|
The Leisure
Connection Dossier - Issue 7 7 May 2011
With
so much information about LC on this website
it can be time consuming finding the leading
items. Now you can download a Word Document
or PDF with
key reports about LC. The dossier refers to
Audit Commission, council and media
sources. Items are listed under headings
that include Problems with Council Contracts,
Health & Safety, Cleaning & Hygiene,
Maintenance, Staffing, Price Increases,
and User Contract Issues. The current
version is Issue 7 published
7.5.11.
Headings from 2007 Headings from 2006
Headings from 2004
to 2005
|
|
Index for News Headings from January 2008
till now Dates on left are when
items were added to LCW. Dates on right are when
reports first
appeared.
|
6.6.11 Review Centre Thumbs Down for LC / Harpers October 2010
|
4.6.11 Dunstable - Grove Theatre Circle Tickets Withheld Until Stalls All Sold 24.2.11
|
26.5.11
E-Petition
set up following Inquest Into the Drowning of
Michelle Gellard at Blackwater Leisure
Centre 19.5.11
"The jury returned a verdict of accidental death.
Yet In May 2010 there was another incident of a
near drowning also involving a young girl swimming
at the same pool. This incident prompted the
Health and Safety Executive to serve an
enforcement notice under the Health and Safety at
Work Act 1974 against the swimming pool. Though
Michelle's death had been deemed accidental, I feel
strongly that some one must be held accountable
for the failure of Leisure Connection..."
To read more or sign the petition go www.ipetitions.com/petition/jfmg/
|
The inquest started on Monday 9 May 2011
and concluded a week later. This page
summarises coverage and provides links to articles
and radio reporting, including podcasts.
16.5.11 Inquest verdict ~ Accidental Death.
Family is pursuing a civil case against LC/Harpers
and their solicitor expects criminal proceedings to
follow.
HSE Inspector says their investigation is ongoing
and does not rule out a prosecution.
12.5.11 LC/Harpers
Operations Manager at Blackwater was ‘unaware’
that a duty manager had been allowing two
lifeguards to patrol the pool rather than four.
He also did not know how his name had got onto
pages of a key document for health and safety at
the centre.
10.5.11 Shortly before Michelle drowned the
lifeguards had been reduced from three to two
when the Normal Operating Procedure required
four. The Duty Manager believed he could use his
discretion to reduce the numbers when the pool
was not busy.
|
4.5.11 Maldon - Inquest
into drowning at Blackwater Leisure Centre
opens on May 9th 9.3.11
"Family
solicitor Peter Todd said: 'This case potentially
has significant implications for all those
involved in lifeguarding or managing a swimming
pool, and for parents of children using a
pool. It is important lessons are learned to
ensure this particularly distressing tragedy never
happens again.'”
|
23.3.11 West Devon
- Swimmers Complain About Lack of
Consultation over Closures
9.3.11
"What consultation? There hasn’t been any as
far as I am concerned," says Mr Kilpatrick.
"Customer forums were held... during which the
proposed changes to the pool timetables were
discussed," says LC/Harpers.
Jackie Jones, who swims six mornings a week, said to
claim any consultation had taken place with early
morning users of the pool was "a joke". "I’ve never
even heard of this user group."
"Who and when did they consult? We must be their
most regular and loyal 'group' so why didn’t they
consult with us, especially as we are the ones
affected?" said Mr Penrose.
|
18.3.11 Harrow - LC /
Harpers Fitness Loses
Harrow Leisure contract 18.3.11
"...problems in the past at the
leisure centre with customer complaints, spates
of thefts from lockers and cars, police closures
of Byron Hall and the discovery of unacceptable
levels of ammonia in the pool."
" |
12.1.11 Norwich - FOI
Documents reveal concerns various
A Quest report for December
2010 reveals that cleaning an issue on
previous visits.
Contract Meeting Minutes from August 2010 show
Council threatens "penalty clauses as per the
contract
will be considered if unacceptable delays in
repairs continue".
Plus - Mystery
shopper has an accident that is not recorded.
|
12.1.11 Oadby
& Wigston - FOI Documents reveal
Council's continuing concerns
various
"The current issues regarding
the contract relate to the catering provision,
noise, cleaning contract,
general management arrangements, contract
enforcement and profit share.” Another document
raises
concerns about the GP Referral Scheme.
|
8.1.11 Harrow - Council asked for
LC/Harpers Contract Manager to be Removed 6.1.11
|
8.1.11 Harrow - Spate of thefts from
leisure centre 4.8.10 |
25.11.10 St Albans -
Service closed but LC/Harpers still gets paid?
25.11.10
|
15.10.10 Ponteland - A lifeguard
short for three hours 25.8.10 |
9.10.10 OFSTED - Worrying
issues raised by inspections of childcare
facilities at LC/Harpers Centres 2008 - 2010
- "During the
inspection, two acting managers were running
the provision. Neither member of staff holds
appropriate qualifications for the post nor is
there a named deputy with an appropriate
qualification who is able to take charge in
the absence of the manager. Lack of training
and experience has a negative impact on the
provision's ability to meet children’s
individual needs effectively."
- "No evidence could be
located regarding criminal record bureau
checks."
- "...insufficient
staffing levels to ensure that children are
supervised safely."
- "No clear systems in
place to promote good hygiene practice..."
- "Children bring water
bottles from home. However, once they have
drunk this, they do not always have access to
fresh drinking water."
- "The programme of
activities is at times unsuitable for children
in the early years age group. The staff’s lack
of understanding of the Early Years Foundation
Stage framework results in a poorly planned
environment.
|
29.10.10 Ely - LC Manager's
inability to test for chemicals and the
excessive chlorination that led to physical
injuries 1.9.10
Documents obtained from East
Cambridgeshire District Council under FOI have
revealed serious health and safety breaches at Ely's
Paradise Pool last year. Over chlorination was
linked to peeling genitalia, irritated eyes and skin
and one bather's costume changed colour.
Council Senior Managers received a rapport but no
action minuted. Complaints continue.
|
1.10.10 Maldon -
HSE Prohibition Notice re Insuffcient
Lifeguards at Pool Already Under
Investigation 1.9.10
Less than two years after the
drowning of a seven-year old at the LC/Harpers
operated Blackwater Leisure Centre, the
Health and Safety Executive has issued an
Immediate Prohibition Notice following another
incident.
|
20.09.10 Peterlee - Pool Closure Not
Reported on LC Website 20.9.10
|
15.09.10 North Kesteven - Report on LC /
Harper's Performance 14.7.10
Issues include maintenance and cleanliness.
|
6.9.10 Daventry -
Council Unhappy with LC's handling of
contract closure 13.7.10
A Council report reviewing
leisure maintenance found fault with LC/Harpers.
" Client-contractor
meeting minutes also indicate that various items
of remedial work were identified and Leisure
Connection undertook to address them e.g. the
pool underwater lights. It is also apparent that
at least some of these works were not actually
undertaken... It
is apparent that Leisure Connection had not
maintained the building in the condition it was
required to, and that the Council had been
unable to ensure that it did so... "
|
1.09.10 St Albans - Further
complaints about Westminster Lodge pool
temperature 31.7.10
“Even the teaching
staff – let alone parents and children – find the
temperature unacceptable, and our instructor urged
us all to complain to reception. It is a teaching
pool and therefore the temperature should be right
for a comfortable learning environment.”
|
12.8.10 Ely - Council receive "numerous
complaints" about centre 12.8.10 Comments from
three parents:
- The changing rooms absolutely stank
of urine and there was black mould around the
side of the pool. There’s no way I’m
going back there – swimming pools and changing
areas should be hygienic places, not
filthy."
- "The changing rooms and everywhere
in general is dirty."
- “I will never return there, we
should not put up with such disgusting
facilities.”
|
29.7.10 Ely - Anger as pool again
closed, plus complaints about cleaning &
facilities 8.7.10
Even though the Children's
Pool has been closed for almost 3 weeks, the
LC/Harpers website fails to mention this.
|
27.4.10 Quest Survey - Flaws
reported in Lesiure Centre Quality Assurance
Scheme
September 2009
"Centres run by large
contractors have too much ability to score highly
through the use of corporate paperwork when the
centre itself does not perform highly."
|
26.4.10 Harrow - No loos and
hot water and no warning on websites
26.4.10
|
16.4.10 Harpenden / Maldon
- Lifeguards sacked after rescue & HSE
Blackwater Investigation14.4.10 |
1.4.10 Maldon - Nine months
on and Cricketers Still Stumped By LC
3.6.09
|
25.3.10 Uttlesford
- Councillors thought LC discount
for faulty pool was "insufficient". 17.3.10
Flagship PFI
pool built in 2002 closed for 7 months due to
leaks. LC blames "age" of expansion
joints!
|
21.3.10 Brent - Vale Farm
Refurbishment Finishes Two Months Late and Has A
Leak Already 21.3.10
|
21.1.10 Ely
- Anger At Four Week Pool Closure Due to
Faults 21.1.10
"...it
has been run so badly in these last weeks that I
won't be going back again."
|
19.1.10 South Kesteven - What Lies Behind
Procrastination and Complaints 8.1.10
255 user complaints
were made about the Grantham centre last year,
inlcuding 30 about cleaning in the changing rooms,
74 about maintenance, and 45 about equipment. The
Council issued 29 rectification notices.
LC / Harpers spent £400k seeking approval for the
charitable status of a leisure trust but failed.
Why did the application take so long?
|
1.1.10 Everyday
Swim Final Report - Commercial Short
Termism a Barrier July 2008
A three-year study of a scheme to
encourage swimming, which included two
LC/Harpers run centres, had some interesting
comments about private contractors in
general. The
report noted:
"The nature of private sector contractors
operating local authority swimming pools creates
a short term focus. The terms of contracts
pre-date Everyday Swim and therefore the project
has to fit around the contracts. Managers are
judged and focussed primarily on their unit's
'bottom line' and this can lead to the adoption
of short term approaches. Managers are loathe to
make changes to their programmes and to displace
sessions that perform acceptably in financial
terms with sessions whose returns are unknown.
The two principles of innovation and
sustainability have been perceived as
potentially conflicting by some partners."
|
30.12.09 Cambourne - Charity set to
take over project after LC/Harper's repeated
delays
28.11.09
|
23.12.09 Milton Keynes - LC "had not taken
all reasonable measures open to it to
prevent the escape of waste"10.9.09
|
20.12.09 OFSTED -
More worrying reports on childcare and
education standards at LC/Harpers Managed Centres" 2008 & 2009
"Managers
are
ineffective in organising the staff to care for
and safeguard children. There was not a suitably
qualified ‘person in charge’ on site and at times,
children are left in the sole charge of a student.
This is a breach of the requirements for
registration."
|
18.12.09 Grantham "Mother
fears staffing cuts at Leisure Centre could
compromise child safety" 17.12.09
|
29.11.09 Grantham
- Journal "Security
cut at the Meres - even though yobs are running
amok" 27.11.09
"And now it has been revealed
that the one security guard contracted to
alleviate anti-social behaviour during evenings
and peak times has been shown the door.
One distraught mother contacted the Journal on
Monday after intimidation by teenage thugs left
her shaken. The anonymous parent said: "The
place is over-run by yobs effing and blinding.
On my way in last night, they were jumping on
the car park barrier and shouting terrible,
obscene things at me and my child." ... The
news came as more readers got in touch to vent
their anger at the "disgraceful" facilities
following last week's Journal investigation."
|
29.11.09 Brent - Vale Farm
Showers Excessively Hot Over Several Days 27.11.09
|
21.11.09 Grantham - Journal exposes
Meres Leisure Centre - "filthy, smelly,
vile, unruly dive' 20.11.09
"READERS are
fed up to the back teeth with conditions at
Grantham's Meres Leisure Centre. They say it's
filthy, smelly and overrun with unruly kids. So
the Journal went undercover to find out the
truth - and showed the evidence to leisure
centre bosses. Over the past five weeks, the
Journal has gone at varying times three times a
week armed with a camera and notebook to record
its findings.
"We found a litter-strewn changing room, mouldy
shower heads and teenage yobs running riot. The
stench of urine in the changing room was
sometimes overwhelming, the pool temperatures
felt cold and the jacuzzi and adjoining splash
pool were open only once..."
|
21.11.09 Brent - Council
and Harpers / LC disagree on start date for
refurbishment 21.11.09 |
6.9.09 Castle Morpeth -
Charged almost £200 by Harpers Fitness despite
leaving two years ago 11.10.09 |
27.8.09 Harrow - 3 Damning Health &
Safety Audits in 4 Years 2007
A 2007 report listing major
failures in basic H&S at a Harrow centre
operated by LC has come to light. As well as the
reports from 2005 and 2009, and 2008 police
criticisms of the company, the 2007
report refers to an earlier H&S
prosecution. Among the horrors discovered in 2007
were: insufficient staff, including lifeguards;
missing duty managers; national procedures that
did not work locally: dirty kitchen; unsupervised
children’s area; and “The standard of cleanliness
is poor; that coupled with a low standard of
maintenance makes the place seem drab and
unhygienic.”
“The operations manager had
been on a pool management course but appeared to
be unclear about the significance of the pool
readings. At times the pool readings were outside
safe operations parameters but these were not
picked up or dosing etc adjusted to bring these
back in line. Readings had been filled in but it
is questionable whether all were actual readings
or assumed. On some shifts, readings had been
missed completely."
|
| 27.8.09 Mole Valley- "Members' anger at sports
centre closure" 27.8.09 |
| 23.8.09 Milton Keynes - Council to
terminate LC Contracts 21.7.09 |
7.7.09 Harrow - "Leisure Centre Slammed
for H&S Risks"
22.7.09
“The kitchen for public hire
was extremely dirty and ill-kept There were also
clear breaches of food hygiene rules and codes of
good practice… dirty sinks and toilets, week-old
layers of oil and fat on kitchen cookers, broken
fire doors… no written safety procedures are in
place for receiving deliveries of chemicals for
the swimming pool … tests on the level of
chemicals in the pool were at times outside safe
levels and at other times missing completely."
|
| 15.7.09 Berwick -
Developments after LC pulled out at short notice
15.7.09 |
7.7.09 Leisure Contractors' List Three Years Out
of Date 7.7.09
The Leisure Management Contractors'
Association website has a summary
of member contracts that is now three years
old. Even when it first apeared in July 2006 it was
inaccurate, as LC had stopped working in
some of the centres listed under their name.
This hopelessly out of date information would seen
to contradict LMCA first objective "To
promote at all times a professional image for the
leisure industry."
How hard would it be to update this list once a
year?
|
3.6.09 Maldon - Cricketers
Stumped By LC Charges 3.6.09
|
3.6.09 Windscale
to Sellafield? What's behind the new focus given
to Harpers? 3.6.09
Is it just me or do you get the
feeling that the Leisure Connection brand is being
downplayed and Harpers Fitness being pushed
harder? Go to www.leisureconnection.co.uk
and Harpers features at the top of the home page.
Click on "Leisure Sport and Fitness" and you
arrive at http://www.harpersfitness.co.uk/ Don’t bother looking for
centres at the old website; all the LC venues
are now at Harpers – not that the old homepage
tells you this.
What could have prompted these
changes? In the nuclear and other industries,
disaster management is often a factor in
rebranding. Is LC bracing itself for an even more
serious dent to its public image? PB
|
| 9.5.09 Harpers - Two Customers
ShareTheir Disappointed Experiences Sept 08 & Jan 09 |
| 17.4.09 Spalding - Will swim pool be any
cleaner? 14.4.09 |
| 13.4.09 Oadby - Hope at last
for residents disturbed by noise from LC Venue
10.4.09 |
| 10.4.09 Harrow -
Allegations of filthy changing rooms 17.1.09 |
| 7.4.09 Spalding - Central government
free swimming leads to new charges 7.4.09 |
| 20.3.09 Brent -
Lifeguarding Improvements 20.3.09 |
28.2.09 LC
finally has new Chief Executive 24.2.09
Six weeks
after LCW reported that Graham Farrant was
leaving, the Danoptra website announced Richard
Millman, its Group Strategy Direct would take
over. As of 28 February there is no announcement
on LC's website of the departure of CE or
replacement. Danoptra owns LC. |
| 28.2.09 Harrow -
"Chemical Incident" shuts Leisure Centre 27.2.09 |
| 11.2.09 Cambourne
- LC's "promise" of new centre in 2008 delayed
yet further - now 2010? 11.2.09 |
| 9.2.09 Spalding - pool changing area
'filthy and mouldy' 5.2.09 |
|
30.1.09 St
Albans - "Out-of-order lift sinks disabled Ken's
pool visits" 30.1.09
|
|
30.1.09
Stoke
Mandeville - "Faulty equipment bars disabled
swimmers from the home of Paralympics"
29.1.09
|
| 11.1.09 Anger as Pool Restricts
Voucher Swimming 5.1.09 |
| 11.1.09 LC Loses Another
Chief Executive 5.1.09 |
| 24.12.08 Issue 6 of Leisure
Connection Dossier now available 24.12.08 |
| 2.12.08 Harrow
- Councillor concerned that
leisure car park "will remain a hot bed of
crime and disorder" 1.12.08 |
| 26.11.08
Harrow
-
Police lambast LC after continuing problems
26.11.08
POLICE
had to shut down one of the largest entertainment
venue in Harrow amid fears the management had lost
control.... after a fight involving up to 50
young people broke out inside the hall during the
event. ...Sergeant Carl Davis...said Byron Hall
and the adjoining Harrow Leisure Centre has a
“consistent problem with crime and disorder”, and
pointed the finger squarely at Leisure Connection
for not doing enough to tackle the problem. He
added managers have “stalled, dithered, dawdled,
and smoke-screened” over a number of years to
avoid putting in adequate security measures, such
as CCTV alarm systems, and employing enough
bouncers, as requested by the police.
|
| 24.11.08 Credit Crunch - How
recession impacts LC, a leisure centre and
supplier November 2008 |
| 22.11.08 Brent - "Dangerous
chemicals closed down pool" 20.11.08 |
| 7.11.08 Dunstable
- Public protest against LC's takeover of
play area 6.11.08 |
6.11.08 Harrow - LC's management
of centre under fire 6.11.08
Residents are calling for a change of
management after problems at Harrow Leisure
Centre... complaints ranging from poor
maintenance to lack of security...
Harrow Council ... said the
building is in a state of disrepair but wanted
to replace it, a project scrapped when
funding fell through... ...a
swimmer at the centre said they should develop
rather than scaring people off. "I'd like to see
them replace the current contractors with people
who would get the place up and running like they
should.”
The Councillor
responsible said he knew there were problems.
“They've got a contract for two more years and
if I terminate that contract before then I will
need money to buy them out.... I'm not
going to spend a lot of money to buy them out of
an old building.” He said
his department told Leisure Connection
that the council is not responsible for its
staffing problems and the company itself must
solve them.
|
5.11.08
Brent - Council email
reveals that mutiple failings led to chlorine
incident April 2008
“The (monitoring) sheets used by
Vale Farm are not fit for purpose “ “…no audit
programme of how staff are performing the
tasks…” Testing
tablets had no expiry date. Manufacturer not contacted
after failure. “What
happens to these reports was my next question.
Again blank faces. It seems no one apart from
the head office sees these reports.” “…no one had
actually read the (health improvement) notice
to see what it entailed…” “The gradual rise
(in chlorine readings) should have been
observed. Because of some of the above
failures this did not take place. At this
point I stated that for all I know these
figures could just be made up. This might be a
strong possibility.”
|
4.11.08 Cambourne - Opening of new
centre now 14 months later than first announced 04.11.08
|
| 4.11.08 Oadby - Residents 17 year battle to
reduce noise of social events at leisure centre
21.8.08 |
23.10.08
Harrow
- Police lash out at LC's
lack of security 23.10.08
Sergeant
Davis wrote: “It has consistenly been apparent
that the premises attracted criminality. The
management of this premises by the licence
holders has ensured the failure to take
appropriate steps to prevent crime and disorder,
prevent public nuisance, promote public safety
and failed to promote the objectives of the
protection of children from harm.”
|
| 21.10.08 South Holland - Survey finds LC's
leisure contract "flawed" August 2007 |
| 10.10.08 Maldon - Recordings
of Drowning Emergency Calls Removed from
Web 10.10.08 |
| 3.10.08 St Albans - LC ban on snorkels challenged
2.10.08 |
| 28.9.08 Spalding - After more complaints further LC promises to improve 24.7.07 |
| 21.9.08 Oadby & Wigston -
Back to basics review by LC after Council notes
complaints 12.5.08 |
| 18.9.08 Stoke
Mandeville - Stadium criticised
for 'run-down' facilities -
no repairs after a year of promises 18.9.08 |
| 12.9.08 Wokingham
- Public not warned of spate of thefts from
lockers 12.9.08 |
| 12.9.08 Lee
Valley - Users angry as pool
closes 3 weeks early due to lack of
staff 11.9.08 |
| 4.9.08 Maldon - Parents
Allege Failures and Sue LC Following
Drowning 28.8.08 |
| 16.8.08 Brent - Penalities
for 8 Willesden PFI Contract Defaults
May 2008 |
| 15.8.08 Pooling
Resources Campaign Group -
link to external site |
| 14.8.08 ‘Wokingham
- 'Guards didn’t see my boy in swim trouble’ 14.8.08 |
13.8.08
Brent
- H&S Improvement Notice for excessive solids
in pool March - July 2008
plus Repeated
litter on pool floor, Third set of vanity units
fail, & Lifeguarding lapses
|
| 13.8.08 Harrow - Policed
warning after Leisure centre Thefts 24.3..08 |
| 13.8.08 Leisure
Management Contractors' Association List of
Contracts Two Years Out of Date 13.8.08 |
| 8.8.08 Maldon - Private Eye
on Council Investigation Plus LCW Updates
7.8.08 |
| 16.7.08 Lee
Valley - "Bad news for pool,
good news for PR" 7.8.08 |
| 6.7.08 Danoptra, owner of
LC, close to a deal to acquire pubs division of
rival - external link 6.7.08 |
| 3.7.08 How many lifeguards
does a pool need? - HSE Guidance 2003 |
| 1.7.08 Maldon - Council
to Inquire into Drowning Despite Concerns about
Conflict of Interest 27.6.08 |
| 26.6.08 Maldon - What
is happening to the enquiry into drowning asks
local 26.6.08 |
| 24.6.08 Oadby & Wigston -
Audit Commission reports satisfaction with
leisure among lowest in country March 2008 |
| 24.6.08 St Albans - Shortage
of Lifeguards Limits Swimming Sessions
19.6.08 |
| 23.6.08 Maldon - More
Comments on Lifeguarding in Maldon 23.6.08 |
| 19.6.08 Are the lessons from other
pool drownings being learned? 19.6.08 |
| 19.6.08 Maldon - Claims that
pool was not busy and Michelle first
spotted by a young swimmer 19.6.08 |
| 19.6.07 Maldon - Father of
Drowned Girl Claims First Ambulance was
Cancelled 18.6.08 |
| 16.6.08 LC sold to Swiss led
consortium 6.6.08 |
| 15.6.08 Maldon - "Lifeguards
fail to save girl, 7, from drowning" 15.6.08 |
| 20.5.08 Brent - EH find Kids'
Pool had 17x Too Much Chlorine 24.4.08 |
| 12.5.08 Ely - A Doctor Writes
about Poor Cleaning and
Management 17.4.08 |
| 25.4.08
Lee Valley - Paper
reports pool looks set to close 24.4.05 |
| 14.4.08 LC
Owner for Sale - LC and other interests have
"struggled" says
Sunday Times 13.4.08 |
| 02.4.08 Advertising Standards Authority
slams LC's science but dubious claims continue
2.4.08 |
| 02.3.08 South Beds - Cleaning and
Staffing Issues Listed in Council Report
28.2.08 |
| 02.3.08 Grantham - "Intimidating
call" allegation and other issues
29.2.08 |
| 20.2.08
St Albans - PR Disaster
as Newspaper Calls Bluff on "Ultimatum"
20.2.08 |
| 18.2.08
Lee Valley - Local
paper identifies "A catalogue
of concerns" 15.2.07
The Concerns
include cleanliness, no evidence of safety
checks, staffing and training worries
raised "consistently", high levels of
bacteria, excessive chlorine, and pool water
testing equipment in "very poor condition".
|
| 15.2.08 Brent
- Maintenance including a year without
replacement for sink unit |
| 15.2.08 Harrow -
LC backed leisure centre plans attacked by
Sport England and Sports Council Feb 2008 |
| 11.2.08
Deepings - "Girls getting
changed in the dark" but no longer "dangerous" 11.2.08 |
| 11.2.08
Same issues but new PR
Company for LC 24.1.08 |
| 11.2.08 Wake
up and smell the snake oil 21.12.08 |
|
Headings
from 2007
Headings
from 2006 Headings from 2004 to 2005
|