cpu computer water-cooling watercooling water cooling cool Always try to improve society rather than just take from it. Until then, lawyer stuff. Those using this information do so entirely at their own risk. Errors and omissions excepted. Contents subject to change without notice. All material herein is subject to copyright, patent and other intellectual property rights. All rights reserved. Copyright (C) J.Partridge. 2004.
Please note: In these days of litigation taking the place of
natural justice, it is necessary that those wishing to read the
monograph must understand that they must not, nor will ever hold
the author responsible for any damage or injury. This is because
the author does not want a parasitic lawyer coming on heavy
because some damn fool thinks he or she is some brilliant
engineer, or stubbed their toe and wants a fortune because they
happen to be stupid.
I don't mind putting my knowledge on the web, after all, we
should help make a better world, but as lawyers get richer,
society gets poorer. So Please use your vote to keep lawyers out
of politics. Have a nicer day :)
As just one of tens of thousands of science graduates and engineers being wasted in Britain. I write this website to help others and as a C.V. - hoping it may lead to a job. Gizzajob.
A few simple considerations.
Efficient design.
Radiators.
CPU header.
Pump.
Plumbing.
Making and setting up the system.
Dummy runs.
Modding your coolant system.
Fitting a header tank or reservoir.
A basic design.
Coolant additives.
Pretty flowing water.
Circuit choices.
Graphics cards.
Build your own headers.
For ten points:
To the max.
Part two, going further.
Some basic arithmetic.
Introduction.
Components.
Pumps.
Car matrix heaters.
Build your own radiator.
Water Walls.
Plumbing.
Putting it all together.
Playing with refrigeration.
Cheap and cheerful.
Sources.
Other stuff.
Always remember that real engineering is doing for a fiver, what it takes a big corporation to do for a thousand quid.
I first got into cooling computers when the large custom chip in my BBC 'B', used to overheat and cause the computer to crash. I soon started developing coolers and discovered thermal paste 25 years ago, along with alloy radial cooling fins and small fan systems. The biggest thing I learnt is just how easy it all is. Modifying computers is still fun.
The other hype is that the more you spend, the better the
system, which is total and utter rubbish. The best systems I
know cost pennies.
A friend who builds high specification computers recently put a
top commercial water-cooling system in his best computer and it
did very little to improve the running temperatures. The
water-cooling was in my opinion, failing in the simplest design
needs and mostly a waste of money. I would happily replace most
commercial systems components.
I have friends who still refuse to accept the underlying
physics, but rather prefer to accept the hype and high price
tags. This is not for them, but for those who prefer to try
building something better, rather then to open their wallets.
I truly dispair of much of the fancy crap they often buy for
massive costs and yet have no useful advantage. The poor level
of schooling today has led most people into knowing very little
and all too often taking hype and bullshit as the truth. The
ability to think for oneself is lost in modern Britain. For most
people, only the big shops and internet catalogues have the
modern form of truth: the more you spend, the happier you will
be.
If you want to buy a fancy, bullshit computer, then stop reading
now, grab your credit card and go surfing.
If you have an open mind, then you may wish to read on.
This web page is large.
It starts with a lot of description of how present systems can
be improved.
If you want to build your own, then the later sections will show
how many different ways can be achieved for no money and with
far greater style then the present commercial junk.
Building your own pumps, radiators and cooler headers is also
mentioned later. including a few radical direct water cooling
designs which are cheap to make, but hard to design correctly.
About watercooling.
Water-cooling is simply a means to move heat from one place to
another. Luckily, water is a superb transport medium, ideal for
regulating beautiful planets. Water it can absorb a great deal
of heat energy without raising its own temperature by any vast
amount. This can then be transported to a device which can
remove the heat energy out of the system.
Water-cooling is in my opinion, open to far too many myths. Admittedly water-cooling of home computers is definitely in its infancy, as is much of the computing world, so many myths have naturally built up.
One of the biggest myths is the amount of coolant flow which is
often greatly overestimated.
I started by calculating just how much water is needed to cool a
typical 70 watt processor remaining around 45 degrees. This
assessment of the basic arithmetic led to many insights and
design possibilities.
Please note that there are thermodynamic booby traps in
calculating such systems. The first is that the ambient air
temperature in the room is the limiting factor and any system
temperature must be above the room temperature. If you live in a
centrally heated, double glazed house, then expect the overall
temperature of the system to be higher than most others, as you
cannot remove so much heat in a warm environment. If you live in
a draughty cabin in the Arctic, then an identical system will
run a lot cooler, as the heat difference between the room air
across the radiator and the warm coolant will be able to
transfer far more heat.
Just speeding up the radiator fan will not make things cooler,
nor create a great difference in temperatures once the system
has settled down.
The laws of thermodynamics state that you just cannot cool down
below the temperature of the room. To learn more, check out the
concept of entropy. Ask your science teacher, as it's basic
science.
I originally thought the many experts out there knew their stuff when they said a pump needs hundreds of litres per minute, but gradually doubt crept in. As described later, I built a small pump for nothing, which pumped 1 litre per minute at 12 volts and half a litre at 5 volts. Surely this pitiful little pump was of no use in a computer.
As part of a four year engineering apprenticeship, I happen to
have studied thermodynamics, so decided to do a little basic
maths. In the second part of this monograph, I've kept the maths
simple, so all can follow.
It turns out that the fancy pumps are not needed. Indeed, even
my little test pump could be run at low speeds. If the experts
got the coolant flow wrong, I wondered what else did they may
have got wrong. The answer was of course is that they got it all
wrong.
Looking closer, it turns out that the experts don't know their
subject very well and prepared to sell selections of poorly
matched, or inadequate components which will indeed water-cool a
computer, but not very well. They are like most British experts,
good at taking money, but not good at physics. They make a lot
of money because no one seems to bother to understand what they
buy. Even the hobbyist computer magazines with articles on
water-cooling make some massive bloopers.
With poor education, we will continue to buy crap. British
education flounders due to poor maths and science teachers. Half
of British maths teachers are not trained as such. Sorry kids,
the likes of me with B.Ed and B.Sc, are out there applying for
jobs to make learning far more interesting, but being white,
male and over forty, we are considered fit only for shelf
stacking. Don't blame the kids, nor the thousands of science
teachers looking for work.
Trained as an engineer, fitting superheated steam systems, a draughtsman and HNC refrigeration, steam generation and central heating, a science degree and such like, blah, blah blah, and even a couple of the totally crap GNVQ's for my sins, I've noticed many computers with water-cooling and all seem to have less than ideal set-ups. The many problems seem to occur with poor plumbing and its consequences, some no better than air cooling and a few that are actually worse. I could easily see a few simple ways to improve such systems. It really is not that difficult with a little background knowledge. (As I was highly commended for my curriculum and lesson plans during my B.Ed studies, I've written lesson plans for 14 yr olds as a set of six technology lessons on heat, with three different water cooled computer systems which can be made for pennies, to allow the pupils to make working measurements and learn about heat, basic thermodynamics and a modicum of engineering. The lessons plans are available by email.)
To prove the point that water-cooling can be done much better and a blatant rip-off, much of the following is done for no cost other than a little time and effort. Be it science or anything else, I don't accept the excuse that money is a barrier to making the best computer, nor a barrier to making the best pupils. (Making projects for pennies is part of a many Brit teachers jobs, as there is no working money in our education system, so the better teachers scavenge and teaches the pupils to scavenge if they want to learn more, than just passing exams.)
Having recently studied a GPU heatsink from a top computer
cooling firm, well, not so much study, as to laugh at it, I was
appalled by the poor design and atrocious build quality. The
connecting pipes cause so much restriction to the flow because
the cross sectional area was less than half of the pipe bore.
The metal body was poorly designed and made. I just would not
want this level of build in any of my systems for fear of it
failing. Simply not acceptable.
If you are going to spend three figures on a CPU and another
three figures on a graphics card, then at least these expensive
components deserve something genuinely decent.
This webpage does NOT include is how to spend money.
What is does include is how to use your brain and hands.
As you read through, try to understand the underlying thinking
behind water-cooling, so you can do it properly, or at least a
lot better than done by many. My last friend who bought a
water-cooling kit, soon removed it because it was not very good,
yet it was from one of the better manufacturers.
Don't get stung like him, start to learn what is happening, and
how to do the job sensibly and effectively. This and many other
ideas are available as complete teaching projects with lesson
plans and homework etc, for secondary schools, as part of my
teaching studies, so if one day, you ever get me as a teacher,
expect technology and science to be a lot more fun.
Let's start with a few simple considerations.
Decide if you need water-cooling; perhaps a hot running
processor, or a small case, or overclocking. If not, then simply
make your life easier and save the hassle and your money. Air
cooling is not perfect for getting temperatures very low, but
for most users and most computers, air-cooling is perfectly
adequate.
A small case should not run hot, even with air-cooling, as you
should be able to control the airflow easily. I build very
compact cases and they still run no hotter than full towers. So
check the internal aerodynamics of a small case before resorting
to water-cooling.
From assholes driving 4x4's on the school run, to full tower
computers, bigger is not always better, merely an excuse for
incompetence or not understanding the point adequately.
Try some cardboard corn flakes packet and adhesive tape to
improve the airflow first, it's a lot cheaper and far more
reliable than adding more, expensive fans.
As to silicon, always remember that if you want to run faster,
get a faster processor and graphics card, it really is that
simple. As Harley owners say, 'there ain't no substitute for
more cubes'.
If you can't afford more cubes, or you have all the cubes that
are available, then it's time to tweak what you can afford.
Water-cooling is now considered a serious option as overclocking
utilities are often supplied with the better graphics cards and
motherboards.
Please remember that much overclocking is NOT
due to a hotter chip, but because the silicon manufacturing
process is giving high outputs of almost perfect silicon, and so
some chips have to be down graded as slower, just to fill the
market niches. - Sometimes the GPU is high spec, but rated much
lower and will overclock without hassle, especially if it's an
end of the line processor, where the fabrication is almost
perfect.
Other systems are crippled with poor memory so
that overclocking the GPU is a waste of time.
Likewise, a
fast CPU with moderate graphics does not make a good games
machine. By choosing the right GPU or CPU and memory, you can
have a perfectly good, much faster item for standard prices and
water-cooling is not always needed.
Always know the bottom line and starting points before venturing forward.
Assuming you have a real need for water-cooling, then here are some incredibly simple facts that some builders never seem to understand.
Water is a superb transport medium, but merely carries the heat
from one place to another.
The amount of heat water can carry is phenomenal and far better
than any normally occurring fluid on this planet. If using water
temperature control with oceans is good enough to keep this
gorgeous planet under control, then it's good enough for a
computer. If there is a God, then he/she/it should be
phenomenally proud of the power of water.
Water-cooling is
superb and apart from refrigeration systems.
The amount of heat transferred depends upon the amount of water in contact and the difference in temperature. The greater the heat difference between hotspot and coolant, the greater the amount of heat that can be transferred per unit area in contact with the water passing over it. For a set difference in temperature, then the greater the coolant flow, the greater the amount of heat that can be transferred in a system. The cooler the coolant, the cooler the CPU.
But the little area between coolant and CPU or GPU is where the game lies. The rest of the system is to get this small hot spot as cool as possible.
You do not need to run a processor at sub zero as it is designed
to run happily at up to 70 degrees, so this is all you need to
play with. Overclocking yet running at 40 degrees is a happy
piece of silicon. Running at a few degrees above room
temperature is an almost perfect system.
Sub zero is
theoretically better, but for playing games then this is
overkill, as the chip will still generate heat, so push it by
all means, but don't worship it. Sub zero is for posing in the
pub with your friends, - if you have any friends after building
a refrigerated computer. Therefore you must aim to present the
hot CPU with the coolest water to be able to transport away the
maximum amount of heat and do so sensibly.
Removing heat from the coolant is usually done by a radiator by
transfer into an airflow.
Always remember a fundamental part of this game: The radiator
cannot reduce the coolant temperature down to the ambient
temperature. (of the room).
The better the radiator, the better the system. Poor radiator,
poor system.
A poor heat removal system will always make the rest of the
system equally poor. Unless all parts do a good job, then the
whole system will be poor. - Your coolant chain is only as good
as its weakest link. The radiator is the weakest link, - if it
cannot remove the heat, then all the other parts are worthless.
The vast range of radiators and how to make and modify them is
discussed later.
High or low pressure systems.
Many commercial systems use a sealed system which has high
pressure flow, more so when the enormous flow rate is
advertised. Other systems run at atmospheric pressure, usually
employing a vent system.
Water-cooling systems do not need high pressure to flow, but it
is the amount of coolant passing which can improve a system, but
that does not mean a system pumping twice as fast will remove
twice the heat, - far from it. The system will settle down to
its happy system, as long as there is some coolant flow, be it
reasonable flow or much faster.
The heat transfer of the CPU header is by its very nature
restricted to the heat flow through the metal, and as such, even
flowing the contents of Niagara through it, will only allow a
certain amount of heat flow to be transferred.
Any advert
touting high coolant flows, is in my opinion, utter crap.
Getting the coolant matched to the heat flow is the way to make
an effective and sensible system. It is for this reason that
most CPU headers use copper or aluminium casings, as these have
high heat transfer rates.
Cars have a pressurised system, but only to reduce steam build
up from a system which must run close to boiling point.
Computers should never get anywhere near such levels of heat, as
the CPU should never get hotter than 75 degrees, as your silicon
can fry at around 90 degrees. If you run your coolant hot, then
it canot cool the CPU as there will also be a poor thermal
increase in the area between the coolant and the silicone die.
The point of water cooling a computer is to keep the silicone
die temperatures safe or lower; water-cooling a computer is not
the removal of heat to simply prevent a car engine from melting,
but cars can get away with running high pressure systems close
to boiling, as the engine does not fry at 90 degrees. Indeed, a
car engine uses a thermostat to keep the engine running about 60
degrees, as this is where the engine is optimised to run, with
warm oil in winter and good combustion from a warm engine.
Computers should run at much lower temperatures.
A coolant design with small bores will need higher pressure to
get around the system and also need to pass the coolant faster
than a slower, larger bore system. All other aspects being
equal, large or small bore systems could both transport the same
volume of water and transport the same amount of heat. A little
increase in bore and fewer restrictions can make for a far more
reliable system.
Lower pressure usually equates to fewer leaks and greater
reliability on a less stressed pump. Water and electricity are
not the happiest of bedfellows. Therefore no one wants a leak,
or a cooling design which could cause damage to the computer if
it should leak. Therefore a low pressure system would be
preferred. All my water systems are vented.
Water is heavier than air, so any bubbles will want to flow to the highest point in the system unless blocked by an entrapment area. A well designed system will use this to advantage to get rid of any air. Air in the system means contamination and lower heat flow.
The last thing that many forget is that pipes should always be neat, but they never seem to be as good as one would like. Therefore the designer should always consider making a neat job.
Looks and style.
The water cooling systems seem to be just a black box pump, a
black radiator and a couple of plastic pipes and metal lumps.
Few systems ever seem to fit well, nor do they take maximum
advantage of the various spaces and airflow available in the
standard desktop, mini or midi tower case.
It could always work better and look far, far nicer.
Many people would assume water-cooling is for overclockers to
take their present processors to new temperature levels, or at
least to keep overclocked silicon at safe temperatures. But not
for all. For me, water-cooling is just good old engineering fun,
a chance to develop designs far better than the mundane rubbish
available commercially.
As a biker, I see far too many 'customs' built from catalogue
parts and too few genuine customs. Even the custom 'build offs'
on the TV are a load of second raters, pretty and expensive, but
otherwise just more of the same old stuff.
(I prefer to build hubcentre steering recumbent bikes, some are
road legal and handle far better then my Ducati. As a
mountaineer, I see atrocious camping equipment and poor,
bedraggled, overloaded kiddies learning that hiking is all heavy
boots and a heavy rucksack. It just ain't so. I walk all parts
of Dartmoor, Snowdonia and the Lakes and enjoy it without heavy
equipment.)
We can all do better and that includes computer builders too.
The options beyond watercooling.
For some, it would seem ideal to be able to run the processors
at just above absolute zero (-273K) but this is unlikely, as
strange things happen to sub atomic particles in this region and
anyway, the pumps used for getting near this temperature are
strange and esoteric. Likewise liquid nitrogen is also a bit of
a hassle. Only astronomers need this kind of chip cooling, and
then only to reduce sensor 'noise'.
A better solution would be freezing down to minus 20 degrees or
lower, but this again is unlikely with present compact
refrigeration systems. Keeping the processor at an ice-cold zero
Centigrade (32 Fahrenheit) with a compact freezer is more likely
in the real world. This is done by using solid state Pettier
heat pumps or by using specialist refrigeration liquid such as
the successors to 'freon' which can change easily between liquid
and gas, so the thermal changes can be used to reduce
temperatures well below the normal background (room)
temperature. These are the less notorious CFC's the
chloro-fluro-carbons. See later.
Tip: If playing with peltier, it is probably best to use the peltier to cool the water of a system, to run it close to zero using antifreeze, rather than use it directly on the processor. The feedback control of a peltier direct on the CPU would need a very fast control system, whereas a peltier working indirectly via water-cooling will give a far greater degree of flexibility and reliability to the system. More importantly, it would allow the processor to reach a stabilised temperature, then stay there with minimal changes in temperature to reduce stress on the silicon and of course, also have a far longer safety and more gradual temperature rise should the peltier or its control system fail.
For most people, aiming for room temperatures using water is
easily possible.
The plot improves with AMD and ATI processors which do not get
stupidly hot. For some intel processors and the latest batch of
nvidia, (if rumours are to be believed), then cooling is needed
just to stay in the game. Many overclockers prefer Far Cry and
therefore choose to be in the ATI clan, rather than the Doom3
and therefore nvidia gang. Whichever path you prefer,
water-cooling for overclocking can go a lot further with cooler
running processors, even if only used to improve reliability of
an overclocked device.
Whatever you use water-cooling for, it must be sensible and
applicable.
Perhaps you indeed prefer hot running processors of up to 100
watts and graphics cards which need two molex connectors to
generate frightening amounts of heat. In such cases,
water-cooling may be simply necessary to protect your
investments, rather than as an aid to pushing the limits.
Before choosing water-cooling, it's always best to check the standard computer running temperature. Pencils rool. Write the temp on the front of the casing for later reference and as a bottom line. It's all to easy to forget the original temperature when thinking of many other aspects of the design. I may find only a five degree drop in running temperature on some after market systems and if so, I would soon be modifying the water-cooling kit, and how it is used.
There are two main types of water-cooling systems.
The most common is the small bore systems, which need higher
pressures to overcome the resistance in the systems. These are
more prone to leaks but are generally neater due to the small
pipes.
Personally, I don't like small bore systems as their connections
are often too constrictive, but they can work well if you get
the system nicely balanced. Their advantage is that they can use
low volume pumps used for small garden water features, or so the
catalogues would have us believe. I believe that even smaller
pumps are possible yet still run with reasonable pipe bores.
The other is the low pressure systems, which use larger bore
pipes and as such do not suffer from resistance in the system.
These are less prone to leakage as the pressures are reduced.
The large bore system needs slightly larger radiator piping, but
this gives the opportunity for greater cooling.
I also use
large bore systems in a special, pump free design as mentioned
later.
The high pressure systems can be more compact in its plumbing,
but their radiators must still be able to transfer the heat, so
radiator size will still remain essentially the same for both
low and high pressure systems.
In reality, the use of a less constrictive system is always
preferred, but that does not demand large, low pressure pumps.
What it does include is the ability to use much better, larger
radiators in small systems.
Getting the heat away from the radiator is the weak link,
whether the coolant is high or low pressure, with high or low
flow rates.
The main point of any system is two stage: To pass cool water
over the hot spots and cool the unit by absorbing the heat thus
raising the temperature of the coolant, then transport the heat
away. Then cool the hot coolant and return it to the system.
Both high or low pressure systems can transport the same amount
of heat into the coolant over the processor heat sinks, then
through the radiator, with catalogues often quoting flow rates
around 20 to 60 litres per minute. I consider this unnecessarily
high.
There is a fundamental thermodynamic problem with
water-cooling.
As alluded to above, all factors being normal with room
temperature and constant volume caused by normal atmospheric
pressure, then the cooling temperature across the radiator is
the limiting factor. No coolant will reach the same temperature
of the cooling airflow, for there will always be inefficiency.
Worse still, as the coolant is brought down near to room
temperature, then the difference between coolant and the air is
so slight that little heat transfer is possible. Therefore
getting the maximum temperature difference across the radiator
by using cooler air, will need the area to be carefully checked
to get the lowest possible running temperatures.
Your water-cooled CPU is not going to get cooler than room
temperature. (Unless using phase change, such as water surface
evaporation and other esoteric techniques.)
The next point is to make sure the CPU gets the coolest coolant, so ideally takes the coolant from a radiator at the bottom of a case of a well designed system straight to the CPU. Therefore it can be seen that the radiator is the main area of importance to get the lowest CPU temperature. The coolest air in the room is usually at floor level, as hot air rises. If looking to drop a few degrees more than anyone else, then by making the coolant those few extra degrees lower will hopefully help to get the CPU a degree or so lower. If you live in a centrally heated house, tough luck.
If, like many of us poor Brits, and making your system from bits and pieces, then always invest in a decent pump, although modifying or making your own is easy and cheap. You may suffer with a poor radiator, but you must have a totally reliable pump. (Apart from one exception without a pump, as discussed later.)
Pumps have evolved greatly in the last year or so and although the best commercially available are still the same models as used in garden ponds for the last few decades, the better models are now becoming available in computer water-cooling kits. You can always simply pop down to your local garden centre, or read on.
The latest pumps have variable speed settings. You can always
modify them yourself or make your own or get new pumps for less
than 6 six quid, or for free. An average pump for a computer
will pump something in the region of twenty litres a minute or
more, but it is how reliably and how efficiently the heat is
transported into and out of the coolant medium that is
important. For overclocking very hot processors and GPU's, then
look for a larger flow pump and larger bore piping. If it has a
higher flow rate but a small bore pipe, then you must have
higher pressure and this may cause unnecessary problems.
Pumps with variable speeds and flow rates for pennies are
discussed in detail later.
The most worrying parts of some systems I have seen is simple
things; like not getting air out of the CPU header. Also
ensuring no potential bubbles build up in the radiator and
perhaps a lack of reservoir.
Very poor radiator design, positioning, use and equally bad fan
or radiator airflow is common. Commercial watercooling systems
often have all these problems. So what is also desperately
needed, is a simple means for getting the system installed,
which should be easier than that seen on some systems.
Convenience and neatness is still a major problem.
Types of radiators.
There are cross flow, where the coolant goes from one side to
the other, or from top to bottom. Also possible is the snake
piped radiators, where the coolant flows through a series of S
bends through the finning. Either is applicable, but for compact
systems the U bend, and for larger systems, the easier one-way
cross flow is often used.
Other forms of radiator are discussed later. If you think radiators are boring then you have lots to learn.
Various designs of radiators have the inlet and exit on the same
side of the matrix by using a segregated header. This causes the
coolant to flow in a U, from the inlet, through half the matrix
pipes to the other side, then return through the other half of
the matrix to the exit header. But where the hot fins of the
inlet are connected to the colder exit area, then heat transfer
will not be ideal. Where the coolant makes a double pass through
the radiator and ensures there are fewer dead areas in the
coolant flow, but also increases internal resistance to the
coolant flow.
Radiators should be positioned with the exit at the top to
remove bubbles, whether the matrix pipes are horizontal or
vertical. Horizontally, the outlet would be at the top, with the
inlet at the bottom, but is not theoretically perfect, but
perfectly good enough for normal use. When the matrix pipes are
vertical in such radiators, then both inlet and exit are at the
top and will also work and vent perfectly well.
It is obvious that if using snake type of internal flow, then
positioning the internal piping such that air can bubble its way
up and out of the radiator is going to be a good idea.
Positioning a radiator so that it captures many bubbles is very
dangerous, yet I've seen many computers with radiators
positioned to trap bubbles and reduce their efficiency.
It is not rocket science to do the job properly.
Without a pump, hotter water in a standard radiator rises to the
top of the radiator, with the coolest flowing to the bottom.
This is not very important in small systems, as the coolant flow
rarely makes much difference in heat between top and bottom, but
it may help.
The varying needs cause a conflict of needs between efficiency,
neatness and accumulation of bubbles, so in most cases, simply
have the outlet at the top or a transparent connection at the
top for recognising any build up of bubbles, then be able to
eliminate them.
Warning: Any system with both pipes on the base of the radiator
will make the whole radiator a potential bubble trap and
effectively ruin its capability to transfer heat should bubbles
accumulate. As radiators are not transparent, then this is a
constant, serious and hidden danger.
Therefore always have at least one upper pipe connection. If you
must have both pipes at the bottom of the radiator, then I
recommend you solder or epoxy a small brass pipe to the top of
the radiator header and fit a clear vent pipe. If the system is
sealed, then the pipe can also be sealed after purging the
system, but at least a long, transparent pipe with indicator
float will show if bubbles are accumulating.
The upper radiator main pipe can often be the inlet, which will
allow any bubbles to be seen, but only when the system is shut
down and the coolant flow is stopped. When shut down, any
bubbles will accumulate and be seen before the system becomes
too inefficient.
The CPU header is often the highest point in sealed systems, so
bubbles will primarily accumulate here if the coolant flow is
poor, but hidden bubbles in the radiator are also dangerous.
Be ye warned; any system may work perfectly well for the first
week, but a poorly designed system could gradually become
dangerous as you get complacent.
No matter what radiator I use, and I use many, it always gets
positioned in the case with great care. No air gets trapped,
and the airflow is unobstructed and cool. The exit airflow must
also be free too.
If the fan or pump is mounted in the radiator, then ensure the
radiator is secure, but free from vibration, possibly foam
mounted, or using rubber grommets on the mounting screws.
Where the fan or pump is separate and ducted, then the radiator
can be fixed in the case.
In most cases, the radiator is often to the bottom front or rear
of the computer case, to be able to take advantage of the
coolest air flow. Never allow the radiator to use recirculated
air in the case, as this is a waste of effort. A little
cardboard ducting on the upstream airflow to the case entry will
help reduce coolant temperatures. In some cases, the radiator
airflow can be kept separate from the rest of the computer. Far
too many computers have atrocious radiator placements.
It is often preferable to have both radiator pipes curving
neatly away from the motherboard side of the case, to allow
plenty of room for the drive cables. With both inlet and exit
pipes to the rear of the case, the matrix would often be
horizontal. Where there is plenty of room in side the case, such
as a midi tower case, then the matrix can be vertical or
horizontal, with both pipes at the top.
To repeat: No radiator should be mounted with both pipes at the bottom. If you demand that both pipes are at the base, then epoxy or solder a small vent pipe to the upper water jacket of the radiator, with a pipe leading to a header tank or vent pipe.
For greatest efficiency, the coolest coolant should ideally
enter the CPU header centrally, so the coolant is spread with
the highest difference in temperatures for maximum heat
transfer. In reality, the system will settle down to a happy
heat regime across the system, with little need to get the last
few hundredths of a degree out of the system.
It is not just the central flow which may be important, but also
the surface area in contact. To get the maximum heat transfer,
the base of the CPU header should be lapped to a fine finish,
then heat transfer paste used.
To get maximum coolant area for heat transfer, the coolant
should be passed over an internally finned CPU header base, so
maximum surface area and flow can extract the heat as fast as
possible. In reality, this is not needed, as most systems settle
down to a working temperature, and such refinements make minor
differences to the actual running temperatures, but it all helps
towards making a more refined design.
Good exit flow is important, especially to expel air bubbles,
but the actual internal flow is a compromise if the header is
simply a hollow casing.
As will be mentioned later, making your own header is not very
difficult. In the most expensive case, having a silversmith
build you a special header is possible. This also allows for a
finned coolant area over the CPU, so the maximum area for heat
transfer is possible, but can only remove the heat that the
radiator can remove. The excellent heat transfer properties of a
well designed silver interface may help protect the investment
of an expensive processor and to be able to overclock to the
max, but a good radiator is imperative. (I design and have such
silver items made to special order.) See other options later.
As many people cannot afford silver for the CPU header, then a solid block of copper with a soldered brass water jacket can be built for a few quid and an hours work. If a transparent cover is needed, then a sheet of thick acrylic or polycarbonate can be bonded then screwed into place, or a sheet of glass can be bonded and clamped to the water jacket. I prefer to rely on the clear piping for bubble recognition unless a complex header is used. More later.
Bubbles may accumulate at the top of the CPU header or high
point in the system and these must be eliminated. This picture
of a commercial design is utter crap, with bubbles even in the
CPU header. What a waste of money. Therefore the coolant flow
must be such that the CPU header outlet pipe is at the top.
Ideally this would be designed to encourage any small bubbles to
leave this important part of the system. The preference for a
transparent CPU header casing is not just for looks, but as a
visual check that all is well. The positioning of the
commercially available design opposite leaves a lot to be
desired.
Making your own CPU header is described later.
Never place a pump high in the system. There is no theoretical reason why the pump cannot be mounted high in the system, then used to continually eliminate bubbles by placing the pump in a reservoir such as a plastic food box to solve some problems but it also causes some problems. In practice, unless you have shaft leaks, then place the pump low in the system, preferably with a header tank, so that any bubbles can work their way up and out of the system and kept away from the pump.
Warning: NEVER fit a sealed coolant system with pump at
the top, because the pump vanes could become filled with air
bubbles and thus not be able to pump any coolant.
In a sealed system, always fit the pump at the base, so that all
available coolant in a leaky system will flow to the bottom and
at least get pumped around, even though much of the upper system
may have air in it; what coolant is left will still get pumped
around and help protect the processors.
Build or buy just the CPU header and fit in into the computer
with very long inlet and exit pipes.
Take the computer to kitchen sink or the garden shed, then make
up a header tank for the system such as a water tank or bucket
on the top of the typical midi tower computer case, and allow it
to flow water through your system. Just two pipes from the CPU
header, and suck the bottom to allow the water to flow down into
the sink. You will have to fit the CPU cooler fan to the
motherboards to ensure the Bios reads that there is a fan
present.
A simple clamp restrictor on the bottom tube will suffice to
reduce the flow. Completely clamping at the bottom retains
coolant in the whole system. Relax the clamp to give
approximately 5 litre (one UK gallon) per minute flow.
You can use a small bowl and sucking the bottom pipe to syphon
the water to start it flowing, then using a jug to top up the
upper reservoir is quite adequate.
When a steady flow, fire up the computer and allow it to settle
down while running your hottest game. Measure a set amount of
water over one minute, and measure the temperature compared to
that of the incoming water flow.
The bios screen will show
the CPU temperature and allow a comparison with normal running
temps.
Get a reasonable flow rate, run the computer and measure the
output flow when running a hot game. Allow it to stabilise and
measure the heat output of the water with a thermometer. Then
compare the inlet and exit temperatures and the flow per minute.
The water will be cooler than you will get from a sealed system,
as the water is colder from the tap if this is used, but the
heat difference is important.
During the test, you can reduce the flow rate by constricting
the pipe while keeping an eye on the CPU temperature.
Now carefully stop the flow and when the restriction is such
that the CPU temperature begins to climb, then release slightly
to get the ideal working temperature with the minimum flow.
Measure the restricted flow rate by timing into a measuring jug.
You may be pleasantly surprised just how small a coolant flow is
needed.
This is with cold water. If the ideal CPU running
temp is 35 degrees, then add hot water to the bucket to bring
the water to 30 degrees. Now run the test again and see how much
coolant is needed to maintain the CPU at 35 degrees. Again, wait
until the CPU reaches 35 degrees then slowly release the
restrictor to get a stabilised coolant flow at a constant 30
degree CPU. This should not need much coolant flow to stablise.
You now have a very good working reference for your choice
of CPU header - the flow rate and working coolant temperature.
By using warm water close to the CPU temp, then this is a worst
case scenario and thus the actual system may run much cooler.
This is the best way to prove that you only need a small pump
flow. You may want to throttle the flow by partial clamping at
the base of the pipe work using a clothes peg or other simple
clamp or partial plug.
You may wish to further restrict the flow until the CPU runs at
a happy temperature, then see how much flow is actually needed.
I was happy with less than 1 litre per minute. If you have an
intel, then you may need a higher flow rate.
After the test, you can tell from the computer running
temperature the optimum and minimum flow for a decent CPU
temperature.
Although the tap water is probably cooler than the room
temperature, the difference between inlet and exit flow will
give you a good idea of the difference in temperature across
this system and at the various measured flow rates.
Running temperature:
If the inlet temperature is 30 degrees and the exit temp is 32
degrees, then you have the possibility of having a system
capable of running at 2 degrees above normal room temperature.
In practice, the inlet water would run slightly hotter in a
normal, closed cooling system, so the actual temperature would
be more then the 2 degrees above room temperature. It may be
four degrees above room temperature, due to the computer
settling down with slightly warmer coolant. But the difference
in temperature from this basic test will give a good idea of the
working temperature to be expected from the system.
If you used a jug to refill the upper tank from the warmer
bottom on, then you have essentially made a closed coolant loop
and your readings will be closer that to be expected in a fully
enclosed system.
When testing this way, by restricting the flow rate until the CPU temperature begins to rise, you will also have measured the minimal flow rate needed for the system and also found an optimum flow rate, where any extra coolant flow does not lower the CPU temperature.
During the test, adjust the flow rate by measuring the
temperature rise of the water as a guide as to whether you need
to go for a bigger coolant flow pump or not.
Never use tap pressure, but a head (pressure) equal to the
height of a typical small garden pump - then the flow through
the CPU header and any radiator will give the true resistance of
the system.
You should now have an expected temperature rise for the optimum
flow rate. From this you can decide if water cooling is worth
the effort.
You can now decide if you need to return to the garden centre
for a pump, or brave enough to go to the car parts department to
try modifying a new, six quid screen washer pump capable of just
1 litre per minute.
Remember that this game is to remove the greatest amount of heat. Although the differences in pump position may only be a degree or so between the various configurations, it is up to the builder to decide what is required: Generally, the parts are mounted in the case first, and only then are the prettiest or neatest pipe routes decided, - but just swapping a couple of pipes can make a safer system.
In practice, the plastic pipes do not bend too easily, especially when cold during assembly, so it is best to assemble parts of the system with their pipes, such as the CPU so that the builder can see where the pipes can easily fit and what sort of bends and lengths are best for the system.
I always fit the pipes to my CPU header, with the exit pipe high to allow bubbles to be removed, then see where the pipes want to lie inside the case. Then I choose the best position for the pump, without undue force on the CPU header from tight bends in the pipes. In most situations, the easiest and safest is to position the pump low in the case. The layout of the typical system is such that the CPU is usually the highest point, with the radiator and pump on the bottom of the case, for easy mounting and to keep most of the system cool and away from the electrics.
Wherever the system is at a slightly lower pressure, bubbles can creep in from low pressure zones, such as minor suction from poorly fitting connections, or a worn pump seal. The pipe seals can be cured with a smear of silicone sealant, but pump seals demand a new pump, a new seal (or two) or preferably a pump of better quality, or as a desperate measure - to submerge the pump underwater. See later.
If any pressure leak (outwards) is likely to occur, it would be
in the higher pressure areas first.
If any bubbles occur (inwards) they would enter in the low
pressure zones.
It is for this reason that I ensure the driveshaft seal is on
the low pressure side of my designs of pump, and that there is a
bubble removal design of plumbing in my systems. This 'belt and
braces' approach eliminates any bubble problems that may occur
and also reduces any potential for leaks in the coolant.
I far prefer bubbles to enter the system, then be purged, rather
than for any coolant to leak out. Luckily, in a truly sealed
system, the volume of coolant will not allow much air to enter,
especially when it gets warm and expands slightly pressurising
the system by flexing the warm pipes.
Making and setting up the system.
The pump can be fitted on the base of the machine, but if
feeling less than confident, can also be mounted in a small
plastic drip tray.
Always dry fit the CPU header to see which of the various ways
around it will fit.
Always have the CPU header exit pipe in the highest position to
remove any bubbles. To optimise the cooling, I always mount my
motherboards upside down, BTX style, but I build my own cases
from scratch, so that my systems are as good as possible.
Getting cooler air across the radiator is a primary part of the
exercise. Even a few pieces of corn flakes packet and sticky
tape will help towards cooler airflow. If you live in a
centrally heated house with double glazing, then tough luck. The
radiator is usually easily fitted near the base, but never allow
dust to accumulate if in a dusty room, especially if the case is
positioned on the floor.
Where the radiator is not mounted close to the case entry, then
always duct the radiator to the outside, to prevent using
recirculating warmer air in the case.
Ideally, the coolest airflow would be from near an outside house
vent from a sheltered part of the house, but this is probably
not worth the effort unless living in Finland and wanting
sub-zero air across the radiator, and of course, you use
antifreeze and that there is no chance from ice, snow or real
lemmings from entering the ducting.
If your computer is to be a permanent fixture, then running a
couple of small pipes through a wall or window frame to allow
the radiator to be mounted outside in the shade and breeze may
be applicable, but never induce too much restriction in the
coolant flow. Make sure the warm and cool pipes are insulated
from each other, even if only by a piece of cardboard.
Water boxes.
Completely submerging some types of pump in coolant is not
needed unless demanding total protection or suffering from poor
shaft seals. Making your own submerged pumps is easy as it
allows any motor to be used and a simple shaft to a basic,
submerged pump body, with the motor above the water level. See
later.
If submerging or partially submerging the pump then consider
using a 'Tupperware'(tm) style of food container and always fit
the waterproof lid. A couple of rubber grommets from a car shop
will seal the inlet and outlet pipes if they are through the lid
or through the higher sides of the box.
Making an air hole, small bore vent pipe and filter will
greatly reduce bacterial contamination of such 'open' systems.
An air vent filter is easily made from a length of small length
of pipe and inserting a piece of cotton wool. Adding some bath
sponge prevents sloshing. Cutting the foam with a harder upper
mounting flange of plastic glued in place, makes for a splash
skirt and makes for a quieter system which mounts the motor free
of vibration.
If wanting to eliminate bacterial ingress, use distilled water, or boil the coolant first for five minutes to destroy all bugs, or add one water purifying tablet to kill off any nasty bugs. Preferably soak any cotton vent in an antibacterial liquid, as used for wiping kitchen work surfaces. If carrying the machine around, then use open cell bathroom sponge as part of any reservoir to prevent sloshing, as this is so much neater than anti slosh baffles and far quieter too. If air contamination is common, then simply float a film of polypropylene on the surface of the coolant. (Polypropylene floats.)
Dummy runs.
Just like fixing hard drive cables, always make dummy runs and
get the pipes perfectly aligned. Always try to eliminate any
potential high points where bubbles may be trapped. Once the
whole piping is sorted, then build the system dry, assembled
into the computer to check the fitting and the run of the pipes.
As most pipes are soft plastic, never allow them to rub against
any abrasive areas, especially the sharp edges of some cheaper
cases.
When cutting the plastic pipes, use a sharp knife and try not to
squash the tube nor distort it, so it makes a neat fit into some
of the cheaper connectors.
When satisfied, remove from the computer and fill the system.
Run the system for a couple of hours away from the computer,
using a 5 volt or 12 volt supply or whatever is required. If
the pump is not supplied with its own transformer, then an old
computer power supply will do nicely, or a 12 volt car or bike
battery charger if appropriate. Details of building variable
controls are mentioned later.
While running, use this time to improve the system. Move the components around to remove any potential bubbles or to get them to a high point were they can be removed by pouring in more coolant. While testing, the pump and radiator can be mounted on the table using blue tack or plasticiene, with the CPU header held for a while in its relevant position with a piece of string to check for any air entrapment problems.
Don't just test the cooling system, check the power supply if a
transformer is used to power the pump motor. Many cheap power
supplies fail due to overheating. I always open the casings,
then carefully add air vent holes to help keep the transformers
from cooking.
Remember that you are building a long and involved way to
protect the CPU. A chain is only as good as it weakest link.
Make all links as reliable as possible.
Bomb-proof is your lowest acceptable standard.
Removing any air bubbles is done by simply making the outlet of each component at the highest point and looking through the clear piping. Eventually all the bubbles will be in one convenient place, when the pipe carefully opened and topped up to remove all traces of air. If you are having lots of problems, then the final purging could be done under water, but this is rarely necessary.
If using a high pressure system without self sealing connections or a poor design, then sometimes it may be preferable to wire the pipes in place, although small hose clips are also possible. These clips are available in metal or plastic. If using tie-wraps, always use two on each connection, with the joins staggered, as the area directly under the join can make a poor seal.
Fully dry the outside of the system, run for another couple of hours and check for leaks. Use any case modding UV neon's to look for leaks if any coolant additive is UV sensitive.
When confident, install the system using the usual CPU heat
transfer paste with any other careful considerations and
alignment processes.
If a noisy pump, you may wish to use double sided, sticky foam
pads, as used for model aircraft servo fixings or to mount it in
foam to isolate it from the case.
In many cases, the radiator fan may be run from the motherboard.
In other cases, the radiator fan may take its power from the
hard drive Molex connectors, when your radiator fan sensor wire
(usually yellow) should be connected to the motherboard to give
a shut down warning. Technically speaking, the water pump is
essentially the same as the CPU fan, but these rarely have a
yellow sense wire for the motherboard CPU fan connection. So use
a fan with a yellow sensor wire on the radiator to become the
feedback for the FAN1 connection on the motherboard. This is
needed, as most motherboards will dislike having no pulse from
what it thinks is the CPU cooler.
When satisfied and all is well after two full checks, refit into
the computer and run the pump and radiator fan for a while just
to be sure, then switch on the computer.
Check that it all looks and sounds well, but be prepared to
switch off immediately.
Run the CPU temperature programme, it may be in the BIOS or a separate programme on top of your operating system. Water-cooling systems take a long while to stabilise, so do not take the first temperature as the normal temperature. Preferably run the computer using your most intensive game for half an hour, then check the temperature. It is assumed your BIOS over-temperature warning or shutdown is active. If all is well, then adjust the radiator fan speed to a preferred level for noise vs. heat flow. Allow five minutes for the system to stabilise at the new fan setting.
Where you wish to run your fastest game and cannot check the CPU temperature at the same time, then set the maximum BIOS temperature very low to give you feedback. Alternatively, you can fit a temperature sensor to the CPU header or use an IR thermal sensor. Alternatively shut down the game or reboot into the BIOS for an instant assessment. Remember that BIOS temperature sensors are not so accurate as one would like, but perfectly acceptable for comparative tests.
Now test the temperature limits by running any overclocking settings and your most intensive games, after all this is why you are water cooling. Then reduce the fan speed slowly to get the best compromise. If the pump can be adjusted, then adjust this too. Remember that pumps are far cheaper than CPU's so don't run them at full power as they are often built down to a price. A slower pump motor is usually a more reliable pump motor. It is for this reason I occasionally use custom high-spec racing motors, then de-tune them, or use high quality motors designed for steady, long term running. You may often find that there is little difference in CPU temperature between the motor running at full power and at tick over, - so always check, then always adjust for reliability.
Keep the temperature programme running for the first few days.
Check every hour for any bubble collection denoting a slight
leak on the suction side of the system and then daily then
weekly. Also check for any coolant loss. Learn to listen for any
audible changes in the coolant pump should it begin to fail
early.
Finally decide if the whole exercise was worth the effort.
Compare the running temperatures with the one you wrote on the
case in pencil before you began. If the cooling is not much
different to air cooling, then consider removing or modifying
the system.
You may find that your standard commercial system offers little
or no advantage over a good air cooler. Do not worry, as the
commercial systems can be improved. - Improved to the point
where only the power plug remains !
Modding your coolant system.
Many people like to tinker with their computer systems, it's a
big toy and lots of fun, and for some, a chance to pose.
Water-cooling is no different.
There are many small or large ways to add to, or improve your
basic water cooling system. But improvements are only
improvements if you have problems, otherwise they are called
unnecessary complexities. The biggest problem or disappointment
is spending lots of cash, with little improvement in the
cooling. If all works well, then there may be a few minor
problems, such as a slight leak, noise or ugliness.
Fitting a header tank or reservoir.
Perhaps your system has a small leak. Make sure you solve the
problem and not apply a reservoir tank. Most water-cooling
systems are sealed and work perfectly well when all bubbles are
removed and do not appear afterwards. In a few cases, bubbles
may enter the system, but this is not a problem if they are
removed automatically, perhaps using a vent or header tank.
Where coolant is being lost, then solve the problem.
A header tank is a passive device containing a higher
level of coolant and only acts to prevent coolant loss and to
give a small 'head' of slight pressure in the system. If
properly designed, will also allow bubbles to move up to the
header tank and out of the system.
A reservoir is usually an active part of the system and
the coolant in the reservoir is often in the general flow of the
coolant. A reservoir is common if using a submerged coolant
pump.
In common practice, be it domestic heating or supplying water to
a large city, the header tank is also a reservoir.
If building your own system or modding, then perhaps some air
bubbles will naturally float to the upper part of the system. As
the coolant exits from the CPU header which is often a high part
of the system, then it is possible to place a T piece in here
and have this going up to a small header tank. This would
encourage all bubbles from this high point in the system into
the even higher header tank. The higher coolant level will also
give a reliable signal of any coolant loss over the years. If
you never check these things, but simply make an occasional
glance, then mark the level when the machine is warm, so you can
check it at any time it's being used.
Note: Due to expansion and contraction of the various
components, the true coolant level should always be checked when
cool, before the computer is run in the morning, so the relative
levels will give true indications of coolant level.
The header pipe will connect to a miniature reservoir which is
open to the atmosphere top prevent pressure or vacuum building
up in the system, and will thus be at the top of the system to
give a 'head' of coolant. As most systems rarely leak, then any
loss will be minimal. A simple length of pipe would be more than
adequate for a header 'tank', but mainly to act as a high point
and thus isolate any bubbles in a problematic system. I often
use a small, clear plastic car fuel filter at the top to act as
a minor reservoir and also keep out the dirt.
In low pressure systems, a suitable tall header pipe can be on the pressure side, but it is always best to place the header pipe on the suction side of the pump or at least in a low pressure section of the plumbing. Therefore the plumbing could be different if using either a header pipe and reservoir.
Warning: Always fit pipes to open atmosphere in the low pressure
side of a plumbing system, never in a high pressure side for
obvious reasons. Place your header pipe on the suction side of
the water pump, so that, should any system blockage occur, the
water will not overflow.
BUT: In some situations where the builder wants INSTANT warning
from the coolant, it may be possible to build the system
'wrong'. If the header pipe is placed on the pressure side of
the pump, then any blockage after the header pipe, such as in
the radiator or CPU header, will cause the coolant to be pumped
out of this higher point which is open to the atmosphere.
Building this to indicate by splashing over the user, or to fill
a water sensing device connected to the computers 'off' button
makes for an excellent safety system. If you prefer such an open
pipe and it is suitably positioned, this can act as a safety
warning device. If such a blockage occurred, then having the
header pipe exiting at the front of the case will give an
instant alert to imminent failure. The heat reserve in the
header coolant should be enough to allow the machine to be shut
down within twenty seconds or so. It is always best to let the
system warn you, rather than you having to keep a regular eye on
it. If you fit an over flow float valve, then this can switch
your machine off using a very simple second connection to the
ATX power button.
The switch will need to be kept down for four seconds or more,
which is not a problem on a float valve, especially if using
just a brass contact and a piece of wire to make the contacts.
These can also be connected to the power switch wires of an ATX
motherboard and all is safe should the coolant get low or spring
a leak.
The ATX power switch can be controlled by connecting to two pins
to be shorted by a metal object. A closed cell foam ball covered
with aluminium cooking foil inside the header pipe, with two
pins pushed into the pipe above the level for an overflow and
two pins pushed in below the minimal coolant level will give a
simple and effective safety system for blockage and coolant loss.
Placing the header pipe just before the pump in a low point in the system, would not eliminate bubbles. Therefore the system will need to have the header pipe at a high point, perhaps just after the CPU header exit. This will ensure the header pipe is in a safe, neutral pressure zone in the system, between CPU header and radiator. Therefore this system would be pump-CPU-radiator, with the header pipe on the neutral pressure area between CPU and radiator on the highest point in the system to remove bubbles and also be on the safe side of the pump.
Any coolant reservoir can be used, but just a simple length of
coolant pipe will do, as the coolant loss should be zero or
thereabouts. Just because bubbles are entering the system, does
not mean that coolant is leaking out. It is this reason I prefer
low pressure systems for minimal coolant loss. On a properly
built system, only evaporation will cause long term problems and
this can be minimised to give extreme longevity.
For a filter, the open end of the pipe can be simply fitted with
a cotton wool stopper to prevent evaporation, yet allow
atmospheric pressure to prevent an over pressurised system.
Another good choice is to use a small, transparent car fuel
filter with a paper filter element. If carrying the machine
around, then use open cell bathroom sponge as part of the
reservoir to prevent sloshing. If air contamination is common,
place a film of polypropylene on the surface of the coolant.
(Polypropylene floats.)
There is nothing to stop the header pipes running outside of the case, or beside the window against a contrasting or zig zag background to allow constant coolant level inspection. This would be particularly good if you mount your ATX motherboard upside down with the CPU and thus the coolant system low in the case, to give a nice, tall header pipe.
For those who do not trust pump motors, a light could be fitted
across the wires to the pump, allowing a warning light to be
activated if the pump stops turning. Alternatively, a small
cheap, digital tachometer could be used and mounted on the front
of the case, perhaps beside the motor speed controller. See
later. The fan would be monitored by the motherboard in the
usual manner. Building in a pulse wire which can interface to
the motherboard second fan connection will also offer an extra
warning device. This could also be interfaced to a number
display, or my preference, a colour bargraph display.
Even a simple cardboard rotating disc pushed onto the end of the
shaft with a spiral drawn on it will give a perfectly usable
visual warning device.
Neatness is difficult with plastic pipes.
If needing a sharp bend in a pipe, simply and neatly wrap a
thick copper or a finer, steel wire around the outside of the
pipe and bend to shape. A small welding rod with the flux
removed, or a small knitting needle or wire coat hanger is
ideal. As bending around the pipe is not recommended, as it can
be crushed, always pre wrap the wire using a piece of doweling.
Adding a flourish of a tie-wrap loop or a stand off mounting can
make for a neater system.
Another way to make neat bends is to slip small plastic angle
bends over the pipe to allow neater corners. Alternatively use
brass pipes, but making such bends is not easy unless a trumpet
or saxophone maker. In such cases, simply make the brass pipe
with an open middle section and slide the pipe in place, then
bend the centre, with the two sleeve ends holding the pipe. See
picture. You may wish to solder on some support brackets before
inserting and bending the plastic pipe, to help make a really
neat case. This also makes the CPU and GPU headers far easier to
position in the case.
At this point the reader should have a system working reasonably
well. It may even seem perfect, even if you bought all the most
expensive bits from the best catalogues and websites.
But a much nicer systems is most definitely possible.
The simple car system is where there was no water pump. Just a
smooth, large bore pipe leading up to the radiator with a decent
fan. Because the system was designed for hot water to rise
easily and the cold water descend to fill its place, the whole
system can be simple and effective, reliable and quiet. Adding a
simple large bore radiator and a suitably designed CPU header
with one pipe high in the header and the other low, would make a
very quiet computer which would only have the one radiator fan
and no inherent mechanical problems. Always use a radiator with
the pipes vertical and the hot riser entering the top of the
radiator.
Surprise, surprise, this will work better if the case has the
motherboard upside down, BTX style, with the CPU at the bottom
and the simple, single pass radiator mounted high in the case.
Because it works without a pump, you can add some flaky chrome
pieces of neutrally buoyant plastic which will highlight and
check the coolant flow. Try scraping the back of a toasted CD
then with light oil to get the buoyancy right.
If you have a tall case, with your CPU near the bottom with one
pipe low and one high in the header, AND it is a large bore
system, AND the radiator is a single design where the hot
coolant can flow into the top and cool by flowing down though
the radiator, - then remove the pump and give this a try. Use
just use one fan set low on the radiator. The radiator is placed
high and vertically in the case. Insulate the hot pipe to
encourage hot water to rise.
It may only take half an hour to get the pipes running smoothly
vertical. If it works, and your CPU keeps suitably cool, then
you have no need for a pump and have a far more reliable and
quiet system. More later.
Pretty flowing water.
Many people would like to see if the coolant is actually
flowing. This is difficult, as placing plastic balls or other
detritus in the coolant for observation is not going to do the
pump vanes any good. If an indicator is needed, then fit a
length of contrasting plastic thread in the pipe. Place
carefully and securely in the system, held by both ends should
it break, and placed in a long, straight length of pipe with a
simple and non constricting clip. Never cause unnecessary
restriction to the coolant flow. A snug fitting plastic sleeve
with a piece of nylon sewing thread may suffice for most people
who do not trust their pumps or who just want to see the pretty
water flowing. A simple loop of nylon thread inserted at the
same time as a clear pipe is fitted over the pump outlet would
be ideal, plus a splodge of silicone sealant. As the cord will
want to stay beside the side of the pipe, always make a knot in
the loop, then keep the knot positioned in the middle of the
flow, so the cord trailing downstream from the knot will remain
in the central flow.
If you want a prettier indicator and your pump is a basic
design, such as an old car screen washer unit, (see below) then
you can but some glitter glue pens, which have the every fine
flakes of glitter which should not clog the pump vanes, then
wash the glitter glue and dry it to remove the glue. The flakes
can then be added to the coolant and if illumined properly, can
give a pretty, dynamic display for checking the coolant flow. As
they are heavier than water, then they will sink to the bottom
and hopefully re-enter the plumbing from the radiator, but
probably best forgotten. I have experimented with them, but
finally ended up with simply addling a whole lot of glitter and
live with variable levels of flow indication.
In a few cases, directing a safe, 5 volt pocket laser onto the
coolant flow will give some interesting effects on reflective
glitter when it all works as intended. Using glitter flakes from
larger sources may cause radiator or pump blockage. Adding a dye
can have some effect on laser light.
If an open system, with the pump submerged in a reservoir, then the return pipe can simply cascade like a small waterfall into the reservoir to indicate that coolant flow is correct and also add a background noise indicator.
If you have a clear side panel, then this could also be the reservoir, where the coolant from the radiator enters at the top and the whole side panel becomes the coolant flow indicator. Making entry and drain holes in such panels is not easy, but plenty of epoxy resin and some car windscreen washer connectors will usually suffice. If building a waterwall (c), then you can add a vane indicator near the radiator exit pipe. See later.
A temporary solution (in more ways than one) to check coolant flow is to mix oil and water together as the coolant, this will separate when not used and if different colours, then will allow the first minute or so of pumping to be seen as flow. Eventually this will be mixed by the pump and may not be discernible until the system has stopped again. This indication is only applicable for the initial few seconds. Making sure the oil and the water are not easily emulsified will depend upon the oil and the design of pump. Try it if you must, but do not expect to be too successful, as heat, oil and water can make something akin to mayonnaise. Best used in waterwalls using thermo syphon.
I do not like many power connections leading to the computer,
when one will do. Keep it tidy.
If you decide to use a separate power supply for the coolant
pump, which is highly recommended, then you may be able to open
up the computer's power supply and add a couple of mains wires
soldered to the back of the mains socket connection, then feed
the wires out with the other PSU cables and add a fuse in this
line. This can then be used to power a very reliable, overrated,
understressed power supply transformer for the water pump.
I prefer to exit these wires directly from the bottom of the PSU
case, through a separate grommet and add some alloy cooking foil
around these AC mains wires to reduce frequency problems from
any nearby 12 and 5 volt wires.
If the pumps' power supply has the three mains socket pins sticking out the back, then these can be cut off, sealed and the wiring connected internally for safety and a new, smaller mains connector used. This wire keeps the whole system integral in the computer and automatically switches the coolant pump on with the mains to power any specific power supply transformer for the pump. I always disassemble these secondary power supply cases to add some cooling holes, as they often fail due to excessive heat in the transformer case.
If you keep the computer switched on all the time, with just the ATX soft off switch used, then the monitor and motherboard are still alive. - But you may only want the pump to work with the standard, single small computer power switch which is connected to the motherboard on ATX systems. If so, then simply connect the mains power supply for the pump via a 12 volt relay switch for a couple of quid. This can then be operated via one of the hard drive power connectors to trigger the relay, without having the transformer and pump on all the time.
For long term reliability of a pump it can be reduced in power, as running flat-out is not always needed. Unless cooling the GPU and playing Call of Duty, Far Cry or Doom all day, the pump motor could be turned down using a rheostat, such as a ceramic potentiometer which can take the power rating of a small pump motor, or a simpler device such as a switch with a resistor in the line or to switch between the 5 volt and 12 volt rails, or using the switch in any separate power supply transformer. If using a powerful motor, something more than a video motor, then use a potentiometer for a rotary control with a TIP 120 power transistor which can handle up to 60 watts to control the motor, as described later. Reducing the motor power may also reduce noise.
You may notice on some air cooled CPU coolers, that by reducing the airflow, the heat transfer remains just as good, as slower, smoother airflow across the fins works more efficiently. My CPU runs at 42 degrees with the fan at 5,000 rpm and 43 degrees with the fan at 3,000 rpm - far quieter and the fan is probably far more reliable and less likely to collect dust. Likewise with my water-cooling systems, reducing the coolant flow rate may cause a smoother flow over the CPU header, reduce turbulence, slow the speed through the radiator and may thus work just as well. Experiment in this area to assess your system, but always remember that a water cooled system will take much longer to settle down to its working temperature than for an air cooled system.
If you decide on a separate power supply for the pump, then it may end up with one pair of insulated wires connected to the 240 volt wire from the PSU, with an internal fuse of about 1 amp rating. Another two wires leading to the HDD Molex connector with a micro relay integrated inside the case, and a third pair of wires leading to the potentiometer or Tip120 controller to adjust the motor speed. This is not exactly difficult, yet many commercial systems have just the motor connected to the HDD connector and can thus cause many problems if the motor fails or causes electrical noise in the power supply to the electronics, so always choose a safe way to power the pump. More later.
So let's go a little further than just the CPU, as the costs of
making a GPU water cooler when compared to buying the graphics
card will be mere pennies.
GPU (Graphics processor unit) coolers are fraught with problems,
as the memory is often superfast, overclocked and needs cooling
too. Therefore it is probably not a good idea to water-cool the
GPU unless considering the onboard memory too.
It's no one's fault, but for water-cooling, the graphics card is upside down on a midi tower. This is because of the superb backward compatibility back to the original PC, 1 MHz 8088 chip, when ye ancient legend hath it, cooling wast nay a problem.
All my custom built cases have standard ATX motherboards upside down to help CPU and GPU cooling, not unlike BTX, but far, far cheaper. It makes GPU cooling much safer. Build your own, it's very easy. See my companion monograph on the same website.
If wanting to cool a very expensive graphics processor and its memory, then always consider turning the motherboard upside down or desktop style, to help remove bubbles from near the chips. If lucky then you may only need to turn your ATX 'beige box' upside down into a pseudo BTX style, and still have it work perfectly well, albeit with a few minor adjustments.
Consider a second water cooling system so that if one system
fails, you have not lost both your CPU and graphics card. It
costs a lot to replace a CPU, but can be survived with a few
tears. Having to replace both CPU and GPU may cause mental
meltdown and chronic wallet failure. Using dual pumps also takes
the load off a single system pump and makes life far easier for
all items, while also increasing coolant flow due to far less
restriction in the systems. Separate systems allow cooler
coolant to both CPU and the GPU, rather than coolant first to
the CPU, then warmer coolant to the GPU. It also allows a blue
dye for CPU and a red dye system for GPU. After all, this may
not be hidden.
If using just one system, then buy a system with a large bore
and coolant flow, as any restriction in one part of the system
is a restriction to the whole system.
Build your own CPU and GPU headers.
Please note: When disassembling the heat sinks from the graphics
card, always make sure they can be replaced. Always be very
careful with the small plastic retainers. As to serious
overclocking and reviving pipelines, look to the wwweb for
specific details on your GPU. Powerstrip is a good beginners
overclocking tool.
WARNING: The heat sink compound may contain silver and when
wiped off, this can short circuit the memory and GPU pins. So
always clean off any heat sink compound INWARDS, towards the
centre of the chips. I use a piece of card to protect any pins.
Although the latest memory chips are surface soldered and do not
show pins, the heat compound can still work its way into this
hidden area, so be careful. If in doubt, clean any remaining
compound scrupulously with a safe solvent and a small, stiff,
non plastic brush. Always make a note of the code numbers on the
memory chips, especially the last letters, as this can tell you
if they are the faster types, likewise the GPU codes.
If the GPU and memory are perfectly level in their upper faces,
then simply cutting a large copper sheet to cover them will
suffice. To check, put a little heat transfer paste, butter or
grease on the GPU and memory chips, then place a sheet of plate
glass over them. If you don't have this, then an old CD clear
case cover. If the memory and GPU are all at the same level, the
pattern of displaced grease will show a perfectly level pattern
on all the items. It is important to put central pressure over
the GPU to make sure this is the centrally level item.
If they are not all the same level, then you will not be able to
build a single graphics card water-cooling jacket for GPU and
memory, and separate items will have to be made.
If the differences are minor, then perhaps some aluminium or
copper shims may be made to build up the height of the memory
chips to the level of the GPU silicon die. Such shims are
possible by measuring the difference in thickness between memory
and GPU, using a set of feeler gauges, available from any car
shop for a quid. Perhaps some carefully flattened and polished
cola can could be used for thin shim, or look elsewhere for
thicker shim. As the typical alloy beer or cola can is cold
drawn to shape, it has inherent springiness, so keep it large,
clean then mark with soap, then heat over a gas flame, until the
soap turns brown, then plunge into cold water to make it
malleable and easier to fit.
Never use more than one shim, so that the heat transfer path is
as perfect as possible from the memory to the graphics cooler
base. Make the shims then always double check using the grease
and glass method. There may be a little room for alignment from
the flexibility in the graphics printed circuit board, but only
by a couple of thousandths of an inch, and only if decent clamps
are used.
At a push, it may be possible to slot the copper so the sections
over the memory can be slightly cranked to give perfect fitment,
but this takes a long time to get perfect.
If in ANY doubt, then simply make separate coolers for the GPU
and memory. Don't forget to check for memory on the reverse side
of the graphics card.
A large copper sheet to cover it all will need a cardboard template, about 1/4 inch thick to absorb the heat and so it does not distort. (5mm thick.) Then off to your local stockist. If no copper, then aluminium will do quite nicely, especially if your system is being carried around. I always ask if I can rummage around the scrap bins, then buy anything likely for pennies.
I employ two ways to make GPU headers, the solid block and the built up version. Both work equally well, as they both have the same heat path. the solid block is better, as it gives a larger heat sink, should the system fail, but takes more engineering skill, and of course a big chunk of alloy. For those who only have access to a moderately thin sheets of alloy or copper, then a built up, sandwich version is also described later, but needing less engineering skill.
A large, square block of copper or aluminium will need to have
the coolant channels added. This is best done by marking out on
the sheet where you want your coolant to flow. Ideally, the
coolant will enter centrally over the centre of the GPU, then
flow outwards, evenly to the memory. Therefore marking out the
positions will allow a well designed water casing to be built
over the copper sheet.
Most graphics cards have a selection of holes perforating the
printed circuit board. Look for those equally spaced over the
memory chips and consider if this can be used to evenly clamp
the coolers on the memory on both sides of the card, so look for
a pair of equally opposing holes across the GPU for clamping the
main cooler. Even a thin bar of piano wire will be strong enough
to clamp them together using a spring and clamping sleeve on the
wire to maintain clamping pressure.
Now make a full size sketch of the proposed coolers. Decide
where the mountings and where any coolant and air entrapment
problems may occur. First drill the main mounting holes to
correspond with the graphics card mounting holes. Then lightly
mark out the GPU and memory positions. Also ensure suitable
clearance for the various components such as capacitors.
Where there are dead spots in the metal block, there is room for
threaded holes for studs or screws into the heat sink sheet, and
these will allow a sandwich of plastic to be clamped over the
heat sink sheet. If you cannot tap a thread, then use
countersunk screws protruding from below the heat sink sheet.
These must be flush and not cause mounting problems. At least
four, preferably six studs will ensure the water jacket sandwich
will be secure.
To cheaply tap a thread, use a steel screw, then taper the ends
and cut a hacksaw slot, lengthways along two sides, to make an
improvised tap. This will suffice for soft metals such as copper
or aluminium if done slowly and carefully.
Ideally, a thick slab of alloy would be used to carve out the
water channels. Do not use plastic which may soften under heat,
such as the lower melting point thermo plastics, if you must,
then use thermo setting plastics.
As a thick sheet of plastic is not available for a water jacket,
then it is easier to build up a sandwich jacket using 'plastic
metal in a tube', available from most DIY and car shops. This
can be built up around a cardboard former, with cling film over
the copper sheet so it can be easily removed. This allows the
mould to be tidied up prior to assembly. If preferring to bond
to the copper or alloy, then simply bond it in place after
roughing up the surface and scrupulous cleaning. During this
process, the brass or plastic pipes must be inserted for best
coolant flow and any smaller air vents included.
If keen on soldering, then the jacket could be made in brass or
copper sheet. Use a high temperature plumbers solder if
possible.
If wanting to view the coolant flow, then a flange can be
moulded into the plastic metal, or soldered to the brass walls
to allow a glass sheet to be siliconed in place and then
clamped. A transparent cover is highly recommended, if only to
check that all is well.
Here is a basic diagram of a one piece GPU cooler, using a
copper sheet and plastic metal in a tube walls with glass cover.
The ones I build are not quite so neat, so a pretty picture is
preferred. The middle section is just some car body filler, used
to easily mould the water channels. If you have one plate over
the GPU and another over the memory, then just build it with an
interconnecting brass tubes for convenience.
Note: I have gone one step further and now mould the water
jacket directly into the CPU and memory chips, using brass
interconnecting tubes. But this is committing an expensive
graphics card to a terrible fate if it does not work as
expected.
Ideally the inlet will be directly over the GPU, or if room is
tight or using a glass cover, then from above as shown with the
black lines. Then the coolant flows around to the outlet at the
top, above the mid point between the memory banks. Making
internal baffles or coolant routes will ensure the coolant flows
past the GPU area, then across each memory bank in turn.
Always make sure the coolant flows in a single path. In this
case, into the centre, directly over the GPU, then up to the
right, down to the first memory bank, then exiting after the
second, upper memory bank. Making two exit paths from the GPU,
over two separate memory paths can allow one to flow easier than
the other. It may make little difference in practice, but the
chance for reduced flow in one channel will be the one that
limits the overclocking potential.
Warning: Always remember that most graphics cards are positioned in mini towers, with the GPU on the LOWER side of the graphics card printed circuit board, so the bubbles will always want to be beside the hot spot in the heatsink and this is very dangerous. Never allow air bubbles to reside near the GPU or memory areas. This is the reason I now always mount my motherboards upside down on my home made custom cases, not dissimilar to BTX format and for better cooling of all components. Having the CPU low, the pump low and the radiator low, obviously makes for less piping, less head for the water to be pumped up to and a lot tidier. For more details, see my website on designing and building your own computer cases.
If the inlet pipe was to enter the GPU cooler from above, as
shown with the black line, through the side wall, rather than
the glass cover, then it could be positioned with its internal
end lower in the casing, to give full flow though the GPU area,
and also make for neater external plumbing. As the pipe would
block the flow, the pipe would enter to the left in the picture.
Another alternative would be to perforate, or slot the end of
the pipe to more effectively direct the entering coolant over
the GPU area. Just use your imagination for the many
possibilities.
As plumbing is awkward, always have the pipes to and from the
graphics card easy to mount and plumb in position. Also make
them securely mounted to prevent unwanted distortion on the
chips, form strained external piping. This will require making
small brackets to restrain the pipes on the graphics card, and
must always be done very carefully to prevent GPU track damage,
yet maintain secure entry and exit piping. I find this the
hardest part, so always make sure you can build up a nice
soldered bracket for the pipes to and from the graphics card.
If you allow the coolant to flow in two directions to the outlet
pipe, such as splitting the flow from the GPU to each memory
bank, then this is asking for trouble, as there will always be
an easier and a harder way through and one bank of memory may
run warmer. If large differences in flow, then you can only
overclock to the warmer running memory. You could simply make
one big water area and cool all at once, but as the GPU is the
hottest, then being able to put the coolest coolant straight
over the 'hot spot' will help reduce the GPU temperature a
little more.
You will also see in this example, I have included a small vent
slot in the top of the GPU area, to allow any bubbles to vent
up, out of the system. This may not be needed, as most GPU's are
mounted horizontally in a mini tower case. In a desktop or micro
system, it is a vitally worthwhile consideration should the
graphics card be used in such positions where the unit is
mounted vertically. The point to note here, is to know your
system first, then eliminate or prevent problems before they
arise.
Once the walls of the sandwich are made, a final layer is added
and while still drying, the upper plastic or glass sheet is
added with a piece of cling film to give a perfectly flat
sealing joint face and also show up any thin areas.
Then the central part is bonded to the copper sheet with
silicone sealant, in the same way as fishtanks, then the upper
cover or clear plastic sheet added. If using a glass cover, then
an alloy strap or plate is used to keep the glass in place, or a
series of spring loaded edge clips, for which you will have
decided the overall thickness beforehand, or simply remove the
glass and file down or build up the thickness to suit. If
plastic, then this can be drilled for the screws from the copper
or alloy base to align with holes drilled though the upper
cover. Minimal retaining forces are another advantage of a low
pressure system.
When all is correct, then the cooler can be tested before actual
use in the computer and pressure tested by plugging one hole and
using a long length of pipe about eight feet to give an eight
foot head of water to pressure test the device. Hang it out the
window or hang the top of the pipe from the ceiling, then allow
to stand for an hour to check for leaks.
I check my systems by submerging in a bowl of water and then
blowing into it to look for air bubbles which are a more
reliable check of any leakage.
If all works well, then it can be lapped prior to use and
assembled onto the graphics card, using thermal transfer paste
and careful tightening down. If all has been done well, there
will be no distortion and the heat transfer from GPU and memory
will be perfect. When replaced in the computer, it should be
tested over many hours and checked for leaks, as the heat and
poor mounting may cause some distortion.
Most graphics cards are mounted horizontally, with the best bits
on the bottom. Viewing the coolant flow through the graphics
card header is difficult, so a small plastic mirror placed at an
angle underneath will help check the system is working properly
and add an extra feature to the 'modded' machine. Including a
white LED will also help. In a few expensive designs, you may
have to replace the fan, to fool the graphics card or drivers
that it is being cooled.
A single large GPU cooler makes for a neat design, but is often
not possible.
The height of the various chips or a rouge capacitor is always a
common problem. It is possible to buy an identical capacitor for
pennies, - look for the capacity in microfarads, and the working
voltage, - then solder on the new capacitor, but use longer legs
to reposition it to clear the cooler, and sleeve the legs with
plastic tubes from domestic or car wiring.
Therefore, three cooler units, one for the GPU and two for the
memory units may be needed. This is very difficult and takes an
awful amount of hard work, but is removable, should it not work
as intended. This is engineering and most people will simply not
want to play this game, so easier options are mentioned later.
On standard cases with the graphics card in the poor position, I
prefer this system, as it give the best cooling, with minimal
bubble entrapment. Only on BTX format do I use other cooling
systems. It is often easier to build your own BTX format case
than do the following.
The trick of course, is to make a drawing of the GPU and memory
layout, draw in the blocks, then decide the coolant flow to
eliminate any bubbles, then ensure they all connect up easily
without any excessive piping. Then decide the best placing for
the pipes from the card to your radiator and pump. This is not
so easy, especially if the graphics card is mounted vertically
as in a micro system or desktop. In a mini tower, the graphics
card is often horizontal, so the bubbles will probably work
their way out. But never assume the bubbles will all leave
happily. See the picture of all three items, below.
For simpler cooler units, just use a thick slab of aluminium (or
if rich, copper) and drill holes for the inlet and exit pipes,
which can be a tight push fit brass tube.
There are many forms of drilled metal slug. The simplest is a
single hole - In one end and out the opposite end, but this does
not give much time for the heat to transfer to the coolant.
Doubling the distance will double the potential heat transfer.
Therefore an internal U in the block may help. A more complex
design is a Z layout with three lengthways holes, but this is
not recommended as it resists the flow too much and is only
suitable for the GPU block.
The Z design illustrated will have problems venting any bubbles
unless placed to allow any trapped bubbles to flow upwards. You
may notice that in the Z block I have added two very small cross
holes which will help expel air even when the unit is placed in
any position.
The drawing shows a transparent unit for illustration only. Do
not attempt to build a heat block from clear plastic nor glass,
as the heat transfer and material properties are not suitable.
The best GPU cooler would ideally have lots of internal
channels, as shown in the CPU block under test in the picture
opposite.
Many internal holes present a large surface area between block
and coolant, to give greater heat transfer for the design. This
is only possible if you are good at drilling straight holes. If
your holes wander while drilling, then use a new drill bit, or
sharpen your drill ends more accurately. Always ensure that the
total cross section of the cross-drillings is slightly larger
than the bore of the main coolant flow, so that the device does
not constrict coolant flow. More on drilling holes later.
You may happen to notice my butane powered 'Prescott CPU emulator' in the picture. After many minutes, only a three degree rise was observed and was considered more than adequate for this approximate 400 watt heat source, - despite using a small waterwall radiator without active cooling and the pump running at very low speed. Yes, this 'simple' drilled block of alloy works a lot nicer than many CPU and GPU headers available commercially.
The illustration shows a design allowing all three items - GPU
and two memory blocks to be positioned for best flow when
mounted vertically. This can be hard to make and fit, so only
attempt the memory if the main block was really easy to make.
The plumbing must be neat, yet not interfere with the AGP or
PCIe socket. The PC motherboard and case is designed to take
very long cards, so the pipes could exit at the rear of the card
for low profile desktops, but this brings the pipes close to the
front of the case. In practice, the pipes often exit from the
top of the graphics card, so the plumbing remains short and
neat.
The headers must not be obstructed by the various capacitors and
other items on the graphics card. I occasionally reposition
awkward capacitors to make life easier. Ideally, both pipes
would enter from the same rearward or upper side, according to
your machine, but this is not always easy. See later.
The layout is typical of most graphics cards, with the memory
banks to the right and also above the GPU. In this example, the
coolest coolant enters the GPU first, as this is the hottest
item, then exits high, to ensure no bubbles occur in this
critical area. The coolant then flows first through one memory
bank then the other, exiting at the top, where any potential
bubbles could be seen to exit. The first memory block will cause
a bubble trap and so this has a small cross drilling to allow
any air to vet from the inlet side to the exit, but the small
hole is not big enough to allow significant amounts of coolant
to bypass the block.
You will note that I have not thought this sketch through well
enough, as if I was clever, I would have extended the upper edge
of the lower memory lump, and not have to have soldered up a
brass pipe with an angle bend or need to use a curved plastic
pipe. See small black lines. Luckily, small alloy blocks are
cheap if you know where to look, as they are often scrap items
from an engineering firm. My latest design uses a single L block
with multiple channels. Therefore always think things through
beforehand, because pencil and paper is far mightier than the
hacksaw and drill and far cheaper too.
The other design point is making all the inlet and exit pipes
line up, with a little gap between them. This gap is to keep
plumbing neat, but still allow a small amount of flexibility in
the plastic piping between each component, so that each item
will be able to lie perfectly flat over their respective chips
when clamped or bonded into position. If very close, then make
the connections a single brass pipe, with a loose fit, and then
epoxy the tube in place, with the coolers positioned over the
GPU and memory for perfect alignment while the epoxy sets. If
you do not like the short stub pipes, then simply mount the
pipes outwards, then use short U bends of plastic piping.
With my latest designs, I reposition capacitors then simply carve just one large block of alloy for the memory on each side, then decide the best drill holes for the position of the card. After lapping the bases, use 2 part epoxy 'metal in a tube' to connect the tubes between GPU and memory. While setting, I clamp the items in position to allow for the differences in height for perfect heat transfer.
Once the design is decided, the alloy GPU block is drilled. As
drilling neatly aligned holes is a pain for beginners, then
start by making centre punch marks, an old nail will do. Then
drill smaller holes, as these can be drilled larger later,
especially if they do not wander from the intended path. Also
drill the larger inlet and exit holes using a small drill, as
there is a booby trap of drilling through the larger holes
first, will cause the cross drillings to go off line. Therefore
drill the many small cross holes first, then the main inlet and
exit drill holes, all using a small drill bit. Then drill these
holes to the required, larger diameter, where the smaller holes
will act as a guide.
If your cross drill holes wander and cross into each other,
don't worry, it just makes for a slightly more interesting cross
coolant flow. Carefully clean out all holes and blow and wash
clean. Dry thoroughly by warming, then plug the cross holes with
alloy slugs, and / or epoxy resin or two-part, instant metal in
a tube adhesive. Then clean out the tubes again, using a drill
down the inlet and exit holes to clean out any excessive
adhesive. Finally insert the brass inlet and exit pipes, using a
snug push fit and more adhesive or instant metal. Pressure test
by blowing air into the item whist underwater, as bubbles show
up any small holes.
Tip: Use a little washing up soap to help 'wet' the internal
surfaces when cleaning through, to help the bubbles leave the
block easier. If the internals have an oily surface, then the
small bubbles may remain during use in the computer.
If the GPU block cannot allow the water pipes to enter from the side, then you can place them at an angle, but this will need epoxy resin or 'plastic metal in a tube' alloy plugs to fill the holes. Always make sure the brass connecting pipes have sufficient length into the GPU alloy block to support them securely. Alternatively make tightly bent brass pipes by heating, then filling them with solder, bending over a soft wooden former, the melting out the solder. If you are making a supremely neat system, then fit the CPU and GPU header inlet and exit pipes last of all, so that any mounting of bends can be refined.
Very carefully lap the mating faces of the block on a piece of
glass, using some brass polish or other abrasive cleaner. This
will give a perfectly flat and clean surface for the heat paste.
The pipes can now be connected to the pump and checked for good
flow through the blocks. A simple syphoning test using two pipes
and a jug of water will do the job, as for primary testing
mentioned earlier.
Connect up all the bits and measure into a container over a
minute. If it is appreciably lower than the intended flow, then
perhaps you have too much drag in the system and be constricted.
If you have a 1 litre container and testing over the sink then
you can fill the container to check against the time taken.
Mounting the header can be a problem.
If finding a suitable spring clip is difficult, then make your
own. I deconstruct the cheap little spring loaded plastic DIY
clamps for their springs, (usually four for a quid), then make
alloy or steel arms to use these springs. The final items are
low profile and the springs are available in many sizes. If
wanting to experiment first, then simply use the clips as
bought, but always make sure they clamp over the centre of the
GPU and memory, and if this is over glass or plastic then do not
use a strong spring.
Where spring clips such as Terry Clips; flat as used for
draughtsman drawing boards, or curved for holding tools.
If other mechanical restraining devices are not easy to retain
the cooling blocks, then they can be bonded in place with
thermal epoxy resin.
As glue is a one-way process, then it is better to use thermal
paste on each item, but employ a dab of epoxy on the inner
corner of each chip, which will allow a reasonable chance for
removal without damage. Do not use superglue, as this sets
instantly. This collection of items will need careful
positioning and need an individual weight over each to ensure
they are perfectly aligned to the chips while the epoxy sets
hard. The faster setting five minute epoxy is less strong than
true epoxy, but is plenty strong enough for holding this in
place with a dab in the corners, with the thermal paste in the
centre of each chip. It will also allow easier removal at a
later date when selling the card at a car boot sale with the old
cooling fan carefully replaced.
An option which is believed to work, is to mix thermal epoxy
with equal amounts of normal thermal paste, to give a less
strong bonding process.
The GPU is usually capable of being clamped in place with
mechanical restraints acting through the printed circuit board.
If making a mechanical clamp device and not bonding in place,
then always add a central dimple, and a corresponding centre
punch in the clamp, so the cooler remains accurately in
position.
Personally, I prefer to glue just onto the inner corners of the
memory chips, as this allows for differing expansion of the
components with minimal distortion then clamp while setting. As
there are often two memory chips, simply gluing just the inner
corners will usually do the trick, but GPU coolers are best
clamped using through bolts and a spring loaded arm. Don't
forget to lap the alloy bases first and a dab of thermal grease.
This kind of stuff is not expensive, apart from the copper sheets or alloy blocks. The rest is simple hobby stuff, with a touch of engineering and common sense. Total cost should not exceed a fiver.
The picture of the graphics card also shows the suitability for
making the memory block as a large L shape of alloy for
convenience, but only if all the memory chips are level with
each other and you have a spring clip which will allows for
different expansion rates.
As can be seen, the interconnecting pipes are short, so full
length plastic pipes will be needed, and these are best retained
by using steel or copper wire to make three turns then twist the
ends for a secure seal. Do not attempt to reduce the gaps, as
this is needed to ensure the blocks seat perfectly on their
chips. A minimum of 5mm is usually needed, especially between
GPU and memory blocks. If possible, simply reposition any
obstructing capacitors and build a large single memory block. A
large L block is possible if your drilling is accurate. If not,
then drilling from both ends to meet in the middle is easier,
plus blocking both ends. Never let the brass pipe inserts block
off the coolant flow, but always make sure the ends are
chamfered where needed.
Another aspect of this design is to decide the routes of the
pipes to and from the graphics card.
The main point to note is to ALWAYS sit down and make a full
size drawing of the graphics card, the position and height of
the GPU, memory and any obstructions. Then work out where any
plumbing can be positioned, in a manner which can actually be
physically made, in a manner which will work efficiently,
reliably and safely.
When your coolers are ready, then carefully lap the surfaces so they will be perfectly flat and thus transfer the maximum heat through the thermal paste. Lapping is done by gradually smoothing the mounting surface to a perfectly flat surface to mount onto the chip. There are lapping kits which cost money and consist of gradually finer sheets of abrasive paper. I simply make an initial flattening using fine wet and dry, while it is placed on a sheet of plate glass, which is perfectly flat, then I use a commonly available metal polish. It's important to keep the metal block level when lapping, otherwise it will become slightly domed, although this is not a problem as the centre of the dome will be perfectly positioned for the reasonable heat transfer, but it is better to have perfect heat transfer from across the whole chip. To maintain flatness, use plate glass and use a small figure of eight motion, using all the plate glass, with the pressure always acting in the centre of the block.
The alloy cooling block has a problem, as many people do not have access to such blocks of metal, nor are very good at neat drilling. It also needs a strong mechanical retention device to hold the alloy in position on the motherboard. Its main advantage is that it is easily removable so you can return to the original manufacturers heat sink.
Another alternative is to make a simple plate to mount on the GPU and memory, then build up walls and a lid.
An easy option is to make simple brass or copper plates to mount
onto the memory chips, then solder a carefully crafted brass
pipe to these, so the coolant draws away the heat.
A single, long, snaking pipe is ideal for the memory chips,
flattened slightly where it passes over the memory pads, so a
little more heat is transferred with plenty of solder for the
heat path. These are much easier to make, but needs to be done
carefully, with a neat, flat wooden jig to ensure the soldering
process keeps all the plates perfectly level, followed with a
little lapping for the heat sink paste.
To make a snaking brass pipe, fill the pipe with lead or solder.
The brass pipe can be crimped at one end, then heated as the
lead is poured into the pipe. Then the pipe can be carefully
bent around a wood former, until it passes over all four memory
chips. The pipe is then heated to remove the lead and is a 14th
century trumpet making technique.
Then the memory heat sink pads are laid out on a nice, flat
wooden block, the pipe laid over and heavily soldered.
Such cards may need over clocking above and beyond the 'call of duty' and a far cry' from the manufacturers standard specs and 'doom' may ensue.
Only those who want to push an old card will be open to a little
further, er, development as mentioned next. It is also much
easier and far cheaper to build and far more efficient if done
well. But it needs total commitment on the part of the card.
If you are running your GPU close to burn out, then you may wish
to 'cool direct', but only if NOT mounted in a mini tower
fashion. The motherboard must be used upside down, BTX style.
The following has NO room for any bubbles.
I place a piece of plasticiene over the centre of the processor
and memory chips, such that a wall can be built direct on the
chips. Then build them up with interconnecting tubes for direct
water cooling, - WITHOUT an intermediate alloy or copper heat
skink. This gives direct water-cooling.
You must ensure the water is permanently against the chips,
otherwise they WILL burn out, especially the GPU, so clean the
surface of the chips appropriately.
WARNING: Some silicone dies are set above the body of the chip,
so if you can imagine it upside down in a mini tower case, then
there is a very dangerous place around it for air to accumulate.
If so, then leave well alone, or use a desktop case, or like me,
simply turn your motherboard upside down, BTX style in a home
made case.
WARNING: Some graphics chips have surface mount capacitors and
on their upper surfaces, along with some laser cut connections.
Therefore it is important to prevent these from water, so apply
a little lacquer.
Place a block of plasticine onto the chips which can later be
removed, then build up a wall using a non conductive paste such
as hard setting resin or 'plastic metal in a tube'. At least 70
percent of the memory chip upper surface must be open to the
water, but in most cases, the wall can be built up on the
surrounding mounting area. A slight taper, plus grease or cling
film helps remove it after the wall has set. Perhaps you may
wish to make a neat little wall first, and then bond this in
place.
If you want to get really sexy with this system, then look up
the art of 'fluidics', which was important when I got a job
designing some or other cooling stuff for nukler reactors.
I never touch any GPU silicon, but build the wall around the
larger surrounding mounting plate, although I apply a smear of
silver thermal grease to protect the silicon from long term
corrosion and the coolant is always distilled water.
I prefer to slightly rough up the plastic surface of the memory to make a better adhesion of the plastic metal in a tube. I recommend that you study the memory mounting closely, as some are hidden surface mounted, some are still using legs. Either way, you must prevent any non insulating material does not intrude between the chip connections. If room is tight, use a small bead of silicone sealant around the lower edge first, to seal the electrical connections, then use plastic metal in a tube on the actual chip. This way, any conductive materials will not short out any memory legs or circuitry, should a leak occur and drain into the soldered memory chip connections. Some hair lacquer over nearby components may also help after a very neat and clean build.
Always decide first where the pipes are to go for the layout in
your machine. I always cool the GPU first, then the memory in
such a way as to ensure good flow to all. A small vent pipe is
often required from the GPU to the outlet on the last memory
chip in the coolant run, to help remove air bubbles. If you
place the exit of the small vent pipe just inside the larger
exit pipe, then you have active purging.
Cut and layout the large bore pipes to make the most of your
card design. Some graphics cards have the GPU and memory at 45
degrees to enable a very clean coolant run in any position and
eliminate bubbles very easily. ALWAYS make sure they there can
be no air bubbles. - With alloy blocks, the chips will still
transport the heat from the chip surface and you can get away
with a few bubbles in the system. But in this design you do not
have this advantage, so there must be coolant against the face
of the chip at all times.
It is possible to lay your pipes in position first, possibly
squashing a brass tube to keep it all neat, then build up around
the tube. I seriously recommend you place the interconnecting
tubes close to the surface of the chips, as they will usually be
upside down in an ATX midi tower case, so any bubbles MUST be
removed easily. Careful pipe work pays dividends. Include
smaller venting pipes or channels where needed, as the card may
later be used in a micro system, desktop, ATX or BTX or special.
Another main point to be considered is to ensure the pipes are
able to take the physical handling force applied by the plastic
tubing to the pump and radiator. Rough handling when fitting the
interconnecting plastic pipes between pump and radiator can
cause problems. This can impart a high force and cause the
coolant channels to be cracked or pull away. Therefore always
fit a mechanical restraint for the exit and inlet piping to
prevent any force being applied to the channelling. Always try
pulling on the pipes to check before inserting the card in
position. Also check with a test run for leaks and safe coolant
flow and ensure perfect bubble removal in the intended
alignment.
When all the walls and tubes are built, you can then use more
paste on the walls, then use cling film and a sheet of glass for
an inspection covering. Then silicone sealant and preferably a
mechanical retaining bracket.
Although this seems a permanent solution, it can be carefully
removed if it does not work out too well. Carefully applying a
sanding disc by hand, then rubbing some fine sand paper over the
memory chips will allow the original heat sinks to be replaced.
The GPU surrounds will also need some neatness, but the GPU
silicon itself should never have been touched.
It is important that the positioning of the tubes is very easy
to get almost perfect, so the plumbing can be built to have
pipes positioned for both mini tower and desktop layouts.
WARNING: Remember that most GPU's in a miditower are upside
down, so be wary so that any bubbles will be away from the GPU.
If you over clock the GPU too far, then check for steam bubbles
by which time the chips have probably died. But the chips should
never be allowed to get beyond 60 degrees. If you push too far
and there are no bubbles, then at least you will know it was not
through lack of direct cooling.
It may seem a bit of a pain to regularly check the state of the
cooling for air entrapment over the GPU. The simple answer is
to temporarily stick an old web cam up close and add a light. If
it does not focus too well, then use a watchmakers eyepiece and
a splodge of blue tacky putty as used in offices.
More simply, adding an LED in the wall of the GPU and a small
plastic mirror at 45 degrees will allow the ultimate in GPU
'modding', where pretty lights are for proper and sincere
reasons for a 'bona fide' modded computer.
Inside the GPU hollow, I would include two white LED's connected
to the 5 volt rail to allow direct visual checking, plus a
couple of thermo sensors should things get hectic. Cheap LCD
digital temperature sensors for general purposes use can be run
from independent 1.5 volt systems for direct measurement. Buy a
handful when they are cheap.
You may want to put some heat sink clips on the larger capacitors too. They are available from electrical suppliers or make your own larger finned items using scissors to make a fined alloy device using scissors and a cola can, held in place with O rings or a nylon tie wrap.
This is not real modding, as it does not include pretty lights
or fans - and it is very naughty, because you may also
invalidate the manufacturers warranty :)
Please do not follow the above few paragraphs, even if you have
a spare graphics card that you wish to torture slowly and
constantly as if in Guatanamo Gulag. You know it's not right.
Have you been reading carefully like good little boys and girls ? Let's find out:
I'm unemployed and Anglo-Saxon, (gizzajob). For these sins, I
was unfortunately trained as a teacher of technology and design,
(B.Ed) and happen to have a science degree, (B.Sc) and HNC in
refrigeration, a registered engineer blah, blah etc, and been
modding computers since BBC'B' days, but like so many today, no
job in this once great country, but now a shit hole called
Britain.
So let's see if you have sense of humour too !
As a final test piece, here is a truly scrumptious X800 pro in a
micro case.
Please note that the graphics card has its cooler removed, but
only to expose the central GPU and the four memory chips on each
side for clarity. (4 memory chips on the reverse side too.) The
GPU is believed to use all its memory pipelines to XT spec by
joining the laser cut in the top right hand side of the GPU, and
has a bios flash to XT. 'Atitool' and 'Powerstrip' on the HDD
shows it may be in fear of being overclocked.
For five points, draw a possible route for the water-cooling
through the graphics card. Assume the plumbing exits at the rear
of the case.
For five points, consider where you would put the pump.
For ten points, choose the THREE best positions for the radiator
and the THREE types of fans which could be used.
Being such a small case, decide if you would you need any other
considerations.
Give yourself extra points if you do NOT use any expensive materials or processes.
You will also get points if you can over clock the machine to the fullest extent of its potential for under TEN quid. This must include a radiator and pump.
If you do really well, I'll promise not to recommend you for any daft GNVQ.
If you decide not to water-cool, - and that's valid too - then separate GPU and memory finned heat sinks could be used. The GPU would have its own fan, but if ducted well, then the memory fins on the GPU side can be cooled via the GPU fan, simply by adding cooling fins to the memory chips and cutting slots in the cooler to ensure they are in the draught. I would probably not risk shimming on this chip. A small fan such as an old 486 fan can be used for the memory chips on the other side, using some cardboard ducting from cool external air which ca