If it ain't broke don't fix it. Maybe I'm just
being cynical, but after Wizards of the Coast's takeover of TSR, I can't
help but think that the 3rd Edition rules were more of an attempt to stamp
their own brand over the product rather than do a worthwhile update. It is
still the best RPG ever though.
This revamp of the the rules was more than welcome. Over the years, the
core rules had spread like a vomit and had become way to convoluted and
complex and yet still carried the awkward charm of a game, albeit a
fabulously successful one that had been put together by hobbyists. This
edition clarified and tidied the whole thing up, and got rid of the crappy
1st Edition art. Unfortunately commercial pressures soon let this edition
swell into a ridiculous size as well.
Another welcome update to the best RPG ever.
Without a doubt one of the worst aspects of the original game was the
generally atrocious quality of the art. This new edition rectified this is
glorious style, not only having some beautiful illustrations, but going
full colour into the bargain.
This is the edition which was released after TSR had been forced to remove
the Cthulhu Mythos from the original. This is a nice collectors item now.
Still, there was more than enough material in here to drive the religious
right nutty and fuel the "people who play Dungeons and Dragons are
all satanists" argument Nice one TSR. Of course we all knew that all
the best demons were in the Monster Manual. . . . ..