bent with minimal stress on the welds.
Once the front tubes are perfectly central, AND the frame
alignment checked yet again, the ends of the front tubes can be
ground to take the steering head.
The front wheel is blocked on the ground in the perfect position
and the steering head and forks rotated on the fixed front wheel
until it kisses the frame tubes perfectly. If the frame tubes
are a little low or high, then just jack up the front of the
trike frame or rotate the fork out of the way and continue with
the grinder. The steering head should now rest on the frame
tubes, equidistant from both rear wheels. The frame tubes can
now be ground and dressed to fit the steering head perfectly and
at the correct rake angle.
As the steering head begins to sit snugly in the tubing, you may
need to slightly roll the front wheel along the floor centre
line until the desired rake angle is achieved. Careful grinding
with the angle grinder will then help to create a perfect fit.
If the frame tubes are a little low or high to fit the steering
head, then simply raise or lower the front of the frame with
wedges or a jack, as this does not appreciably change the
overall alignment of the machine.
Now take your time to ensure the fork is perfectly aligned.
The front wheel contact patch on the ground must be identical
distance to the two rear wheels,
A plank set across both identical rear wheels will give a
spirit level reading. This spirit level is then moved in front
of the front wheel, and a set square used to ensure the vertical
alignment of the forks is perpendicular (90 degrees) to the rear
wheels with the same bubble reading.
To get the front end accurate when seen from the front, use a
straight plank across the top of the identical rear wheels and
check with a plumb line and a spirit level. If the tyres are not
identical, probably with a slight more wear on one side, then
measure the difference in overall diameters then place a shim of
card on the smaller wheel to make the plank level with the
axles. Now mount the spirit level in a similar manner beside the
front wheel and note the bubble position. Then a set square can
be positioned on the spirit level to give the accurate alignment
needed. A plumb line will confirm.
There is no point using a plumb line if the rear end is not
level. - Use the plank and spirit level to confirm.
The rake and trail are as intended or the amount of trail very
close to a heavy bike front end if in doubt.
When all is perfect, you may then proceed with the welder.
When welding the steering head in position, the heat will damage the steering head bearings. Just tack weld the steering head in place, then check carefully. New bearings can be fitted after initial testing. If special pullers are available, which will NOT upset the steering head alignment, then this is acceptable to remove the races after the steering head has been tack welded. Do not hammer them out, as a misaligned steering head is infinitely more expensive in the long run than any new set of head races. It is better to leave them in place to reduce chances of misalignment and buy new ones later. Yet another advantage of using affordable, easily available components.
Measure many times, then tack weld the steering head in three
places for each frame tube, plus a couple of strong welds on the
bottom of the lower tubes.
The rear wheels will be perfectly horizontal with the spirit
level, so the front forks can be aligned with the spirit level,
as seen from the front. On well raked machines, this is often
done by suspending the plumb line from the centre of the top
yoke, over the centre of the bottom yoke and dangling close to
the ground, to be perfectly in line with the centre line on the
floor. It is called being accurate.
When the steering head is fitted, gently allow the whole machine
to relax, free of any supports.
Unblock the wheels and always roll the machine backwards and
forwards to allow the chassis to fully relax.
Now check ALL alignments again.
Check the front end accuracy from two independent methods, to
help confirm accurate frame alignment. Also checking the
distances between front axle and left and right rear axle bottom
pivots. Checking the alignment of the top of the steering head
from the top of the wheels, and also checking the alignment of
the bottom of the front wheel from two lower wheel hub mounting
components will give a confirmed check of the accuracy. If a
third check is needed, mark the centreline on the rear of the
machine and view from this point, to confirm the front wheel is
accurately aligned relative to a plumbline hanging off the
centre of the steering head.
If anything seems wrong, take your time to find out why. Also
use your eyes and common sense for anything obvious or dubious.
TIP: A classic trick for most of us humans with mismatched eyes, is to look down the length of the machine using a pocket mirror as well as normally, as any non symmetrical aspects will show up more easily.
You now have a basic rolling chassis, which is tack welded so that it can be easily modified or even replaced.
Place each of the three wheels in turn on a bathroom scale and
note the load. Do the same with the rider and make a note, so
that you can adjust the load on each wheel according to its size
and profile, by moving the rider and later, the fuel and battery
etc.
If you have a mid - mounted car engine, then your three wheel
loadings should be close to a very nicely balanced machine.
If you have a VW with a moped front end, then you may wish to
consider your wheel loadings very, very carefully.
Take your time at this point and give yourself a good long breather.
Allow a day or two, to remove doubts or reconsider any suspect
or marginal design areas.
You can still break the tack welds if needed. Be prepared to do
so, as you will find it increasingly more difficult to overcome
inaccuracy as the work progresses.
Checking costs nothing but is extremely important. Keep in mind
what happened to the Hubble space telescope.
Now carefully assess the forces ruing though the frame, and
decide where the bracing is to go. For long lengths of
unsupported tubes, then triangulation is needed, unless you are
using very strong tubes. Flex the frame to see where any
secondary strengthening us needed.
Where fillet plates are to be used, such as either side of the
steering head, these should be done after the main welds are
finished.
When the basic frame is complete, carefully remove the engine and all components.
Fully welding a chassis while it is off the machine will allow
easier and thus better welding.
It also encourages the builder to add any little fillets and
refinements, and also to add any late changes, flourishes and to
dress the welds for a smoother shape and reduces chance of
fracturing from any sharp stress points. A clean profiled
chassis makes checking for fractures much easier during initial
testing. A bare frame can also be measured for assessing general
accuracy from it's basic alignment points.
Where any last minute changes are to be made, usually in awkward
areas, such as a better fitting tube, always brace the area with
tack welded tubes before removing the item, then fit new and
finally remove the temporary bracing.
NEVER weld on one side of the chassis and then the other side, as this will cause distortion. Weld both sides of the chassis as pairs in the same manner. For example, weld the left, then the right upper suspension mounts, then the left then the right rear engine mounts etc.
A fully welded chassis will allow the chassis to be fully loaded at rest position, and the steering head to be checked accurately for distortion prior to final welding of any head stock fillets. You still have the chance to twist the steering head into perfect alignment if the welding causes distortion.
Replace the fully welded chassis, note the problems and then
tweak, or grind out and reweld parts if distortion occurs.
Use the tape measure and spirit level with a vengeance.
When fully satisfied, check and double check the steering head and then add any steering head and other fillets when confident.
A bare, fully welded chassis will often show up imperfections when the components are replaced. This may require minor grinding or tweaking for an easy fit of the engine, suspension etc. Occasionally the steering head may need a little tweaking back into line with a scaffold pole, which is best done before the side fillets are welded in place, and old bearings are still in place.
Having made all the effort, the chassis may well be a great deal more accurate than most. Accuracy does not ensure good handling, but it does eliminate many handling incongruities.
When fitting the engine again, there will probably be a few holes to file to get a clean engine fitting, but if the holes need a lot of filing, then just make another check that all is well, as this is sometimes a way to tell if something is amiss.
Removing big engines.
Where a big engine is fitted, perhaps a V8 in front, then it may
be necessary to extract the engine by having a lower frame rail
removable.
If particularly heavy, such as Detroit lump or a V12, both
bottom frame rails could be removed as part of the engine, and
supported on a rolling dolly, allowing a more rigid upper frame
which can be lifted off the engine.
When building a removable tube, first get the main frame
strongly tack welded in position to keep it all together. Do not
use full welds at this stage, as distortion may be incurred,
causing springing when the tubes are cut, thus helping to
misalign the frame.
Support the engine just enough to take the load off the frame,
but still keeping it in place on the trike. Then cut the tubes
where needed to remove the engine. A hacksaw is ideal as the
resultant gap is small. Undo any engine mounts and remove the
section of tube.
The removable tube can be secured in place in many ways. The
simplest is a slightly larger diameter tube which is split
lengthwise, to act a split sleeves, so the inner part of the
split tube is welded to the bottom of the fixed frame rail, and
the other half welded to the removable tube, so that both halves
will support the engine and ensures that failure of any bolts
will still keep the engine from dropping.
Slash cutting the main frame tube will allow the engine to rest
on the lower cut of the frame, and if done with a little
sophistication, will be self aligning and allow easier removal
and replacement. It can also be a little more fail safe.
Only tack weld the split tube components, to check the tube can
actually be removed and will not distort under load. When
satisfied, fully weld, fit bolts and release the engine weight
to check for frame distortion. Adjust as needed. This is an
advantage of building rear first without the main frame fully
welded, as any deformations are accounted for before final front
end alignment and final welding of the steering head.
If through bolts are used, the inside of the frame tubes will
need spacers to prevent the frame tubes from squashing when the
bolts are tightened.
Solid split bar ends are also possible, but heavier, requiring
an engineering firm to make matched pairs to fit the tubing.
Also study motorcycle split frame tubes for alternative
mountings for lighter engines. Reassemble and fully weld the
removable parts and refit to the engine, suspension, forks and
wheels. Allow the frame to relax fully and check before further
welding. Always build up and fully weld split frame tubes before
fully welding the chassis.
Find the most level part of the floor, make a paint line with a second line at right angles to align the rear wheels. If in the garden, place three concrete paving slabs so they are level when checked with a spirit level and a straight plank. A central line is scratched accurately on the slabs. The kiddies are banned from playing here.
Block up and align the engine and wheels, the anti roll bars,
radius arms and prop shaft splines.
Make any special suspension items such as wishbones and radius
arms, preferably on simple wooden welding jigs to improve
accuracy, and fit them in position on the hubs etc.
(For front engined trike with a shortened prop shaft and a
one-piece, solid rear axle, reposition the front mounting of the
radius arms to be either side of the front end of the prop
shaft.)
Align McPherson strut suspension units, which may need tying a
plank over the engine to keep them in position.
Position the front wheel, forks and steering head, to give a
guide position of where the front of the frame tubes should
reach.
Start the frame by bending and fitting the two bottom tubes of
the frame using two long, symmetrically shaped tubes. Such tubes
are often similar to scaffold pipes in diameter and wall
thickness. These often run from engine mounts and suspension
mountings, to a little beyond the steering head area. Check
alignment and tack weld in position to align engine and
suspension. Front of tubes may need a simple offcut of sheet
steel support to keep them in position while tack welding.
Fit a dummy gearchange linkage using an old broom to check the
clearances of subsequent tubing.
Add upper main frame tubes as needed. Check accuracy.
Add cross braces and any suspension mounting lugs for the rear
springs which take the main load of the trike.
Add all other main tubes, such as for cross bracing and to
reduce flexing.
Strongly tack weld all parts with four tack welds per joint.
Three to maintain alignment, and one for luck.
Loosen all engine and suspension bolts to allow frame to relax.
Remove all blocks. Allow one wheel to slide sideways on a plank
and rollers, then lightly load the structure to check for any
obvious deformations and suspension movement. Decide on any
strengthening requirements.
Check alignment and tweak as needed. Tighten components and
check. Expect a few welds to break. If all welds are equal, then
any breaking will highlight the areas of most concern, as this
may be the weakest part of the design.
Replace the machine accurately on the centre lines.
Fully align front end and steering head, yokes and forks etc.
Check trail at proposed steering head rake angle. Adjust
position of the front of the frame tubes as needed.
Grind out shape on front of frame tubes to accept the steering
head. Align the whole machine on a perfect centre line and roll
the front wheel on this line to align to the front fame tubes.
Adjust height of front of frame for perfect fit. Align rear
wheels to be level to ensure a plumb line will give accurate
front fork alignment.
Use metal tape measure, spirit level and plumb line to check
front end alignment relative to the rear wheels. Tack weld the
steering head in position and check. Tweak as needed. Add more
substantial tack welds. Add support or localised strengthening
where needed. Gently test until acceptable.
Place each wheel in turn on bathroom scales and note the load.
Do the same with the rider and make a note, so that you can
adjust the load on each wheel according to its size and profile,
by moving the rider and later, the fuel and battery etc. If you
have a VW with a moped front end, then you may wish to consider
your wheel loading very, very carefully.
If you have a mid -mounted car engine, then your three wheel
loadings should be close to very nicely balanced.
When it is as good as possible, remove all items and weld the
frame fully and evenly.
Reassemble, check alignment and tweak if needed, then add any
steering head side plates. At this stage a structurally
complete, if very basic trike is created.
Now check you can easily remove the engine, and also gain access
to service the engine completely.
Ensure easy access to replace the clutch plate may be
particularly useful for thrashers, or those with unusual gearing
or excessively large rear wheels.
Check the exhaust and gearchange routing and any other potential
problem area is acceptable.
Trying to break the design is necessary to ensure the basics are
right. There is no point doing anything else until the basics
are right. It is better to find out at this stage if there are
any dangerous aspects as yet unknown.
NOTE: If anything may break, it should be allowed to break at
this stage, as it is much easier to remedy.
Welcome the kids back. Allow them to misbehave a little.
Remove the blocks to allow one wheel to slide sideways again, as
mentioned above using a plank and dowels or marbles. Now, with
at least three people on it, jump up and down on the basic trike
frame, complete with engine, forks and wheels.
Give your work of art a really hard time.
Simulate hard front braking by rolling it gently into a wall, so
the front telescopic forks will just bottom out, many
times.
The steering head bearings may need to be adjusted as they
settle.
Jump up and down on the inner rear suspension mounts to get the
suspension to move fully, right up to the rubber bump stops and
preferably beyond.
As a group, kick the wheels really hard from the front, back and
sides to simulate rocks and kerbs. If this is your first trike,
you may well misjudge the kerbs, so do this testing with real
dedication.
Do not omit this initial testing, you know why, so don't delude
yourself.
Continue until confident.
After this disgusting act of gross abuse, inspect everything
carefully, especially where the wire model frame broke. If the
frame fractures or breaks, you have everything on hand to repair
and modify the design.
Check to see if the frame has twisted or become distorted, then
straighten it and design a cure for the problem, possibly a
little more triangulation or a fillet plate, cross bracing etc.
It is better to do this now, rather than after the paint and
expensive work has been added. Load to max, see how it flexes,
then think, then modify as needed.
If not at all happy with the design, then simply modify or
re-design and build a new frame in the light of experience.
You may merely wish to grind out the upper or lower main tubes
and replace with a different design, or reduce the wheelbase, or
make a better riding position, or any of many aspects of the
design.
Now is the time to get the basics as good as possible.
Small changes may make a few differences to handling, but may
also make a stronger or less flexing chassis.
The most important part is now completed, give yourself a pat on the back, you deserve it. Now a real breather is possible and to take time to truly appreciate your work.
You now have just the three wheels, suspension and engine, in what is hoped is perfect harmony. So let's find out !
From now on, it is the primary object - the rider, and secondary stuff such as battery and fuel weight distribution which will help refine the last few percent of its potential.
If in doubt about handling, then make a temporary lash up to see
how the machine handles.
A simple moped fuel tank, a bungeed plywood seat and a lots of
nylon tie-wraps or luggage straps around a small battery or use
jumper leads, and minimal wiring will often get most machines up
and running.
A quick thrash around a few quiet bends or carpark, once the
brakes are working, will usually instil confidence in a
reasonable machine.
It is possible to bump start the machine in second gear with a
little help from friends, and pull the wire off the battery to
stop the engine.
This is also a very good opportunity to refine the riding position and suspension.
If a bracket is made, so the front wheel is replaced with a towing hitch, then the trike can be towed behind a car like a trailer, using it's own rear wheels, so it can be towed to a testing area. A simpler design would have a special spindle or special bracket to replace the front wheel, so the trike can be attached to the towing hook. A simple Y frame bolted to the frame, possibly with a couple of bars to make a rigid structure and to take the towing hitch. Or you can make a ball cup to replace the front wheel axle. (Make sure the trike cannot jump into gear while being towed, or remove the chain.) Don't forget to fit trailer lights and a copy of the towing vehicles number plate.
Centre of gravity: Part II.
Not all of us can easily get to a test areas, but would like to
know what the general character of the machine is, before doing
al the fiddly detail work.
With a complete rolling chassis, but not a finished trike, it is
a good time to check the basic weight balance, especially if you
cannot test ride the machine at this stage. This will give a
good view as to where the weight is acting and allow you to
modify the seats and secondary components to refine the weight
balance. As mentioned earlier under the section on the centre of
gravity, it is also possible to predict if the trike has a
predisposition to roll or slide. This requires knowing the
centre of gravity of the basic machine, so it can be further
refined.
On a trike, the weight probably precludes the option of hanging
a complete trike from different positions from the roof and
probably not a good idea unless you have a chain block or other
tackle. Luckily, the centre of gravity is usually along the
centre line of the trike. The centre of gravity when seen in
plan view will depend mainly upon the position of the heavy
bits.
If you decide to hang the trike from the ceiling, make sure it
is as complete as possible, or at least with all the heavy bits
and wheels etc.
Then take a photo, with the chain or rope in view, plus a plumb
bob, so you can draw a drop line. It will probably be best to
put a strop or the hook through the rear suspension or around
the diff or gearbox area, or somewhere near the middle of the
trike, so that it hangs at an angle which will highlight the
centreline below the pivot, usually the top of the chain or
rope. Where the vertical crosses the trikes centreline will be
the centre of gravity, although for most accuracy, check from
two different points.
A much safer way:
If, like me, your roof is weak, but you still want to know where
your centre of gravity is, then pump up the tyres, grab a few
strong friends and balance the trike on the ground on one wheel.
You will have to block the wheel or apply the hand brake. Now
lift the trike up so it balances with no effort on a single
point on the ground. Use a plumb line to see where the centre of
gravity is directly above this point on the ground. In this
example, it goes through the gearbox and assumed to be on the
centreline of the trike.
As shown in the second piccie, when hanging or balancing the trike, also look for the vertical line from the side of the trike, with all three wheels level in your sight, so you can see how far above the ground the centre of gravity is. The riders weight will raise this, but it is not recommended to have a rider sitting on the trike in the search to get perfect data.
Now that you have a couple of chalk lines on the trike, one to
show where the centre of gravity is along the centre line, and
another to show the height of the centre of gravity as seen from
the side, then you will truly know where the centre of gravity
is for the basic trike.
The centre of gravity will be somewhere twards the rear of the
mid point of all three wheels, and should not depend too much
upon where the engine is.
If you have a flimsy front end, then you may wish to move the
weight back a bit. If you have a special front and want serious
stonking ability, then you will be looking for almost even
balance on all three wheels, dependant mainly upon the relative
sizes of front tyre and rear tyre choices.
The centre of gravity when looking down from above the trike in
plan view, will give you a good approximation of the overall
balance on the three wheels.
Although you will have known the weight on each wheel from the
bathroom scales, until now, you did not know just exactly where
this weight acts. This can now be improved with sensible rider
placement fore or aft of this point to get the axle loading just
the way you want.
You may wish to re-read the section on heave, yaw, and slide or skid etc - to assess what you have in front of you.
Heave up and down. The amount of stiffness in the springs and
the damping rates. These are best sorted out with test rides,
but the shocks should be such that you can push them down to
make them move with a reasonable force. If they are really
stiff, then you have to modify. This can be done by using a
shallower angle or softer springs or using different shocks. If
too soft, then use two sets of shocks on each side.
Pitch fore and aft. You can asses the chassis under braking by
using the bike front brakes to see how the trike pitches.
Yaw side to side. This cannot be easily assessed, but if the
engine hangs out the back like a VW then expect a dumb bell
effect. The best machines have their mass centrally, like a
fighter aircraft.
Roll. This can be assessed by pushing the trike sideways, to see
if it is too supple or too harsh. The real test is on the road,
but a rough approximation can be made at this stage, and a hard
push sideways from the tallest part of the trike will show up
any tendencies which may need to be restrained later, perhaps
with an anti roll bar.
Camber angle. At this stage, the rear wheels should ideally be
pointing straight ahead and any adjustments should be made for
this, although a slight toe in may help with cornering. If the
engine is from a front drive car engine, then you will probably
be using the steering linkage to make easier adjustments to the
wheel alignment.
The Camber will also be set up to allow the tyre profile to
remain as ideal as possible with the suspension at 1/3 rd
compressed, where most cornering forces will be applied. So
remove one rear shock and see how the tyre lies relative to the
ground as one side of the trike is lowered across its full
movement, to simulate a side roll or over a big bump in the
road. Also check the toe in while under this extreme movement.
Will it want to Roll or Skid ? See above, especially now that
you have the actual centre of gravity measurements. Don't expect
big fat tyres to give more grip, as they will be applying
lighter pressures, so the overall effect will not depend solely
upon size. (excuse the pun).
When seen from the side, this check will indicate the height of
the centre of gravity above the road surface and will depend
upon the height of the heavy bits. The lower the centre of
gravity, the less roll. See earlier concerning whether the trike
will roll or slide. Height will often be limited by sump
clearance and how the riders are seated. Have a look at a
Porsche V8 and consider why it's sump is wide and flat, allowing
the whole engine to be so low.
You now have a general idea of the overall balance of the machine and can further refine it by carefully placing all the other bits and pieces, including the riders.
Poor integration of the rider and styling can now spoil all this
good work, so don't let standards slip.
Even an excellent rolling chassis and engine can be turned into
a pile of poo if not finished decently.
Do not worry too much, as a good frame can have many and various
generations of superstructure and brackets ground off and
replaced until a perfect trike is achieved.
If deciding to try a rough frame rather than take the effort of
a more involved approach to design, manufacture and testing,
then do so. You may possibly be on a tight budget and using
scaffold bar, off-cuts and recycled bits to keep costs down,
then do so. I do.
It is preferable to make a second rate machine than to make none
at all.
(One of my finest ever handling chassis was just thrown together
to check a design concept. The whole bike cost 35 quid to build
and handles far better than my Ducati.)
Now that the main frame is in place, the next stage is to fit
the parts which take priority over all minor items. Start with
the just the riders seat and gearchange as first priority.
The steering, brake, clutch and passengers should then be
positioned ergonomically. You may have to juggle these with the
overall style, gearchange, fuel tank, the airflow for the
radiators and all their associated mountings.
Before building the rest of the trike, an appraisal of the various parts which must be considered more closely now that the rolling chassis is ready for the seat, the controls and the many other aspects. Building these onto the rolling chassis are discussed, so they can integrate better, once they are more fully understood.
Use a cussion or a foam base from an old car seat and check all possible positions for comfort. Check that controls including handlebars and foot controls can be positioned effectively and safely. Remember what it is like when thrashing around tight corners, so ensure the riders control is as perfect as possible.
A trike need not be an example of discomfort over style.
A trike should always be an enjoyable experience and this is the
time to get it right. Trike riding positions range from a racing
bike forward lean, to fully recumbent as in a reclining chair.
Whatever is decided, do it well.
If wanting a comfy seat, but not the style of a car, but needing
spinal support, then get a car seat and cut the frame down to be
narrower at the top. This is simple cut and weld, so that you
can retain the adjustment of the squab (backrest), which may
make a trike usable for many hundreds of high speed miles,
especially if disabled.
If very disabled, then you can retain the electric adjustments
of a second hand car seat, allowing you to power yourself into
position and perhaps even allow the seat to power sideways to
slide into a wheelchair. - The technology is there for pennies,
so don't be afraid to use it. See disabled options in the
appendices.
In some cases with front engines, exhaust routing will be a
problem for the legs, so either work around the standard exhaust
for convenience of replacement, or be prepared to modify or
build new items. Seriously consider the heat flow from the
engine mounted between or around the legs, and how it will be
shielded, or have fresh air flowing around.
Exhausts are incredibly light, so they can be fitted anywhere
without upsetting the balance.
This is the time when remote or direct steering must also be
finalised. Foot controls should be positioned for best control
in conjunction with the seating. See later.
Only when the ideal position is decided should any extra support
tubing be added for the seats. On some seats, a removable base
will allow access to the electrics, plumbing or an air filter
under the rider.
Like all development constructs, all gearchange parts should be
built with tack welds until everything works fine.
Fit the riders seat in place to decide the most natural position
of the gear stick. You will surely have problems with some areas
of design, so start with what seems worst to sort out. This is
usually deciding on the best path for the gearchange linkage, as
nothing should get in the way of smooth gearchanges.
Left or right hand gearchange will depend on personal
preference, often by the country in which you normally drive.
There is nothing stopping the designer from having the gear
lever sticking up from below, or pointing forward out of the
engine bay, or whatever works best. Car-based trike gearchanges
are a riot of up-down, left-right, fore-aft, and pivoting from
all points of the compass. Whatever suits your fancy, it's
usually possible, and probably been done before. If using a hand
clutch, you may have problems.
The mid engined transverse engine is often the worst gearchange
offender. If lucky, the gear linkage may be above the gearbox.
Always bear in mind such annoying problems when choosing a donor
vehicle.
The biggest problem is when transverse engines have the
gearchange entering the sump. On many engine / gearbox
combinations, the gear linkage is often a stub-shaft mounted low
down and to the rear of the engine, the worst possible position.
The paths of such linkages are particularly difficult.
It is this offender which will be used as an example of how to
solve such problems.
The linkage must obviously pass over or under the engine. On low
gearboxes the higher route may be preferable, especially if the
gearchange is modern, very slick and easy to use. This allows a
small, slick gearstick, and occasionally a gate similar to
Ferrari's. It may be necessary to allow room for an intermediate
linkage. Where the sides of the sump have a gap, usually between
sump and clutch housing, study this as a possible path for the
linkage.
It is not recommended to pass any linkages under the sump where
ground clearance will be a problem. A gearchange over the
gearbox may conflict with the passengers seating area. Also
consider the fact that engines move about on their rubber
mounts, where a low linkage, positioned close to the area of
minimal engine movement will tend to be easier to control.
Think gearchange linkages through very carefully.
Automatic gearboxes also need a change mechanism, which usually
employs a cable. Always use the standard components wherever
possible. This must be set up carefully, so begin by mounting on
the gearbox to see where the standard controls can fit for the
riders benefit. If required, use a longer cable from a similar
design. If no suitable cables available, then consider small
aircraft throttle cables, or carefully modify a thick car clutch
cable, such as from a Ford Escort Mk4. A rigid link or rod, if
used, must allow the gearbox to move without upsetting the
settings.
As modern gearchanges are appearing with increasing regularity,
then for those with the luxury of paddle or button shifts,
similar to formula one gearchanges, then these can be integrated
into motorcycle handlebars, but will need to be on adjustable
mountings until the ideal ergonomics are sorted. This is
especially important while hanging onto the handlebars when
cornering. Paddles allow a strong grip on the handlebars and
interferes less with the brakes. If using a handlebar mounted
front brake lever, then consider changing down from third to
second etc, with the free left hand. (80's BMW bike indicator
switches are rather good for this.)
Manual gearchanges.
The design mentioned below is NOT the only way to make a manual
gearchange linkage, but it is one of the narrowest and more
reliable that I prefer. The other main methods include using two
separate link rods which in many situations may be preferable
and can utilise parts from a similar dual bar linkage such as
from a box van.
If the gear connection is a small stub shaft exiting the rear of
the sump or gearbox, it is usually rotated and also moved in and
out. There are usually three positions for rotation, plus two
for the in and out action.
Always insist on being able to use reverse gear.
On most well designed engines using an awkward stub shaft gearchange, there will also be a fixed mounting point on the gearbox casting. This mounting is for the original gearchange linkage which must be securely connected at the gearbox end. This is an important part of any design, by ensuring the linkage will not misalign as the engine leaps about in it's mountings. Use this mounting appropriately for mounting the gear linkage on the engine, and expect the riders end of the gearchange linkage to move relative with the engine.
The gearchange 'in and out' is normally indented. This is so that each gear is mechanically aligned inside the casing.
In some cases, the rotation of the sub shaft may not be
indented, as the external part of the original gear lever may be
sprung loaded externally so that the driver of the standard
machine will know the levers default position when in the
middle. (Sit in a car and note that the gear lever is normally
sprung to sit in the middle of the left - right movement.)
Often the low gear means having to push the lever to the left,
and higher gears pushed to the right, with a couple of fun gears
self aligning in the sprung loaded middle position. This means
that this (slight rotational) alignment may be controlled with
an external spring or pair of springs. In such cases, the
rotation of the shaft will need to be centrally sprung loaded by
the new mechanism. This is not difficult and can be left until
later, with a spring each side of any new linkage, or a single
centring spring and simple arm often doing the job perfectly
well.
Two control rods are needed. One rod is to rotate the gear shaft, and the other to move the shaft in and out. A narrow tube with internal push rod is often ideal for both the rotating and sliding linkage between rider and the rear of engine.
The rotation tube is considered first.
The rotation of the gearbox stub-shaft is often about thirty
degrees. This is easily managed by fitting a simple lever on it.
The rotation control tube that will lead forward to the rider,
can lie over or under the engine, and the engine end of this
tube can employ a similar lever to match the lever on the
gearbox stub shaft. The engine end of the rotation tube should
rotate on a bracket mounted securely on the engine or gearbox.
A simple link arm connects both these arms, so that rotating
one, rotates the other in a similar manner. If the gearchange
action is back to front, then simply rearrange the levers to
give the action in the other direction.
The front of the rotation tube will contain the gear lever so it
can rotate about the angle required. Because of the rotation
forces and the distance involved, the rotation tube should be of
a reasonable diameter or wall thickness to prevent buckling.
This rotation rod need only be fixed on a simple pivot mounted
on the engine, but the front of the tube must be mounted
flexibly to allow it to move as the engine moves.
Push pull shaft.
The push-pull part of the gear linkage will need to slide the
engine stub shaft in and out.
This can be accomplished by moving the stub shaft in and out by
using a forked end on a lever which fits either side of the
rotating lever already connected on the sub shaft. A simple
forked end around the stub shaft which rubs against the rotating
lever, to pull it out. A single finger pressing on the end of
the stub shaft can push the stub shaft inwards.
By ensuring the forked end of the arm acts directly on the stub
shaft lever, good alignment and feedback is improved.
This forked lever is part of a longer arm which is pivoted half
way between the stub shaft and the rotation tube. The pivot for
this arm may not be easy to mount on the gearbox, and may
require a large plate or bracket to position the ideal pivot
mounting which must be attached to the engine or gearbox. See
drawings.
A simple bracket welded onto the tube so the gear lever pivots
above central axis of the tube will move the inner rod and also
rotate the outer. If the fore aft movement is the wrong way
around, then simply mount the front gear lever pivot below the
rotation shaft, rather than above it.
Pulling and pushing the top of the arm should be able to easily
move the sub shaft in and out.
Rotating the tube should easily rotate the stub shaft.
If an external centring spring is required to centre the
rotation arms, one or a pair of springs can be fitted in one of
many places along the linkage.
It is very sensible to run the push-pull rod through the centre
of the rotation tube.
This layout makes it easy to swap gearchange movement at the
riders end for standard gearchanging positions. If the in out
movement is the wrong way around, then simply change the arm
pivot at the front of the tube.
Large scale engine movement.
As engines flex on their rubber mounts, especially under
acceleration, then they can cause the gears to be missed or even
jump out of gear when the engine rocks about. Therefore the rear
of both gearchange parts of the linkage must be mounted on the
engine, not on the chassis. Because the rear of the linkage is
mounted directly on the engine, the riders end of the linkage
must therefore be rubber mounted to take into account the engine
movement.
If you have a lively engine and a long or heavy gear lever, then
always add a mass balance on the other side of the gear lever
pivot, so the lever does not jump out of gear - or far worse,
jump into gear when revving the engine in neutral !!
Because of engine movement, some pivot links should be slack, so
they can flex with the engine.
Therefore some of the pivots are allowed some play, in the
Kalashnikov tradition, and some foam or rubber padding added to
stop them rattling around noisily. Expensive spherical rod ends
will also do very nicely, but can be added to exhibition trikes,
once the initial design has proven effective.
Because the front of the tube is rubber mounted, and the engine often rocks fore and aft in the chassis, the rear mounting of the control linkage will tend to fracture. Therefore it is very important that the engine mountings at the rear of the linkage must be secure, but also rubber mounted to account for any bending forces caused by the engine movement. A basic engine steady is very important to prevent the engine rocking too much.
As the rotation shaft is ideally a straight tube, the push pull
rod can run inside it. The outer tube works the rotation, while
the inner works the fore and aft movement.
A few simple plastic bushes slid inside the tube will prevent
the inner push-pull bar from bending and a little extra rubber
foam will reduce rattling. The advantage of a single tube is
that it will pass through a fairly narrow gap in the engine or
frame and just as importantly, will not catch or snag any other
components.
There is a large amount of design freedom to allow such linkages
to clear obstacles. The only real concern is to ensure both ends
of each rod will slide and rotate freely under full control of
the riders gearshift lever, and to take into account the effects
of a flexible engine mounting.
The front of the rotation tube must mount the gear lever such
that it can move the push-pull rod along the tube and also
rotate the tube.
The riders end of this gear linkage must be flexibly mounted to
allow engine movement. For simple rubber mounting bushes, use
old motorcycle swing arm bushes or rubber blocks compressed
between bolts and washers. For simple alignment bushes and
pivots, such as for the rear push pull arm pivot, also for the
front upright gear pivot arm bush, simply use Honda C90 stepthru
front fork bush kit and push fit the plastic sleeves into old
handlebar tubing.
It will be seen from the little animation, that if the rear end
of the tube is not connected to the engine, but allowed to float
and slide freely on a sufficiently strong inner bar, then the
upper linkage can be loose. This allows the rear linkage to
have adequate movement as the engine moves on its rubber mounts,
yet the linkage will still work effectively. Therefore only the
middle point of the in/out lever need be mounted on the engine
casing.
Do not use rubber bushes in the actual linkage, only for their
mountings. Rubber bushes in the links will want to return to a
mid point, causing the gears to jump back to the neutral
position.
A slick gearchange linkage requires a smooth, slop free linkage.
This will take time to refine, but well worth the effort.
As some modern gear changes are extremely slick and very smooth, there may be no need to use a traditional large gear linkage. The use of modern, small stub gear levers makes for a neat layout, especially if ergonomically positioned. This also helps the trike riding experience to be faster and more responsive.
The front ends of gearchange should be positioned for the best
ergonomics and will depend upon rider preferences. Because the
described linkage is nicely concentric, the orientation of the
riders gear lever can be at almost any angle. If the tube ends
level with the rider, the gear lever can be straight up in the
traditional manner. If the tube ends a little way behind the
rider, the gear lever could be bent upwards and forward, to give
an angled action. If the gear linkage can be made to end in
front of the rider, the gear lever can be angled back to face
the rider. A simple, solid bar front gear lever arm can be
easily bent to clear obstacles such as frames and knees.
To repeat: If you have a lively engine and a long or heavy gear
lever, then always add a mass balance on the other side of the
gear lever pivot, so the lever does not jump out of gear - or
far worse, jump into gear when revving the engine in neutral !!
This is the system I prefer for most trikes, but the Alfa
gearchange finally used two bars, adapted using the gearchange
from a small Japanese box van, extended with a little extra
tubing. After a few attempts, the front gearchange eventually
exited close to the handlebars for minimal hand movement and for
fast gearchanges. A small lever allowed reverse to be locked out
or engaged.
A reversing light plunger switch was fitted on the rear gearbox
mounting via a bendable bracket and adjusted to work when in
reverse by shorting the live reverse light to earth. As this was
a live connection near the fuel tank, this was soon changed to a
sealed switch for safety reasons.
If in doubt, check out the arrangement and how to design the
linkage before buying the donor vehicle. The scrapyard can often
supply the automatic variant, but this may only be considered as
a final option, or as a temporary measure until gear linkage
design skills improve.
Use whatever is available from other machines, as there is often
very little need to reinvent the remote gearchange.
Gear changes can pass over the top of the engine or underneath,
but the underneath is occasionally difficult if there is lack of
room between sump and clutch housing. No one would want to pass
the gearchange under the sump if trying to keep the centre of
gravity as low as possible for better handling.
Yes, I have seen trikes where the gearchange passes under the
sump and often smashes up a gear when rubbing over a speed bump
in the road. - Just don't go there !
Where there is a gap, then underneath is common as it allows the
front lever to be long, allowing easier control, especially on
older, clunkier gearboxes while it also clears the passenger
area. As the engine mounts are usually on the bottom of the
engine, a lower gear linkage will not move much.
Make sure that all gears - including reverse - can be EASILY distinguished from each other and do so smoothly. This may take some fettling and tweaking of the assembly, often a little redesign work too. Then remove any sloppiness at this stage by removing and refining the linkage until slick rather than slack.
When building a linkage, some play is quite acceptable. In the Kalashnikov tradition, a little play prevents the links from getting locked or stuck, which can be ameliorated by light springs or foam rubber to prevent the assembly from rattling.
Work the linkage hundreds of times until it beds down well.
Take time to get the gear change right, as this is often the
biggest disgrace on trikes and can destroy the enjoyment of the
driving experience of the most perfect handling trike.
Gearchanges are difficult, but after about three varous
attempts, it should be working as required.
If the gearbox is well designed, it may only need a small amount
of effort to transmit the movement, allowing a light, slick gear
linkage with a small control arm.
To see a really classy piece of engineering design, check out the original Porsche Boxter front gear change linkage as shown at it's Geneva launch, it's a work of art. The Spyder also has a similar design of gearchange. (Unfortunately the production Boxter gear levers are a very lame design and nowhere near as good.)
Make all other trike owners jealous by making the gearshift a work of art, not just a suspect metal bar with a brass skull screwed on top. A couple of weeks of intriguing work is not unknown to get awkward gearchanges working well. The effort is always well repaid over the following years.
Actuating the reverse gear usually requires a simple lock out
mechanism, often by pulling the standard car gear knob up, or
pushing down to release before being allowed to move into the
reverse position. This is usually done in the linkage. Reverse
can be a problem for trike riders, especially if forgotten while
riding.
When building a simple mechanical reverse interlock, place the
gearlinkage in reverse and then decide a basic mechanical
lock-out. This is often fiddly and annoying rather than
difficult, so keep trying. On a particularly sloppy gearchange,
this should ideally be close to the gearbox stub shaft or arm.
A simple movable block, lug or arm and corresponding obstruction
plate often works well. Fit a small spring loaded lever under
the gear stick operating via a pedal cycle brake cable so the
block can be lifted away to allow reverse to be engaged.
If the riders gear stick is tubular, then a plunger or pull
action could be used by making the top lever slide on the shaft,
with a stiff spring to move the block.
If like some brave or foolish trike builders, it is decided that
a reverse lock out is a little too complex, then leave it out,
but remember the consequences that can ensue.
Such gearchanges are the sorts of problem I've developed
carefully for my production trike designs so the customer always
gets a well behaved, reliable machine.
I've spent a lot of time and effort on trike gear changes, and
so should you.
On particularly big trikes with a front engine, such as V8's,
the remote steering will need a second fork yoke to mount the
handlebars nearer to the rider. Steering engineering takes
precedence over steering style, so get the steering sorted
before fitting instruments and such like which may mount in the
steering area. Remote handlebars allow almost perfect handlebar
position, so use the opportunity to advantage. This occasion
should also be used to maximise the available space for easy
interaction with the steering and engine. With such a big engine
requiring remote handlebars the cornering forces may well be
large, requiring larger effort and control.
Always try to make the pivot point centrally between the grips,
so the rider can hang onto, even wrestle with the bars around
fast, bumpy, off camber corners, without upsetting the steering.
Wherever possible on distant front ends, use parallel push-pull
rods for a remote fork yoke. Two link rods offers higher
reliability in this area which must not fail. Keep the linkage
parallel and equispaced on both front and rear yokes. If the
front pivots are X mm apart, and Y mm forward of the steering
axis, then make the rear pivot points X mm apart, and Y mm
forward of the steering axis. Geometrically similar.
Keep the rods widely spaced apart for best control. This
eliminates any compound geometry misalignment which could lock
up the steering at high angles. Use spherical 'Rose' joints and
their rubber covers for reliability. The threads on rose joints
will enable slack to be removed. Keep a minuscule amount of
tension in the rods, to reduce buckling.
If the machine is a monster, you may wish to retain the power assisted steering and use a car set-up using the original steering wheel at first, purely for testing purposes, then modify this to assist normal handlebars later. The control valve on the donor vehicle steering will need to be carefully modified. For both style and lifestyle reasons, use of a steering wheel is often frowned upon. For disabled bikers, variations on this theme can be a godsend.
Even granny should be able to safely ride a V12 trike.
When properly designed, even an extreme invalid can ride a V12 trike.
Controls are personal, but don't expect to design a foot
gearchange for a car gearbox with reverse overnight, unless you
cheat with an automatic.
Car clutches working off the handlebars are no fun, try if you
must, but practice by squeezing tennis balls first.
A realistic approach for car engines is to use a hand gearchange
with foot clutch and foot rear brake. Using automatic
transmission is a perfectly legitimate cop out.
Throttle can be a handlebar device similar to a bike, or foot
similar to a car. The foot design will also need a foot rear
brake close by, being ideal for posing / cruising hands off,
such as looking cool while rolling a cigarette in a traffic jam,
on a hot bank holiday. This may also be preferred for custom
shows, where waving to crowds is expected while under power.
Choosing car style foot controls will help clean up the
handlebar clutter to just a couple of switches for horn and dip,
or even less.
The classic bike throttle is often considered as part of the
biker image and should be decided according to lifestyle. See
also cables later.
There is no point in making a trike if it's going to be dangerous. Brakes are very important, they save lives - but only if they work properly.
There used to be a truly awful trike in my neighbourhood, - a VW
engine with small trail bike forks and rust coming from the
front drum brake. He said he "only got the front brake working
for MOT's".
I have not seen him recently.
He is one of the reasons I wrote this monograph.
Trike brakes should be hydraulic to get the best power and
reliability.
There is little to worry about when balancing the pressures in a
dual system, as both outlets of the master cylinder are
pressurised identically.
Where you have to worry, is where this pressure is applied.
The main reason for dividing the outlets is to allow the design
to fail with at least one front and one rear brake. (When two
independent front callipers are used.) It is the relative
diameters of the pistons and the disc rotor diameters which will
decide the overall braking balance.
On some cars, there is a pressure limiter in the rear of the
system, so that a lightly loaded rear axle does not have too
much pressure applied relative to the front to help prevent
skidding in cars. This is often operated via a lever sensing the
load on the rear wheels but can be adapted to a manual control.
If great differences in luggage and passengers are expected,
arrange a pressure limiter as on the original vehicle. It may
also be used with a manual adjuster to allow the builder to
simply modify the front to rear brake balance during testing and
should be considered a useful option if excessive rear braking
problems occur.
If keeping any of the original car plumbing, then blank off any redundant splitters or caliper openings with blanking bolts and copper washers, or steel ball bearings under the old threaded pipe fittings to seal the internal holes. Do not use small ball bearings, as these may get trapped, so always use larger balls so they can be easily removed.
Like any vehicle, the front brakes should be the strongest.
As some trike front ends leave much to be desired, it may be
preferable to have the rear brakes with a slightly heavy feel,
to prevent the rear brakes doing all the work. Some people
prefer rear braking, but is not conducive to ultimate twisty
road thrashing.
Rear brake effort can be increased by removing the servo from the brake master cylinder which was designed for a four brake system on cars. This will also make mounting the basic master cylinder easier. The pressure needed can be easily accomplished and the pressure modified to suit rider preferences by using a longer lever or suitable ratios in the linkage.
A servo will be needed if using a fully linked car system to
operate both font and rear brakes from one foot lever, or if
disabled.
There is no need to fit any brake servo where it may be seen.
Both the brake and clutch levers should be adjustable for leverage to sort out any problems when testing on the road. Use temporary adjustable actuating arms, with various connecting rod mounting holes to allow adjustment of the lever pressures applied to the master cylinders.
The brake and clutch master cylinders can be positioned under
the seat to prevent little fingers from messing about with
filler caps and because these cylinders are often ugly items.
Motorcycle items are less ugly, but may not always manage the
volumes of fluid displacement required, unless used in the
standard manner with bike components.
Check the suitability of all components first and try to match
with the original components.
Fitting bike discs to the rear of a trike may well be useful
especially if three spoke allow wheels are used for show.
On a recent project, the trike had forward controls using
stainless steel link rods to the brake and clutch master
cylinders hidden beside the hidden rear car engine.
Always prefer a tension rod to actuate brakes. If going for a
push rod, make it a reasonable diameter tube so it will not
buckle. Also make sure it cannot be stepped on by the passengers
to prevent it being used, or buckled. If they are running near
the passengers foot well, then decide if you need to run them
inside tubes for safety.
Make sure the brake and clutch systems work exactly as required,
modifying the pedals until they work smoothly and efficiently.
Make sure it is easy to check and fill the brake and clutch
fluid levels. Wherever possible, use the original donor machine
clutch master and slave cylinders in conjunction with the
original donor brakes and clutch actuator.
The designer may want to use a right foot brake lever to couple both the front and rear brakes off the master cylinder. When using a single master cylinder for all the brakes, the vacuum servo assembly should be retained, but hidden under the rear. It can be activated using a remote linkage and a longer length of special vacuum hose, available from many car shops. Vacuum hose is specially designed, thick wall tubing that will not collapse under the effects of high vacuum, especially when on the overrun.
Do not attempt to fit fiddle brakes as per trials cars, as setting them up is a nightmare.
Standard brake arrangements.
The single foot brake car set-up is open to interpretation,
even though this is how a car works and would leave the
handlebars free of clutter.
The brake master cylinders of most cars operate two diagonal
circuits separately.
If connecting a car master cylinder with two outlets to just the
rear brakes, then use both pipe outlets, one to each rear brake.
This arrangement gives an even and balanced pressure across
both, due to the nature of most single barrel master cylinder
designs. The two separate pipes also give a degree of redundancy
for extra safety. For rear brakes only, a servo may not be
needed.
If, like many, you are connecting a car master cylinder with two
outlets to operate dual front discs and the car rear brakes,
then connect one master cylinder outlet to one rear and one
front brake, and the other master cylinder outlet to the other
front and rear brakes. This ensures that should a brake line
fail, the other will still allow reasonable braking.
If you only have one front disc, then fit one master cylinder
outlet pipe to the front brake and the other to split to the
rear brakes. This way, if one fails, you will either have the
front brake or both rear brakes for even stopping. If you had it
linked to the one front brake and a rear, and the other outlet
to just one rear brake and one failed, it may well leave you
with just one rear brake - not a nice thought.
Linked braking.
Linked braking is often less than well appreciated, being either
a fixed design by the manufacturer, or a cobbled together design
without adjustment. It is not difficult to see why such brakes
are often ridiculed, even when expertly made by large
manufacturers.
Simple braking application from a single lever is an ideal, but
only if it can be set up for personal preference and the road
conditions.
Ideally a braking system should be able to sense and adapt to
the axle loading, such as passenger or not and if the weather is
wet or not.
Anti lock braking is for the oft common real world scenarios
where inaccurate braking skills, unknown road variables or poor
feedback are to be expected.
The following is a simple yet effective design to see if the
builder wishes to reconsider linked braking for a particular
design.
Never try to link braking with other components such as
electronic gearchanges until all other parts of the primary
design have been fettled and proven reliable and safe.
For the simplest, yet effective linked braking with cables, a
linked cable dual braking from one lever is possible using a
swingle tree. A swingle tree is a cross piece for an equal pull
on two horses when ploughing a field. (See appropriate text
books. - Any farming text from the Middle Ages onwards should
suffice.)
The basic principle is equally valid for linked braking on
modern vehicles and systems. More so, as it can be adjusted for
a proportional load on front and rear brakes. Yet even more so,
as by using cables, one of the brakes can be also independently
incorporated into this design without an extra brake being
needed. This is applicable for any cable brake or a hydraulic
system with the master cylinder force applied by cable.
For cable and hydraulic brakes, the swingle tree is best
employed by a direct action on front and rear master cylinders
when positioned close together. This allows easy adjustment of
front to rear braking bias, even while riding, so that even this
simple system can be adaptive.
The basic set-up uses a linked bar between the front and rear
master cylinders, acting on the pistons. The pull on this lever
is offset, with a bias for the front brake and should be
adjustable. The rear brake should also have a secondary,
independent action on the rear master cylinder end of the lever.
Do not use linked hydraulic braking unless a second, separate
brake system is also employed.
As shown opposite, Formula One now use a similar system which is
adjustable from the cockpit. The system has the brake pedal
pushing against the front and rear master cylinders, with a
central link which can be offset. The F1 design is poor, and
uses a primitive adjustable pivot, rather than a proportionally
adjustable movements which would be far more subtle.
Another fault of the F1 design is that it is not fail safe
should one system fail, whereas fitting a back stop to allow one
side to work if the other fails, will be far more reliable.
There are many other variations on this theme which can be used
to assess this concept.
Brake imbalance.
If separate front and rear brakes, then the leverage of each is
easily modified to give good braking.
Warning; Because the pressure in the car and bike lines are
probably not designed to be the same, the braking effort of the
rear and front brakes on a linked system may be out of balance.
There are ways around this.
To get more braking effect on the front brakes, use larger
diameter piston cross section at the front than at the rear, or
use larger discs and callipers on the front than those used on
the rear brakes. A mixture of both usually helps balance out the
braking to match the handling characteristics.
If using a linked system acting off a single car master cylinder, where all the brakes receive the same pressure, then the brakes themselves will have to be modified. -
You cannot add extra force into the system unless using a servo. Therefore, if the main brakes are good and just wanting to decrease the offending brakes, then these can be ameliorated to behave properly.
The brake pads could be cut down to offer less braking material to the disc or drum.
Another option is to change the callipers for smaller units. Reducing the disc diameters is not recommended, as they are usually proportional to the wheel diameter and will ensure the forces needed to be applied will be of the correct magnitude and within safe limits.
Alternatively, you could use a Light Laden Valve. If you suffer serious problems with fore to aft imbalance, then the offending braking circuit could employ a light laden valve. This usually operates via a lever which can be adjusted to balance out the rear brakes relative to the front brakes. These are often found near the rear underside of cars and vans, where the rear load makes a great difference to the braking and enables the rear to be less effective if the van is unloaded. To decrease the firmness of rear braking, a car load limiter as fitted on vans (e.g. Ford Escort, connected to the underside via a lever to the rear axle) is a way to be able to adjust the system to the rear braking forces. By adjusting the lever, you have the ability to modify the pressure applied to the front and rear brakes, as used on dual braking line systems.
Where the front brakes need to be stronger, then the trike with a bike front end can have the latest large diameter discs and multi piston callipers. DO NOT apply servo assisted braking to motorcycle discs, as they may possibly warp under the excessive pressures. Only apply hand pressure, to stay within working limits of these flimsier types of brakes.
Where the front end uses a car disk brake, then TWO callipers can be fitted onto a single chunky car disc, preferably working off separate master cylinder outlets for balanced braking under partial failure. This doubles the braking force with no other modifications. Where possible, use the ventilated disc from the sports version of the donor car, especially if using dual callipers on it.
Dual callipers should be used as part of a dual linked system, such as used from just one foot brake in a car style, linked system. When fitting dual callipers to a front car disc, the symmetrical donor callipers will be handed pairs, so the bleed nipples of both can be mounted to allow easy bleeding.
Never put excessive pressure on the front brake if using a bike front end, as the tyre will be limited in its ability to transmit the force to the road.
On a trike, the braking will be compromised by the amount of weight on each axle and the tyre profile. A lightweight front end with a skinny tyre is not going to be able to handle too much of the braking. Therefore a truly reliable rear braking system, well balanced and effective will be necessary, even though it is not ideal for best control or handling. Conversely, a trike with a heavy front end should not have too heavy a rear brake set-up, neither should it apply all the braking to the front, even if of a soundly built design.
If using a jet engine, then seriously consider using two sets of 320mm diameter bike disks on each rear axle, separated by the width of the callipers and well ventilated. If you can fit inboard and outboard rear discs, then do so.
In small trike set-up, the front brake is usually a motorcycle handlebar set-up, simple and easy, with a car rear brake without the servo, just acting on the car master cylinder, without the vacuum pipe attached. If the rear is then too soft, the servo can be connected, then the vacuum pipe partially strangled and the foot brake linkage modified to get a good balance with the front brake.
On a recent V12 trike project, the whole machine kept the Jag braking system, acting off a foot brake lever, but the front axle was replaced with a much stronger axle machined from EN steel allowing heavier single axle loads and braking. The original Jag front disc and wheel was retained but a second calliper was added, so the whole system was balanced fore and aft, although the front tyre had to do more work. Because it's a trike, and the prop shaft was shortened to get the engine rearwards, there was a little less front axle loading, to help ameliorate the overall braking balance on the wheels.
If the engine runs, and the rear is blocked up off the ground, then the engine can be set on high tick over and the (rear) brakes applied to see how the rear brakes behave., If one wheel stops much earlier then the other, then there is brake imbalance. If there is imbalance after fully bedding down the brakes, then check for any imperfections and adjust the brakes until both rear wheels work as a balanced pair, with both wheels slowing down at the same time when applying the brakes while under engine power.
The parking brake is often a problem for trikes. The transverse
engine front wheel drive being the worst offender, as most
parking brakes are on the rear wheels. Mounting a second
calliper on the rear discs can work well, or alternative
callipers from a car with discs all round. Using the car's REAR
wheel callipers on the trike (front, now) rear discs often works
well, if the disc rotor diameters are not too dissimilar.
Because most cars have the same wheel studs front and rear, and
the cast iron brakes are often mounted on these, then it is
often very easy to fit standard rear disks to the front wheel
assembly of car wheel hubs for use at the rear of trikes.
Mount the callipers on the disc, then look for the easiest way
to retain them. Sometimes just cutting off the original mounting
lugs, fixing them on the calliper, then rewelding into their new
positions. Sometimes a simple extension plate will suffice, but
make sure it tends to straighten when braking in the forward
direction, as this is how the heaviest braking forces will act.
When mounting callipers, use new pads and always slip a strip of
thick cardboard on the edge rim of the disc, to give suitable
clearance and to maintain even radial alignment while fitting.
Where no room for extra calliper or suchlike is possible, then a special parking brake cylinder which works in-line with the standard hydraulics and acts on the original callipers is available from some racing suppliers. This often fits between the master cylinder and the rear brake callipers, allowing the brake line to be locked hydraulically, usually by a hand lever. It closes off the rear hydraulic line and then applies pressure on a standard handbrake ratchet.
Some front engined modern cars with rear discs have the parking brake integrated into the design, needing little or no modification. Occasionally a modified calliper mount or cable mount is needed to employ this particular set-up on the discs.
For many of the lighter show trikes which need a much better disc than the lump of iron normally supplied with cars, then motorcycle discs and callipers can be used, especially if seen through three spoke wheels. These lighter trikes will also require motorcycle callipers and if rear engined, will probably also need the intermediate hydraulic hand brake unit.
Some Honda callipers use dual systems on single callipers, allowing the main braking to be on the outer two of the pistons, with the builder adapting the parking brake to act on the centre cylinder. Similar alternatives are also found with car systems.
For front engined trikes with central prop shaft, use the
following to eliminate complexities and to have completely
independent parking brake for emergencies. This also allows for
a cleaner inner wheel look with a single calliper of choice.
On many cars with a prop shaft leading from the gearbox to the
rear differential, then a single motorcycle or car brake disc
can be fitted on the prop shaft flange on the differential. A
brake calliper can then be fitted to lock the whole drive
assembly. This is excellent yet common practice on 4WD's such as
Land Rover, allowing them to lock all wheels with just one
brake. This is simply done by welding on a mounting flange, or
inserting a thin flange between the prop shaft and the
differential, then running the engine and prop shaft while
truing the disc mounting flange in situ.
If machining without a lathe, mount the blank metal disc carrier
on the end of the gearbox, as the diff and gearbox flanges
should normally be the same dimensions. Then fire up the engine
as a lathe. Carefully apply the angle grinder or file until a
perfect fit is made to mount the brake disc. Ensure a shoulder
is included to align the disc before drilling its mounting
holes.
If there is no room in the differential area, then the parking
brake disc may possibly be mounted on the gearbox output flange
of many car engines.
As the differential has a large gearing ratio, the effort
required on such a disc is low compared to a wheel mounted
brake. Because of this gearing, small discs are possible. A
second calliper on this disc can act as the rear brake if
wanting to have a clean rear axle for show use.
If a cable parking brake is preferred but a cable operated
calliper is not found, then simply use a standard car drum brake
on the prop shaft, which can also fit on the rear wheels or
around the propshaft, although the brake shoe backing plate will
need modifying to fit the appropriate mounting. There are a few
cable operated car disc brake callipers and these should be
considered, although they are rare and will need hunting down in
scrap yards.
Please note that drum brakes with a leading and trailing shoe
are usually better in one direction, so choose the donors
vehicles left or right drum brake appropriately so that pulling
away uphill will be easier, requiring less force on the
handbrake lever.
If the gearbox is integral with the engine with no prop shaft, there may be room for a small disc in the inboard coupling of the drive shaft. The inboard discs of the Alfa and later 2CV's and 4CV's make parking brakes an absolute doddle. They also allow a totally open and clean inner rear wheel area, ideal for wire spokes and skinny three spoke alloys.
When mounting disc or drum brakes, always mount and true the disc or drum first, then fit new pads or brake shoes, and apply pressure to the calliper or shoes, to align the supporting assembly in position. Then the backing plate can be welded in position with perfect accuracy.
When mounting parking brake callipers, remember that they must
work in both directions, - when parking both uphill and when
pointing downhill. Ensure the calliper mounting is secure in
both directions. If using a car control layout, always ensure
the parking brake will work easily and safely, especially when
pulling away uphill.
Some trikes have problems with a basic parking brake which works on single piston callipers. In some cases, a simple valve in the rear hydraulic brake line can suffice, as shown in the picture. Push the brake pedal down, then lock the hydraulic line. I personally don't like it, but evidently this has passed the MOT. In such a system, I would prefer cheap rubber pipes, which allow a degree of flexible 'pressure reservoir' for any minor leakage, as the high spec. hydraulic lines would not give this slight margin of safety.
On the clutch, (and rear brake) the foot should have complete
control, so design the foot rest and it's lever to pivot as one,
usually near the heel or instep. Often known as an 'organ stop'
pedal. This will allow the rotation of the foot to work the
action for accurate control. This is particularly important for
a sensitive foot clutch.
If the movement is large, then use running boards with a heel
support to act as a reference point for the foot on the lever.
This way you will have much better control over the clutch
'bite' point.
Car clutches working off the handlebars are no fun, try if you
must, but practice squeezing tennis balls first. See also cables
later.
Only if the trike is a light weight design, and not intended to carry extra loads, then a car clutch can be operated by a hand lever, especially if the fingers of a clutch diaphragm spring are reduced. This can be modified by removing opposite fingers of the clutch spring until acceptable. Always note that if too many fingers are removed, the clutch will no longer be able to transfer the same amount of power, so clutch slip may occur at top speed. (where aerodynamic drag is high).
For an easy life in town use with a 2CV engine, always consider fitting the superb automatic clutch option, which releases at low revs, not dissimilar to a Honda C90.
Side loads when cornering will cause sloshing in long
across-frame tanks, so ensure they have baffles, or use a
standard tank such as some cars mounted in their normal
alignment.
The fuel capacity is normally similar to that of the donor car,
so that the range is sensible. If touring abroad, a second long
range or emergency tank can also be of use.
All tanks should be rubber mounted to prevent fracturing. All
tanks should be away from damage by other vehicles to minimise
fire hazard during crashes.
It is very popular to have a small motorcycle tank for styling
purposes. This need not be a limitation, but an advantage if a
secondary, hidden main tank is also employed.
If filling a main tank from a primary tank, always make the
interconnecting pipe large enough to allow petrol to flow
reasonably fast when filling. This will mean modifying with a
large bore stepped pipe in the bottom of the 'bike' fuel tank.
Please note that there is a very good reason to have the large filler interconnecting pipe high on the primary, filling tank. When filling, the primary tank will fill first, ensuing there is enough for emergencies, and only then will the fuel overflow into the secondary or main tank. If a small show bike tank on the trike, it is high enough to allow gravity feed to the carbs, then even if the fuel pump fails, you can still get home.
If one tank is the reserve, make it the smaller of the two and
always fill it first. Don't let the emergency tap leak so that
both tanks empty without knowing, leaving the trike stranded
without a reserve.
If the primary tank is a small capacity, traditional bike tank
with the main filler cap, and it is used as the reserve, then
the filling connecting pipe should be positioned high inside the
tank. In this way the first tank will always be filled first,
ensuring the tank is always full of fresh emergency fuel. The
bottom of the upper tank can be tapped for reserve only.
Ensure a breather pipe is fitted on each tank. If the tanks are
at different heights, use long breathers to a high point above
the highest tank, or into the highest tank for a neater look. A
small plastic fuel filter makes an excellent vent filter on the
end of such a pipe.
Where a large bore intermediate pipe is used, then it is very
easy to fit the lower vent pipe inside the larger pipe, up to
the upper tank, so the plumbing is neater, with less chance of
fuel leaks and only the upper tank needs a vent hole. Make sure
that each end of the vent pipe is in the top of both tanks.
If no emergency tank is used and dual tanks are fitted, then
only one fuel gauge sender is needed if the tanks empty evenly.
If they do not empty evenly, put the gauge in the last tank to
empty, to get a genuine reading of when fuel is low.
Most fuel gauges work in the same manner, allowing the float arm
to be reshaped to give sensible readings. Always keep the same
matched fuel sender and fuel gauge. Always test and check by
moving the arm when wired up, but before fitting into the tank,
then adjusting it's arm as needed.
If using bike or car fuel senders, simply cut out the sender and
its mounting for welding into the new tank. A C90 sender and
gauge will do just as well as any other fuel sender. Simply
modify the arm to sweep through the full displacement of height
of the fuel tank.
On some trikes with high fuel tanks and low mounted carbs, a fuel pump may not be needed. But high, heavily loaded fuel tanks will make cornering a little more difficult by accentuating roll. Wherever possible, keep all heavy items as low as possible, this includes fuel and passengers.
For better handling, the fuel tanks should be mounted low, so
their mass does not cause the trike to roll sideways excessively
when cornering. Low fuel tanks require a fuel pump.
There are two types of electric fuel pumps for ordinary car
engines. One about three psi, the other about six psi. The low
pressure type is for a pump mounted near the carb. The high
pressure pump is used when mounted near the rear fuel tank of a
front engined car. Use the low pressure type as the first choice
unless the trike is long and the fuel pump is far from the
carbs.
Connect the fuel pump on the ignition circuit so it won't pump
when parked. Use a separate fuse, because pump contacts
occasionally weld themselves together. Spare contacts are
normally available for decent electric fuel pumps.
In rare, exceptional circumstances it may not be possible to
connect the fuel pump directly to the carburettor, whereupon a
header tank is required. Possibly a set of carbs fed from a
motorcycle tank, with a secondary, main tank elsewhere. This
should maintain a reasonable height (head) above the
carburettors and maintain the level with an overflow back to the
fuel tank. With such header tanks, the fuel pump will want to
over-pump constantly, so a restrictor can be used, capable of
being adjusted to supply fuel at just a little more than
constant full throttle requirements. This can be easily
calculated at max miles per gallon, then the time for this
distance, then time and measure the fuel flow from the pump into
a measuring jug, then restricting the flow as required.
For simple, adjustable restrictors, the use of the very old
technique of fitting a larger restrictor, then adding more or
fewer fine wires though the restrictor to attain the required
flow. It also has the advantage of being partially self
cleaning, as the loosely held wires will help to unblock any
small particles. Wire brush strands are ideal. This is also fail
safe, as an escaped wire will increase the flow, but be trapped
by the fuel filter. This is an old technique from the steam age,
but still applied on modified or development engines to vary
their oil flows.
An alternative is to fit a simple level gauge in the tank to
operate a relay to the pump. On a small plastic tank, a simple
float with a magnet on its base can operate a reed switch on the
base of the tank and thus a relay for the pump. For micro header
tanks, there is a vast choice of discarded two stroke oil tanks
with level sensors, which are ideal for operating fuel pump
relays of engines with moderate fuel needs.
Never fit a fuel tank where it can be damaged in a crash. This is especially important at the bottom rear of the trike, where a shunt will spill the contents and lead to serious burns. On a trike you are less likely to be trapped in the flames, but never take chances.
Most fuel tanks are mounted in rubber and held in place with steel straps. Use donor vehicle components if they are appropriate.
For those who build their own fuel tanks, then either make the cosmetic trike outer shell mould first, so the fuel tank(s) can be built to fit within the shell without upsetting the overall shape of the trike. Or make a special fuel tank, making sure the shell can be well styled. This may also require juggling the shell mounting points to clear the fuel tank. Hidden fuel tanks can be built in any shape and should be considered as adaptable items which can utilise wasted space.
When making sheet steel fuel tanks, arc welding can be tricky,
so the edges should be flanged outwards and clamped, tack welded
and then finally fully welded. Tack welded outer flanges allow a
neat seam with a little extra flange strength to prevent
fracturing. There is nothing worse than poor welding on a fuel
tank. Unlike a frame weld, a fuel tank weld can rarely be ground
out and neatly repaired.
Always fit baffles if in doubt, which can be soldered into place
using plumbers solder before the tank is sealed.
It is often easier to weld the filler pipes and fuel level
sensor mounting flange prior to assembly of the fuel tank outer
surfaces.
If not at all happy about making small pipe outlets at the base
of a fuel tank which can leak, simply because welding such thin
metal is too difficult, then use a punch to pierce the top of
the tank with a hole. Into this hole can pushed a long tube
which will touch the bottom of the tank. Always make sure the
bottom of the tube is a little way off the base of the tank to
prevent clogging and to allow good fuel flow. The top of the
metal fuel pipe can be soldered in place using plumbers solder,
which is stronger than electricians solder. The shape of the
punch hole will give a little extra strength as it helps create
a longer pool of solder. Always clean back to bare metal before
soldering. The shorter filler and vent pipes can also be done in
a similar manner. Where the bottom of the fuel pipe is located,
make a small sump in the fuel tank base to allow all the fuel to
be used. If you can get hold of brass wire mesh, then this makes
a neat sediment filter around the base of the fuel pipe, and the
larger it is the better. As the fuel sloshes around, it may even
be self cleaning if designed well.
Always fit a cleaning hole, probably the fuel sensor plate, and
if this is not used, then make a small bolt which will allow the
fuel to be drained out, especially if the fuel tank is not
easily removable for servicing.
If worried about sludge or sediment, then leave a small sump in the fuel tank and also a small magnet to catch any rust. The fuel filter should preferably be transparent and with a paper element. A good engineer will always align the filter so the sediment can be easily seen.
The connection between the fuel tank and the filler cap is done with a simple length of fuel resistant rubber pipe and if needed, an intermediary length of standard car steel pipe, all secured with hose clamps.
Little, or sticky fingers may also find carburettors
irresistible, so some stylised form of shielding or security may
be suitable.
Alloy sheet can be easily shaped by using a ball pein hammer and
a bag of sand. Panel beating is an art, but even minor attempts
can make a sheet look like it naturally belongs there, rather
than just another nondescript bracket. When shaping aluminium,
it will work harden, so regular softening is needed. Rub some
ordinary soap on the alloy and heat until the soap begins to
turn brown, then quench the alloy in water to anneal it to make
it malleable.
There are alternative ways to secure expensive carbs to engines,
including special nuts, or simply making the removal components
very difficult to reach.
If out in the open, the carbs may get cool in winter so the
covers should try to duct some warm air over them in the winter,
to keep from icing at high speeds and in bad weather. Shielding
should also prevent any linkages from sticking from road salt
and general road dirt. If this is not possible, liberal amount
of rubber boots and thicker silicone maintenance spray may
suffice.
To make custom plastic boots, cover the linkages with plaster of
paris, then covering in silicone rubber. This will allow the
plaster moulding to be picked out, leaving a perfect silicone
rubber boot. Using white foam is much easier, as petrol will
dissolve it after the silicone has set. Carving with a
concertina shape and some styling will offer a degree of style
to the proceedings. Using silicon bathroom sealant which is
colour matched to the trike, creates a little more perfection.
If not for show, but used in harder climes, preferably look for
harder rubbers, such as shoe base material which can be applied
from a tube. I use Buffalo brand.
For other options, fibreglass suppliers also supply a plastic
dipping moulding material similar to that used on the handles of
pliers and similar tools.
As many engines are rear mounted, the cables will be often need to be modified and lengthened. It is increasingly difficult to find anyone who will make a custom cable, causing the builder to improvise or make their own.
Improvise: Using a standard bike twist grip and cable, position the cable in the best route towards the carb. Then fit the standard engine throttle cable and route it towards the front cable. They will either reach or not reach. Then make up an intermediate connection to fit the standard cable ends of both. This intermediate linkage can often be a third standard cable or a light rod mounted along a frame tube. Make suitable clamps to securely position each outer cable in a suitable position along the frame.
By employing standard cables and components, many hassles will be negated and spares will be much easier to buy and fit.
Make your own: Some motorcycle aftermarket suppliers still sell reels of Bowden cable and a selection of cable ends. Find a cable supplier and buy plenty of inner and outer cable. With many trike friends, cable skills will soon be in demand. Choose the more flexible inner type of cable, as all throttles should be a light action. Outer cable should ideally be nylon lined. Also buy a good selection of nipples and ferrules at the same time.
In Britain finding cable may be a pain, but it does exist. Go to
a friendly dealer, the sort who is a small motorcycle shop and
ask when the parts supplier representative turns up, they
invariably arrive within the same hour every week.
"Hi, when does the pattern spares rep turn up? Tuesday
afternoons? - great. Is it OK to be here to see if he can supply
some rolls of control cable and bits, as it's a bugger to hunt
down. - Cheers, - I'll pop in early on Tuesday afternoon."
The problem behind making a direct approach is that most big
dealers want to sell full price cable, and smaller shops simply
don't want to have the hassle of ordering bits you may or may
not want. If you turn up in person, then you can ask the rep
yourself and the shop owner will have no hassle over what is
available and what you think you may need, nor end up with
unwanted stock.
Be polite and ask it its possible to be there when they arrive,
Then ask the rep what cable they have and then order it though
the shop, leaving full price as it's not really expensive. It
should arrive within a couple of days. My friends shop's rep can
supply four sizes of wire and outers, plus a host of cable ends,
nipples and ferrules. But I can only get the stuff if I am there
to quiz the rep.
Use light cable for throttle, and strong cable for clutch. If a cable operated car clutch, preferably keep to the original components. Again, if too short, use two standard car clutch cables and make a simple cable joining linkage.
Scavenge the ends off old cables to make a good fit for the
twistgrip, then clean up to fit the outer cable.
Where the cable outer will not fit the standard mountings and
will tend to misalign, it is often possible to slide a short
length of rubber fuel pipe over the outer cable join to prevent
misalignment of the cable run.
When cut to length, fit the outer and check the run. If suitable
nipples are not available, then make them from steel or brass
bar. Brass is better as it solders easier and wears better. Old
brass screws can supply the twist grip nipple, by drilling a
small hole first, then countersinking the hole slightly and then
cutting to length evenly either side of the hole. Larger nipples
may need to be made from old steel bolts. Always countersink the
nipple holes.
The inner cable should be soldered around the new ends before
cutting, so the strands will not distort. When the strands are
in the nipple, file a small nail to a tapered point and gently
hammer into the centre of the strands to swage the strands open
and spread in the countersink. This is particularly important
for clutches with their heavy loads. Then solder fully and file
flush when solid. Make sure the nipple will rotate freely in the
twistgrip to prevent undue wear. Always lubricate fully before
use with a light grease around the nipple and light oil in the
cable, allowing the oil to drain all the way through the cable.
Always use a light oil in the throttle, not a thick engine oil,
as this causes drag. Always make the cable route as smooth as
possible with minimal bends.
The carburettor end may require an unusual fitting, possibly the
use a push bike brake type of clamp to secure to the carburettor
linkage.
If the car carburettor return spring is too heavy, try
modifying, or use a different spring. Double check it will not
stick open and always use an ignition kill switch if in doubt.
(See my 'Builders Guide to Motorcycle and Trike Wiring'.)
Choke. Where a choke lever is needed, it can be mounted almost
anywhere, possibly even with a simple high tech variant of a
piece of string and a return spring. (Please don't use string.)
Some automatic chokes work on engine or water temperature acting
on a bimetalic strip or similar device. As a trike carb is
mounted in the open, some adjustment may be possible, such as
adjusting the setting for winter use. See the appropriate car
manual.
Some vehicles can use aftermarket manual choke conversions for
carburettors for those who prefer this option. As the engine may
be front mounted, the choke lever on the carburettor may even be
operated directly or by using a simple extended lever.
If problems occur, then have the engine set-up and fettled by the certified specialist. They usually know what they are doing and have the tools to do it. They may often offer priceless advice to improve the system. (Ask the mechanics quietly if the motor will take the 'sports programmes'. This is because some computers can have their programmes wiped and the faster upgrades written into the EPROM's for an extra 10 percent horsepower over the standard model. Usually a 'test drive' to somewhere quiet with a laptop and a few minutes reprogramming with the updated software and a few quid changing hands for an easy extra 50 horse power.)
In most cases, only oil coolers look good at the front of an engine, more so if using stainless steel braided plumbing.
If the engine has an engine driven cooling fan, simply remove it and place the radiator anywhere that is more stylish or suitable by employing electric cooling fans instead.
The pulley part of the fan mounting usually needs to be retained, as it is often part of the V belt drive for the alternator and water pump, or a mass damper to prevent unwanted vibrations building up in the longer crankshafts such as straight sixes.
When choosing different radiators, keep the radiator cooling area at least the same as the original or a little larger. See what the scrapyards have to offer. Radiators are a design opportunity, so don't be afraid to experiment with them.
Radiators are essentially simple technology with only a few booby traps. They are fairly cheap and are easily made to measure from most local radiator suppliers at prices less then original components. Various designs of trikes can adapt the positions of the inlet and exit pipes, choose from a variety of widths and have the matrix any height you want. You can also specify single or double thickness matrix. So get the tape measure out and study the possibilities. Make a cardboard cut-out as a pattern to check fitment and for the local radiator maker to copy if you can't find anything suitable in the scrap yards.
Radiators are prone to stones, road kill and general clogging, so keep the airflow away from wheel tracks or similar impact problem areas. Wheels can also cause air turbulence and upset an otherwise superb air flow. A wire shield or F1 style 'barge board' deflector may be needed in some cases.
Keep the engine areas looking sleek, so consider placing the
radiator(s) out of sight. Hide radiators unless they are stylish
such as the styles so enamoured of formula one and some
supercars. Even then, some stylised ducting to control airflow
should be considered. See also shell later.
Study the Lamborghini Countach and formula one cars, they seem
to have more than just a little style in the radiator area.
Always consider if two smaller radiators will be preferable for
aerodynamic and often aesthetic reasons. Or maybe different
shapes and mountings can be used to enhance the looks.
Styling of the rear outer shell will open up many possibilities
with air ducts and such like. The Ferrari Testarossa, (Red head)
for all it's faults, had world famous side mounted air scoops.
Modern cooling systems use a header tank to allow for expansion of the coolant when hot, which must be placed at a virtual 'high' point in the system. Make sure all air in the system can bubble its merry way up towards this tank or can be bled from the system at a high point. Many modern cars use little plastic air vent taps for this purpose. Recycling the cheaper screw-in schrader cycle and motorcycle inner tube valves can also be employed for venting any awkward plumbing, but good design is better.
Rubber mount the radiators as they can be fragile. Make all connections with rubber tubing. The plumbing can be a mix of radiator hose and steel pipes that can be easily shaped to fit awkward bends. Ask the radiator builders what types of inlet and exit pipe positions are available to make plumbing much easier.
The thermostat, temp sensor and the cooling fan control will do their jobs whether in a car or trike, it doesn't matter which. As the temp sensor and thermostat are built into the engine, they all work at the temperature that the engine designer requires. If a remote thermostat, then the thermostat must be kept very close to the engine.
If the radiator is large and mounted horizontally or at an angle, then the matrix should be supported at various points to prevent collapse when jumping hump back bridges. Use light steel bars and heavy duty foam which will not collapse, with a hard rubber pressure spreader sheet between matrix and foam, to prevent the matrix cutting through the supporting foam.
On front engined trikes where the water pump is positioned at the front of the engine, use large bore coolant pipes hidden under the frame rails. If they cannot be hidden, use stylish tubes and routing, possibly stainless.
As the radiators may be much further away, the use of larger
bore coolant pipes will reduce problems of restriction from the
longer coolant flow. Never use smaller pipes as the water pump
may not be up to the effort of a restricted flow. If things get
really desperate, such as for big motors, an electric water pump
or even two can be used, one for each radiator.
On monster motors, two electric waterpumps, each feeding a
separate radiator, will ensure that on radiator or pump can
fail, and you can still get home and the monster motor will not
die.
Connect the engine with steel or stainless cooling pipes to match the shape and style of the engine, so they won't look out of place. Alloy or copper pipes can fracture with time, so only use if building for show or custom. Steel pipe will rust unless using antifreeze, so always use antifreeze except when on racing circuits. If in doubt, clean the steel pipe fully, then coat the inside with epoxy resin. Paint may flake off and impede the water pump or radiator matrix.
For many custom trikes, the coolant can flow through the frame tubes. As coolant rarely exceeds boiling point, most paints will be unaffected. Another reason for having long, uninterrupted frame tubes.
It may be advisable to place the small coolant header tank under the steering head, so it can be seen when it overheats, especially during testing or if wiring up a temperature sensor and gauge is too much hassle. Ensure the header tank can accommodate the difference in volume between cold and hot as the system reaches operating temperature. The cap will normally maintain pressure in the system and allow excess coolant to be vented if overfilled.
On the Alfa, two smaller radiators were used, partly to keep the
height down and partly for posing in style. They were wide and
short, rubber mounted an angle either side and just in front of
the suspension, angled to catch the updraft of the hidden air
dams under the passengers feet.
The coolant split to flow into both radiators to prevent causing
too much drag on the water pump. If the water pump had to pump
through one radiator then the other, the increased pressure drag
may cause the flow rate to drop, and overheating could occur. By
using two radiators in parallel, if one radiator became damaged,
it could be clamped off to allow the other to be used to get
home. If one radiator became clogged, the other would still
work.
Two vent pipes allowed trapped air from the top of the radiators
to go to the header tank via a Y piece from a windscreen washer
system. Wire mesh protected the radiators from damage. With
passengers either side of the rider, make sure the footrest
position is chosen with heavy braking in mind, or you will be
scraping friends off the wheels. On the Alfa, two seats were
fitted between the rear wheels and driver, with long thin
raditors under the pasengers seats, the back of the seats
resting against the suspension cross member. The front of the
passenger floor panels could then be angled up to channel the
air into the radiators, acting horizontal air scoops with side
dams while maintaining styling. It also helped keep road spray
from the front wheel off the passengers.
On most car cooling systems, cooling fans are used and
controlled by the standard car temperature sensor via a relay.
The water temperature sensor often shorts a fan wire to earth
when the max temp is reached. This can be used to control one
radiator fan, or control a pair of fans via a simple relay. Some
temp switches work directly on the fan without need for a relay,
but check the manual first. Use of two temperature sensors is a
cheap safety measure for an expensive engine.
The radiators may not get enough air at low speeds, so make sure
the thermostat, cooling fans and temperature gauge work
properly. The temperature gauge should be the standard donor
vehicle item, as the engine designer prefers it this way,
although just about any thermostat will do. The temperature and
fuel gauges may need a voltage stabiliser from the dashboard to
keep them reading properly, as most gauges are voltage
sensitive. Check the wiring diagram, or check by noting the cold
and then the hot position on the gauge at running temperature.
Make sure the cooling air can flow easily between the engine and
passenger seats so no-one gets too warm.
For trikes used in more Arctic climes, heat ducting louvres
should also be considered.
Radiators and aerodynamics.
The biggest problem with cooling is not the radiator size, nor
bad design causing the liquid coolant flow to be restricted, but
the inability to get sufficient cooling air through the radiator
to begin with.
If the cooling fans are often on, or if the engine keeps
overheating, check the thermostat, carburetion and ignition
timing first. Then check the water pump and at the same time
flush out the engine block and all waterways with a hose pipe.
If the engine still overheats and all else fails, then check
airflow. Cut some three inch long strips of bright wool, grab a
friend, a bamboo stick, some blue tack and find a quiet road. If
you can see the radiators while riding, stick some wool strands
in and near the radiator matrix to highlight the airflow. Blue
tack some tufts of wool around the air flow areas, wool strips
around the radiator areas, with the passenger using a piece of
wool on a stick to check other areas.
Ride the trike through different speeds and wind directions to
find out just where the air actually flows. Problems may involve
the action of the wheels, a 'dead spot' of air flow, or
turbulence which can break up or destroy a clean airflow through
the radiators. Not only must the air reach the radiators in a
clean flow, the heated air from the radiator must then exit
cleanly away to ensure a totally balanced and effective air
flow.
The passenger may also be able to use a flat piece of card while
driving to deflect the air to effect possible solutions,
followed up with Duct (gaffer) tape and cardboard ducting
modifications. See also aerodynamics.
Too many trikes suffer poor cooling, especially when thrashed.
Poor cooling will destroy an engine especially on a long run. It
should be sorted at an early stage.
If you have a hand cam or digital camera wit movie mode, or a
laptop with a remote USB web cam, then this may also suffice
while riding, if its secured to the seat with bungees and the
camera to the radiator area with lots of blue tacky office
putty. (More fun with laptops later.)
Front wheel.
On light trikes, a motorcycle front end will often suffice.
On heavier machines, some work is needed and often involved to
get the best from the design.
The tyre is the most important item, so choose it well. The front wheel profile is mentioned earlier and will help get the best from a trike front end.
If building your own front end for a heavy trike or one needing much more braking force, it may often be better to use a car hub and wheel mounted on monster forks with attendant heavy duty disc brake. An modified motorcycle style wheel with dual discs is possible, but perhaps built up using stronger items from steel car wheels, and a wide front tyre, often using a rear bike tyre to take the weight and braking forces. Where an ally car wheel is used, then the discs cab hidden inside, using standard car components, but on a specially made axle to be supported on the custom forks.
Buy a steel wheel to fit the tyre. Sensibly compromise rim width, to retain some rounded profile on the front tyre, but not that it looses its lateral stability. Check by moving the mounted tyre in the manner expected by the trikes' front end, taking into account the rake angle, to see how the profile matches the road surface. As the trike does not lean like a motorcycle, a partially curved profile tyre is acceptable.
By using a steel rim, a special wheel and hub can be more easily modified to fit a custom or heavy duty set of forks.
A steel motorcycle hub with dual discs can be built up to take a car rim, but make sure it is as strong as possible and with strong bearings. As such hubs are rare, simply make new items using similar techniques to the steering head to give a strong, twin taper roller or ball race hub and axle. Motorcycle wheels rarely take side loads, except for sidecars, whereas a trike will be pushing standard motorcycle wheel bearings to their limits, so always build a better, stronger hub. Harleys and some BM bikes use taper roller wheel bearings and are recommended for medium to heavier trikes.
There are two basic front hub designs.
Either to build a simple axle unit similar to a steering head or
to modify or re-engineer a bike or car hub. Re-engineering a car
hub or a bike hub such as a Harley rear hub with taper roller
bearings is often easiest, but it must be steel to allow easy
welding. Those who can afford to commission special billet
wheels should have few problems.
For those who need to, or prefer to engineer and build their own
wheels, then there are many ways, and careful consideration
always repays the effort.
The standard car dished wheel centre will only easily accommodate a single disc, but two callipers can be fitted, but rarely worth the effort unless the braking system has the hydraulic fluid capacity (such as using car master cyclinder componets).
Shy clear of a lightweight motorcycle floating bike disc except
for show use. Road trikes need all the help they can for front
end braking, so get strong tyres, a good footprint and strong
brakes.
With a very strong solo disc such as used for a car, it is
possible to use dual callipers, usually spaced 180 degrees apart
on the disc, to double the stopping power. The tyre will often
handle this, although severe braking on cheaper tyres may lead
to more regular disc and tyre replacements for purposes of
safety.
Don't go stupid, so never put more braking than the tyre can
handle. If desperate, consider using rim bolts as used on
motocrossers and trials bikes which can prevent the tyre from
slipping on the rim, but these are only available for bike rim
profiles.
Car disc and pads are very cheap, even the ventilated types,
costing less than a set of bike brake pads and they last much
longer.
The only limits to building a decent front end are the strength of the hub, brake components, a decent tyre and a strong fork design.
For wheels which look more like bike wheels, it is easy to
demount the steel car rim by grinding away the inner spider.
Drill or grind out the six or more heavy spot welds keeping the
rim on the spider.
If you don't want to remove the centre, a lighter, 'motorcycle
style' inner design can then be built up by carving the original
centre to maintain some motorcycle styling. Alternatively, use
tubing to build three or five spokes or whatever wheel design is
appropriate. Most custom catalogues offer some ideas on the wide
variety possible.
I regularly rebuild car rims to make narrower or wider rims on standard spiders for rear wheels, or my own specialist centres for front wheels for my hub centre steering designs.
When suitably strong, the shape of wheel spokes can then be
built up with filler or fibreglass to match the style of the
rear wheels. Sometimes it is possible to wax the rear wheel and
take a cosmetic moulding using cloth and plaster, then apply
this to the front wheel and lay up the identical shape for
cosmetic reasons.
If required, a car rim can be drilled and recessed for heavy
wire spokes, but must be mounted on a strong hub. Always spend
plenty of time getting the spokes accurately positioned. Indent
the nipple recesses using a simple jig and nipple profile socket
BEFORE drilling the holes at the correct angles. Some earlier
sports cars had spoked wheels - seek and enjoy.
Alloy car wheel rims can be deconstructed and rebuilt onto motorcycle alloy wheels. Both will need careful machining and welding. If using alloy sheet, the new wheel may also need heat treatment prior to final machining. for strength and safety reasons, it may be preferable to use a rear motorcycle alloy wheel at the front if needing a wider rim and tyre profile. Many car tyres will fit bike rims and vice versa. Check S.A.E. rim specifications.
Building stronger front ends does not mean that style flies out
the window, even though many trike alternative front ends leave
much to be desired. Most front wheels for car tyres can be built
up from a wide variety of parts.
When forks are not acceptable, especially where the engine is
large and intended for serious thrashing, then strength and
suspension control are major design concerns.
For alloy wheels, choose the tyre first, then find a suitable
wheel, probably styled to match the rear wheels. Many custom
wheels can be matched in a variety of rim sizes.
If you are awash with cash, then buying two wide versions of an
alloy wheel and one skinny version may cause the retailer to
give you a weird look, but you are the customer, so get what you
want. If they get worried, say the small wheel is for an
emergency backup wheel to fit in a small boot (trunk) storage
space.
Some top of the range car alloy wheels are built from split
rims, where the rim is in two or even three parts. If lucky, the
manufacturer may be able to mix these parts to give wide rims at
the rear and a narrow version for the front wheel.
Where designer alloy wheels are used at the rear, possibly low
profile racing tyres, then the front should consider machining
back a similar wheel rim area and adding an alloy rim machined
from a much narrower, larger diameter car rim. This rim can be
machined to a narrower version by careful deconstruction
followed by welding. Cross breeding the two will maintain
compatible styling. This is often the case where an excellent
rear tyre is not available in a suitable front rim size.
For those on a realistic budget or who prefer to try this themselves, then off to the scrap yard and buy a set of four wheels. Two for the rear, one to deconstruct for the front wheel centre and one for a rear spare. Then either cut the sides to fit a narrower tyre or cut to fit a different alloy rim.
Alloy can be machined comparatively easily. Mount the wheel with
the new front rim in the trike and run the engine. With a
differential, it is necessary to lock or brake the other wheel,
which puts a strain on the diff, so do not go stupid. A high
tick over is usually sufficient. Using a VERY strongly mounted
lathe tool, carefully trim back the inner part(s) of the alloy
spokes until the rim is left with a sensible amount of metal so
it can be welded the reprofiled inner rim.
If brave or stupid, you may be able to get away with a coarse
hacksaw or old woodsaw mounted incredibly strongly to a broom
handle to slowly cut away the wheel rim as the wheel turns.
Always wear strong gloves, jacket and goggles and be ready to
jump out of harms way.
You must ensure the rim sides of the wide car wheel can be
remounted to the new, narrower inner section, therefore make the
cut 'stepped' to allow easy alignment for welding.
Once the side of the rim is off, leaving a bare wheel centre,
then a chamfer cut, so it parts off cleanly. Do likewise to
machine back the inner wheel section of the wheel with the worst
rim, so it matches the chamfer of the new outer rim for perfect
alignment. As the new front wheel is often of a larger diameter,
just the sides of the rim may need to be removed. If there
remains a gap between the rim and the wheel, then a spacer strip
of alloy can be shaped to fit the gap.
A slight interference fit keeps it all together prior to
welding.
Do not use magnesium alloy wheels.
Always take great care when using power tools and similar
set-ups. If a cutting tool is not available, it is possible to
use an angle grinder with the wheel spinning to ensure
concentricity of the cutting process.
Take the wheel and rim to a professional welder for alloy
welding and heat treating to prevent distortion.
The wheel must then be tested. If possible, use as much water in
the tyre insead of air when pressure testing, as this reduces
the explosive effect should it fail. Place the wheel and tyre on
the trike, then load it fully and then a bit more, to about 30
percent more than normal load, to simulate heavy braking forces.
With the tyre pressure gauge at the top to prevent water
damaging the pressure gauge, check the tyre pressure as the
reference. Then remove the wheel and pressure test fully. Always
pump up the tyre behind a brick wall, so nothing flies your way.
An alternative is to have a tyre pump with a pressure gauge,
with the connecting pipe running under the garage door to the
test tyre on the ether side for enclosed safety.
The tyre is then pumped up to 25 percent more than the maximum
trike load pressure and left for at least an hour. If all is
well, the water can be drained out and the wheel inspected.
If a wanting a different rim, perhaps from a motorcycle to fit a
car centre, then trim the inner item to fit the new rim and
always get it welded by an expert. For best results, leave a
full circle of the original rim area around the outside of the
machined down centre section, so the rim can be welded fully
around the rim.
If the two parts are machined such that they are a concentric,
firm press fit, then this is ideal for checking and adjusting
the centre line alignment to the rest of the trike prior to
welding. Alternatively a corresponding alignment ridge, step or
flange could be accurately measured and machined on each item to
ensure perfect alignment prior to welding. Three self tapping
screws will prevent misalignment before welding, but always
remove them and fill their holes after. If thrashing, this is a
good time to get the rim welded on both sides with an inner
ridge, similar to a car rim, to reduce the chances of the bead
parting from the rim during side loads. The welds can then be
dressed to shape on the axle used as a lathe. If you take the
axle along, it can be mounted in a vice so the welder can more
easily make a truly concentric, neater internal bead lip.
Once the wheel and discs are mounted, it is possible to weld on brackets to fit better brake callipers to position them where they will not foul the steering. Clamp the callipers in position on the disc prior to welding by connecting the plumbing and pressurising the system, as normally used. With new brake pads and a clearance spacing strip of thick cardboard on the edge of the disc, adjust the callipers as required. Then the mounting brackets can be accurately made and welded onto the hub carrier, torque plate or other brake calliper mounting device.
The use of dual callipers may be considered for both front and
rear. Dual front for extra braking or linked or biased braking.
Dual rear for separate main braking, with the other calliper for
the parking brake. See also brakes.
When fitting dual callipers to a front car disc, the symmetrical
donor callipers will be handed pairs, so the bleed nipples of
both can be mounted to allow easy bleeding.
For rear custom steel wheels using donor components, the
standard axle mountings may not fit the larger wheels required,
either for gearing or style. Begin with larger wheels using the
same studs, or redrill the hub to take a new stud pattern or
have adapter plates made. Adapter plates are similar to wheel
spacers, but without excessive overhang which destroys the wheel
bearings.
If redrilling the flange, always make sure the central aligning
shoulder is accurately machined first, so the new wheel will
align concentrically. This can be done by simple welding of
three alignment lugs followed by machining in place, using the
engine to power the wheel flange. When concentric, the wheel is
then mounted accurately on the flange to align the new stud
holes. This must be done extremely accurately.
For greatest accuracy, drilling the stud holes is best done on
CNC or a milling machine with an indexing head. Alternatively
spin the hub in the axle and carefully cut a fine groove to the
'pitch circle diameter' of the new wheel studs. Then weld up
spot welds then spin the hub and dress the alignment welds to
accurately become a minimal mounting flange so the inner hole of
the new wheel will align. Then the four or more stud holes can
be positioned accurately around the PCD. Not all hub flanges
will be able to take slightly larger wheel stud patterns, but
some can. If the stud holes are close to the edge of the flange,
add a safety band and weld it fully.
Rear wheels can use similar techniques as for the front wheel.
There are many basic front and rear wheel hub to rim support
designs, including carved from a single sheet, modified or
re-engineered car parts and a set of new identical spokes built
onto a hub with central mounting flange.
The simplest is using a standard bike or car steel rim and
modifying a standard car centre. A car rim can be removed by
drilling out the large spot welds then cutting and reprofiling
the centre to run true to the new rim position. By slitting the
outer bell of the standard car centre, it can be opened up and
reprofiled to accept larger diameter rims for lighter use.
Alignment of rim to hub. If jigs are not available, the hub can
be built up and assembled in position. Jigs are second best to
building on the actual bearings and spindle which allows
absolutely perfect alignment and balance.
For first attempts, consider re engineering car or other steel
wheel centres, trimming them down to suit any lighter loads and
new profile.
Rear wheel and single sided front new wheels centres which bolt
onto the hub can be built from steel and fitted accurately to
the hub flange and studs. Fixing is usually via conical faced
nuts on studs. Always dish the areas where the nuts will fit
onto the new wheel centre. Then spin to mark in the various
alignment and other features, which can then be perfectly
concentric. Double check by repositioning on the other studs to
check concentricity. Then add the spokes and spin to run true,
spinning the wheel and gently grind down the rim mounting points
for a accurate fit to the rim.
If the studs do not allow perfect alignment on all holes, make a
detent and corresponding hole in the wheel, so only that
particular wheel can be used, and it can only be fitted the
correct way.
Push fit the rim firmly on the spokes until running true, then
tack weld and double check.
Spokes can be built up in many designs, from simple square bar mounted in a triangle pattern, to the many complex designs seen in catalogues. Heavy gauge sheet can be shaped and flanged for a variety of styles to make three or more identical spokes which should align perfectly. Round bar can be gently squashed to create basic aero style spokes.
When building spokes from new, balance is especially important.
Always mark out the degrees of equal spacing to ensure accurate
centre lines, to which a cardboard profile can be applied and
drawn around to ensure even weight and thus better balance.
Clamp the bare spokes together and trim them as a matched set
before fitting.
If the rim is slightly heavier on one side when the valve
fitted, then the rim should be rotated on the spokes until the
whole balances as well as possible. Then the spokes dressed to
balance perfectly.
If large alloy or steel spokes need some depth in cross section for more rigidity, such as for extreme offset for hubcentre steering, then they will need flanges. These can be made by panel beating grooves along the edges and centres of flat plate spokes. Use a leather covered sand bag, or profiles in the end grain of a wood block and use a ball pein hammer. Edges can also be flanged inwards to create ribs, similar to early Honda Comstar wheels. Cutting lightening holes in wide spokes will allow the edges of any holes to also be flanged for more rigidity. If making from separate sheets, usually as a set of spokes, always grind them to shape as a set, clamped together. On heavy machines, consider using a butted, stepped or overlapping design of spoke to improve both strength and alignment. Align the steps to improve braking load resolution and the central angles to assist accurate radial alignment.
It is possible to use a single sheet of metal for a one piece
inner wheel. Start with the mounting either a set of studs on
the hub flange or the hub itself. Then a series of concentric
lines marked into the sheet for alignment by spinning on the hub
and the spokes cut then bent to shape. Rest is as above.
If heating very thick aluminium to assist bending, a rough
temperature guide is to rub some soap on the surface and heat
the sheet until the soap turns brown, to give a safety margin.
Then use a modified pipe bender to give a series of gentle bends
so that all the forces are not directed at one place.
Do not plunge hot alloy into water to cool, as this makes it
softer. For wheels, always allow to air cool evenly. Then test
the design by subjecting the wheels to twice the maximum forces
expected under the worst circumstances. See also testing later.
If a hub centre design is employed, always build the hub unit and steering pivot first. This allows the steering axis to be used to align the rim perfectly onto the steering centreline. The swing arm and whole front assembly can then be aligned to the frame.
Unfortunately car exhausts are notorious for being rusty tubes.
Fortunately car engines are more tolerant of inexact exhaust
systems.
Try to get the airflow matched by cylinder capacity, a 500cc car
cylinder pumps almost as much as a 500cc motorcycle cylinder.
(The difference is the revs involved, numbers of valves and
inlet tract design and carb sizes.)
When making car exhausts, routing will be the biggest problem.
This splits into two main problem areas, the visible engine
mounting area, and the hidden exhaust routing.
A car engine vibrates and so must the exhaust.
The exhaust is therefore held in flexible mountings form the
original donor machine design, and will thus prevent the more
common fracture problems.
If securing the exhaust to the chassis, then a flexible section
will be needed. This can be a special flexible exhaust tubing,
or a spring loaded ball and socket join, made by panel beating
the exhaust pipe ends to a cup and socket which is retained as a
sealed flexible joint by strong springs.
Keep to standard donor car exhaust components at first, until the design has proven reliable, then consider any fancy exhausts at a later date, as exhausts are simple customising work.
If making the rear of the trike to look like a formula one car, please note that the vertical exhaust system may need to be a dummy in some countries or may need to be quiet. The public may never know that the 2005 style F1 exit of the exhaust has a pair of silencers, or even catalytic converters hidden just under the rear shell.
In lands of excessive bureaucracy, some specified exhaust markings may be needed, requiring specific aftermarket exhausts to be employed, so start here and work backwards from this soulless burEUocracy.
For trikes with open car engines, it is most unlikely that the
trike will look exciting with a cast iron exhaust header. If
possible, use the exhaust header but cut it down to give the
best exhaust mounting flange or brackets. This ensures the
standard gaskets can be used. Fit stub pipes into this header
flange and bell out the ends to a tight internal fit, weld them
to fit internally, then file flush to fit the gasket face.
Alternatively, spring mounted exhaust pipes can be used, similar
to racing exhausts. This is particularly useful for rubber
mounted engines which will need a degree of flexibility between
chassis, exhaust and engine.
Where a standard exhaust is used, study how the fixing between
engine and chassis is achieved, copying the original
manufacturers set-up to prevent fracturing of the exhaust. The
standard exhaust may be rigid on the engine but flexibly mounted
to the chassis along its whole length to prevent fracturing.
Always try to keep to the original exhaust rubber mountings as
they are designed to ensure minimal fracturing.
Anything up to twelve separate exhaust pipes may need to join
into a silencer. The easiest way is to make each pipe enter a
box separately, which can be easily welded from the inside for
greater neatness. This can then be joined more easily to an
approved aftermarket silencer.
Alternatively, separate exhausts for each cylinder can be
employed, using aftermarket, pattern VW Beetle exhaust flutes
inside the end pipes to keep the noise reasonable.
Unfortunately some rear exhaust systems may need to be bolted in place to route through some tight or awkward area. This may require a flexible joint. Flexible exhaust joints can be built from special flexible exhaust tubing, available from some retailers. Another method is use of spherically swaged ends to pipes with the other pipe 'belled' or rounded to fit, and the two parts held together with flanges and springs. There are many variations of this on cars, such as the font lower join on Ford Escorts Mk 5, which can be salvaged according to use and adapted to spring loaded use. Keep your eyes open - you don't have to reinvent the wheel.
Trying to make a heavily convoluted formula one exhaust requires
many skills and such exhausts may preferably be bought. For
those with real-world budgets, get as much new tightly bent
exhaust tubing as possible and prefer using oxyacetylene when
making tricky snake-nest exhausts. If keeping the trike, use
stainless steel and tack weld, then hand over to an expert. If
testing, use second hand pipe from scrapyards or exhaust
fitters, where a great deal of good piping is thrown away.
By law, exhausts should normally exit to the rear of the
vehicle, although some side exiting exhausts are possible. Local
regulations may even allow the incredible vertical exhausting
slashed systems as per formula one machines - no one need know
there is a bog-standard silencer just under the fibreglass
shell.
All exhausts get hot and must therefore have good airflow between themselves and other parts. On lumpy engines, heat shields are prone to rattling and falling off, so mount securely. Where exhausts are close to other components, use heat insulating sheets available from most car parts retailers or some caravan / camping shops.
NEVER allow any fuel related tap, pipe, connection or other fitting to be near or above an exhaust.
When mounting turbochargers always keep to the manufactured set-up and waste gate settings until the machine is sorted and fettled. Use standard chips in any engine management computer until fettled. Where the engine is open to public view, cover the turbo with a metal guard and always try to shape the guard to ensure good airflow around the turbo. Panel beating softened aluminium is excellent. Always use an oil cooler with turbo engines.
Catalytic converters are now often mandatory and should be hidden wherever possible. They work best when they get hot quickly, so keep them close to the engine and nice and cosy under their own little heat shield. Likewise any lambda sensors which check for unburnt oxygen.
A V8 or V12 exhaust should be a work of art, not only for looks,
but in the music available.
An American V8 throaty burble is never forgotten.
A V12 'on song' is a wondrous song.
Try not to stifle them too much.
Rotary Wankel engines should use the original exhaust, as they have many unusual needs. They get much hotter than others and may have unusual over-run requirements. Done properly, they should howl nicely.
I hate catalogue 'customs'.
If building on a budget, the best engine modification for more
power is more cubes.
Fit the 1600cc car engine in place of the 1300cc. Fit the turbo
version instead of the 1600cc.
Simple, reliable, effective.
If building on a reasonable budget, consider buying a complete, running old Porsche 5litre V8 for a grand or so (2002 prices). It instantly makes engine customising a total waste of time and money - in one simple stroke. It ensures real reliability when thrashed and imbues an instant and serious street presence that few other trikes could ever hope to achieve, but check the insurance first.
If using low, expensive engines such as the Porsche, always consider a sump guard. A steel cage under the engine will take the force without deforming enough to damage the engine. For very low engines, where room is at a premium, this is usually a thick sheet of aluminium restrained firmly at the front, to resolve any drag, and loosely held at the rear, to allow for deformation. There should be a stout piece of rubber between the sump guard and sump.
Do not change too much until primary testing has proven the trike handles and brakes to a high standard. When the design is deemed acceptable, only then may a programme of engine and chassis refinement take place over the lifetime of the machine.
Clean engines.
When a front engined trike is designed, a lot of junk can be
removed from the engine to clean up its looks.
When removing the front radiator for styling purposes, the
plumbing and some fan pulleys can be removed or dressed down.
Some engines also use the front pulley as a vibration damper, so
check first and if so, always leave it in place.
Only the alternator drive may not be negotiable, but if it is a V6, 8 or 12, the alternator can nestle between the rocker banks, out of sight under the steering head gussets. If a belt adjusting bracket is difficult, a spring loaded jockey pulley may suffice to keep tension on the V belt on its slack side. V belts come in many sizes and can turn various corners if needed, as found in some VW's and porshes. Always make sure the drive to the water pump is correct.
A mechanical fuel pump sticking out the side of an engine may look awful, so blank off the hole with a plate and use an electric fuel pump. Alternatively for show use, the hole may be opened up and windowed with polycarbonate, using an internal light to show up the polished crank and con rods for petrolheads. The starter motor must be left on the engine, but it can be colour co-ordinated, plated, covered or disguised with a beer label, such as Old Speckled Hen.
An alloy engine crankcase may often be first target for polishing. The mounting points for alternator, air-conditioning and power steering may look ideal subjects for grinding down for better looks. Do not succumb unless the trike has been fully tested, or if spare crankcases are easy to find. It is better to keep any mountings, simply making them look like they should be there - by employing them as brackets for holding any coolant pipes, cable brackets and such like. Where unused, simply fit short dummy bolts in any threaded holes or use flush fitting plugs or button head Allen screws or an enamelled engine badge.
If the engine is long, such as a straight six, the standard head steady may want to fit part-way along the top frame rail. This may not be good practice, as it may cause fracturing of any long unsupported top frame tubes. Therefore consider the use of two lighter head steadies, one at each end of the engine. Use softer rubbers to allow the engine to move as intended. If two head steadies are not desired, then use the standard head steady, but repositioned closer to a strong frame point where it will mount with less flexing of the frame and spread the load into both top frame tubes with a secondary cross brace. A wide Y-shaped head steady may suffice. Then check by blipping the engine, to see if it twists too far out of line, then tune or adjust the bushes as required.
Battery box out of the way of rain and dirt, fuses where they
can be reached easily. Likewise the air filter, fuel pump, hi-fi
amp, beer cooler etc. Easy access for all maintenance work is a
must. A tool box with wheel wrench, jack and foot pump should be
carried. If the front wheel is a car wheel, carry a spare front
wheel if it will also fit the rear axle in emergency (if you did
your homework).
If a bike front tyre is used, then carry a spare rear wheel and
a spare front inner tube and levers.
If the trike is poorly balanced, then the battery is positioned
after the fuel tanks, then the axles checked on scales and the
battery positioned to even up the axle loads. If you have a VW
engine, then the battery is probably best positioned near or
under the steering head or any frontal small or dummy fuel tank,
to reduce the tendency to lift the front end.
Tool kit.
Always carry a tool kit when testing. Carrying it on the person
is dangerous. Always carry the tool kit in a secure container on
the frame. During testing, the tool kit is always larger than
for normal use, so make container accordingly, or use an extra
strap on tool bag. Always include a first aid kit and carry a
cellphone when testing.
If the donor vehicle is a common machine and spares are cheap, and you intend to tour many countries, then consider adding a backup fuel pump, electronic ignition unit, coil and other parts. They could be mounted beside the original and protected in sealed plastic bags ready for use, ISDE style. Likewise cables.
The first and best check is to check it all works properly before the donor machine is stripped. Removal of the loom from the car can be difficult, so be very careful. An extra half an hour teasing a loom out of a car is still faster in the long run than having to fault-find, then repair or rebuild a damaged wiring loom.
As mentioned earlier, the modern car alternator is a self contained item, supplying perfect 13.8 volts and even a warning light connection. It can be positioned almost anywhere a V belt will fit. Make sure it rotates the same way as originally fitted, remount, or use a different alternator. Alternators are very easy to mount and adjust for V belt tensioning.
To get started, simply use the standard wiring loom and carefully blank off what is not needed. If preferred, lay the donor wiring loom in position, then connect up all relevant parts, even if they are not in the right places. Then cut away the loom binding and rearrange. Do not remove, but tidy up any redundant wiring, as it may be needed later. Connect the battery and check all works as intended. Only later should you modify as required.
Main beam, indicators and horn switches can be made to fit by reading the manual or opening up the car stalks, then deciding which wires are which, then paring them back to connect to bike switches. It is preferable not to use car switches, which are only designed for a dry environment. They can be waterproofed, but rarely integrate with trike styles.
When assembeld loosrly on the trike, check that the battery charges at about 13.8 volts with the engine running and all works well. Then make a special loom later if needed, or simply, but carefully reduce unwanted wiring from the original car loom.
The way the loom is routed on the trike will depend upon the
complexity of the design.
If a fuel injected design, then the electrics will often
encourage the units to be fitted in just one place, which may
require a special housing. If making a front engined trike for
show, then consider making a modified custom copy of the wiring
loom to position all components out of sight. This includes the
loom itself, which can often be well hidden.
As trikes are wide, 5 Watt side lights will be needed which must
show a white light to the front and a red light to the rear. As
most trikes use dual car rear light units, the rearward pointing
red side lights are often unnecessary. Often, just the front
side white 5W lights are needed on the front of the rear
mudguards, often made from customised torches or such like.
Side repeater orange indicators are also recommended, especially
on very long trikes.
If a fuel pump is used, it should be wired in the ignition
circuit, preferably with a separate fuse - and if a big engine,
then with a relay. See fuel system above. As the fuel pump is
important during testing, make sure you are able to wire it
directly in an emergency to get home. Also include an emergency
direct connection to the ignition coil for the same reason.
Where complex electronics such as computers and engine
management systems are used, keep them on their own cosseted
little circuit, well protected with the correct fuse rating and
bagged in foam. If they are finned or may get warm, then always
allow cool air to circulate.
As many custom builders have a reputation for poor design and manufacture of wiring looms, consider self resetting thermal fuses, which will reduce the number of blown fuses from poor wiring until the fault is found. On a good day, they may even allow you to travel ten miles before the fault re-occurs.
If in doubt, get wiring done by an expert, or keep it very simple and use separate ignition circuits for sparks and for the fuel pump.
Also consider a separate circuit for lights, with a separate
circuit for the rest such as horn, brake lights etc. Protect
each circuit with its own fuse.
Always put the fuel injection and such like on a separate
circuit.
A basic wiring guide.
The output from the alternator goes to the battery, then to the
main fuse.
The main fuse then supplies the ignition switch and relays for
any pumps and fans.
The ignition switch will also supply power to three other fuses.
These three fuses normally supply 12 (13.8V) volts to:
1. The ignition circuit / electronic ignition.
2. The head and tail lights circuit.
3.The auxiliary circuit which contains the indicators, horn and
brake lights.
Three or more separate, fused circuits from the ignition switch output are easier to design, build and repair than one big circuit.
On sophisticated (expensive) engines, the ignition (sparks)
circuit should also split into fused circuits for any fuel
injection and the fuel pump. Each should be protected by its own
fuse. When you switch off the ignition or kill switch, all must
switch off.
See also fuel injection.
If required, such as for large custom show machines, separate switches can be used to supply power from the main ignition switch (or independently) to each circuit, aircraft style. E.g. sparks on/off, fuel injection on/off, fuel pump on/off. (Mainly for show use or if building with aircraft engines.)
For styling purposes, starter switches can also use an identical
looking switch but with a momentary action.
A small light above each switch can be used to check if its on
line, or to tell if the fuse has blown and the circuit is out.
Safety flip covers or preferably protection bars between each
switch are also useful. Do not put a safety flip cover on the
spark / ignition switch if there is no dedicated kill switch or
if the ignition key is hard to reach. Preferably have a safety
cover over the starter button unless an electrical lock-out
circuit is employed.
If using this style, always have the switches in a sequenced
row, so you can easily switch each in turn, - fuel pump first,
to build up pressure, then fuel injection computer to begin
reading the temp sensors etc and settle down, then the sparks
(ignition circuit) and finally the starter button. - Flick,
flick, flick, press.
Give passengers decent foot rails to take the braking forces.
Mounting the passengers in a luxurious reclining manner will
also help during cornering and especially braking, with a rise
to the front of the seat, as shown opposite.
Side loads when cornering will have passengers complaining after
fifty miles of country roads, so consider seats with side
padding or armrests as shown opposite.
The picture shows my friends beautifully handling sofa which is very comfortable at 100+ mph. This trike can take five at a push, and three in complete comfort.
If not offering any form of security for the passengers, at
least include hand rails or strong straps to hang on to.
Position the standard car seat belts with consideration for left
and right. This way, the passengers get maximum safety and will
not slide out from under a right handed seat belt when a left
handed belt would save them getting squashed under a bus.
Even if not making an art form, preferably get an expert to make
the seats in water resistant leather or vinyl. Also consider a
cloth based waterproof lining between seat foam and covering.
Fit closed cell foam on most components, but open cell foam or
similar between seat base and backrest, so that rain will not
accumulate in the seat, but wallets will not dissapear.
Where required, there is no excuse for not having a trunk (boot) on a machine. My friends first trike shown opposite has a boot (trunk), is incredibly comfortable and can take four people. It also has a low centre of gravity and handles extremely well.
Good details need not be sophisticated. A flush fitting cover in
a fibreglass shell, carefully cut from the moulding can be
cleanly secured with internal bungees and opened with a simple
finger recess. Hinges may also help. The luggage compartment can
be built onto the frame to take the loads without actually
touching the shell or boot lid.
See shells later.
The bare rolling chassis can now be built up to become a fully
functioning trike.
If in doubt about handling, then a simple lash up can be made
before fitting the seats and controls in a finalised form, as
mentioned earlier.
If the testing shows the trike is reasonable, then start with
the riders seat. This should be positioned to optimise front
axle loading.
If a lightweight front end or a VW, then weight the trike, then
place the bathroom scales under the font wheel and sit well
forward without upsetting the styling and ergonomics.
If the engine is mounted forward and heavy, then sit to the rear
as much as possible to ameliorate the poor effects of a heavily
loaded front end.
The passengers can also be positioned to maximise the best
handling. Passenger side seat supports are always recommended on
trikes.
The fuel tanks should ideally be positioned close to the centre
of gravity, so that changes in mass do not upset the overall
balance, but in reality, the fuel tanks are mounted low and in a
suitably convenient place. See fuel tanks, above.
The car battery can now be positioned to help refine the balance.
Once the heavy parts are positioned, the superstructure can be made to support them. This should be such that the riders and passengers are kept low, where the gearchange and suspension permitting.
Most superstructure can be built from three-quarter or inch
section square tubing for ease of manufacture and lightness.
Where the engine needs to be replaced often, then the
superstructure can be pivoted or lifted off, with a few bolts to
hold it in position. Always use nylon locking nuts or other
safety retainment to prevent serious failure.
Where a boot (trunk) or rear engine cover is used, then make a
suitable superstructure to support the hinges, and support the
lower load carrying floor, either from steel or heat resistant
or coated plywood on a steel frame.
If using countach style radiators, then make up suitably shaped
superstructure to support the radiators in rubber supports and
without airflow obstructions.
When supporting exhaust systems, the superstructure tubing should have strongly supported exhaust brackets which can take the rubber or flexible mounting lugs.
Onto the superstructure may be mounted any electric fuel pump, electronics, fuse box, etc. It is often preferable not to mount too much directly onto the chassis, as there is often a major rebuild just a few months or a year away. This ensures the main chassis is kept clean for inspection for faults and reduces the need to respray the trike, other than to build an new, or rebuild the old superstructure. I prefer to mount ancillaries to the superstructure, as this is often changed within a year as the seating and styling are changed, without upsetting or damaging the main chassis components. Unfortunately, the radiators) and exhausts often need secure chassis mounting points so some additional modifications to the chassis may be necessary.
The battery is ideally kept low in the frame unless you
encounter a lot of river crossings.
Seats with folding bases make excellent access points for the
battery / fuse box and for small luggage areas. Keeping the
access areas secure should be done well, with standard locks as
used for motorcycle top boxes, or using hidden, spring loaded
cable pulls, often hidden under the seat, engine or mudguard
area, where only the builder knows how to easily reach the
toggles or opening levers.
If very heavy loads are to be carried, consider pulling a
trailer.
Trailers are straight forward attachment and often considered
boring. But for trikes. . . .
If a four wheel drive engine is used, then a powered trailer is
possible. Army Land Rovers do it, then so can trikes. A classic
example is the Subaru engined trike, using the excellent flat
four engine with four wheel drive.
Build a trailer using the standard Subaru rear axle. The trailer
prop shaft should be able to slide onto the spline drive on the
rear of the engine and be restrained by the standard towing ball
joint or a more sophisticated pivot.
Make sure the ball is just above or below the universal coupling
on the prop shaft, as this greatly reduces wear and reduces
handling problems. For this reason, the ball joint may be
recessed under the back of the trike to get it all properly
aligned. Using such a set up makes a good starting point for the
ultimate field churner when exiting muddy fields in winter or to
roost gravel.
It may be better to be able to disconnect the drive for general
purpose use, or even have a differential lock on each axle for
happy triking in swamps.
See also the German Kettenrad, 'half track trike' - thing.
The rear end of the last trike I worked on was often mistaken
for a Lotus or 'something Italian'.
This should be a basic goal.
Lamborghini Countachs and Diablos look nice too, as do many
other vehicles.
For those who want to try, a few words of advice: Take your time
and use sketches. 3D computing will greatly help, as will a
simple lump of modelling clay or plaster.
If the donor vehicle is a Porsche, an XJS or something of note
with a well recognised rear end, and the tail lights are
available, then consider making a mould of the original.
Trying for a Ferrari or Lamborginini style is always worth the
effort, but the downfall will often be in the details. See
later.
Always invite others to offer advice, as the designers ideas are not always what the rest of the world will see.
But despite all best intentions from others to the contrary, always follow your dream.
Secondary testing has been mentioned above, where it is important to test the flexing of the frame with tack welds, allowing modifications to resolve any deformation and fundamental structural problems at an early stage. Then tests after fully welded and the basic rolling chassis loaded with a few friends aggressively testing the structure, plus any front end distortion to be sorted prior to steering head side plates.
The next stage is to get the whole machine ready for basic road
use.
This may be riding to the testing station to become legal, or
preferably on a trailer to a local disused airfield or other
site for gradually increased thrashing and fettling. Fitting the
trike front wheel to a car's towing hitch can make it a trailer.
If so, use the appropriate number or licence plate. Will need a
special bracket to clamp the front assembly.
At this stage the machine will need fettling.
The first few hours of running will be in the garage to adjust
the carburetion, wiring, fuel gauge settings, radiator cooling
assessment in still air and to get the gearchange and brakes
working reasonably well.
Testing is done with the following problems in mind.
If the engine has lain idle for a year or more, test the clutch
carefully. The front end may jump up if the clutch is fierce, so
use second gear when testing for the first time. - Choose the
wall you want to crash into. Use second gear with the front
wheel of the trike against a wall and a brave friend standing on
the front wheel. Second gear is more likely to stall the engine
rather than lift the front end too far. Be ready to jump off if
the clutch is too fierce or stuck, causing the front end to lift
or plummet you down the road. An anti-wheelie block jammed under
the rear of the frame is a must, so place blocks tight under the
rear to lift the wheels off the ground if a wheelie should
happen. Do not rev the engine as the gear is engaged, but allow
the engine to stall, as this may be enough to release the clutch
after a few attempts.
In some cases, (often very brave or stupid) it may be possible
to start the engine and pull away in first gear along the road,
frantically working the clutch while pumping the brakes and
blipping the engine until the clutch releases.
In suspect cases, it is highly preferable to strip the clutch if
in doubt, if only to save blood or embarrassment.
The engine will need anything from a tune up to a total rebuild.
Leave full rebuilds for later. Just get the engine reasonably
reliable.
New steering head bearings are probably needed if they were
welded with them in place, but old ones can be used for initial
testing and if you suspect you may want to rearrange the rake
angle.
The radiators may not get enough air at low speeds, so make sure
the thermostat, cooling fans and temperature gauge work
properly.
The carburetion and exhaust may need fettling.
If a fuel gauge is not fitted, carry a spare can of fuel until
the range of the fuel tank is known.
The gearchange may take some getting used to and adjusted until
it becomes a slick piece of engineering.
The brakes will probably be exciting too, so make sure there is
some adjustment.
Ensure the brakes are bled properly and all brake items are in
good condition and not binding. No serious rust on the drums or
discs, with drum brakes on the correct sides and no squeals or
rattles. If necessary, lift one wheel at a time in the garage
and run the engine gently, to check each brake works as intended
and to bed in the pads or shoes.
To check REAR brake balance, allow the FRONT wheel to roll
sideways on a plank on dowels, then very lightly apply the rear
brakes and ease out the clutch a tad, to see if the rear brakes
are balanced, or if the front of the trike tends to swerve
sideways while stationary.
Be prepared to find that the rear brakes may be too severe or
too weak.
During the first few hours of use, the rear wheel alignment and the tyre pressures may affect the way it handles. Be prepared to experiment with both. Signs include poor wear of the tyres, such as scuffing or uneven wear patterns. Carry tools to adjust the toe in or toe out as they are compared and refined over a good test road.
Stamp your own frame number or that of the donor vehicle on the
steering head or as required by local laws. Use proper stamps
and take your time to get it tidy. Your own frame number could
be your initials, date of birth and other numbers to show its
your fifth frame, or whatever. This will allow it to be traced
to whoever made it and which model or item it is.
When stamping, temporarily stick a straight cardboard guide
plate to help make a neat line as the frame number is stamped.
The SAE, (Society of Automotive Engineers) have a special frame
number coding, showing the country of origin, manufacturer etc.
If it is necessary to have the new machine tested by the
authorities, they may ask you to stamp a specific frame number
on it too, according to SAE rules, but with the manufacturers
part of the code changed to 'unspecified manufacturer'.
There is nothing to say it cannot have your own frame number
too, but just one frame number makes for an easier life.
Always keep the receipts for the parts and try to get any
documentation such as log book etc.
It may even have a 'valid' MOT or tax disc. The ministry will
often demand proof of ownership of each and every important part
such as engine, frame, differential, etc.
In the UK, it may well need to be put through the SVA 'single
vehicle approval' for one off designs. This is less than 200
pounds and checks it complies with legal requirements such as
mirrors, assembly standards etc. A Retake is twenty pounds. The
SVA manual /guide is about twenty five pounds, or like me, visit
your library. 1998 prices.
Spare a thought for the official tester, who may have to test
three cars, a campervan, a restored 1920 tractor - and your
machine. This poor soul does not always like to have to test a
machine which is so far out from the norm that he has to
frighten himself before deciding if it's safe or not. At
least attach a note as to where the gears are, plus any
'interesting' points of note, definitely including the kill
switch. Tape this information where it can be seen.
The tester has probably seen it all, so use his knowledge
to make a truly better trike.
Never assume that because you can ride it, that it is safe.
Other trikers may test your machine and offer an endless list of
improvements. Listen and learn. Take notes.
Therefore it is always advisable get many second opinions before
finally deciding the final settings for brakes, handling and a
host of other variables.
Destructive testing should not be necessary if a sensible and
cautious approach is taken.
If the very harsh early attempts to trash the basic frame were
unsuccessful then the reader should be feeling cautiously
optimistic.
If a cautious approach is not taken, the test rider may
unwittingly be undergoing a destructive test regime, with one of
two possible outcomes. - One involves a long wooden box.
If deciding to test on the road, always wear protective clothing until confident. Always test first on quiet roads until confident and the machine is fettled as much as possible. Suspect all possible frame, steering, suspension and brake problems until confident. Never be too confident.
There are two main types of testing. Basic testing using the
whole machine.
The second form is a more involved structural tests using just
the bare chassis so that its flexing can be measured and
predicted on a graph. The latter is for techno heads who wish to
develop ultra light weight chassis, or simply to understand the
structure more fully.
The usual method is to load and test the while machine to about
twice what the worst case is likely to be. As leaping off a hump
back bridge at seventy miles an hour is difficult to replicate
in the workshop, some assumptions must be made. Most other tests
are a little easier to do. A variety of tests are mentioned so
the reader can get a reasonable feel for the limits of the
chassis.
Use easily cracked lacquer over any suspect welds or tubes etc.
This will help highlight any problems before they get too
serious. Thin, white hard varnish is useful to highlight cracks,
or use clear varnish and good eyes.
In some cases, cover large areas which my distort with lightly
lacquered fine tissue stretched over suspect areas. This will
highlight potential fracture areas and general distortion on
long term tests and also during static tests.
If in a country where corrosion is a problem, use a light
coating of clear lacquer to stop the frame from rusting for the
first few months, allowing regular checks for problems such as
fractures.
Plastic coating the frame from the outset is never recommended
for obvious reasons.
Before applying the finishing touches of paint and trim, grab a few friends, take the machine somewhere quiet and literally thrash the nuts off it. Jump over ramps, slide into walls, and generally commit positive vandalism. You know it makes sense. You will find problems much earlier and will also get to understand the handling much more intimately.
If you have fuel or oil in the frame, pressurise it for a couple of hours after testing. Use the valve of an old inner tube clamped or tied over the filler hole and a cycle pump to pressurise. If any leaks, lightly grind back and reweld. Preferably do not to fill with fuel or oil prior to initial pressure testing, as further welding can cause explosions. Initially pressurise with air and then 'paint' the empty frame with soapy water to check for leaks.
Once the machine is deemed physically safe and seems to work well, then full testing can begin.
The first test ride must concern safety; mainly structural
strength and brakes. All cables, bearings and brakes settle
during extended testing and will require adjustment.
ALWAYS try pulling away up a steep hill, a short bank, or wheel
ramps in a garage to balance the clutch and brakes.
There is nothing more annoying than taking a machine out to
test, only to find some simple, annoying problem has halted the
test.
Once the machine holds together and the brakes work, the
handling can be studied.
If using differing or unusual tyre dimensions and profiles,
pressures may be even more important. This can only be fully
assessed by riding, but start by noticing tyre deformation on
standard load. Then experiment with pressures to get suitable
deformation patterns. Try to steer clear of maximum rated tyre
pressures and be prepared to aim for a sensible and balanced set
of pressures. Larger rear tyres may need less pressure for a
sensible footprint. The ideal method is oil on glass, then
looking from below, but this is usually too awkward to do.
Load the trike to normal conditions. Then roll the tyre over a
flat piece of road or a wood sheet. While carefully noticing the
contact patch, lower the tyre pressures until the tyre contact
profile begins to sag. Note the pressure. Now pump up the tyre
until it starts to get too rounded. Note the pressure. Now set
your starting test pressure midway between the two.
If you can do this on a wet sheet of glass, then you can easily
see the actual contact patch as seen from below. If you have a
similar tyre, perhaps on a well set-up Porsche or Jag, then use
this too, to check the contact patch as a reference. If no glass
floor, then jack up the wheel, rub on a little dark grease, then
lower carefully onto a sheet of paper. Then carefully jack up to
remove, without rotating the wheel. Use this as a
standard starting reference profile for the tyre in question.
The tyre pressure will probably change after various testing
sessions, but gives a good starting point which should be in the
'ball park'.
Basic tests includes riding in a straight line, applying the
rear brake and checking for veering to one side while very
lightly holding the handlebars.
Test the fastest constant speed into a sharp turn such as a
right angle street junction. The use of real or imaginary road
cones, and chalk to mark the ground, and a big, quiet car park
is ideal. Many large car parks have quiet times, so keep an eye
on them so you can choose your timing and test without hassle.
Comparisons. Although this should have been done a long time ago, when setting up the suspension on the bare frame, once again push the wing of a car down, to see how the shocks behave, then do the same on the trike to see if it is in the same ball park.
Important tests include the minimum turning circle, both slow
and under power. Both in first and second gear, plus reverse.
Check the steering does not want to dive under on full lock.
With smaller front wheels with light loads, the limits of the
front wheel may need to be pushed, especially if worried about
safety, such as sudden breaking away without notice.
In a safe area, try to get the front end to break free in faster
tight corners, with and without braking. Find out how the front
or rear breaks away first and under what conditions. This puts a
reasonable load on the suspension and helps show up problems
such as sloppiness as the suspension and other components bed
down. A little tightening of parts between tests goes a long
way. You will also build up your reactions for the day when a
fool swerves in front and you slide off the road.
Always aim to refine the overall handling from the outset, which is always more important than finding the top speed.
Don't loose vital information: The first test gives you a major
opportunity which will soon disappear. The first ride will have
no reference points and you will be assessing the way the trike
behaves in a raw, untainted manner.
As more tests are done, you will naturally adapt to the trikes
peculiarities and thus loose totally subjective assessment.
You will get used to the machine and its foibles, so from the
very outset, set high standards and always be critical, so that
your assessment does not become devalued with familiarity.
A minimum cornering radius at a natural speed will soon be found
and could be recorded for comparison with other rakes and
trails.
As the subtleties of handling are gradually refined, there may
often be a trade off between tighter cornering vs straight line
stability. The final decision will depend upon use. A
comfortable touring machine often turns less well, but with
better stability, whereas an animal machine will usually be set
up for urban motocross. A comparison is where transport planes
are usually stable, whereas modern fighter aircraft are
intentionally designed to be partially unstable.
If the machine wants to pull to one side when trying to brake or when driving hands-off in a straight line, then the brake imbalance, steering, frame or rear wheel mis-alignment may be the cause of problems. All machines must brake in a straight line with hands off. Start by checking chassis and wheel alignment, tyre pressures and then the brake components, ensuring they are properly bedded in. If you have not set up the brakes in earlier tests, then rear brake imbalance tests should be done near the end of the riding tests, when the brakes are probably better bedded in.
The front and rear suspension may need to be stiffened or
softened. The normal amount of adjustment on standard shocks may
suffice, but ideal positioning may need a little refinement.
If antidive is integrated into the forks, test to see how well
it performs. Tony Foales excellent website contains all the
theory.
A section for trikes can be added here if requested.
Learning the handling and braking characteristics in a quiet area will be advantageous for knowing the limits. This will help the adjustment of the braking system by modifying and refining brake lever ratios and pressures for best use. It is very easy to build a machine with misbalanced front and rear brakes, yet fairly easy to cure. Choice of pads, reduction of braking material, lever ratios and many other methods can lead to matched brakes which can be a pleasure to use and brakes save lives.
Play around with the toe in to see how this changes the
handling, straight ahead and especially in the bends. Adjust the
camber and toe in, just to see what happens, If it gets worse,
then try adjusting the other way to see what happens.
It all helps to bring the overall package closer to the best
possible.
Unfortunately, adjusting for tight turns in urban terrain may make the machine handle worse at high speeds. Always make sure the machine handles best at high speeds, then adjust to get the reasonable handling at low speeds too, if possible. While riding in normal use, you may be able to correct an unexpected handling problem at 20 mph, but not at 100 mph.
When the initial handling is as good as possible, measure everything, shock settings, tyre pressures, toe in, camber, (rake and trail, if adjustable,) and anything else you have changed.
Mark it all down on paper for the first minor rebuild.
There is no excuse for inadequate or poor braking.
With reasonable brakes, the handling envelope can now be pushed.
(First practice riding close to walls on each side of the
machine, so you learn that bikes are narrow and trikes are not.)
Pushing the limits:
Use of a water patch and a gravel patch will help understand the
machine, so carry some water for any depressions in the car
park, and a small bag of sand to make some impromptu testing
areas. An area of sand about four times as long as the trike is
excellent for getting a feel of the way the machine breaks away
in loose conditions. If it handles well, it may be preferable to
choose less efficient tyres if a little power drifting is
required.
If no kerbs, a rounded edged wooden strip or preferably an old
door, held to the ground with blue tack (after brushing clean)
will make adequate bump strip for straight and side angle kerb
testing. Kerb tests are not suitable for delicate wheels, unless
replacements are available for general road use. (The scrap
yards have plenty of cheap wheels.)
Kerbs will be an annoying part of learning to ride a trike,
especially when used to motorcycles. Be prepared to build up a
set of reactions for the times when judgements into corners are
not always so accurate as you may wish.
During testing, the more specialist suspensions with custom
suspension arms, shock units and front end must be carefully
assessed in accordance with what the designer and test rider
require. This may require gradually bringing the machine up to
roll or slide, and shall require a good, accurate speedo and
plenty of run off area.
Getting the turning circle tighter may require many hours
playing around with rake and trail, tyre pressures and profiles.
Do not be put off by science or expertise, as most moderately
well designed trikes will usually handle quite well first time
out.
If it handles quite well from the outset, just think how good it
can be with a little tweaking and fettling !
Testing must be built up to put a reasonable load on the
suspension and help show up problems such as sloppiness as the
suspension and other components as they inevitably bed down.
A little tightening of parts between tests goes a long way.
Always remember what gets loose, so that simple tightening can
be done, while also looking for problems such as fracturing,
misalignment and distortion.
There are many other tests, such as engine reliability, cooling airflow, comfort, but these are comparatively all fairly straight forward.
After as many problems as can be found are written up, and the
builder has decided whether the machine handles poorly and is
unacceptable, then it may be preferred to modify or even to
rebuild the frame until it handles well, from which a final
design can be created.
In less extreme cases where just the steering is not ideal, the
builder may wish to modify the front end trail or rake angle
until ideal. Do not assume the rake angle is the main culprit of
a poor handling machine, as a surprising amount of rakes can be
applied on otherwise similar handling machines.
Always try to test with other variables (where possible), such as adjusting the fork leg offset angle to adjust the trail, by variations on the upper fork yoke or front suspension pivots if using leading link forks.
Adjusting trail.
Lightweight bike forks: To increase or decrease trial then upper
central hole of the top yoke can be slotted for and aft , then
shims added to adjust the amount of trail.
Heavy duty leading link forks: If your machine is not as good as
you would like, then it is highly recommended to have extra
pivot points either side of any fork pivots, to allow back to
back testing of various amounts of trail.
Suspension settings will need careful assessment, especially the
front.
In easy cases, simply adding fork spring spacers and a little
heavier damping oil may suffice for standard bike forks.
On special front ends, the spring rates can be too soft or too
stiff, which can often be solved by repositioning the shocks
slightly.
Never test with a steering damper, as this merely hides bad
handling and you will never get a truly better machine. If you
must use a steering damper after final testing, then do so, but
it is hoped the machine should never need this level of
compromise.
Mark it all down on paper for the first minor rebuild.
Rear suspension should be fairly acceptable, possibly a little
soft for three up riding of a transverse rear engined design. If
too soft, simply use components from the sports version of the
donor machine or fit spring spacers to add a little extra spring
preload, or use slightly heavier shock oil for increased damping
firmness or add a second shock unit each side.
Although not officially a good idea, most of the cheaper
standard shocks can be drilled near the top of the body and the
fluid drained out. Beware of pressurised systems. Then a nut
soldered over the hole, ensuring the heat does not damage the
seals. Then new, heavier or lighter oil can be pumped in and the
shock compressed fully a few times to allow excess oil to drain
to prevent any hydraulic lock. Seal with a screw in the soldered
nut, preferably sealed with PTFE thread tape.
Mark it all down on paper for the first minor rebuild.
Once a good handling machine is achieved, very accurately
measure the rake, trail, toe in or out, axle offset and axle
loadings, rider position, steering ratios and whatever else can
be measured. Mark them permanently on the main drawing. This is
priceless information and will form the basis of the next
machine. During any refining process always measure and record
all other rakes and trails used for future reference, with
descriptions of the effects at slow, medium and high speeds.
Also mark this information permanently on the main drawing for
future reference.
Yes the next, even better trike may not be far away.
Grab your kids skateboard knee and elbow pads, thickest leather
jacket, a helmet, a friend with a cell phone and a first aid
kit.
Begin by riding over bumps, jumps and anything else you can
encounter.
Test, Test, Test. This is positive vandalism. If the machine
remains complete, even after many modifications or bodges to
improve the problems, then confidence is the first survivor and
a lighter machine may be it's progeny. At least you know your
welding and frame strength is 'up to scratch'.
All testing will depend upon the purpose of the machine and its
unacceptable problem areas.
If deemed unsuitable, it can also be heavily modified to
improve it's handling and tisis recomended next. - Refitting
the steering head, rear shock mounts or whatever is needed can
be done in light of feedback. It is such situations that allow
the best research to be done. You will soon understand if your
ideas make the trike better or worse, and from that you can try
modifications in the other direction, or to find that your
original idea was pretty close to the ball park.
Do not be afraid to experiment.
The hacksaw, grinder and welder are now your best friends.
Saw part way though the frame tubes near the headstock,
reposition the steering head angle and weld up fully.
Play around with various rear shock mountings. Reposition the
anti roll bar or radius arms. Adjust the toe in or out, and
finally lower a tall machine, just to see how this makes
handling better.
Remember - a lot more can be learnt from a poor machine than from a perfect one.
There may still be a complete machine to test. Where breaks occur, reweld and prepare to test further. So use the opportunity to keep modifying until it is as good as it is likely to get.
The last test, if the machine is not acceptable for general use, is by loading to destruction. Chassis deflections against load could be taken for future reference.
Like JPseries crash testing, if one can't get help from the experts, then study their work and do it anyway. (Always be painstakingly careful when crash testing with real riders.) It is hoped that computer crash analysis will be made available to all vehicle builders as soon as possible. Please contact the author, as the safety of many testers, including the author are directly affected.
Structural testing can be studied from books then applied, but
for most purposes, it is just a case of seeing how far a design
and it's quality of manufacturing can be pushed.
The headstock, handlebars and linkages are unlikely to be
damaged, so can be salvaged later. Remove all expensive non
structural components such as lights, carbs, disc brakes etc.
Leave the structural parts in position to prevent the machine
from distorting unnecessarily, including the engine and
suspension.
Unless extremely expensive, the forks should be considered
sacrificial and part of the dynamic testing procedure, although
fork legs can be replaced with simple tubes for static tests.
Choosing somewhere quiet and safe with good lighting, will allow
the builder to see and hear cracks as they form. Always wear eye
protection goggles. This is important, as this will help to
discover the weakest points earlier than in less refined
environments.
Final testing is accomplished by copying the basic loads as
found in use, but more so.
Torsion.
First clamp the rear wheels to the floor or a solid wall, or use
a plank over the wheels and block with heavy weights or concrete
blocks etc. If this is not possible, then weld up a vertical
brace and jam it in a door frame.
Lift the front of the trike lightly off the ground with a jack,
or simply place the wheel on a plank which is allowed to roll
sideways on marbles or dowels. Apply a bar across the front fork
yokes and measure deflections, by gradually loading to twist the
frame. If clamps are difficult, place a bar over the front wheel
spindle nut and suspend using a rope from the handlebars to give
a crane jib effect. Although unlikely, do not distort the frame
too close to permanent failure of the structure.
Where a digital camera is avilable, it can capture video sequences, then these can be run in a loop to see which part of the frame flexes the most. Try to get visual deflections in plan and looking from the front and rear and from the side, so a tripod is particularly useful. If you cannot run video sequences, then mount the camera on pre-set points, so that it can take individual photos of the deflections which can be built up into sequences using programmes such as Gifcon.
It is important to assess torsion on the front end, as traditional motorcycle forks are not set up for heavy side loads, although symmetrical tubular types are capable of the same forces from braking and gravity. All front ends will suffer from the side loads found when cornering, but also the frame, so checking the way the steering head support tubes behave will highlight any areas of concern. Problems can often be ameliorated with plates or cross brace tubes.
To help recognise fractures early on ultra light machines, do the tests somewhere quiet, so cracks can be heard easily. Also cover the frame in fine strips of tissue paper, tightly glued across suspect surfaces or similar sections, possibly using little strips or larger sheets which will easily tear or distort, or larger sheets which will buckle or ripple. If the machine does not fail where expected, this helps refine the design process by real experience. Listen for creaks and worse noises.
Not all distortion may be in the frame. As the rear suspension
is the first part which deflects, block this with wood blocks or
temporary welded struts to replace the shocks, so that it is the
frame which flexes.
Record the torsion deformation at various forces and at various
positions along the frame, to see where the torsion is most
pronounced. Record for comparison with other machines. Using a
video camera looking along the frame to record the deflection
will allow the sequence to be rerun back and forth faster on a
computer to closely study the chassis deformation. Viewing from
above also helps.
Single sided front suspension systems may need mounting bars to fit. Always test from the front and rear axles, otherwise the exercise is not highlighting all possible weak points along the structure.
Compression.
This involves adding increasing load onto the trike until a load
which is higher than the worst case load is applied. This may be
the forces applied to each part of the trike which are needed to
survive leaping a humpback bridge at seventy miles an hour, or
whatever your preferred riding style may be.
To know what sort and ratios of loads are to be applied over the
chassis, check the final wheel loading using bathroom scales or
something bigger if needed. On a heavy axle load, use two
bathroom scales and a plank to spread the load, then add these
loads together. As weight balance should have been decided at an
early stage, be prepared to adjust the position of the
passengers, fuel tank and battery if needed to improve the
overall weight balance.
When about right, measure the wheel loads with a full complement
of heavy passengers and luggage. Mark the load for each wheel in
pounds or kilograms on the chassis in felt tip pen. This gives
the static load on each axle of the structure which can then be
used to calculate the maximum 'safe' load. This is NOT a
guaranteed safe load, merely an approximation.
As maths is not everyone's favourite subject, consider the front
wheel resting on the ground, which is not suffering a heavy load
while static. In reality, it is supporting the mass of the trike
under the effects of gravity.
At top speed over a bumpy road, this force into the trike can be
four times the static force, into the tyre and suspension, and
will do so many times a minute, creating lots of stress as well
as the general load.
This force and load must not distort the trike suspension or
chassis in a dangerous manner. All structures will distort, but
they should not impair handling to a dangerous manner. Knowing
how much the structure will distort and in what way, is the aim
of testing and checking. Some tests must be done while riding,
some can be done while stationary.
If you ride gently, then the front end may only need to take
three times the static load. If a thrasher, then this can rise
to six times or more. Luckily, if suspension is fitted, then the
actual force into the structure is gentler, due to shock
absorbers which spread the force from an instant shock, to a
gentler force over a short time, possibly as long as a second,
or as short as a tenth of a second.
The tyres usually absorb minor road irregularities. This reduces
the shock load onto the frame, but all the forces must still be
absorbed. As the analysis of the way a structure is loaded
dynamically and everyone rides differently, then making the
trike to handle three or four times the fully loaded static load
will usually suffice for normal safety. If during testing, this
load is easily accommodated, then perhaps the trike is
overbuilt, or you can thrash the beast a lot more.
Mount one rear wheel on rolling blocks so the frame can spread
sideways. The wheels will normally allow the frame to stretch
lengthways. If the wheels are not fitted, perhaps just testing
the bare frame, then use planks and rollers. This is to ensure
no constraint as the machine spreads under the load. To check
gradual deformation under the machine, use an extended matchbox
mounted on blocks under the frame mid point, so the inner of the
matchbox touches the bottom of the frame when extended, and can
be marked or measured at each stage. During flexing, the inner
will be slid inside the matchbox, and can be read off at each
stage, to help generate a graph. Use a matchbox with a stiff
sliding action, improved with extra paper in the slit. Anything
taller than a matchbox will allow a failed machine to drop too
far. Mark with pencil line and the load applied. For basic
tests, measure with one rider, then one jumping, then with two
riders, and finally measure with two or more jumping up and
down. Be ready to support yourself if the frame suddenly breaks.
The crumpled matchbox can be straightened and assessed later.
To see how the machine behaves, a graph can be plotted of load against deflection. Start by gradually applying twice the expected maximum load, as most general purpose machines should be capable of this with minimal flexing. If many plots are made, then the graph may even be able to predict the failure point.
When preferring a slower, more subtle approach to loading, then
use two or three dustbins or garden water butts placed on the
machine, mounted more securely on a sand bag or a welded support
and gradually filled as deflection is measured. If mass
measurement is needed, measure the water by pouring in one
gallon at a time.
It is important to mount the water butt so that its load will be
applied in a similar manner to the ratio of the static load of
the trike. If a heavy front end, then place the waterbutt nearer
the front. If a light front end, then place the water but closer
to the rear. The ideal position would be over the centre of
gravity when fully loaded. A reasonable position will often have
to be the best guess.
As most vehicles rarely go beyond 2G, in any plane, other than
the suspension, then twice its weight is fairly safe, but three
times its weight is getting close to a reasonably safe structure.
When filling a water butt, a reasonable load can be applied.
Water has a density of 1000 kg/m3. A cubic metre is quite large,
but equates to the weight of more than ten average riders.
One litre of water weights one kilo.
If wanting to find out how much load is being applied,
One cubic metre of water weighs one metric tonne. ( 0.98 real UK
tons.)
One gallon of water weighs 10 lbs. 2240 lbs per ton. 1 ton = 224 gallons.
Static testing could take all afternoon and best done in the
garden.
As big buckets are not too stable, consider using a long plank
or small ladder balanced on the seat, its other end on a
suitably level item, but free to move. This will keep the water
butt level should the frame break.
Always have the water pipe under the water, so that creaks can
be heard as the load increases. As the load gets towards the
limits, it is worthwhile checking the distortion once the
suspension has reached its limits and can move no more, where it
is the frame (and tyres) which must absorb further extreme
loads. Now the real frame distortion tests can begin, but should
not be taken too far, just enough to ensure the frame can take
twice the expected load after the suspension has reached its
maximum compression.
If forks are removed and not replaced with steel bars, then the genuine bending force on the steering head will also be lost.
At first, the suspension and tyres will compress, then the
rubber blocks, and finally the frame will begin to deform.
Suspension will begin with a gentle curve, followed by a steeper
curve until it reaches it maximum suspension movement and the
rubber bump stops.
Then as the frame begins to distort, the load will increase for
little deformation and it is time to look and listen.
For simplicity, it may be better to remove the wheels and block
at the upper suspension points, (upper shock mounts) so that
just a frame curve is measured, but this does not allow the
tester to see how the suspension load deflection curve builds up
to the fully compressed suspension point, then extended into the
purely frame distortion curve.
The frame distortion should be fairly straight for a while, then
begin to curve. Note the load as the curve starts. This is the
maximum load. Relax the load at this point, or if wishing to
test to destruction, the curve will get worse, until failure
occurs. Failure may be a broken weld, a bent tube or one or more
of many other failures.
When the suspension units bottom out, take the process very slowly, and always be aware of any creaks or other untoward noises. Always wear eye protection. At a very basic level, deflection should be proportional to load, to give a straight line. This will gradually deflect more as the maximum safe load is exceeded, so the graph is no longer a straight line. When the graph starts to deviate from the initial line, you know something's getting desperately unfit. Hopefully it's just a weld ripping out, or a tube bending, so take note and stop when you can see the fault. Do not get too close, unless the load is removed, or considerably lightened, otherwise you may get a face full of steel.
A maximum working load (which is not the maximum load, when it
can break), but the maximum working load can be calculated from
the maximum load to compress the suspension to the rubber
blocks, then reduce this figure to take into account high speed
heave and roll. About half to two thirds is often acceptable. If
the load is too light, the suspension will feel stiff.
For a reasonable safety factor, it is assumed the maximum
overall load when testing with the water butt will be at least
twice that used to compress both the suspension also the rubber
bump stops. These are only rough approximations, so always study
your own machines and aim to play safe.
If getting keen, and with at least six points on the graph of
load against deflection, (two of the suspension compression and
four closer ones for frame distortion), a graph can be plotted
of load against deflection. If many plots are made on the graph,
then it may even be able to predict the failure point as the
curve begins to deviate from the early profile. At a very basic
level, deflection should be proportional to load, to give a
straight line. This will gradually deflect more per unit load,
as the suspension bottoms out and the frame begins to bend
seriously. After this point, when the graph is no longer a
straight line, then you must go slower, making more accurate
plots.
As the maximum safe load is reached the graph will have begun to
change from a straight line and stop, and check as the frame may
be close to collapse. Therefore draw the graph as it is
measured, so any danger signs can be recognised. You may be very
happy with a high load and decide not to push the frame any
further. It may well take a lot more than you expected, and is
not unusual with home made frames, where a cautious approach to
choosing frame tubing leads to overly strong metal for the main
frame.
Making three different measurements along the bottom of the
structure, evenly spaced between rear axle and head stock, will
highlight localised deformation and possibly predict the point
of highest flexing, which may or may not be the failure point,
depending upon the design.
If you feel confident with the graph, you may wish to push
further.
If the structure fails, and you are happy with the max load, it may be better to rebuild the frame, as it should not have been allowed to fail more than an inch, onto the safety blocks. It may well be returned to its original state. If this is difficult, then turn the trike frame upside down and do the same again, but to return the frame to its original shape prior to stronger welding at the failure point.
After testing, look carefully for everything from general
distortions across the whole machine, to the smallest fractures.
The frame breakage may not be the only failure point.
Soaking the suspect chassis areas in thin fluid such as dyed alcohol, or ink, then lightly wiping dry, so the ink remains in any cracks. Then spray or covering in an absorbent film which will absorb the fluid and highlight cracks and imperfections. Dusting with chalk, or talcum powder from your bathroom, or a thin spray water based undercoat paint often works adequately. This is a cheap variation of the 'zyglo' method used for checking gas turbines etc. Repair if suspect, carve back any damage and repair as necessary. Do not be tempted to simply fill a crack by welding over it - until after perfect grooving and cleanliness is done to check the extent of the problem.
If the frame does not break, then consider making the next machine a lighter design, with thinner metal and / or other design considerations. Wherever possible, try until an unwanted frame breaks, as this will highlight the weakest points and offer excellent feedback of the design, its manufacturing and welding abilities and a host of other clues which can only be read directly from the 'failure.'
If needed, return to making a better machine in the light of
experience.
Many components can be salvaged, such as the steering head if
they survive acceptably. Re-use only after extreme checking for
cracks.
The components which did not break should all be carefully
studied. The remaining components will probably include the
bearing housings, seats and steering linkages which all take
time and effort, to leave the next step with 'just' the main
frame to build.
Do not get despondent in having spent so many hours building a machine to the highest skills, as this is never lost. Yes, heartbreak may follow such preparation, but the next machine will be even better. A good apprenticeship is never easy. The builder invariably learns a great deal more by mistakes than making a perfect machine first time.
Most trikes are poor, but a few are superb. The poor ones are
usually plenty good enough for most purposes, but a few of us
aim for perfection in style and handling.
If the second machine is also poor, then consider making a more
adaptable design, until the handling is correct. Use the
second poor machine as a continuing test rig until a
satisfactory design is created. Then use the vital info you have
gleaned to build a refined machine from this. Salvaging whole
sections from the old machine is often possible by reintegrating
engine mount sections, and such like, even if using a very
different design, or possibly most of the original.
When just a few problems of flexibility occur, a few gussets or
fillets, or cross bracing may cure minor handling problems.
On the occasionally complex or precision machine, testing may
take on another level of intensity.
If making a lightweight, or very refined trike, then it would be
nice to just use the trike on the road to see what the day to
day forces are. Then it is possible to see just how much the
trike can take in the workshop, and from this work out the
safety factor.
If you have a frame you suspect as being less then strong as you
intended, then this will also help you to decide the working
safety factor of your machine.
There are many tests to assess the normal forces exerted, so you can statically test the trike later, as you already know the normal working forces.
At a basic level, a digital thermometer can be augmented with
temperature sensitive memory strips, - such as where exhaust
cooling airflow or cooling from the radiators may be a problem.
It is the frame strength which may worry most people. While testing on the road, the normal levels of stress (load over area) or strain (elongation over original length), can be measured by simple devices. See also Young's modulus in any engineering text book.
Strain gauges need not be electrical, as mechanical deflection devices such as amplified arms can be welded at an appropriate point on the frame, to accentuate movement and to rub on a matt white painted surface somewhere else on the frame to give feedback of the distortion in both directions. A light, flat bar which will not flex in the plane of measurement, by using a wide strip of metal, will often suffice. Similar to the basic, 'bendy bar' torque wrenches, but where it is the frame which bends, not the arm. Make sure it is the frame deflection which is measured, not that of the measuring device. Weld the long, wide plate across the length of the frame, and house the end in soft foam to prevent vibration, and allow a point to rub in a small marker area. This can then be carefully recorded by marking the extents of the flexing during use, by very carefully scratching a fine upper and lower line with a sharp knife. Then the frame can be loaded well beyond this working load to see just how much safety margin is available.
Static load testing, probably with a water butt to the maximum road use, will show how much the machine flexes under road conditions, allowing you to se just how much the suspension has moved and how the wheels align to the road. This can then be loaded further to compare during this non destructive testing to research the true safety margins.
The non-bendy bar in use, when compared to the deflection during static testing is probably your best bet to know just how strong the overall trike actually is. The initial deflection from thrash testing, then compared to static testing until failure will give the best insight to the true safety margin.
For those wanting to know the shock forces on the frame are,
then a simple spring loaded pendulum pivoting on a ceramic
potentiometer can be calibrated for acceleration and
deceleration of the bike or swing arms and other components.
For one G, (acceleration due to Earth's gravity) calibrate with
the spring against the effect of gravity. (Turn it ninety
degrees).
By using a rubbing mark, then the builder can later read off the
maximum acceleration that was acting on the device.
A potentiometer as the pivot of the spring loaded weight, will
make a simple electronic G meter. Connecting it to a good
battery (not the trike battery which will fluctuate between 12
and 14 volts) and across a volt meter will give a G meter. I
would prefer to use mechanical devices as they rarely give false
readings if designed well.
Another means of testing is to use electronics such as strain gauges, (although the bendy bar is also a form of strain gauge) but lots of electronics is not only expensive, it does not offer much extra insight, unless running an experimental machine. For most people, a bendy bar will be enough to measure the general parameters.
Real engineering is a craftsman doing for pennies what any commercial company usually does for a fortune. Never be put off by the 'sophisticated' talk and equipment of 'experts'. You can spend a fortune on expensive equipment, but it is rarely necessary. Know the data to gather it and how to assess it. It's not black magic.
If keen, an old laptop or hand-held has analogue, usually
joystick game inputs and these are reasonably capable of
differentiating between minor changes, then an interface can be
built to read resistance's for strain gauges, pressure,
temperature and other sensors. Even if the hard drive and
batteries have failed, a basic computer can run on 12 volts for
simple check routines stored into memory from floppy and stored
and down loaded to floppy, powered from the trikes battery.
The BBC micro was a particularly excellent machine in it's day
for the purpose of static testing and I soldered up small
interfaces and wrote programmes for testing a wide range of
things. In 2005, any of the old laptop PCs are usable data
gatherers despite their age and can become a part of a test rig.
Always mount in foam rubber. Always mount away from moisture or
in a poly bag when testing in the rain.
If an old laptop with no hard drive or screen, then make a boot
floppy on a desktop PC, so that when the laptop boots, it starts
measuring. Then remove the floppy an fit a new floppy ready for
the next boot run. Easy-peasy and for pennies. I have three old
'useless' 386 laptops for this purpose; all modified to run from
12 volts supplies because their batteries are defunct. Minimal
DOS 5 with a few simple utilities, or with Q Basic will usually
suffice. (See my monograph on aerodynamics and wind tunnels for
more info.)
If new to this game and just needing a simple counter, use a
pocket calculator and connect a wire to operate a switch
connected between the + plus sign contacts, then input 1+1= and
the switch will count on the calculator for ever. Using the
rolling circumference will give an odometer. For rotating or
non-contact parts, a magnet and a reed switch are ideal and held
in place with glue.
Most PCs can accommodate a variety of simple or complex home
made input boards, often using analysis software and virtual
oscilloscopes. Basic second - hand laptops with simple home made
interfaces are ideal for road testing. Hand help digital
oscilloscopes are also useful, especially those with large
memories. Cheap temperature sensors are available using a
variety of car and other devices.
See my website for windtunnel computer interfacing for pennies
to get some idea of the possibilities.
The basics of a good machine still come from optimising the rake
or trail of the designs, the wheelbase, centre of gravity etc.
Handling or specific ergonomics must come from experience, so
begin by measuring angles and dimensions on the next club run or
catalogues and deciding if they have the right answer, or at
least the ball park measurements.
Once the frame is good, the rest can now be assessed.
Not all machines will be ideal.
Even the worlds best manufacturers make the occasional blooper.
The vehicle industry is littered with vehicles best forgotten,
not only by reputation, but also by serious basic design flaws.
After an atrocious machine is built, a vastly better machine
often appears next time around, in the light of the excellent
understanding from the many design hurdles and pitfalls
encountered, which focus the mind very effectively.
View a bad machine as an opportunity, not a problem.
Occasionally, an impeccable machine is created. In the JP
programme a couple of machines have been created which are sheer
bliss to ride. Such machines occasionally exhibit excellent
handling, ergonomics or control harmony and occasionally all
three.
Never destroy an impeccable machine, but allow others to test it
to understand why it's so good. Just knowing it's good is not
enough, you must always take this opportunity to understand the
fundamentals and subtleties. Always get other riders points of
view, ensuring as little as possible is missed from such
opportunities.
Some machines 'thrown together' to quickly test an aspect of a design have also turned out to be outstandingly good machines.
If not completely happy with the first attempt, possibly because
manufacture is not superb, or the ergonomics are unsuitable, it
simply does not handle well enough, or a host of other reasons,
do not despair. Test ride it anyway to fully understand where
the problems are, as bad machines can often highlight what to
steer clear of second time around. Only then should destructive
testing be considered, possibly with the intention of a partial
or total rebuild afterwards.
Remember: Much more can be learnt from an imperfect machine than
from a perfect machine.
Sort out the annoying problem that has occurred from the
beginning, and add the little flourishing touches that should
have been there from the start.
Sort out the nasty little rattle and redesign the constantly
fracturing exhaust system. Fit the splash guards under the wheel
arches and tidy up the wiring loom.
Tweak the gearchange to perfection.
If wiring is not a strong point, learn more and in the meantime
buy plenty of fuse wire. (Note for traditional bikers who hate
wiring: never waste money buying lots of fuses, simply straddle
the fuse holder with correct rated fuse wire and hold in place
using a blown fuse. If desperate, use ordinary copper wire from
ordinary wiring, and guess a similar cross section of the wire
because copper is the same everywhere.)
Perfection is in the detail, - don't spoil it at this stage.
Public image may not be the same as the builders image, so
consider a variety of form, styles and paint for maximum public
effect for all.
Paint and finishing has been covered by many specialist books
and magazines and need not be covered here. See also shell
later.
Always check for disastrous ideas with friends first, such as
colours or floral pattern seats.
The advantage of building the machine oneself is that money, time and skills are the only limitations. Never be put off by all the hype about the expense of racing or development teams. The costs need not be high. Being able to spend money like water is a luxury, - whereas being poor is not a limitation, merely a chance to truly understand just what exactly is needed.
Building your own machines and test gear makes the whole process much better understood and develops a natural curiosity with a genuinely innovative approach to design. Having a brain is the best gift of all, use it.
There is no point in building trikes if the builder does not enjoy riding them. Always take every opportunity to enjoy the ride, as this is the ultimate goal of such processes. Always carry a notebook, because further improvement is often just another ride away.
If the machine is so radical that it gets strange looks from
others, always smile when parking up and engage in polite
conversation, for the perception of others is always welcome.
A radical machine is often a conversation starter, so use the
occasion to advantage. The stranger may well be an old biker to
whom you can enlighten to the advantages of new ideas. They will
probably want to have their photo taken sitting in it. You may
well be invited to the next local bike bash.
The JP6c, when ridden to a show, attracted a massive crowd
around it before I could alight.
Sometimes I prefer to walk away with helmet on and then quietly
rejoin the crowd as another spectator, passively asking
questions of others for a true reaction.
You may be followed by police vehicles for a few miles, so get
the paperwork sorted, but usually they just want to look and
chat, so ride politely and don't bullshit when they enquire.
On one occasion, a radical JP machine was chased for miles
across Bordeaux roads to end up in an impromptu photo session by
many excited French strangers.
Life is for living.
The rear of a well engineered trike does not need a bodyshell,
but many builders prefer it.
Shells are wipe-clean and visually acceptable to the public and
to keep little fingers out of places they should not be.
An open trike is difficult to get looking perfect, as the many
small items must be co-ordinated into a single style, which can
be horrendous engineering exercise to get just right.
Shells cover the whole and make the many uglier unseen parts
much easier to live with. Shells are ideal for hiding home made
tanks, square tubing and to direct radiator airflow.
Shells widen the possibilities for luggage, passenger comfort
and aerodynamics. When styling, the shell moulding must take
into account the servicing, shape of the fittings such as
lighting, cooling and passengers.
The styling ideas are totally personal, so just one tip. Make it look good from all angles and do not be afraid to beat the Italians and British at their own game.
Developing a basic sculpted shape.
Decent shells can be made later if required. What you are
building is a first attempt, to ensure the aerodynamics are in
the ball park, that the radiators get enough airflow and don't
overheat the engine, that the passengers do not fall out at
every corner, and that the boot (trunk) opens as intended etc.
Once the basic chassis, airflow, passenger seating and other problems are sorted, the shell can be built. There are many ways, but a simple and effective way is as follows.
If in doubt about any aspect such as cooling airflow, then begin
with gaffer tape and large cardboard sheets grabbed from behind
shops or from recent large purchases or the backs of shops. Use
the cardboard to build up an initial airflow test shell for the
first few test rides, until the basic shape is decided. All too
often the shape is built first, and then modified the hard way
when the airflow is inadequate.
The best start is cardboard and gaffer tape lots of it, plus
wool strands held by blue tacky office putty in the radiators
and run a quiet, open test area. See also testing.
It is not always possible to find a test area for a cardboard
test shell to be built up to check airflow. Therefore a first
guess is often used, so always ensure the first attempt is as
minimal as possible, allowing for hidden air ducts to be
rearranged or modified until satisfactory. This usually means a
minimal covering for styling purposes, with temporary plastic
sheets for under shell adaptations.
If you don't live next to a disused airfield, or even a
municipal football car park, then make up big cardboard sheets
to fan the air over the rig in the back lane to see how the
cotton tufts behave when making the biggest draught possible.
Once the cardboard stage is sorted, then the real sculpting can
being. Either keep the cardboard in place, and build up plaster
over it, then sculpt back to the desired shape prior to making a
fibreglass skin. Unfortunately, cardboard and plaster do not
always work well together, as the cardboard gets soggy and
collapses. If your cardboard is the plain type and suffers, then
cover in cling film and build up slowly. When dry, the plaster
can be sculpted to shape.
Get the passengers seats, fuel tanks and other parts built and
tested. Cover the basic trike with thin polythene sheet to keep
it all clean. Food cling film is ideal.
The cheapest method is to scrunch up lots of newspaper and then
lay over sheets of paper with cheap wall paper paste, and
gradually build up to the shape you want. The make it stronger
with more paper or old wallpaper and then with plaster and
unwanted cotton cloth to achieve the final shape.
Do one side first.
On smaller trikes, consider using aerosol rigid foam as used by building trade for sealing holes. It sets rigid and can be carved. Another alternative is a two part rigid setting foam as supplied by fibreglass suppliers for filling buoyancy chambers in boats. These are very sticky and the trike must be completely protected with heavier gauge plastic sheeting and this can be held in position with string or tape. Lay the bike on one side, then apply the foam, expecting to smooth the foam around the bike as it sets using cardboard spatulas. This is very messy.
(An alternative to carboard is to build up the trike with
large white wall insulating foam blocks. They are available from
most building merchants. Restraining the blocks is a problem,
but some non solvent glues or double sided tape will suffice.
The blocks can be taped or glued together with cheap silicone
roof sealer and possibly sewn firmly with string. Anything which
will prevent the blocks from moving.
The blocks can now be carved with hot wire cutter, or the very
messy sanding disc on an angle grinder technique. (If brave or
stupid enough to power sand, do so either in a garage, on a day
without wind and have plenty of vacuum cleaner bags and a face
mask, or do so in a hurricane when far from civilisation.) White
foam is cheap and easily cut.
With foam, now perform the art of the sculptor.
The sander, serrated bread knife, wood saw or hot wire cutter
will allow the general shape to be developed.
A hot wire cutter.
If using some foams, especially white or blue foam, a hot wire
cutter can enable long slices. These slices need not be in a
single plane as demanded by a conventional saw.
To build a hot wire cutter, carefully unwind the element of a
1kW domestic electric fire, or heater from an old washing
machine or similar item. Stretch this firmly between the ends of
a one metre bow, weak bamboo pole or similar, so it is tensioned
enough not to distort under the pressure of cutting. A broom
handle with end arms tensioned by a Spanish windlass or a spring
will also suffice. There is no need to straighten the wire
fully, as it will straighten itself wonderfully when heated. It
need not get red hot. (Mine stays the same dark metal colour
when cutting.)
Connect each end of the wire to a 12v transformer output such as
a domestic car battery charger and test. If it does not heat up
enough to cut cleanly, use a larger amperage transformer, or tap
off prior to rectification, or position one of the connectors to
heat a shorter length of the wire.
Although accuracy at this stage is not important, a length of
hot wire longer than is needed is not a good idea, as excessive
bowing of the cut can ensue. Likewise, if the wire is too short,
the ends will cool too fast and will not give an even cut.
Speed of hot wire cutting is important and must be decided by
the pressure felt by the builder, as bowing of the wire will
cause a variation of cut. Greater wire tension is a solution,
but hot wires can only be tensioned so far, whereupon a shorter
bow, hotter wire or variation thereof must be contemplated. As
this is only to crop the outer layers of foam, there is no need
to get too sophisticated.
The use of pinning profiled thick card or wooden side plates on the foam will allow the wire to be cut along an intended path. Reversed, they will allow perfect symmetry on the other side. This has been the stock in trade of most model aircraft builders for many decades. Before doing so, mark out the centreline, using a piece of string from steering head to rear mid point.
Further shaping.
When the basic shape is carved and is slightly undersize, apply
plaster then smooth to get the shape perfect. Where the foam
blocks leave gaps next to the seats and other areas, simply use
a mixture of plaster, cloth and foam bits to fill the gaps.
At first, get one side sculpted as needed, then mark in the
centre line and use cardboard or wire templates to copy this
profile to the other side.
Thick wire templates allow you to modify the template on an ad
hoc basis.
If one side of the foam is cut and shaped, these wire template
can be bent to fit. When heated they can mark the identical
profile of the other side in the foam for easier sanding or
cutting to shape, or simply to melt the rough profile.
If the shape is not what you want, simply add more plaster, or
sand away and continue until one side is perfect. If not too
sure about how it will look, splash on some cheap poster paint
or some pigmented plaster to see how it will approximately look.
If you have shaped only one half, use a long, dress mirror on
the centreline to get a double sided view.
When the shape is finalised, smooth the whole and make a
symmetrical profile on the other side. Take time to get it
perfect.
Where needed, carve out the gaps to fit the tail and side lights.
Go berserk, pop down to the scrap yard and get those tail lights
and fog lights you always wanted to use.
Mask up the lights with tape or thin polythene film then fit in
position using a little plaster to hold in place. Then smooth to
blend into the profile.
The light mounting brackets can be moulded internally after the
shell is built, or the palmp vovered in thin plastic and a
fibreglass moulding taken of the rear, then this fibreglass
mould fitted in to t he plaster shape, ready to be integrated
into the fibreglass main shell.
Likewise fit other items which need a carefully profiled
interface with the shell.
When the lights are removed and the fibreglass laid up, the lights can be covered in polythene, then pushed into the fibreglass just before it begins to set, to make a perfect fit.
If air scoops are to be used, (always recommended, even if only for dummy styling purposes), then carve the smooth radiuses just enough to allow internal ducts to be added inside the recesses later, to make sure that the moulding can be removed.
The seats should fit neatly and be covered in bin bags for
protection.
Do not forget the moulding around the side lights.
Always allow the lights and other items to stand off the shape
by a few millimetres, as this is to account for the layers of
glass fibre and resin which will be laid on the profile. Ensure
the various items will lie flush when the shell thickness is
built up. This is not too important, as the various items such
as tail lights can be adjusted to lie flush later, before thier
brackets are moulded in place.
The above use of plaster allows the shape to be refined, easily shaped and built up over and over again with more plaster until perfect. Take full advantage of this opportunity to search out the best shape of side and other light units from the many cars available, to integrate into the plaster shape to best effect.
Extreme customs can take just as long to create the styling as it is to make the rest of the machine.
The act of integrating the tail lights and number (licence)
plate can become a work of art in it's own right. Sculpting the
recessed hi-fi mounting should keep it clear of most rain while
remaining stylish. Even the access hatches to the electrics can
be sculpted to stylised panels to blend in with the overall form
of the machine - simple square openings are rarely necessary.
For some, the styling just will not appear easily, taking weeks
until the subtlety becomes refined enough for public
presentation.
For many, this is the best part of trike building, where the
imagination runs riot.
If you find yourself just standing and looking for an hour or so, with a cuppa or beer, do not worry, this is quite normal.
Use a pencil to highlight and develop the styling lines in the plaster work as it develops.
When all parts are fitted into the foam and plaster shell, the
lay-up is almost ready to begin. Do not forget items such as the
radio slot, any top, bottom and side vents and air scoops, also
the badge and fuel filler recesses.
Keep all access hatch screws flush and never fit any accessory
or item which will impale or damage the rider or passengers.
The simplest theft proof panels are flush fitting and bungeed from behind, requiring blue tack or a sucker from a kiddies arrow or bathroom sucker hook to remove them enough to unhook the bungee from behind. Dummy screw heads will also help. Dummy screw heads can be mounded by using a genuine item as a mould. Prefer the unusual, torx or safety screw head, so vandals are deterred further.
One of my favourite openings is to cut the hole neatly in the shell, then put a small shoulder step on the rear, so the cut cover lies flush. Then simply put a bungee on the rear of the pannel to keep it in place. To open the panel, simply leave one corner of the support shoulders on the rear missing, so that pushing that particular corner allows the panel to lever open enough to get the fingers behind it. Ideal for engine and battery access, hiding hi-fi, or glove compartment etc. Fitting dummy screws further reduces the chance of theft.
It is always posaible cut the shell later - but if you have the mould in place, then take advantage of it for greater styling and accuracy.
Where major openings or slits (cut lines) in the shell are to be
made, then it may be useful to make a shallow accurately aligned
groove then inset a piece of thick vinyl covered wire or waxed
string. This should stand proud of the underlying shell mould,
to thereby create a thin recess on the inside of the main
moulding, allowing an easier cut very accurately after the shell
moulding has set to accurately segment the one piece shell.
To accurately mark any grooves or cut lines, use a chalked piece
of string pulled taught over the shell profile. Then draw the
string back and forth for a neater line in the plaster.
Where the cut lines are made with string cut into the foam and
plaster, a thick plastic strip can furthur be slotted into the
groove, to make a plastic wall, allowing the shell to be built
in separate sections.
Where the shell is to be later sliced into separate sheets and
is of a structural nature, then also carve two strengthening
ridges into the mould an inch or so either side of the proposed
cut. Do not make the strengthening ridge on the cut line unless
they are to be bolted together at the cut line, as the slicing
may not align perfectly. It may be better to align and make
mounting brackets later.
If the shell is to be separate pieces, then the string can cut a deeper cut, a thin sheet of waxed metal, firm cardboard or plastic inserted and the groove deepened to create flanges.
If the shell is to be a single piece, then take this opportunity
to carve strengthening ribs into the foam and plaster profile,
to ensure it will retain it's shape as intended. It is very
common to fully remove a one piece shell, especially ultra light
shells. Therefore it is important to ensure it can support it's
own weight when off the machine. Such shells may be hinged for
easy access, so will need suitable internal bracing, applied now
and refined later.
To make strengthening strips, choose where to make the strong
ribs in the shell, cut grooves in the plaster, and lay up some
cling film to prevent the ribs sticking, then apply fibreglassed
strips. When set, inject some rigid aerosol building foam, and
when this is set, sandpaper it all back to flush.
When all is ready, wax the shape using anything suitable which will allow fibreglass to be removed. Simple candle wax will often do, but do not crack the plaster, so warm the wax and apply with a gentle touch and a hot air gun or old iron or similar. Margarine, grease or the kids old crayons will also do, but may get messy. The best is a couple layers of cling film.
Lay up the fibreglass. some people stipple the resin into he dry glass cloth on the shell, other prefer to use a roller on the glass cloth while on an old glass window, then drape the glass cloth over, which gives a lighter shell.
While laying up the shell, cover the tail lights in masking tape and offer them up into place to make sure the tail light sockets are perfectly accurate befiore the resin sets. This is best done just before the green stage, just before the resin is beginning to set.
Remove the lights and seats, then carefully peel off the shell.
Clean and trim to thoroughly to remove any imperfections. The
shell may still be a light, flexible structure, so handle very
carefully. If very light and flexible, place it upside down on a
partially inflated beach air bed.
Thoroughly scrub clean the inside to remove any wax, then build
up the inside of the fibreglass shell with more ribs and gussets
to create any strengthening and mounting points needed. Simple
ribs can be built up over rolled paper, folded card etc.
Loosely mount the metal shell mounting brackets onto the frame,
so they will align and support without distorting the shell.
Adjust the shell in position on the frame. When aligned, tack
weld the final positions of the brackets to the frame. This will
allow the shell to fit perfectly, without any undue stresses or
distortions. Now the shell mounting lugs can be fibreglassed
into the shell. When set, they can be unbolted and the shell
removed for more strengthening in these areas. Always make sure
all the items can be easily removed.
Remove the shell, then use the internal grooves or ridges to cut
any slots or into sections, or hatches to service the engine,
access the trunk (boot), f