The Art of Writing Critiques

Writing critiques of dog shows is most interesting to both the writer (judge) and the readers (exhibitors). But do the exhibitors know what the judge is really thinking when they are writing those critiques. To help the exhibitors better understand the judge’s written word, the following will be a great help: -

 

Showing better than in previous class - I reversed my decision

Skilfully presented - A good attempt at hiding its faults

Full of spirit - Damn near had my hand off

Well handled - The exhibitor wouldn’t leave it alone

Had been hard done by in the past - All previous judges were wrong

 

Well known winner - I knew it had won before

A new one to top honours - Why wasn’t I told it hadn’t won before

Must be made up - All future judges please follow me

One for the future - Come back in 12 months time

Not quite ready yet - Should have stayed at home

 

Needs to tighten up - Why don’t they give it some exercise

Has much to offer the breed - There is nothing else like it in the ring

An outstanding puppy - And even if it isn’t I know the owner can make up anything

Always one of my favourite breeds - Why aren’t I asked to judge more often

Enjoyed judging the breed again - It’s time I was asked to do CCs

 

Sporting breed - Someone who didn’t win bought me a drink

Pleased to see it do well in the group - I told the judge it was a good one

Moved like a train - Had steam coming out of its ears

Moved well going away - But it looked like it was beating eggs coming back

Sporting owners - Can be bumped without fear

 

A quality entry - I wish there had been a few more

An easy winner - The rest were shocking

These two could change places - I was probably wrong

Strode well out - Was moving too quickly for me to see anything

Not putting all in - It wouldn’t stand up

 

Has one big ‘if’ - I’m not saying what it is though, everyone knows about it but I don’t want people to think I missed it

Well handled by his young owner - I was watching the handler not the dog

A most popular win - The owners husband clapped

An enthusiastic gallery - The owners husband brought his mother and they both clapped

A packed ringside - The children came too

 

Promising puppy - I am going to put it up the next time I judge

Unlucky to meet winner - -ditto-

I understand this makes him up - I played safe

This was a difficult class to judge - I didn’t recognise a soul

Typical of this famous kennel - I know they have good ones and I hope this is one of them

 

An old favourite of mine - I put him up last time I judged

But a worthy champion - Past its best and should be retired

Short of coat - Bald as a coot

Coat not at its best - Needs a good brushing

Well bodied up - Fat as a pig

 

Impressed me on the table - But looked nothing off it

Not enjoying himself - A quivering wreck

 Rather heavy in ear - Ears like a cobblers apron

Spirited - Ferocious

 

Reproduced from Pekinese News 1975 and taken from SW Tibetan Spaniel Newsletter. Additions invited......

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

 Return to Shanesque St. Bernards

 Return to my humour zone