Quadricycle Background

For the last few years I've had a design in mind for a recumbent quadricycle (sometimes called a pedal-car or pedal-kart). Not sure what the official definition is but basically it is a 4-wheeled bicycle where the rider sits in a seat rather than on one. In my case it looks a little bit like a go-kart with pedals and narrow wheels. My original intention was to design and build a 4-wheeled mountain bike, as I have had too many hospital visits from outings on my traditional mountain bike. It was to feature all-round, fully independent suspension and 4-wheel drive but, my first design and costing exercise showed this to be hopelessly unrealistic in terms of weight and cost. It remains a dream in carbon fibre and titanium.

One advantage of having more than two wheels on a recumbent cycle is that you can stop at junctions and other obstacles and not have to put your feet down. This means you can leave your feet clipped to the pedals and hill starts are much simpler, with no set-off wobbles. The other advantage with recumbents (depending on the configuration), is that you push against the seat to extert pressure on the pedals and don't just use your body weight. This means acceleration and top speed are increased.

The perception that recumbent cycles are less safe than a normal cycle is misplaced. The very nature of the seating position means that your head is supported and relaxed in the position required to look at the road ahead, rather than the standard 'head down' cycling position. The low centre of gravity means that accidents are less likely and you are better protected in the event of a crash, through a feet forward riding position. In slippery road conditions a skid is also much more likely to be recovered, before you make contact with the road.

Why have I chosen four wheels and not three? A good question that everyone asks. I have no doubt that trikes are lighter, faster, have less rolling resistance and a lower centre of gravity. A trike is also naturally designed to keep all of its wheels on the ground over varied terrain. If speed is your only goal, then a recumbent bike or trike is the solution.

A quadricycle is slightly more stable and has better all round balance. It is also shorter in length and offers greater manouverability (depends on design though). The main reason for me though, is that it has the right handling characteristics, in that it matches my experiences of car and kart racing. It is something that I can throw into corners with confidence. It has two driven rear wheels for good traction. As designed, it also has more storage space. Another factor is that it simply looks better with matching small wheels. My final reason is simply that I like engineering challenges and the elegant drive of my quadricycle avoids the huge chain lengths, chain tubes/tensioners and carriers I've seen on recumbent trikes.

My goal has always been to keep it relatively light and to build from readily available parts. This almost explains why it has taken so long to design and build my quadricycle. Even now I have had to resort to some custom made parts but, these are fairly generic in their application. The breakthrough in terms of implementing my plan was the discovery of go-kart component suppliers on-line. Go-kart parts are superbly engineered and fairly light-weight. They are also very cheap, since they are made in large numbers.

Requirements

My requirements have changed over the last few years. Originally I was looking for a 4-wheeled alternative to my mountain bike but now I'm looking for a commuter bike that can handle the bridle paths and cycle ways, I encounter on my way to work. As a commuter quadricycle the other key requirements is that I can use it every day, regardless of weather and that I stay dry in doing so. It also has to carry a couple of bags containing computing and electronics equipment and require no change of clothing to ride it to work (a 4Km ride with no hills).

Efficiency is not a critical design issue, as one of the reasons for commuting by pedal power is that it involves some exercise. Having said that the quality components and bearings used mean rolling resistance is very low. The quadricycle is as light as possible but sturdy enough to withstand some reasonable off-road use. I've compromised with the tyres which are not going to be road going slicks but fairly chunky. The reason is purely because of a non-functional requirement, in that is must look good. The 16" black wheels with chunky black tyres will give it a fairly aggressive look. I'm also using black wheel hubs, chassis and transmission parts. The go-kart parts are all gold annodised and the steering and seating is all metallic red.

My quadricycle is 160cm long to allow me to fit in the steering, chainset, seat, rear axle and storage space. It could be shorter but this length guarantees my feet can't foul wheels, the steering, the chassis or the ground. It could be made narrower but I've constructed it to be 90cm wide for improved stability on cornering. The downside is that it may not fit between some bollards found on some cycleways. The size of the wheels affects the look but it also affects the ground clearance and the turning circle. Ground clearance is pretty good, being nearly 6".

I can't confirm the final weight until the quadricycle has been completed, but it will be fairly light. My target weight for the completed quadricycle as described here is less than 24Kg (~54lbs). This is based on estimates and actual weights of components and includes everything from chassis to wiring for the lighting.

Chassis

The first build of the chassis is in wood, as it is a very cheap and easy material to work with and allows me to try out various measurements and configurations. My basic assumption is that if the wooden version can survive riding, a aluminium or steel welded equivalent frame would be well up to the rigours of my daily commute.

The design is a fairly simple and conventional space frame chassis, largely made from 1" x 1" square section tubing.

Wheels

The overall look of the quadricycle is heavily determined by the chosen wheel size. 14" rims were my initial choice but, I eventually decided to use 16" rims. 14" wheels are only really used on children's bikes and sourcing quality rims was pretty much impossible. Sourcing some good quality 16" rims was also hard work but, I eventually found a supplier that sold aluminium rims, in 36-spoke form to match my front and rear hubs. The rims are painted black to improve their appearance. The wheels and hubs account for a large part of the total cost.

Front Wheels

Shimano Deore XT front disc hubs in black are used for each front wheel. The wheels are custom built to my 16" rims. As the quadricycle does not lean, high lateral forces are placed on the rim under hard cornering. For this reason 36-spoke rims and hubs are used to provide a strong and rigid wheel. These hubs come with a 9mm hollow axle which had to be replaced with a longer, solid axle, to improve the strength of the single-sided mounting. The axle is mounted through a 9mm diameter by 20mm deep, threaded hole in the upright, with a locking nut added on the in-board side. The locking nut and bearing cone on the out-board side also lock the axle in place.

A front wheel with brake disc attached.
(1338 x 1410 pixels, 538KB)

If I have one concern with the design of this bike, it is the use of a 9mm axle for mounting the front wheels. I have added collars to increase the effective diameter of the axle but longer term I am going to try and find a thick axle on which to mount the front wheel. A 12mm diameter axle is the recommended miniumum for recumbent trikes but then they have a much worse front:rear weight distribution, placing much greater loads over the front wheels.

Rear Wheels

The rear wheels use the same 36-spoke 16" rims. My original plan was to get some custom made hubs fabricated but these were going to work out as being rather expensive. Instead I've modified some existing rear kart wheels (machined down to 80mm width and purchased from the manufacturer without valve holes in the rims) and put spokes through the rims in a radial fashion. These bolt to a standard go-kart hub, on three 8mm diameter studs at 58mm PCD. The modified kart hubs are also painted black. Each complete wheel, with inner tube and tyre weighs 1225g.

A rear wheel based on a kart hub and a 36-spoke 16" rim.
(1024 x 768 pixels, 538KB)

Brakes

My chosen design means that in-board disc brakes or drums are the only real options. There are simply no mounting points for rim brakes with side-mounted wheels. Wear on my expensive and hard to find rims was also a consideration. I decided to use disc brakes all round but this is an expensive solution and probably over engineered. Disk calipers are also quite heavy. Bearing in mind my hospital history due to mountain bikes, I took the safe rather than sorry option.

I use Shimano RT-60 160mm discs. The front ones are mounted on Shimano Deore XT front disc hubs. The rear discs will be mounted in-board on custom shaft mounts. I'm going to see how I get on with front brakes only and add rear brakes if required. This will save weight and about £200. There wil also be a parking brake.

My quadricycle uses Shimano V-brake levers. The right one operates on the front brakes and the left one will operate the back brakes, if they are added. The brake cables run a BMX bike adaptor which converts one cable to pull on two cables. These connect to the two rear cable-driven, Shimano Deore disc calipers. It is worth noting that these brakes are designed to stop 26" wheels and I'm using them on much smaller wheels. The reduced torque on the brake disc will mean the stopping power is going to be pretty awesome and I'm going to get through front tyres very quickly.

I did consider hydraulic brake calipers but the costs are much higher. A cable calliper is £45 and a hydraulic calliper is nearer £100. The levers are also more expensive. Hydraulics have the advantage of in-built self-balancing but at the cost of twice the brake lever travel. My cable solution will require a harder pull on the lever and careful balancing by manual set up. I'm also investigating the use of a balance bar to ease adjustment of the brake bias.

Transmission

The transmission is split into three seperate sections. Firstly there is a single ring chainset. This drives a centre hub via a chain and then, two chains link the centre hub to two free-wheels on the rear half-shafts. The multiple gearing effectively makes the 16" wheels act roughly like 26" wheels and provides a range of gearing from 75.6 to 26.0 inches. There are no complicated chain paths and tensioners, the chain does not run through any piping at any point and is as short as possible. The centre hub is adjustable to tension the rear chains. The objectives are minimal weight and minimal friction. Even the derailleur is positioned right under the seat to minimise the length of cable required.

Front Transmission

Drive is from a single front chainset with 36 teeth and a standard 170mm crank. Getting hold of a 36-tooth single chainset is impossible so I use a twin 42/36 tooth chainset. The outer ring acts as a chain guard and helps keep the chain on. The inner chain ring is interchangable to alter the gear ratios, if required. There is no front derailleur but I can manually move the chain across if I wanted to tour with a higher set of ratios (100.8 - 34.7 inches). I also use a custom fabricated 'chain-keeper' to stop the chain falling off the inner ring, something that can occur with a single chain ring driving a 9-speed cassette. The bottom bracket is mounted through part of a normal bike frame which has been cut down and mounted on plates to bolt to the chassis.

Centre Transmission

The chainset drives a 'centre hub'. This is a Shimano Deore rear wheel hub with a 9-speed cassette (11-32 teeth). The hub provides a free-wheel capability and a mounting point for two 26-tooth sprockets (with four 8mm mounting holes). The two sprockets are mounted to custom sprocket carrier disks, fabricated from 5mm aluminium plate and then cut down the middle. The two halves are then mounted around the wheel hub and then bolted to the wheels rims, using 2.5mm bolts through the spoke holes. There are also bolted to the two sprockets which are passed over the hub rims and are bolted onto the sides of the carrier. The free-wheel obviously means the quadricycle has no reverse gear and drive. A Shimano Deore 9-speed rear derailleur is used to change gear on this central cassette using a handlebar mounted Shimano Deore STI gear lever.

The centre hub.
(1221 x 1101 pixels, 358KB)

The centre hub is mounted in a lightweight frame, which is attached to the chassis via bolts. This can be rapidly dismantle to remove the chains, if required. The centre hub drops down into a guide channel which provides fore/aft movement to tension the rear chains. For now, I've retained the quick release hub to acheive this but this will probably be replaced by a pair of nuts, which will be much lighter.

Rear Transmission

The two 26-tooth central sprockets drive two 18-tooth free-wheels mounted on the end of each rear half-shaft. The half-shafts are custom fabricated from solid 25mm aluminium rod, to provide a light-weight and short version of standard 25mm go-kart axle. They are of unequal length due to the offset centre hub and have a 6mm keyway. The free-wheels allow the shafts to both be driven but to rotate at different speeds whilst cornering. This removes the need for a differential as the outer wheel simply free-wheels to catch up with the inner wheel on cornering. The free-wheels are attached to the half-shafts via custom made mounts that are also keyed. They accept standard single free-wheels on a 1.375", 24tpi thread. These mounts are the only custom fabricated parts on the bike that I've paid someone else to make. They cost me £141 for the pair.

These are the carriers that allow the single freewheels to drive the 25mm kart axles.
(1525 x 803 pixels, 261KB)

The half-shafts are mounted to the chassis using custom made bearing hangers, go-kart bearing plates and 25mm go-kart bearings. These are fairly heavy but offer a reliable, low friction means to mount the axles. The bearings have twin grub-screws to stop the shafts sliding sideways in the bearings.

Sources of bearings found so far are:

The shafts have standard go-kart, gold annodised hubs on the ends, which have a three 8mm wheel studs for the rear wheel mounting. These also have a key-way.

These are the gold anodised kart wheel hubs. They are an amazing bit of engineering for the £14 they cost each.
(1146 x 1074 pixels, 293KB)

Chains

The bike uses four Shimano HG53, 9-speed chains (114 links). Two are reduced down to 96 links to drive the rear axles and the other two are joined to form a single chain from the chain set to the centre hub (? links). The tension of the rear chains is adjusted by moving the centre hub fore/aft in its mounting frame. Tension in the front chain is maintained by the 9-speed derailleur on the centre hub.

Steering

The steering is a via handle bars which pivot on the chassis, just in front/under of the seat. This has the brake levers, gear lever and light switches mounted on it. An short stem mounts through the chassis rail in front of the seat. Tie rods connect this to the pivot points on the front uprights.

The front steering uprights are acheived using a Cane Creek C2Remote site headset on each side with a custom fork column tube, to which the front axles are fixed. Nuts are welded to this tube and the axle runs through them at 23° to provide the centre point steering action. The upright also has fixing points for the disc calipers and fixing for the steering pivot. The upright is also inclined backwards by 12° to provide a self centering action.

The tie-rods are installed based on Ackermann steering geometry to ensure that the inner wheel turns more to optimise grip on cornering. Because Im envisage lots of high-speed cornering, the wheels will be slightly more parallel than pure Ackermann geometry dictates. This counteracts the bikes basic nature to continue in a forward motion due to momentum. There is no toe-in, toe-out or camber angles on my design.

There are a few web sites worth looking at about steering:

Having measured up the front wheels and steering geometry, I need a king-pin inclination of 23° to get full centre-point steering. This is quite a bit more than the recommended maximum of 15° for a recumbent trike. I'm going to go with this though because the weight distribution on my quadricycle is very different to that of a typical recumbent trike.

The reason for limiting the kingpin angle is because an angled kingpin means that the bike is actually lifted when the wheels are turned. The more it is inclined, the more it lifts the bike and the more effort is required to turn the wheels. Based on measurements from a friends recumbent trike, the front:rear weight distribution is typically around 70:30. Based on my measurements with two set of scales my quadricycle has a weight distribution of 45:55. Simple maths shows that my weight distribution and a kingpin angle will require less effort to turn the wheels, than a recumbent trike with a 15° kingpin inclination and 70:30 weight distribution.

Seating

The single biggest difference between quadricycles and bicycles is the seat. Recumbent bicycles offer much better rider comfort due to the fact that they distribute the riders weight and offer better back and head support. I've spent ages on the design and build of my seat, making sure that it is very comfortable, suitably robust and also light-weight. Unlike some recumbent seats I've seen, I've deliberately tried to avoid making a seat that looks like part of a hacked about rucksack.

The seat is in two parts. The base is a small, contoured, solid foam with an easy clean/dry, black vinyl finish. The seat back uses a light-weight aluminium tubular frame, covered with a tensioned polypropylene, black mesh fabric, as used on trampolines. It provides comfort, lateral support and ventilation. All exposed metal is painted deep metallic red. The seat is bolted to the chassis at four points. The angle of the seat base and back are adjustable. The seat back is shaped and incorporates an angled head support. The position of the seat can be changed if required but a fully adjustable mechanism was dropped to reduce weight.

A recumbent seat has numerous advantages as outlined in this articleRemote site.

Electrics

The bike features twin halogen front lights powered by a 6V lead acid rechargeable cell. This cell is also used to power front and back LED lighting, via a voltage regulator. The battery is mounted under the seat, out of sight and to keep the centre of gravity as low as possible.

The LED lighting is for normal use and allows the bike to be seen. Three, very high intensity, 10mm white LEDs are used on the front of the bike and three similar red LEDs are used at the rear. These are mounted through 40mm diameter, circular reflectors, directly to the chassis and indicate the extremities of the bike. A further red LED is also mounted at the rear of the bike, at the top of the seat.

The halogen spots are for lighting up the darker bits of my route to/from work. They are mounted to the handle bars and thus turn with them, allowing the lights to 'project around corners'. A convenient, handle bar mounted switch allows them to be flashed momentarily or switched on permanently.

Suspension

It's too heavy, so there isn't any, apart from the air in the tyres and the flexibility and fabric in the seat. If it really gets too hard, I will consider front wheel articulation for the next version of this bike. This may also help keep all the wheels on the road. I've also consider some rubber bushes in the seat base mounting but will experiment later with this idea.

Storage

At the rear of the quadricycle, behind the seat is storage space for a small rucksack and a briefcase. This will be a waterproof, light-weight enclosure with a lid and be big enough to carry a PC briefcase and seperate bag.

Enclosure

One objective of this quadricycle is get me to/from work in any weather without getting wet and without requiring a load of wet weather gear. The enclosure has yet to be designed but it is going to be a real challenge. My current plan is to use fibre glass rods to provide a frame for a tensioned nylon fabric cover. It will weight less than ½kg and will not be a permanent feature of the quadricycle. It will use bright red, ultra-thin nylon tent fabric. The hard bit is going to be to make it look really good. I don't want my quadricycle to look like thisRemote site.

Another aspect of the enclosure is under investigation. Ideally, I would like to enclose the underside of my quadricycle to keep water and dirt out of the transmission components. This is likely to be in the form of a very light nylon covering.

Security

Anti-theft devices are under consideration.

Miscellaneous

Solar battery charging is something I'm looking into. My preferred alternative would be to use a shaft driven dynamo to power a complete set of LED lighting.

At the rear of the quadricycle will be a towing hitch. This is so that I can mount a towing bar and pull my children along on the unpowered go-kart I've built them. This also doubles up as a handy point from which to suspend the completed quadricycle to weigh it.

Since I'm using standard go-kart components at the back end, I've also brought a spocket carrier, to mount on one half-shaft. This would allow me to add electric power to the quadricycle very easily if I wanted to.

I've maintained a list of all the tools used to build/maintain the bike, so that I can carry a light-weight toolkit around just in case. So far, it's a few allen keys, a screwdriver and a 10mm spanner, plus the usual bike toolkit parts (tyre levers, chain splitter, etc.).

Other Interesting Links

16th December 2002

My seating fabric arrived from Point NorthRemote site. Looks very good and is very strong. Ordered 1m at £13.50/m and the fabric is 1.8m wide.

1st April 2003

Bought some rear kart wheels from Kart ComponentsRemote site to use as the hubs of the rear quadricycle wheels. These are 120mm wide and have a large rim so I will get them machined down to about 90mm in width and then get the rear wheels built with spokes coming out radially from the hub. These are specials, requested off the production line before the valve holes were drilled in the rims. These 'hubs' will also be painted black.

The Kart wheels as delivered.
(1024 x 742 pixels, 129KB)

30th May 2003

Huge gap in progress, while I've been landscaping the front and rear garden. Got the completed front wheels and new axles. Also received the kart hubs for the rear wheel hubs. The 25mm rear axle that I've bought turns out to be 25.1mm in diameter and this means the bearings and kart hubs don't fit. The axle is not straight enough to turn down on a lathe so I've been using cloth backed wet and dry to gently rub it down but is taking a while. Have bought some Schwalbe MarathonRemote site tyres in 16" x 1.75" size. Ouch, they are expensive (£15 each) but seem to offer good compromise on size, looks, etc. and are puncture resistant. They can also go to 70psi which means lower rolling resistance on my cycle paths. Slight shift from the chunky looks I envisaged in favour of on-road manners. Now I can work out the rolling diameter and finalise the steering design and sort out the centre point steering.
A rear wheel hub after machining. Yet to have the spoke holes drilled in it. The blue ink is to hilight where it was marked for machining on a surface plate.
(1024 x 768 pixels, 181KB)
I've found a company that sells suitable front disk hubs for single sided mounting, complete with bearings, and 12mm axle. Inspired Cycle Engineering LtdRemote site make recumbent trikes and sell spares which would be suitable for this project. Not very cheap but reasonably priced considering these are custom parts, hard to obtain anywhere else.
 
Copyright © Robert Collingridge 2003